- Two dudes.
- Two tummies. - 52 ice creams.
- Let's talk about that. (upbeat music) Good Mythical Morning! - Welcome to our 1700th episode! - What?
(clapping) - One thousand and seven
hundred, that's what that is. - Crazy!
Thank you, sincerely, thank you so much for comin'
along on this journey with us and making us a part
of your daily routine. - Yes, and to celebrate
this very special occasion, we're going to eat a lot of ice cream. - Oh, yay. Y'all may not be aware of this, but we are not the only old
guy buddy duo in the world who like to eat strange things. There's another duo that's been concocting a plethora of sometimes strange but always delicious ice
cream flavors for decades and that's Jerry and Ben.
- Yup. So today, we're sampling all 52 pint size Ben & Jerry's flavors to one, make us happy--
- Uh huh. - And two, to determine the best. - And three, to celebrate!
- Not a sponsor. Not a sponsor.
- 1700 episodes! - But you're welcome, anyway, B and J. It's time for Gut Check:
Ben & Jerry's Edition. Okay, 52 flavors is a lot,
so we're gonna have to taste every single one
in rapid succession. This is gon' get crazy. - And B-T-dubs, Ben & Jerry's also has a whole bunch of frozen
yogurt and non-dairy flavors but today, we're just dealing
with the ice cream pints. It's plenty.
- Yes, okay. We're gonna be spoon
fed every single flavor and then, using our initial gut instinct, we have to immediately score each one on a scale of one to 100 and then create an official combined score,
which, when calculated at a rapid speed by our very own CPA, that's our Creamy Public Accountant. - Hi, thanks so much for hiring me. Tax season is not the most
stressful time of year for me, so this is great timing (laughs). - After we've tasted
and scored every flavor, the top four flavors will
receive a closer taste inspection until we're left with
only one, the official very best Ben & Jerry's ice
cream flavor in the world. - All right, Stevie, help
us kick off our festivities. - [Stevie] Gentlemen, if
at any point you feel that you need your palates to be cleansed, you have access to the ultimate palate cleanser, a salt lick. There's nothing scientific about that. I just really wanted see you lick those big pieces of salt.
- Thank you. - [Stevie] We shall begin
with the chocolate category. Are you ready?
- Yes. Here we go in three, two, one. Chocolate Fudge Brownie. - Ooh, ooh, that's good.
- Oh, that's good. - Especially with the brownie. I'm talkin'--
- 81. - I'm talkin' 72.
- Chocolate Shake It. - Shake it, what? - Oh, there's somethin' chewy in there. - Oh, I like that.
- I like that one less. I'm givin' it a--
- I like it more. 82.
- 58. - I think I like--
- Chocolate Therapy. - Mm, it's a richer chocolate. But it's--
- Oh, it's so dark. - Kinda boring, 43.
- What? 72.
- Oh. - [Stevie] Glampfire Trail Mix. - Mm.
- Oh, it's like a Rocky Road. - Ooh, but it's somethin' different. - Little crunchy. (stuttering) 77. - Um, 69. - [Stevie] New York Super Fudge Chunk. - Mm, I've been to New York. - Oh, once you get to that fudge. - Got walnuts in it, not a fan. - Yeah.
- 53. - Mm, 29. - [Stevie] Phish Food. - Ah.
- Oh, like the band. - Not a fan of Phish.
- What happened to, maybe too much.
- Not my favorite, 58. - I don't love this one either, a lot, 21.
- S'mores. - I've been campin'.
- Oh, I can actually taste-- - This is pleasant.
- I can taste the campfire. - I'm back up in the 70s, 74.
- It's 71. - The Tonight Dough.
- Ah. Shout out to Jimmy Fallon.
- Our friend, Mr. Fallon. I love all the doughs,
that one went down quick. - It's nice, it's simple, it's-- - 80s, 89.
- What? I, yeah.
- It's not that, sorry Jimmy, it's not that good, 76. - I like that dough.
- Minter Wonderland. - Mm.
- Eh. - I love mint in my chocolate. I know he doesn't like it.
- I don't love mint in my chocolate.
- Yeah. I'm gonna give that one,
I'm gonna give that one an 83 'cause I know he's
gonna score it really low. - (laughs) Yeah, I gotta give that a 19. (Rhett laughs) - [Stevie] Okay, now it's time for the vanilla flavors category. If you haven't licked your salt, which, I saw you do it, Link, I really-- - I'll do it again.
- Yeah, thank you. Please do it now and we will begin with Vanilla. - Oh.
- Oh. - I'm white.
- That is a good-- - I'm just, I'm just, I'm just trying to-- - Trying to connect?
- I'm trying to connect with it on some level. - That's a good, it's good
that it's that simple. Man, I gotta give it a 50.
- I'm gonna say 45. - [Stevie] Vanilla Caramel Fudge. - Oh.
- Mm. We're gettin' better. - I feel like a baby
on his birthday every. "Mama's gonna feed you."
- That's good, that's pretty simple,
I'm gonna give that a 61. - Too much caramel. Yeah, I'm gonna give a 32.
- You gotta be faster. - [Stevie] Americone Dream. - Mm, 'cause it's got cone pieces? - I don't even know what's
happening in my mouth but I like it.
- It is fun. - So good.
- I didn't know that I would love it.
- 78. 78, that's good.
- 59. - [Stevie] Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough. - Did I get some of your thumb in my mouth with that one?
- Yep. Sorry. Mm.
- How is that happening? - That's a classic.
- I like cookie dough. I'm not a huge fan of it in my ice cream. - 57.
- What? I was gonna give it higher than that, 61. - [Stevie] Chubby Hubby. - What--
- I was a chubby hubby, like,
one year into marriage. - Now, there's some peanut butter in this and a lotta crunch. - There's a very crunchy wafer-y thing that I'm not liking in my ice cream, 41. - Yeah, that's a struggle for me, 34. - [Stevie] Ice Cream Sammie. - Okay.
- That just tastes like an ice cream sandwich. - But it should be an
ice cream form, three. It only works in its form.
- 74. - [Stevie] Milk & Cookies. - I've had both of these.
- This is like Oreo but they can't say Oreo. - It's cookies and cream. Yeah, that's cookies and cream. It's solid but there's a much bigger world of ice cream out there. I'm gonna give this one a 55.
- I'mma give this a 55. - [Stevie] Salted Caramel Almond. - Um.
- That's a good ice cream. - Tastes like hard candy if
it was cold and not as hard. - 68.
- 27. - It seems like you guys
might need a little pick up, so we're gonna switch to our next section, which is the coffee section.
- There's a coffee section? - It's true.
- Just like a grocery store. - [Stevie] Here we go in three, two, one. Brewed to Matter. - Oh, there's a punch to that. - I like that. - 80. - I don't feel that great about it, 78. - It's exquisite.
- Chillin' the Roast. - Has, like, an amaretto thing in it, really not liking that.
- Frappuccino. - 28, that's the worst one for me so far. - Yeah, what is that amaretto thing? - Amaretto. - 12.
(Rhett laughs) - [Stevie] Coffee, Coffee, BuzzBuzzBuzz! - Hm, not as good as the
first coffee, by a long shot. Not bad, though.
- 47. - 53. - [Stevie] Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch. - Same coffee as the last time. - But with toffee, me likey. 82.
- Mm-mm, I don't like the toffee. 22. - [Stevie] Cold Brew Caramel Latte. - They like to put
caramel in a lot of stuff. - You don't like caramel? - I don't think I like it in my ice cream. - That's subtle but not
enough happening for me there. I'm gonna say 57.
- 43. - [Stevie] Okay, boys, we're moving on to the fruity category. - Oh, we gotta really lick. - Get that fruit. (Link groans) - Here we go.
- Are you having fun yet? - In three--
- Oh, I'm having tons of fun. - Two, one.
- Gotta go. - Chunky Monkey.
- Chunky Monkey! - I love banana. He doesn't, surprise. - I'm sorry I don't like
a lot of things, I mean-- - 84, that's one of my favorites. - 33, Patrick Huey! - [Stevie] Cherry Garcia. - Another one of my favorites. We got cherry, 85, that's good. - 17. - [Stevie] Pumpkin Cheesecake. - Now, I like pumpkin
and I like cheesecake and this is really, oh, that's smooth. - It's good, but the
pumpkin spice is just not, 78.
- 68. - [Stevie] Red, White & Blueberry. - That's weird.
- It's almost like a strawberry shortcake theme. - That's surprisingly good. It's got a crumb to it. - Too fruity.
- Ooh. - 61.
- 88. - [Stevie] Strawberry Cheesecake. - That tastes exactly like
strawberry cheesecake. - But there's a little
bit of a graininess. Like a graininess. - 64. - 66. - [Stevie] Okay, that
concludes the fruit round. - Okay. - But do you have--
- Wow. - [Stevie] Room for a round of legumes? 'Cause it's the peanut butter round, boys! - I thought you were
gonna say bean ice cream and I was getting excited.
- [Stevie] Here we go, in-- - All right, I'ma be tough on these 'cause these are my fave.
- Three, two, one. Peanut Butter World. - Ooh, I'm entering the world. - That is good! - Wow.
- 90! - I can't believe I've never had that. - You've gotta just give,
you gotta just given it-- - 87. - We gotta get fast.
- Peanut Butter Half Baked. - [Link] Even better, 89. - 88. - [Stevie] Netflix & Chilll'd. - What is that, so gooey? - This is still great, too, but I'm, I'm down to 80.
- 82. (coughs) 82.
- Peanut Butter Cup. - What a classic. - I like the tag it
with the peanut butter. 78.
- 72. - [Stevie] Peanut Butter Fudge Core. - Oh, that core.
- That fudge core and then you get a complete cup. - Oh, and the fudge bringing it back up. That's a 84. - 87. - [Stevie] Okay, sorry to say that's the end of the peanut butter round. - We loved the peanut
butter round, both of us. We can agree on that. - [Stevie] But happy to say
that our next expanded round is the wild cards round. - Oh, we got the wild cards.
- The ice creams that don't fit into any other category. And we're gonna begin in three, two, one, Wake &
No Bake Cookie Dough Core. - Oh, Cookie Dough Core. - Not bad. 65. - 66. - [Stevie] Caramel Chocolate Cheesecake. - 43, rich--
- Very rich. Very rich, 67. - [Stevie] Everything But The... - Oh, that was it.
- What? Too many flavors trying too hard. - [Rhett] 33. - 31. - [Stevie] Sweet Like
Sugar Cookie Dough Core. - Oh, that's weird. - Something's not working in there. 45. - 32. - [Stevie] Cinnamon Buns. - Mm, I freaking love Cinnamon Buns. Ice cream, even better
than the cinnamon buns. - I like cinnamon buns better
than Cinnamon Buns ice cream so I'm gonna give this a 52. - 94! - [Stevie] Half Baked. - I love a Half Baked. - A lot of these are tasting similar now. - Starting to blur.
- That was good, 71. - 82. - [Stevie] Oat of This Swirled. - Oatmeal cookie. - This is not one of my favorites. 49. - I really like this one. 86. - [Stevie] Salted Caramel Core. - 29.
- 73. - [Stevie] Triple Caramel Chunk. - 75, smooth. - 22. - [Stevie] Urban Bourbon. - Urban Bourbon? - Not a huge fan of whiskey
flavor in my ice cream. 17.
- 7. - [Stevie] Boom Chocolatta! Cookie Core. - Cookie Core. 51. - 38. - [Stevie] Pistachio Pistachio. - Mm, take it or leave it, 44. - Very weird, 22. - [Stevie] Mint Chocolate Cookie. - Could be worse.
- Minty. 67.
- 49. - [Stevie] Brownie Batter Core. - Ooh, that brownie batter's
a naughty, naughty person. - Whoa, that's got a distinct flavor. - Like brownie batter?
- 79. - Yeah, I agree with that, 79. (Rhett laughs) - [Stevie] Chocolate
Chip Cookie Dough Core. - Haven't we had that? - Mm, 57. - 74. - [Stevie] Cookies &
Cream Cheesecake Core. - What? - Mm-mm.
- It's good, but 51.
- No. 76. - [Stevie] Karamel Sutra Core. - Karamel Sutra. Ooh, man. We've only got three more.
- Sexual chocolate. - I don't like it, 19. - 54. - [Stevie] Cannoli. - Cannoli? - Not doing it for me. 28.
- 12. - [Stevie] Gimme S'More! - Eh, not wowing me. 44. - 69. - [Stevie] And the last
one, Justice Remix'd. - It's sort of a weird
cinnamon thing happening. - That's--
- I'm not digging. 33.
- 49. - [Stevie] Okay, guys,
that means you've tasted all 52 flavors.
- Wow! - [Stevie] Let's tally up those scores and see what your top four flavors are. (upbeat music) - All right, in honor
of our 1700th episode, we're honoring you with this super limited Mythical Crew Honorary Member tee. This thing is only available for 17 hours at mythical.com.
- Today. The timing has already started, the counter is counting
down at mythical.com. Go over there and pre-order this T-shirt to be a part of history and
thank you, again, so much. All right, let's find out
what are our top four. Don't give us the rankings, so it doesn't. We're starting over in
terms of ranking these four. - [Stevie] In no
particular order, we have: Peanut Butter Fudge Core. - Of course, peanut butter,
but with the fudge core. - That makes sense.
- Peanut Butter Half Baked. - Peanut butter?
- Okay, I see it. - Half baked.
- I see a theme. I sense a theme.
- Okay. - [Stevie] Peanut Butter World. - We love peanut butter. - [Stevie] And the other
thing that you love: The Tonight Dough! (both laughing) - Now--
- Shoutout to Jimmy Fallon. - But I will say that The
Tonight Dough does have peanut butter cookie dough in it. - Okay, so now we gotta figure out-- - Let's taste that one again.
- We gotta rank these. I'm coming in on The Tonight Dough. - Yeah. - [Stevie] The Tonight Dough has caramel and chocolate ice cream with chocolate cookie swirls and gobs of chocolate chip cookie dough and peanut butter cookie dough. - It's a very good ice cream. It's a very good ice cream. - Two types of doughs? That's good. Let's go in here. - [Link And Stevie] Peanut Butter World. - [Stevie] Milk chocolate ice cream with peanut buttery swirls
and chocolate cookie swirls. - I mean, it's got actual peanut butter. - I love the way they put peanut butter into their ice cream. I like this better than this. Because I know the dough is good but the real peanut butter swirls, yeah, it just does something for me. - I don't know yet. I think that those may be our top two. So let's go into these. - [Stevie] Peanut Butter Fudge Core. Chocolate and peanut butter ice cream with many peanut butter cups
and a peanut butter fudge core. - What the crap. - Yep, so, that core in the
middle is softer than ice cream. - It's got peanut butter cups in it. I don't like it as much.
- Yeah, me neither. The peanut butteriness of it,
because it's within fudge, it's just not as pure.
- Yeah, yeah. So these two are better than
that, I agree with that. - [Stevie] Peanut Butter Half Baked. Chocolate and peanut butter ice cream mixed with gobs of peanut
butter cookie dough and fudge brownies. - It's good but I'm missing
the straight up peanut butter. - Let's get rid of the
Peanut Butter Fudge Core. - Okay.
- Now, let's confer a little bit. Do you disagree about number two? - Okay, I don't disagree.
- Okay. - This is not as good
as either one of these. - All right, so we're
placing this at number three. Half Baked. - But I'm still torn. I'm torn on these.
- Yeah. I know what the deal is. - Are you just trying to get invited on "The Tonight Show" again? I think--
- Absolutely. - I think we can just go back if we have something to promote. - I think we agree. The Tonight Dough is second place. And--
- Officially the best, in my
estimation, by a long shot, now that I've compared these top four, ice cream that Ben & Jerry's has to offer is Peanut Butter World!
(clapping) - Peanut Butter, oh, crap! (producer laughs)
Warn a guy! All right? - We did it, man. We did it, we came, we saw, and we determined who had the best--
- Ate a bunch of ice cream. Thank you for subscribing
and clicking that bell. - You know what time it is. - In Jackson. It's time
- To. - Spin the Wheel of Mythicality. Of Mythicality. - Mythicality. Mythicality.
- Thank you. - (laughs) The old edit trick! - Mashup! - Click the top link to watch us read 17 notes about what GMM has meant to you and Good Mythical Morning.
- And to find out where the Wheel of Mythicality's gonna land. In honor of our 1700th
episode, we're honoring you. Get the Mythical Crew Honorary Member tee. Pre-order it for only 17
hours at mythical.com.
I absolutely LOVE Rhett and Link but I have to admit that their faces in the thumbnails are quite... too much, Link's face above all :/
Part of me always wants to punch Link everytime he speaks even though I do enjoy their shows every now and then.
I lije their show but I'm gonna be honest if Link weren't there I wouldn't miss him too much. His voice gives me indigestion.
Their tumbnails are so horrible at times that i just dont watch the episode because of it
When your buddy makes that face after any little thing... fuck its hard to be
Uh I think you're confusing him with Onision....
honest mistake.
Protected!