- "But there are some things "that just don't make sense to me. "I've asked to video chat
with Tomorrow multiple times, "but she says her camera is broken." I mean, come on. - How often do cameras break? They don't break that often. - No. But I'm just starting to think that something isn't right. A never ending mystery. - Like the Kennedy assassination. - "Dear Nev and Max, my name is Solana "and I'm 18 years old, "currently living in Ocean View, Delaware. ♪ I've been searching
for long kind of love ♪ "I need your help to find someone "who has become a very
important part of my life "over the past five years. "His name is Elijah, he is 20 years old "and lives in Minnesota."
- 20 years old. ♪ Hey, can you hear what I'm saying ♪ ♪ I can't seem to get through ♪ - " I met Elijah on", get this, "Myspace when I was 14. "My parents had just
gone through a divorce, "but Elijah held my
hand through everything. "And then we fell in love." ♪ Hey, can you hear what I'm saying ♪ ♪ I can't seem to get through ♪ "As boyfriend and
girlfriend, we were a dream. "Then suddenly out of
the blue, he disappeared. "His Myspace account was deleted. "He no longer called "and I couldn't get
ahold of him in any way. "I felt abandoned. "Had I done something wrong? "For two years I sat through my mistrust, "when out of the blue I got a message "from Elijah on Facebook. "He was searching for me. "We started up communication again, "but I wasn't over his disappearance "and didn't really trust him. "How do I know that
this is the real Elijah "that I'm talking to? "Over the years, Elijah and
I have never video chatted. "He doesn't have a webcam
and the last time we spoke "on the phone was six
years ago when I was 14 "before his Myspace account was deleted. "We now only message on a
text app and on Facebook. "I have recently met a
guy here in Delaware, "his name is Danny, he really wants "to move our relationship
to the next level. "But in my mind, I keep
thinking about Elijah "and what could have been. "I need to know whether I
should move on with my life "or potentially move forward with Elijah. "Best regards, Solana." She can't shake this
guy, this mystery crush. - Elusive Elijah. - Let's get her on the old horn. Solana. - Hello. - Hi, you have pretty
gauged earrings there, huh? - Yes, I have two, like one on each side. - And what are you doing now in Delaware? - So I work at like a salon spa. - We just read your email. We've got a lot of questions. First of all, how did you meet Elijah? - Well, we talked a lot on Myspace and messaged back and forth. He was always giving me good advice and really like there for me when I didn't know anybody else. Our relationship kind of grew really fast and like I confided in him
and told him all my secrets. - And then one day just, he went offline? - One day, I signed onto
Myspace to like message him and his profile was just completely gone. - Wow. - It just says, "User does not exist." At first, I was really bad and like, I kinda thought like maybe
I did something wrong - But two years after Elijah
disappears on Myspace, all of a sudden he pops up on Facebook. - Yeah, exactly. He messaged me saying, "I used to talk to a girl named Solana. "and like, I'm hoping it's you. "And if it's you, like reply to me." I didn't want to let
someone back into my life that was just gonna walk out. And I told him to text me,
but he didn't have a phone. - What do you mean, he
didn't have a phone? - He still doesn't. - Do you really believe that? - Not really. I mean, I don't know. - I mean, everybody has a phone. - He has a texting app on an iPod. - [Nev] You are still holding onto this. - Yeah, there's a big question
lingering from my past. - But you've also started
dating this Danny guy? - [Solana] I really like
Danny and he's good to me, which is really awesome. He's a great guy. - Does he know that you reached out to us? - Yeah. - Yeah, I told him. And honestly, he really
wants me to be happy. So, he's been supportive,
which is really awesome, 'cause most guys would
be like, "Screw you. "I'm out of here." - Inviting us to come into your life and connect you with Elijah
is only gonna cause waves. Are you ready for that? - I just need to solve this thing. And because it's been lingering and it's been basically holding me back from committing fully to Danny and that's not fair to him. And I don't want to wonder what if about this person for the rest of my life. - We want to help you and I want to see if we can figure this out. - That's super awesome. Thank you so much. - This cyber courtship needs to end. - Or start. - Perhaps. (Solana laughs) All right. Okay. We're gonna just right now. - We're going. - [Nev] Bye. - All right, bye.
- [Nev] Bye. - [Solana] He made me forget about everything that was going on. - And so, Elijah's like your best friend? And your support system. - [Solana] Exactly. - And your boyfriend? - Eventually, yeah. After like a month or so of
us talking and feeling it out, he asked me to be his girlfriend. - Very quickly, you guys
started talking on the phone. - Well, he had a house phone, so I could let him call me,
'cause I had a cell phone. But I wasn't allowed to call him, 'cause his mom was like super strict. It's like, "She caught me
calling.", or whatever. - And you kind of grieved
for him after he disappeared? - Definitely, yeah. That was really messed up, honestly, for him to like give me advice and tell me everything's going to be okay and then one day just
be like completely gone. Maybe I pushed him away, by like telling him
too much about my life. - You don't hear from him, nothing? - Not at all. - And what are you
feeling during that time? - One day I'd be super sad about it and the next day I'd
just be like ticked off. But then I would always
just try to push it in the back of my mind. - So a year or so goes by
where you guys don't talk. - Out of the blue one day, I get a message on Facebook from Elijah. - Do you have messages? - Yeah, we do. And you can read them and
show him if you want to. - Oh, wow, so this is
the message he sent you reconnecting back back in 2012? - Slowly but surely our communication started picking back up. And so, he texted me from his
app text number or whatever. And basically we'd just
been texting ever since. - Did you ask him what happened? - He told me his mom had him on lockdown, like took his stuff away and wouldn't let them have internet access or phone access or anything like that. - Have you ever asked
Elijah to video chat? - I mean, I've asked him,
but he doesn't have a webcam. - Do you buy his story? - Parts of it, yes, but
there's a lot of like holes. I don't want to like accuse someone who's done such nice things
for me of like doing bad stuff. - And we did a Google search for a bunch of the pictures
off of his Facebook page. And the first one that got us a hit showed up on a YouTube channel. - Ah. - Have you ever seen this YouTube channel? - No. There's a lot of videos on here. Why would he not tell me that? - I want to play a video for you, perhaps you'll recognize his voice. - Okay. - What's up, you guys. My name is Elijah. - It was so long ago,
I'm not like a 100% sure about that being his voice. - I got a brand new camera,
so I'm pretty (beep) excited. - He has a camera, but he can webcast. - You guys can talk to me on Skype. Just look up Elijah.prague. - Oh, okay. That's cool. - Yeah, that's about it. - Why is this Elijah
that you're talking to so private and hard to get in touch with, when he's got a Skype? - Oh. Okay, are you sure? Okay, go.
- Yeah. - Do it. - Do you hear anything? I didn't hear a bell. Do you hear anything? - Do it again. Do it again. - No, no, just knock. - Just ring the doorbell like a man. - I didn't hear anything. - Ring the knocker. - Hi.
- Hi. - What's up? - What's going on? - Hey, man. Are you Elijah? - No, I'm Joshua. - Joshua. - Nice to meet you.
- Nice to meet you. So you live here? - Yes, this is my mother's house. - Okay, cool. Got it. - You guys want to come in and meet him? - Is he in here? - Yeah. - Well, why doesn't he come out? I don't know. I guess we... Yeah, I guess, yeah,
we want to meet Elijah. - Well, come on in. - So, okay. - Okay. - [Joshua] And I'll go
get him for you guys. - All right. What the hell? I don't know what's going on. That was weird. Is he just gonna come back up? - I don't know. - I'm scared. (eerie music) - [Nev] Wow. - [Max] Oh my God. - Dang, you look gorgeous. - [Nev] Hi. - Hi. How are you? - I'm awesome. - When you came up, I was like scared. - Psych. - This is crazy. Oh my God. I can't believe I'm meeting you right now. - This is insane. How's it feel to be
here actually? (laughs) You were expecting the beard, weren't you? - We weren't expecting you. - How are you? - I'm awesome. I'm nervous now. (laughs) - [Solana] You're real. - Yeah.
- I'm real. They're real. - Is the hair real? - Yeah, my hair's real. - [Nev] Wow. - [Max] I think we're all
in a little bit of shock. - That was Joshua? - Yeah, my older brother. You know, I was tending to my hair, I gotta make the mop look good. - I'm Nev. - [Elijah] Nice to meet you. - Nice to meet you. - Hi, I'm Max.
- How's it going? - Nice to meet you. - Your name is Elijah? - Yeah. - [Nev] The whole time
it's been you talking? - I'm the one, you know? - And this is your family's house? - Yep. - And how old are you? - I'm 20. - Why couldn't you audio
chat or video chat? - I have Skyped with people for awhile, but then that computer broke, so I don't really have a
webcam for that anymore. - Well, we just saw the YouTube videos. - I didn't use like a
webcam or anything for that. I bought like a really nice camera after I got a job, you know? - [Nev] But you still have
your video camera, right? I mean-- - No, I sold that to help pay for rent. Sucks, but... - And what about not having a phone? - I have a phone. Yeah, I just use my iPod right now, but otherwise I don't have money. - Really?
- Let me see that. - Yeah, it's like generation two. - [Nev] This is what you have? - Yeah, the texting app. Yep, Text Plus. - Oh, and there is no camera. - No. - [Nev] So far everything we
thought you were, you are. - I don't know. I'm just like kind of
overwhelmed right now. (Elijah laughs) - From your point of view, what happened? - It just started when I got on Myspace and you was kind of
like a suggested person you would know and she had my style. So, it was like, you're cute. You know, I'll talk to you. Over time, she was someone
that made me feel, you know, be myself with this (beep), you know? And it's nice to feel that way. - When she texted you the other day, well, what was that about? - See, I was nervous. I was like, what if she's taller than me? You know, that type of thing, 'cause a lot of people are like, "Your videos, you look taller." I'm not that tall. (all laugh) So, I'm glad that you the same height. (laughs) That was one thing that I was really super nervous about. You disappeared kind of mysteriously. - My mom and dad, they didn't really want
me talking to someone who I don't know who it is. - So your mom really did
pull you off of Myspace? - Yep. And basically, my next
social media was on Facebook. - We definitely thought that
you were not going to be you, because you do have a lot of fakes. - Yeah, my fakes will have
like girlfriends or something and it sucks to have to
go out there and be like, you're probably talking
to either a dude, maybe or another chick, you know, who knows? - "Dear Nev and Max, I
just turned 23 years old "and live in Calvert, Texas. "About eight months ago, I saw pictures "of a beautiful girl online "and knew I wanted to
get to know her more. "And luckily he messaged me back. "She's the most beautiful
girl I've ever seen." ♪ I'm alive with you ♪ ♪ Inside your love ♪ - Get your hands off of me. - (laughs) That's very sweet. - It's sweet, but there's
more to life than beauty. - "I'm a dad, so meeting women
can really be hard sometimes, "but Jasmine accepts me for who I am "and says she can't wait to
meet my daughter one day. "She makes me feel very special. ♪ See you found someone ♪ "She is 22 years old and
lives in Houston, Texas, "which is only a couple
of hours away from me. "We're both pretty busy. "She works at a hotel "and she is working
toward becoming a model." The fact that she's not a model, that's better than him
saying, like, "She's a model." "Even with our busy schedules, "we message each other all the time." - [Max] So there's a lot of messages. - "We have talked about meeting up." - We've talked about meeting
up, but they haven't met up. - "But whenever it comes time, "she is all of the sudden not available. "I'm not interested in a fling with her, "I want an actual relationship. "Please help however you can, Felipe." - Felipe, period. - He's 23, she's 22, that's a good start. - They're still young enough, so that if it doesn't
work out, it'll be okay. - I mean, I don't know why you immediately think it won't work out. - We don't have a good track record. - Let's get him on. See what he has to say. Felipe!
- Yo! - What's going on? - What is Calvert like? - It's a pretty small town and where everybody knows everybody here. - Do you have a kid? - Yeah, she'll be five in March. - [Nev] Wow.
- [Max] Wow. - And so, Jasmine knows
about you being a dad and your daughter and she's cool with it. - Yeah, she said what happened, happened. - Sure.
- She's not judging you. - I tell her a lot of things that I wouldn't tell just anybody. She tells me stuff that I think
she can't tell nobody else and she just, when we
talk, it's just like, she gets me, so everything
just goes off just awesome. (upbeat music) Something about it just made
me feel like I can be myself. I can just be me. Don't have to worry about nothing. - So then, what's the deal? - Oh, I try to meet up
with her a few times, I won't get a response for about a good two, three, four hours. A few hours later, "Oh,
I got busy at work, "we have to try again next time." - Now, when you say talking, are you guys Facebook
messaging or are you texting? - How do you talk?
- On the phone? - Just messaging, 'cause
she doesn't have a phone. - Felipe, Felipe.
- Wait a second. So you've never heard her voice. - No. - What 22 year old girl who has a job-- - And is a model. - [Nev] Doesn't have a phone? - That's why I'm here. - I mean, clearly, you know something seems a little off with the whole thing. - Yeah, that's why I was just like, okay, I want to find out what's going on. I want to get to the bottom
of this as soon as possible, because I'm in the process
of joining the military. - Oh, wow. - With my basic training,
I want to make sure I have someone, you know, pretty much have someone to come home to. That way I'll be able
to focus more out there when I'm doing my training
or wherever the send me. I do have a feeling that
this could be the one that I end up spending
my life with, you know? - It's a big deal. It definitely sounds like
the kind of situation I think we could be really helpful-- - We could be of service.
- Yeah. - That'll be awesome. - All right, Felipe, see
you really soon, buddy. - Thanks, Nev. - Obviously, we've known
from previous seasons, if you don't speak on
the phone, big problems. Someone's getting out
of the passenger seat. There's a lady on the left
and a guy on the right. Do you know who these people are? - I know the female. - [Max] Who is she?
- Yo do? - Yeah, I've hung out
with her a few times. - [Nev] Like, dated her?
- Yeah. - Did you diss her? - No, she kind of dissed me. - How you doing? - Hi, I'm good. - What's your name? - My name is Alex. - Alex?
- Yes. - Okay, hi. And your name? - Louis.
- Louis. Good to meet you, I'm Nev and this is Max. - Hi.
- Hi. - What's funny? - I'm not laughing, I'm just-- - [Louis] Nervous. - Yeah. - [Nev] Nervous, okay. - Who's Jasmine? - Me. - You're Jasmine? - [Nev] Okay. - [Max] Then who are you? - Well, I'm his best friend. I'm here, because I dated Felipe and I found out that he
was messaging Jasmine. Louis told me. I felt, you know, really hurt. I didn't say anything. I just stopped it. - Wait, have you guys ever met? - No. - So let me just clarify. So, when did you guys start dating? - Like in June. - So, six months ago. And according to Felipe,
you messaged him-- - Way before that. - Right. You had of this profile for Jasmine and at some point you saw
Felipe, you started talking. Then after you guys started talking, you guys started dating. - Yeah. - I've known about this
profile for awhile. - His Jasmine profile?
- Yes. At the beginning, I was
like totally against it. I was like, you know,
why would you do that? But he wasn't gonna listen to me. - For as long as you
guys have been friends he's had this Jasmine profile? - Yeah. - Never really cared until you found out that
his fake girl profile was talking to the guy
you were sleeping with. - Yeah. - What are the chances that he randomly-- - It's a small town.
- [Alex] Very small town. - So everyone, literally everyone in town is like friends with everyone. - You've had like an eight month, pretty romantic relationship with Felipe as a female on the internet, so why? - It wasn't really romantic. - Yes, it was. You guys talked about being together. You talked about like a future together. - I didn't really know him, so it was like, I'm not trying to be mean, but I didn't have no feelings, it was just like, whatever. - Do you use the Jasmine
profile to meet guys? - No. So then why Felipe? - It wasn't, I mean, I don't know. It just... - [Nev] I mean, are you attracted to him? - No. It's not like, no. - Are you attracted to men? - [Louis] No. - Okay, 'cause--
- [Louis] Yeah, I know. - That's just what it looks like. - That's what it looks like to me also. - You wanted to have a
relationship with Felipe. - But I didn't, like, I swear, dude. - But then why? - It was just a messing game. Like, it's not just with him, like it was multiple people
and like I said, I take-- - Multiple people or multiple guys? - Multiple guys? - Like, girls and guys. It all started as a joke. And I just, I guess I
just got so used to it and I was just like
playing along with that. - [Nev] What's up? - Nah, I just had to walk
away for a little bit. Little pissed right now, just was like two seconds
from just going off, so I just had to walk away. - I felt like I was played with, I felt like I was just taken advantage of, by my friend and the
person who I was with, because why are you sitting here messaging other girls on Facebook? - My anger is just
starting to build up again, because who I am, he pretty much just told me in my face that I was a joke. It's just crazy right now. - "Is this Dorothy ever
going to meet her Oz? "Dear Dave and max, my name is Zak, "I'm a 27 year old from
Wilmington, Delaware. ♪ I see you clearly now ♪ "I'm reaching out because I met a guy, "his name is Garrett
and he's from Kansas." - Kansas, Oz. - "I found myself falling
for Garrett pretty hard. ♪ If I beg you to stay, will you stay ♪ ♪ 'Cause you know I am
too hard to please ♪ "He's just so charismatic "and always knows exactly what to say "to put a silly grin on my face. ♪ If I beg you to stay, will you stay ♪ ♪ 'Cause you know I am
too hard to please ♪ "He gives me flutterbies,
as in butterflies "every time I see his
name light up my screen. ♪ If I beg you to stay, will you stay ♪ ♪ 'Cause you know I am
too hard to please ♪ "But I wish his face
would light up my screen, "not just his name. "Every time I call on video chat, "the room is almost pitch black "and I can only make out
the shape of his head. "I decided that I liked Garrett enough "to want to meet in person "and offered to fly to Kansas to meet him. "At first, he agreed, but
then he told me to hold off. "He said he wanted to meet
me, just not right now. "Then I suddenly couldn't
get a hold of him. "He changed his number
and forgot to tell me. "WTF!" - [Max] Change number, whoa. - "I really like Garrett "and I want to see if
there's any sort of future "there for us or if I'm
just wasting my time "chasing a hopeless fairytale. "I need your help." I think we should help this kid. - Should we wear our silly smiles? - Hey, what's up? Nice hair. - My wavy hair. - Yeah. - It's very natural, actually. - That is nice. (Zak laughs) So, you're in Delaware? - Yes. - Have you always lived in Delaware? - I'm actually from Montana. - Oh, okay. Cool. - A couple of years ago,
I met somebody online, surprise, surprise, and
I just kind of decided to move to Delaware. - And then what happened with the guy that you moved to Delaware for? - He just wasn't really
ready for a relationship. - So you're at a crossroads and there's this guy, Garrett in Kansas. - Yes. - Tell us about this guy. - So, I have this online
persona, called Zacheri and Zachari is my overly
gay persona that I created, because I ended up in some drama amongst some Facebook friends that felt I was being too over the top. So I created a separate account that I could kind of
be how I wanted to be. Pretty soon I was getting 40
to 60 friend requests a day from people, mostly gay guys. They would be sending me
messages and dick pics. I was like, "Oh, thank you. "I'm so flattered, but no." So, finally one day, Garrett
made a comment on my Facebook and I thought he was
the cutest boy I'd seen. He was not like everybody else. He didn't message me, we
just kind of communicated through comments here and there. And so, finally, one day, I decided that I was gonna message him. And I was like, "Hey, I
just thought I'd stop by "and say, hey, I think
you're kind of cute." We started talking more frequently. Like I've opened up to him. I've told him hopes and dreams and fears and he seems like he
genuinely cares for me. But then things got weird. He got a new phone number and
just kind of forgot to tell me that he got a new phone number, he like changed jobs that I
didn't know anything about. And when we Skype, it's usually at night, so I just can see like
the silhouette of a face. - Oh my God! - Come on, Zak. - Why do you think you're
so kind of interested? - He's a catfish. - What is it about him? - I can't explain it. He just has this air of trust around him, like I trust him with everything. I could see a potential future with him, but I mean, you can only know so much about a person from being online, which I learned the hard
way by moving to Delaware. - You're really rolling
the dice with this guy, but I'm always up for the adventure, I say, like, go for it. That's my vote. - All right. I mean, if you're going
for it, I'm going for it. - Plus, you could fly out to Los Angeles. - That's right. - Yeah, I'm sure the weather's probably way better in LA than it is here. - So let's walk down the yellow brick road and see what we find or skip, we can skip. - Sounds great. - Bring your red shoes. - [Nev] All right, Zak.
- Thanks, guys. - [Nev] See you soon. - Bye. When I offered to fly out to Kansas, he was onboard at first, "Yeah, I'd love to see you." I was like, "Cool, you know,
I'm gonna book my ticket." And he's like, "Ah,
maybe don't book it yet." And then I texted him
and it didn't go through. And so, I tried a few more times. It's like, message not delivered. So I sent him a Facebook message. "Hey, what's up? "Is your phone shut off?" I kept waiting for him to message me, a couple of weeks later, he's like, "Oh my God, I completely forgot." - How's he going to forget to tell you when you're his future husband? - Things happen, I guess. (phone rings) - Hello? - [Olga] Hey, it's Olga. I was supposed to pick
up Garrett at the airport and I can't get a hold of him. He was supposed to land
about 20 minutes ago or so. We're sort of not sure
if he got on the flight? - Is there any way to see
if he got on the flight? Like, can you-- - [Olga] I'm trying to reach our production manager right now. It's Sunday, so maybe she's just doesn't have a phone nearby. - All right.
- Weird. - All right. Well, yeah, so we're just gonna hang out until I hear from you. - [Olga] All right, bye. - Bye. - [Max] We've lost Garrett. This is bad though. - This is kind of what he does to me. - Is he just gonna ghost us? - [Katie] Hello? - Hey, Katie, it's Nev. - [Katie] Hey. - Quick question and up-- - [Garrett] Hello? - Oh, wait, I'll call you right back. - [Katie] Okay. - Who is it? Is that him? Did he just come on his own? Is that what's happening right now? (suspenseful music) Oh, wait a minute. What?
- Hi. - It's you, like, this is actually you. Well, come on in. We didn't know if you'd made it or not. - I landed and then I had the
address, so I just kind of-- - So you jumped in a cab?
- Yeah. - Look at that. Well, Max, Nev, Zak. - Hi. - We were concerned, 'cause we hadn't necessarily heard that you landed. Anyway, it doesn't matter, you're here. - Okay. - [Max] So what's the deal? - Yeah? You seem exactly as you promised. We're confused. - [Max] Why didn't you FaceTime him? There's the whole mystery. - There's a lot that goes into that. This guy I was really
into lived in Georgia. We did sort of an online
long distance relationship, we were together for
about almost two years. I flew him back to
Wichita, he stayed with me. Everything was cool
and then he gets a call at three in the morning,
basically from this guy he was dating and I kind of flipped out. - So, your ex-boyfriend had fallen in love with someone in Georgia. What was up with this
whole thing with him, hacking your profile? - He got really angry and then basically hacked
my Facebook account. So, I'm kind of hesitant to the whole long distance
online relationship. - Sure, but the whole shroud of mystery and the double profile and not telling him about your other profile. - The other profile's sort
of irrelevant, the Gary one. - Right. - That's how my family and
close friends use to address me. I made that profile as
something I could use to hide this part of
my life from my family. - [Nev] So, you created
a second more generic friends and family page. - Just like Zak. You guys... (laughs) - [Garrett] I grew up in a
very small Catholic town. - What were you so worried, that Zak would be disappointed about? - I just kind of felt that I
didn't want to let you down. That's why I didn't basically show myself, the whole FaceTime thing, 'cause I was still like
trying to keep my guard up. And I was kind of hesitant, because you also had
two Facebook profiles. - So hold on a second. So there's no big, crazy-- - [Max] Yeah, what's the big deal? - Thing that you've been hiding? - It's basically, I just
didn't want to be vulnerable to another person,
falling for someone online and being vulnerable to them,
it's kind of nerve wracking. - I offered to come to Kansas to see you. Why didn't you want me to come see you? - Basically when I first came
out, my family told me to lie. They told me to keep everything
to myself, tell nobody and basically be like their straight son, so I was terrified for
our first time to meet to be where they are at. I wanted to meet you first,
before I start telling my family, there's this
great guy that I met that I'm super into and-- - Is that true? - Yes. - That you're into him? - That you met a great guy
and you're super into him? - Yeah. - Okay, just making sure. Zak, how do you feel right now? - [Nev] You've been very quiet. - I'm kind of shocked
that you turned out to be who you said you were going to be. We probably have a lot to catch up on. - Yeah, there's a lot we
should probably talk about. - I am going to go to our email here. Here's the email from Tamirra and the subject is, "Blinded by love". "Hey, Nev and Kamie! "My name is Tamirra and
I really need your help! "My best friend, Jason, has been talking "to a guy named Keith
for the past two years. "Jason tells me he loves him
and even wants to marry him. "Keith is sweet, sexy, and attentive. "And Jason won't stop
talking about this guy. "But Jason lives in LA and this Keith guy "lives in Detroit and they've
never met or even FaceTimed. "He has stood Jason up multiple times. "Recently, Jason went to Detroit-- - And let me guess, nothing happened. - "He went all the way there "and Keith stood him up again. "This has all gone on too long. "He needs help seeing the signs. "You guys are my last hope, Tamirra. Oh! - Hello, Jason. - Hey, surprise. - Oh, you... (laughs) What the (beep)? (laughs) O M G, I can't even
believe this right now. - Do you think this whole
quarantine was gonna stop us? - Well, I mean... (laughs) - Nothing can stop "Catfish". - Yeah, I guess not. (laughs) - Hearing a little bit about
your relationship with Keith and we're very curious to
learn a little bit more. - So, I've been single
for like four years. I was in a relationship
for quite some time and I was doing hair with a lot of different celebrity styles and stuff and I was getting a lot
of Instagram followers. So I was scrolling through it and then I came across his introduction. He was like, "I think you're attractive." I was like, "Okay, I think
you're attractive too." - What is it about him that
you're so in love with? - I like how I am treated. I like how I'm spoken to. I like the way that he
pay attention to me. He just fills that little
void, that's there. - Tamirra mentioned that, like, you guys have talked about being together and maybe even getting married. - Just so it doesn't seem so crazy. - It already seems pretty crazy. (all laugh) - And I brought up marriage
because I was engaged before and I would like to create my own family. So, you know, it's something
that's on the table. - And he wants to start a family? - Yeah, he was cool with that. We're in a place where
we want to be together and now, unfortunately we can't even make that happen because of this. And God knows how long this
could even take, you know? - You did try to see him
in Detroit or something? - I was in Detroit, I got stuck there. It's like 11 hour
layover and I hit him up. He was on his way over with his friend. And he said his friend's car broke down. I was annoyed, 'cause I told him, I said, "You keep making (beep)
excuses all the time. So I said to him, you know, "I'm not going to keep doing
a long distance relationship. "I think that you should move to LA." He comes to LA for work sometimes. - Oh, like since you've
been talking to him? - He actually texted me the other night and said that he's surprised he came here. - Wait, whoa, who, whoa. This week? - There's no way. - I don't know. - It's COVID-19 and you fly to LA? - Listen, if he's here, he's stupid, 'cause one, I will not see you. You need to go sit down
somewhere for two weeks. - You have not ever
FaceTimed with this person, but they can fly to LA because
they want to see you so badly during the middle of a pandemic. - Right, why not FaceTime me? Why not Zoom me? Why not Skype? I mean, you send him money. - Who? - What? What happened? - (beep) you up so bad. - [Nev] You sent him money? - I did send him money once. It was to get another phone
as the other one was broken. - [Kamie] How much money was it? - [Jason] It was like 800 bucks. - He still hasn't FaceTimed
you, on the phone you bought. - Ooh. - Yeah. All right. Speaking of red flags here,
we looked at his Instagram. What the hell's going on? There are pictures of
different guys on there. - No, some of those pictures
are him when he was younger. - So, like before he had
the tattoos and stuff? - Yeah. I mean, you know how
often people get tattoos, they can have one today and not yesterday. - I think, clearly there
are a couple images on his Instagram that are questionable. - The faces are different people. - These are two different
people, like skin tone. - [Nev] Does that just not bother you? - It is him. - What will it mean for you if this guy isn't who he says he is? - I'll get (beep) heated. I mean, it will mean that, you know, just another deceitful bastard. You know what I mean? I'm not convinced that he's not him. Everybody wants the truth and this is the perfect time to get it. - Yeah. - So, we're gonna do some research, see what we can find out about this guy. And at the very least,
try and get you guys to finally video chat. - [Jason] Yeah. - Hopefully you can definitely get him to take off those rose colored glasses. (Jason laughs) - Thank God for having
good friends like that, 'cause they always got your back. - Exactly. - We'll speak to you guys soon, all right? - See you guys later, have a good day. - Bye. - Oh, man. - Where are my flags when I need them? - Most of this guy's story-- - Is bull (beep). - Yeah, right. - There's something about this Keith guy that is keeping him around. - [Nev] Keith is an absurdly bold liar who will say anything. I definitely think this
guy's getting messed with to a very large degree. - Normally we have like a
little bit of an inkling, like the door will open. There is nothing that is
like preparing this moment. - Unless we made the Zoom calls, and maybe there's a
way you can do it like, so people have to request-- Oh! (suspenseful music) Is that Keith there? Press the button. - [Keith] Y'all can't just
come barge into my life, like, what is it that y'all trying to do? Why do I have to reveal myself now? That's what I want to know. - Why wouldn't you ever
reveal yourself before? You have been scamming me for two years. - [Keith] I did not want to hurt you. - What would hurt me? The vision of you? The sight of your face? Like, what the (beep) supposed to hurt me? - I mean, obviously
the guy in the picture, you feel like the guy is fake, but you still have been in love
with me and my personality. - But who are you? When do I get to see who you are? Like you see me right now. This is exactly what you see, all day, every day, Instagram, whatever-- - [Keith] Okay, fine. All y'all coming at me sideways. Like y'all making me nervous. (suspenseful music) - All right, hey. - Hi.
- Hi. What's the problem, Keith? - Because I don't want to
deal, like I'm already hurt. I'm embarrassed. Y'all got me on this camera and now what? Like, what's up? - You're an attractive guy. What is the tea? - It's no tea. - But let's just clear something up. So, wait, Keith, that's your name right? Keith? - My name is Tayy. - Tayy.
- Tayy. - All right. Well, nice to meet you. And you live in Detroit? - Correct. - What do you do for work? - I'm like a model, a fashion
model and stuff like that. - Is there a reason why you
haven't in the last two years, told him the truth about who you are? - I really, I didn't mean to catfish you, like this is not a fish fry. But that's the only way
that I can get with you. - You didn't try to hit
me up this way first, so you never gave me the
opportunity to get to know you. - We actually met a couple of times and I didn't know how he
was gonna react, because-- - Where? - I met you in LA out before like at a couple of clubs out there. We actually had conversations
and exchanged numbers, but you never called the number, so I assumed at that point,
like, I wasn't your type and you know, you weren't feeling me. - I meet a lot of people when
I go out, but I don't know. - I'll reveal myself, so now, like, y'all want to see the whole. So, basically, what you're telling me, is that you don't recognize me at all. - No, I don't remember you. I don't have a Tayy in my phone, period. - Why Jason? Jason's great, but
like, why do all of this and go to such great lengths? Did you create this page and like customize it just for Jason? - Yeah. Jason, he got, I'm
attracted to his lifestyle and what he do and what
he can bring to the table. So that's what I like. - Do you really like Jason for him or is it just what you see on Instagram, 'cause you know he's popping? - I mean, at first,
when it all started off, like it was like that,
it was just like for him, it was for the lifestyle. But then once I actually got
to know him over the time, things did grow and now I
do have feelings for him, but I'm gonna just be honest, I do have a boyfriend in real life. - You gotta go. You're (beep) wack. - [Keith] Listen-- - No, (beep) you, I don't
want to listen to you. Liar. Lying ass. - Pause, hold on. Jason, he has been worse
to me over the two years than my actual, you know,
the person who I'm dating. Jason, he buys me red bottoms
and everything like that. - Bitch, don't lie. - So that's what the money was for? That Jason was sending
you, for red bottoms? - Supposedly, it was for a phone. - Well, yeah, I did get me a
pair of Christian Louboutins. - So you want to have
your cake and eat it too. You want to have a boyfriend
in real life in Detroit, you want to have a sugar
daddy that lives in LA. What do you think that this is? - Tell your little boo, to
go get him a (beep) job, where he can afford your
lifestyle that you want to have, which is the one that I currently live, which neither one of
you bitches gonna get. - I got to say, I'm not really buying it. You seem like you made a profile to talk to successful
guys who have a following to see who will fall for
it and send you money. You're like a con artist. That's the vibe I'm getting. - (laughs) That's crazy. And it's not even like that. My loyalty lies to
Jason more than anybody, because I've been with him for two years. - Yeah, but I don't buy that, because your aunt called and said for me to stop ruining the
(beep) perfect relationship. - Yeah, because strange
people keep calling her phone. - We didn't call her, she called us. - Your aunt contacted us and left us a very sassy voicemail. - She just don't want
charges all up in my space, because my boyfriend
actually just like proposed to me two weeks ago. - So you're engaged. You don't have a boyfriend,
you have a fiance. - Yes, here's my ring right here. I said yes. The wedding is actually in Cali, so... I'll leave the wedding the way how it is and then I'll just replace the person who I'm marrying now with Jason. - Boy, bye. - Look, we got to figure
out what's going on here. Let's take a break. - I'm going to take a break. (laughs) - Let Jason think about this
and see what we want to do. Tayy, we'll be in touch with you shortly. - Okay. - Bye. - Bye. - What is with that guy? I mean, I don't believe anything he says. - He's full of (beep). - Full of... - We need to figure out if this guy has anything real to tell us, 'cause if not, we're done. - Who the (beep) was I
in a relationship with? 'Cause you're just a
bamboozling lying bastard. - Nev and I, both think
he's full of (beep). But I want to know if you actually think that you have met him in real life. - No, we never had a dialogue. You never called me, I never called you. You didn't text me, I didn't text you. I'll tell you one thing
that I know for sure, this person is all about my lifestyle. - Cloud. - (beep) cloud chaser. - This is all just like
a performance for him. The hits just keep coming, you know? Oh, and by the way, this
and I'm in a relationship and actually he's my fiance. - He's an actor. He is an actor. - Well, guess what, honey? There's no (beep) tickets to your show and nobody is sitting in your front row. - Oh. (laughs) - I'm gonna assume that
you're not interested in Tayy. - No, I am not. - I would be concerned if you were. - [Nev] "Help me meet my Tomorrow." - Very poetic. - It sounds like we might be
doing some time traveling. "Dear Nev and Max, my name is Tyreme "and I am a 27 year old father of two "living in Newport News, Virginia." - Newport News, Virginia. - "About nine months ago, I
met the girl of my dreams. "Her name is Tomorrow." - Wait, her name is Tomorrow. - When he says, "Help
me meet my Tomorrow.", he literally means Tomorrow. "We started talking on Facebook "and immediately exchanged numbers. "We talk daily and she
has become my best friend. "She is the most beautiful
girl I have ever seen. ♪ It's hard to tell the
difference between you love ♪ ♪ In a true love that
will never ever fail ♪ "She was there to comfort me
when I lost two people I love. ♪ Out of the shadows I'll
come dancing and laughing ♪ ♪ Can you hear it ♪ "I'm ready to move to
Alabama to be with her." Wow. "I talk to her all the time "and I've even talked to
her family over the phone. "I know Tomorrow is the one for me "and I hope this relationship is my last. "But there are some things that
just don't make sense to me. "I've asked to video chat
with Tomorrow multiple times, "but she says her camera is broken." I mean, come on. - How often do cameras break? They don't break that often. - No. "We've tried to meet,
but she lives in Alabama "and money has always kept us apart. "I'm at a point in my life
where I want to settle down, "but I'm just starting to think
that something isn't right. "Please help me meet her in person "and finally figure out
if this is the woman "I'm going to spend the
rest of my life with. "Thanks, Tyreme." - This is gonna get
really confusing though, talking about Tomorrow. When are we gonna meet Tomorrow? - Do you want to meet Tomorrow? (Max laughs) All right, well, why don't
we get Tyreme on Skyperoo? Oh!
- Hey! - [Nev] Tyreme, what's up? - What's up, fellas? - So tell us a little bit more about you. What do you do in Newport News, Virginia? - At the moment I'm unemployeed, but I like to draw and I'm a great artist, so everybody, you know, be like, "Ty, why don't you do
tattoos or anything?" You know, I would like to try that. - How did you meet Tomorrow? - When I had posted
something and she liked it, then you know, I sent her a message. Then I even started
talking up, like, late, when we exchanged numbers. - What does Tomorrow look like? - Like a goddess. Just beautiful woman. Falling asleep on the phone, call each other in the morning, throughout the day we'll talk and text. I asked her would she want
to, you know, date me first, then she said no at first,
and then the day after, she turned around and
asked me, I said, "Sure." - Tell us a little bit more about her. How old is she? What does she do? - She's what? 25. She works at a nursing
home in the kitchen. - And what do you love about Tomorrow? - She'll be there for me. I'll be there for her through, whatever. You know, we're both diabetic. When she told me, I was, oh, damn, she doesn't really keep up with it though I try to help her
out as much as I can. A couple of days ago, she left work because she was feeling
lightheaded, everything like, maybe it's your diabetes, she's like, "Well, that's the same thing my mom said." I'm like, "Well, you
need to listen to us." You know, I've talked to her mother, talked to her uncle, aunt, I
even talked to her grandfather. - Wow.
- Really? - It can't be the same person
doing all those voices, right? - [Tyreme] No. - Has she ever sent you like
a video message or anything? - Nothing videos, just straight images. - No video. Not even something that
she made in a video and then sent to you? - No. - What do you want to happen? - I want this relationship
to be my last relationship. I'm pretty sure that she
wants the same thing. I love this girl. And I even bought her a big teddy bear for Valentine's Day, though. Which I haven't sent to her yet. I want to give it to her in person. That's what I want to do. - I hope we can make that happen for ya. - Please, please, please. I would love for you guys to, really. - All right. Well, sit tight. We'll come to Virginia and
hopefully we'll meet Tomorrow and your whole life will change. - You mean we'll meet up tomorrow? - We'll meet up-- - We'll meet up with you tomorrow. - That's not Tomorrow, that's Tyreme. - But we'll meet up with Tomorrow-- - In a couple of days. - [Max] Right. - All right, sit tight. We'll see you soon, okay? - All right, peace out. - Bye. Okay, let's start at the top. Okay, so this is Tomorrow? - [Tyreme] Yeah. - [Nev] She's very pretty. - She is. - [Max] She's got an iPhone six. - [Nev] Yeah, that's an iPhone six. - [Max] And her phone has two cameras, so both cameras on her phone are broken? - That's her sister's phone. - Oh.
- Oh. Sure it is. Okay, what is that? Missouri State? Yeah. - Mississippi State. - [Nev] Are you sure? - That says Missouri. - Oh, does it? (knock on door) (suspenseful music) - Ah, someone's coming. - [Max] Someone's coming right now. - Yeah. - [Christina] Hello.
- Hello. Hi. - How are you doing? - Nev. - Christina. - Christina, yes. We saw your Facebook page. How are ya? - I'm fine, just a little nervous. - You're nervous? Okay, well, so are we. We're really not sure what to expect. I don't know if you know Tyreme at all. - I've heard of him, but
I don't know him at all. - Okay. Well this is Tyreme. - Nice to meet you. - Same to you. - And do you know Letrease? Okay, Shodesia? - Yeah, I know her as well too. - Yeah, okay, so, did
they all get my messages? - I'm not sure, but
when you replied to me, I know I had to, you know, reply, because I feel kind of
responsible for some of it. - [Nev] Oh, okay. Well, is it just you here right now? - No. Well, you guys came to Dolting, so I guess it's time for
us to kind of, you know, reveal everything that's going on. - Okay. - Okay. All right, just one second. - Okay. She says she's sort of kind of involved. - [Max] Yeah, she said--
- But not really. - Right. Who knows? Who knows? Maybe there's like seven girls
that are in love with you. - Hi, I'm Tomorrow. - [Nev] Did you say that you're Tomorrow? - Yes, I'm Tomorrow. - You're Tomorrow, okay. And you're Letrease? Okay, hi, I'm Nev. - Nice to meet you. - Nice to meet you. - Hi, I'm Max. - Nice to meet you. - And this is Tyreme. So it's just you guys here right now or? - Yes.
- It's just us. - Okay, what's the story? - Okay, I'm just her best friend. She told me about this a couple months ago and stuff like that. And when she told me about
it, I kind of, you know, thought it was at some point in time, you have to come clean. So, that's why we're here. - I never meant to hurt you, Ty. I made a fake page to get back at my ex, which never happened. So one day I was liking his
posts and it went from there. But I never thought I
was gonna fall in love with someone over the internet. - But why though? I mean, you could have... You know me, I done kept
everything with you straight and... - I have asked you questions about myself and you have gave me answers that I really didn't want to hear. - As Tomorrow, you asked him about you? - Yes, sir. - What kind of questions were you asking? - Basically, if I'm his type and he was like, "No, he would
never date someone like me." Then when my feeling
got deeper and deeper, there's plenty of times I was like, "Ty, will you go with her,
'cause I know she's ugly." To the point I started dogging myself out. Yeah, she is ugly. Yeah, she is big. - You talked to Tomorrow about Letrease and used some of that language. - Yeah. - Well, that kind of made
me nervous even more. To like Tyreme, that's
not me on the picture, but everything I said, it's me, only the picture was fake. - And who's phone are you using? - It's my phone. - Why is it in her name? - She's underneath the
same account with me. - And who's Shedisia? - That's my baby sister. - [Nev] That's your little sister? - So how many people are reading the texts that you send to Tomorrow? - Just one person. - Just you? - But he's talked to other people, right? - He spoke to my mom. She didn't know what was going on. - He said you guys spoke about diabetes. - Yes, I do have diabetes. That is true. - Unfortunately, that's
the one thing that is true. - Yes, sir.
