(phone ringing) - Oh.
- Oh, what? - We're getting -
where's the phone? - Oh, it's Kailani, hello? - [Kailani] Sam just called me. He told me he was on his way. - On his way to where? - [Kailani] He took an Uber and he's driving
towards my house. - [Max] Jesus.
- Okay, well, we're just leaving the hotel, so we'll just get
over there quickly. - [Kailani] I really don't
want to meet him alone. - [Nev] No, no, no,
we'll be there soon. - [Kailani] Okay. - [Nev] Bye. Whoa! All of a sudden, he's Uber-ing? - [Max] That's
weird, that's weird. - We better get there fast. - I mean, he's on his way there. - If he gets there before us
we could be in big trouble. I wish we had a siren. - I know, we need
a Catfish siren. - [Shirlene] Oh my gosh. - [Nev] I know, just
like a weird PIN. Somewhere in this area. - Start honking your horn. - Must be one of these
houses right here 'cause this is like
where the PIN is. - Do you want me to text
him, like, "we're here"? - I thought I just - - You saw that person? - [Kamie] Wait, what? - I thought I just saw somebody
like behind that fence, sort of sneaky-looking. Crouching down. - What the (beep). - I mean, I guess we could look
and see if that's the house. - Wait, I'm not
getting out, okay? - You don't wanna get out? - Unh-unh. - You stay here. - Okay. - Let me see if
someone's in there. Sweet dog. (phone dinging) - I got a message. - You did? - "Are you at the blue house?" - Yes. - Yes. - Come on. Let's go. - Wait, no, no, no, I'm
not getting out yet. - Shirlene, it's
now or never, girl. - Stay right there,
stay right there. - [Kamie] Are you ready? - [Shirlene] Yeah. - [Kamie] Come on. - [Nev] How you doin? - [Catfish] I'm
nervous, really nervous. - [Nev] Nervous, okay,
well that's okay. I think we're all
a little nervous. - Who is he talking to? - I don't know. - [Nev] Why don't you come out? - Stand by me. (dramatic music) (gate creaking open) - [Kamie] Whaaaat? Hi. - What's up? - I'm Kamie. - Mya. - Mya? - Mya, yeah. - Nice to meet you. - [Nev] And this, as
you know, is Shirlene. - [Mya] Yeah. - So, James? Is that - - Is he real? - No. - Is it you? - Yeah. - [Nev] It's been
you the whole time? - [Mya] Yeah. - [Nev] Okay. - Why did you do this to me? I mean, you basically wasted my
time coming out here. I have a little boy. - Yeah. - Let's go in here. - [Mya] Okay. - [Nev] Just so you
don't have to feel like everybody's looking at you. Do you live here in Tuba City? - [Mya] Yeah, I live
here and in Zuni. - Okay, so you are Zuni? - Half Navajo, half Zuni. - [Nev] Half Navajo,
half Zuni, okay. And how old are you? - I'm 18. - You're a youngin'. I'm way older than you. Oh my gosh, this is weird. Are those little girls real? - The daughters that
James said died, are those - - No. - It's a (beep) up
thing to lie about. - Yeah, I would never
lie about my son dying. Like, that part you
should have never said. - I know. - How did you come up
with all these lies? You talked about kids,
you talked about dying. You talked about a lot of stuff. I cried, I literally cried. - When I did that, that
was of me trying to let that profile die down, and I tried shutting it down but I couldn't really
let it go and everything because I would have
no one else to talk to. - [Nev] And when did you
start the James profile? - Roughly, I can say
about two years ago After my sister passed
away from drinking. That's when that
James profile came in. That love, I was missing
that love, that affection, that comfort from somebody. - So, was the profile
mostly talking to women or men? - Both. Just to create a friendship and to create a bond. - Shirlene tells
us that she thought you guys were in a
romantic relationship. Is that how it felt for you? You thought this was kind
of like your boyfriend? - Yeah. - You guys were
sharing "I love you's". You said I love
you after a month. - Well yeah, but you know like best friends
can say that too. They say like, "oh, I love you." - Right, but when a hot guy
tells a cute girl "I love you", it means something different than when two best buddy
girlfriends say "I love you". - Yeah. - [Nev] So, for her, that "I
love you" meant a lot more. - [Mya] Yeah. - And you knew that? - Yeah.
- [Nev] You had to know that. - Yeah. If you wanna be mad and
frustrated with me - - Oh, I'm mad. - I understand that. I just did it because I was
missing that love and affection. You know, you were that person
that was there to listen to what I had to say. I told you things that I
never even told nobody. I never even told my
family, my friends, nothing. And when my sister passed
away, I was put in foster care. - I grew up in part of that too. - That (beep) was rough, man. Like, they took my little
brother away from me. They took a lot of
things away from me. I'm really sorry, I
really wanted to tell you. (Mya sighing) But I never got that
courage to tell you. - So, I don't know
what your feelings are and what you're
comfortable talking about, but, I'm willing to bet that
you do have feelings for her. - No. When we talked, it's like,
she's really there to listen. And that's what I liked about
her, that she can listen. She's caring, she's
loving, she's smart. But it was like a friendship. (Dallas shivering) - [Nev] Here we are here. - [Dallas] We're here! I'm scared! - Let's do it. (Dallas groaning) - I'm nervous. - [Nev] Let's find a nice
little quiet corner back here. - [Dallas] This
little quiet corner. - [Nev] So, now we wait. - [Dallas] Oh
(beep) I'm nervous. - [Nev] I see a guy over here. - [Dallas] No, don't do that. - [Nev] Shirtless man. I think this guy is
walking this way. - You better not walk this way. Stay over there with your dog. I like your dog, though. Nice dog. - [Nev] Okay, he's just
taking the dog for a walk. - Yo, my heart is
actually (beep). My heart is (beep) going. - [Nev] Who's this
guy, over there? - I swear, no, dude. It's not, it's not, it's no way. I've seen that (beep) guy. - You've seen him before? - I've seen him before,
it better not be him. - Wait, where have you
seen that guy before? - Just like living in LA. - [Nev] No, seriously? - I swear, it better
not be that (beep) guy. Don't come over here, dude. I swear. Y'all are (beep) kidding, bro. - Hello. - [Tallulah] Hi. - Oh my gosh, bro. - [Nev] What's your name? - William. - [Nev] William, hi,
Nev, nice to meet you. This is Tallulah. - Hi, I'm Tallulah. - [William] Nice to meet you. - Nice to meet you. - [Dallas] Nah, bro. - So - - I (beep) knew it
was some (beep). This is beyond me, bro. - [Nev] Hold on, let's
just get an explanation. So, what is going on? - I saw him a few times,
like, around town. Slut Walk a few times and
some Amber Rose events. - [Nev] Okay, so you have
some mutual social circles. - Yeah, I've seen
him a few times. And I was like, you know, I thought he was
a really hot guy, and he's posting all these
photos of his like ass on Instagram and
Tumblr and whatever. And I was with my friend Safari, and we were on
social media drunk, and she was like, "you
should totally DM him." And I'm like, oh my
God, I'm so nervous. I couldn't do such a thing. Like, I don't think he's gay. She's like, "well
just look at how he's posting his photos on Instagram, he's got an Only Fans page." That he uses to, you know,
target the gay community. (dramatic music) - [Nev] Wait a second. Only Fans, what's that? - Dallas is always
posting his nudes. You can subscribe to his stuff - [Nev] And people subscribe, and he'll host special content? Do you have subscribers? - Yeah. - And Safari said, why don't
I just give him my number? and then it's
really your number. - Who was he texting with? - Me. - [Nev] But then why
approach him as a woman? - I feel like girls can
make a guy feel comfortable. Like, let's say a
threesome or a foursome. You know, I could have
been that fourth person in his threesome. - That (beep) is weird, bro, I'm sorry. - So, you asked
about a threesome, he even said he would be down. Then you suggested
the roommate, not you. - But he was okay with that. - Why not suggest
yourself or then say, okay, Safari let's go meet him? Like, why not see if it
actually could happen? - We were gonna do that, and then Catfish
came out of nowhere. - Okay, so the plan was - - [William] To
eventually get to that - (Dallas groaning) 'cause these guys are so,
like these guys are so - - This is beyond me, bro! - Most of his fans are gay. - But that ain't got nothin
to do with what I like. - Kinda feels like you're
trying to blame him for the fact that you
lied and pretended to be - - No, it is not lying, I'm
not pretending to be someone. - You've been pretending
be Safari for two months. - You a catfish-catfish, bro. This is some -
- [William] No. No, no, no, no. - But surely you understand
that it still feels like you don't think you
did anything wrong? - I didn't do
anything maliciously, I wasn't asking for money. - That's true. - So, if I wasn't doing
none of those things, I don't feel like in a sense
of I was doing any harm. We didn't mean for
someone to call Catfish. - Just ask me, be like,
"bro, you gay? You get down?" And I'd be like, no, it
would've ended right there. - Dallas, calm down, like - - [Dallas] Bro, I'm sorry - - If you're not (beep) gay - - He's allowed to
have his feelings. - I understand that he's
okay to have that feeling but if he's not (beep)
gay then why do you sell to the community and make
money off the community? - But I think that's a
really unfair argument because I think that then you're
making a decision for him. I think that you can kind
of say that like, you know - - [William] Well, it
could go both ways - - Girls dress a certain way then that means
something about them. - I think it's fair to say that it would be
easy to interpret his social media presence
as someone who might be bisexual, whatever. - Yes, of course. - [Nev] I still don't think
that makes it okay, though. - We were going to go to
find out where Dallas lives, arrange a date and to talk
to him about this situation, get him comfortable. - Okay, but he wanted
to meet up so bad. Why not meet up all these times? - I already knew you mutually,
you shoulda just been like, "yo, let's hangout." - Because I wanted
to do it with Safari but she was always gone. - [Nev] So, she's
just not in LA a lot? - Yeah, I don't wanna
do it by myself. We were supposed to
all hang out and talk. She's gonna introduce
me as her friend. - Right. And then from there? - And then from
there she would have faded off away eventually, and then me and
him would have got on a personal relationship. Who knows what
would have happened? But now we have - - Not that. - [William] Dallas, come on. I apologize if it
came off wrong. Safari can tell you
her side of the story - Where's Safari? - Safari is at her
friend's house. - In LA or is she in Arizona? - In LA. - [Dallas] She is in LA. - [William] If you wanna
talk to her about it. - [Nev] Okay, great,
so she's here. I mean, yeah, I would
like to hear from her. - I will go and call Safari
and send you guys the address. - Alright, so, text us where
to meet you and Safari. - Okay, for sure I will. - [Nev] Alright, thanks. - [Dallas] That's crazy. (dramatic music) - Okay. I'm gonna go wait
for him in the lobby. - Alright. - See you guys in a second. - [Rashad] This is it, man. Finally get an opportunity
to meet who James is. Is this what you envisioned? - No, not at all. I didn't think that there
were gonna be many lies. - [Rashad] Especially this many. - Especially type like this. It just, yes, it threw me
off a little bit. - Oh, someone's here. Is this him? Are you James? - [Catfish] Hi. Is he okay? - [Nev] He is, but
he's very eager to figure out what's going on. (Deven sighing nervously) - [Rashad] Yeah man. Yeah, you've been
through a lot there, man. - [Nev] Are you okay? - [Catfish] I'm nervous. - [Nev] Is he gonna be, he's gonna be pretty
surprised, I guess? - [Catfish] Yeah. - [Nev] Well, why
don't you come on back and we'll see how he's doing. - [Rashad] Kinda putting
yourself out on a limb. - Here goes nothing. (Deven sighing nervously) - [Nev] Right in there. (dramatic music) (Deven chuckling) - [Nev] What's your name? - [Catfish] Sha'Quan. - [Nev] Sha'Quan. - Hi. - [Rashad] What's up?
- Deven, apparently you guys know each other.
- Yeah, we know each other. - So, y'all know each other? - [Nev] Were you guys friends? - We were pretty, we
were friends, yeah. - Did anything ever happen? - Occasionally. - [Nev] Oh. Okay. Did you know he lives here? - Yeah. - You mentioned that you have
one friend who lives in - This is that friend. - Yes. - [Rashad] That's crazy. - So, when did you guys
last see each other? - Last time I came out to Vegas. - August. - Alright, so hold on a second. Here's what I don't understand. You guys had a
physical relationship. - Why would you have
a fake identity? - I wanted to see
how you're doing, but every time I
tried to talk to him, he doesn't respond. - Is that true? - Yeah. I just, yeah. - You never really thought that it was a relationship
there between... Gotcha. - No. - Did you ever make
it clear, kind of, where you were at with things? - I mean, if I
don't text you back, why wouldn't that
give him that hint? You can't just beat a dead
horse, it's already dead. It's (beep) up. - But if the horse is dead, everybody can say
the horse is dead. Sounds like Sha'Quan, is it? Is saying he never got the
scoop that the horse was dead. (Rashad chuckling) - I'm sorry, I can't. I'm tired of this (beep). (beep) I'm tired. - Tell us, then, in your own
words, what was the plan? - Well, I texted him
to hangout as James. And then if he come to Vegas,
James wouldn't show up, he'd probably text
me, tell me he's here, and I show up. - Oh, wait a second. So, you thought I'll make a profile
as this guy James. I'll invite him to
come meet me in Vegas. And then when he gets here
and James doesn't show up, he'll text you because
he knows you live here, and you'll just sort
of come to the rescue. - Yeah. - You had a plan, though. He did have a plan. - I gotta tell you, that
is actually a decent plan. - Hey, if it wasn't wrong -
- It's messed up. - I would come dap you up, bro, you thought about
some stuff at least. - [Nev] So, then
wait a second, so - - [Rashad] Dang, bruh. - When you made the profile,
why did you choose that guy? - He's somebody I've met. - Someone you've actually met? - [Sha'Quan] Yeah. He sent me photos
through Snapchat, and then I sent those as James. - [Nev] Re-gifted nudes? - Yeah. - Wow. - Do you know that Deven
follows that guy on Instagram? - I didn't find that out
til like a week later. - So, it was just
a total coincidence that you picked the
picture of a guy that Deven actually
follows on Instagram? - That's crazy. - I just wanted to know
if he just didn't like me as a person or my face. - That shouldn't matter. - What you did wasn't cool,
and you shouldn't have lied. - I understand that. - At the same time,
like, he likes you. - Mm-hmm. - And he got a chance to
show you a side of him that maybe you would not
have otherwise have seen, that you really liked. - That's fine and
everything, but, I'm just not into him enough to be in a
relationship with him. (dramatic music) That's it. But, any right person would
understand that way before now. - But you've been
physical with him, so, I can see how it could
be a little confusing. - But if you don't say anything, I don't know anything. - Still a lot to
take in all at once. - Right. - To kinda collect
your thoughts. - Why don't we take
a little break? We could meet back
up in a little while, and see if there's
some resolution. - That's fine. - [Nev] Okay, I'll walk you out. What were you
expecting would happen? - I thought he would be
upset, but not that upset. - Did you ever
get the impression that he did really like you? - Yeah. I have text messages from
when we first started talking of how, you know, we could
hangout, stuff like that. - I feel like you
should've said that. - I get really nervous
around him sometimes. - Alright, well, you deserve
some kind of clarity, I think. - What is it? Is it his personality? Is it the way he looks? He kinda needs a
closure as well. - It wasn't his personality,
that wasn't the problem. I'm just not, I'm just not attracted to him. What else do you want me to say? - Right, I'm just thinking, not attracted to you, but, I did things that I do with
people I'm attracted to. So that could be confusing. - You could be
attracted to a hooker, but that don't
mean you love her. (dramatic music) - [Kamie] Should we go
through the doggy door? (Nev knocking on door) - [Nev] I wonder
if she's here yet. - [Kamie] If we're knocking
on some random person's house I'm gonna be very upset. (dramatic music) There's another
door on that side. - Over here? - [Tony] Yeah. - [Nev] Oh, oh yeah. (dramatic music) - This is weird. - [Tony] Hold on, what? (Kamie gasping) - Hello. - [Kamie] It's her. (Nev gasping) - [Nev] What! Hi. I'm Nev. - Tiana. - Tiana, nice to finally meet you.
- Kamie, nice to meet you. - [Nev] You know Tony. Obviously, you're you. It's you in the pictures, so it's confusing to
me why we're here. What's up with all
of your profiles? We found like an older Facebook and a couple Instagram's.
- Oh yeah, probably from a long time ago
when I was younger. That's my Facebook since
I've been an adult. The other stuff is like
when I was younger. - Okay, fine. And you have a son who's two? - Yeah. - [Nev] And that's
it, just one son? - Yeah. - [Kamie] What do
you do for work? - I work at a nightclub. - Dancing? - No. (Tiana chuckling) It's like bartending and stuff. - [Kamie] Have you
ever been in the Navy? - No. - It does say
you're in the Navy. - [Tiana] Yeah, I know. (Tiana chuckling) - So, that was a lie? - But it says that because
I was going to the Navy, it was a process. I never went to my bootcamp. So, no. My son's dad is in the military. - And then, do you
work at Target? - No. I told you I worked at
Marshall's, Walmart. Maybe you're getting
stuff confused because I never
worked at a Target. - Very different. (Tony chuckling) (Tiana chuckling) - Who is Shavon? - Yeah. - [Kamie] Is she your roommate? - [Tiana] Yeah. - But on your Facebook page,
you posted a photo of a car. That's your car? - Well, that's her car. - But you posted it
as if it was your car. - No, my caption said
"this car is poppin'". - It said "new car poppin'". - I guess it's Shavon's
new car, I don't know. - I mean, that's
just how I talk. - So, did you tell
Shavon to lie to us? - I mean, yeah. - [Kamie] And why did you take
a video of us talking to her? - Because I just felt at
the time it was extra. Like, I was not ready for that. - Why? It's been two years
since you first started talking to Tony. - Tony, mmm, unh-unh. - What is going
on with you guys? Why haven't you FaceTime'd? - Honestly, I was going
through a situation-ship. But he knew about that. And I was living
with my son's dad. We was co-parenting. - I know but you can
find five minutes to ... Is this a relationship that
you were serious about? - We friends. - Okay, but Tony describes
this relationship a lot differently. So, at the beginning,
or at any point, did you think that this could be more than friends? - Yeah, back then, yeah. - So, towards the beginning? - Yeah. - But is it totally
wrong of him to think that there's
something between you? - Yes, because I've
told him about dudes that I'm talking to. I always unfriend you. I have unfriended you
at least 30 times. - Never, never. - What? - Never. Never. - I wish I could prove
it, but I can't obviously, 'cause we Facebook friends now. - [Tony] Never. - But I have deleted
you multiple, a lotta times, Tony.
- [Tony] Never. Never. - Have you flat out told him,
like, I'm not interested, stop calling me - - Yes, there have been
times where I told Tony stop calling
me, stop texting me. Have I, or have I not? - You only told me one time. - Okay, one time. And what you do? You still hit me up, right? - 'Cause if you hit
me up, I call back. - Oh my God. So, I call you? - You called me that day, talking about something,
about some (beep). I don't know what the
(beep) you was talking bout. - Tony -
- [Tony] It was a minute ago. - you sound dumb, and honestly, you pushy. You're extra, you're
disrespectful. I mean, you said
I was a thot, so. - What? - Nah, I didn't say that. - You said, "I knew
you was a thot." What was I doing
to make me a thot? - You talk to hella
people, what you mean? - Okay, but you
lied about a kid. - I never did lie. You told me you
didn't have a kid, and then a kid just
appeared on your Facebook. - Wait, do you have a kid? - Yeah, I got a son. - [Nev] What? How old is your son? - One. - That's something
that you tell somebody that you supposedly
talk to, right? - I can understand being
confused and a little surprised and upset to find out that
a guy that I'm talking to didn't mention
that he has a kid. I'm surprised that I
didn't know he had a kid. - Me and my baby
mama wasn't talking. Me and my baby mama don't talk. We (beep) around two
times, three times. - Did you know that your
baby mama was pregnant when she was pregnant? Or did you not find
out that you had a kid until after she had him? - I didn't find out until after. - Hold on a second. All of this is irrelevant if you don't actually
have feelings for him. - Well it went out the
window once he did all that. - [Nev] So you did?
- Yep. - So, your interest
in Tony was real? - Yep. - [Nev] But over time
you just lost interest? - Yeah. Y'all don't understand. Tony can get annoying as (beep). Like, he blows me up and I don't like that. I even told you I could be busy, I could be busy with my kid. When you blow me up and
call me like 10 times, I just feel like you been stalking me. (dramatic music) - [Nev] Can we see
some of the messages? - Okay, so, that's Tony. Tony two times. Tony 25 times. - But you're saying he
blows up your phone a lot? - He blows me up. He do stuff that he
don't need to be doing, like, I don't like that
blowing me up stuff. I don't like that. - We see the phone records. (dramatic music) - [Nev] The question remains where and who is this person? - Right. - You, interestingly,
had mentioned that a couple of years
back somebody was sort of messed with you. This guy, Vance. So, we went to
his Facebook page. One of the things he posted
today is this article about me being in town. - Are you (beep) serious? - We thought it was interesting
that someone from your past seemed to be excited
that Catfish was in town. And get this, Dom told us he
was stationed at Fort Bragg, just like Adonis. And look, here it also says
Vance was in the military. So, it's not impossible that Vance could be Adonis. - [Kamie] But that's kind
of where we left things. - The only way of really even
figuring out who this is, is to just ask them
to reveal themselves. - Okay. So, can I ask that question? - Sure. - (beep). (dramatic music) - [Nev] What did you say? - I said, "Hey, I'm with Nev. We do know you're not the
person you said you were. We would like to meet
up as soon as possible." - [Nev] "If I don't
hear back from you at least by tomorrow
morning, I'll move on and just let this go." - This guy sure knows
how to play hard-to-get. - Alright, well, let
me know obviously if you hear anything. And then tomorrow
morning we'll check in and hopefully he'll
decide to meet us. - Okay. That'll work. Thank you man. - Check to make sure
that the news vans aren't on the front yard. (Alfred chuckling) - The Sanford Times. - [Antonnio] Hey Alfred. - [Nev] Oh. - [Alfred] What
are you doing here? - [Nev] Who's this? - It's Antonnio. I heard Catfish was in town. - [Alfred] What that
gotta do with you? - Why are they here? - [Alfred] Get in
your car, go home. - So, you really gonna leave? - [Alfred] Get in
your car and go home. - Can I talk to you over there? - Why? - For five minutes. - For what? - So I can talk to you,
I don't everybody else in my business, I
don't need that. - [Kamie] Hold on, hold on.
- [Alfred] Bye, bye. - [Antonnio] Why are they here? - [Nev] Here, why don't
you go back inside and I'll explain to Antonnio
what we're doing here. - You're Antonnio? - Yes. - I'm Kamie, nice to meet you. - [Alfred] This is what
I was telling y'all. You see what I'm saying? - Well, he's probably
just jealous and upset. - He's always (beep) jealous,
that's what I'm talking about. - It is Alfred's business, but, we're just, we're here to help. - This is a perfect
opportunity to just say - - I told y'all, I told y'all. - Right, but you
don't need it anymore. - I told y'all. - It's not your responsibility. So, why don't you go out there and let him know how you feel? (crickets chirping) - What you have to say? - [Antonnio] Why are you
bringing Catfish out here? Am I not good enough for you? Like, why you trying
to meet somebody that you don't even know? - [Alfred] Look at this
(beep) you pulling right now. You hear something from
Sanford and you coming at me. - We've been together
for five years. Five years is a long-ass
time for you throw it away on somebody you don't even know. - It's all been you,
it's been about you. - [Antonnio] But you don't
even know this person. - It doesn't matter. - It'd be different if
you knew the person, you don't even know this person. - [Alfred] So, that's my point. - [Antonnio] So, you gonna
leave me over somebody that you don't even know? - [Alfred] You
damn right I would. - That's stupid as hell, that's crazy as (beep).
- And? What you gon' do about it? - You look dumb as hell. - And that's fine. - [Antonnio] You
look dumb as hell. - [Alfred] Okay! - [Antonnio] You
look dumb as hell. - [Alfred] Okay! - And the reason why you
can't find the person is because I'm Adonis, bitch. - [Alfred] Bitch! (Kamie yelling) - [Nev] Oh (beep). - [Kamie] Stop guys, no, no, no. - [Nev] Chill,
chill, chill, chill. - [Alfred] Let me get him man. Nev, please let me get him. - [Nev] Chill, chill, chill,
please, please, please. - [Alfred] Nev, let me get him. Nev, let me get him. - [Kamie] It's not worth it. - [Alfred] He better
be lying, y'all. - [Kamie] It's not worth it. - [Alfred] He better be lying! He better be lying! - [Nev] Hold on, hold
on, hold on, one second. - [Alfred] He better
be lying, bro. (Alfred crying) - Take a seat right here. Sit with me down here. - Nev, Nev, I'm sorry. - [Nev] Let's take
a second, alright? - Oh, he better,
he better be lying. - We're not gonna get
anywhere right now, when everyone's upset. - [Kamie] Are you okay? - Yeah, I'm okay. That (beep) is crazy. He's mad at me because
he's been cheating on me. This is just too much, I
can't talk, I gotta go. I can't do this. - [Kamie] Please
get home safely. - [Antonnio] I am. (Kami groaning) - I just wanna
know, is he lying? - Do you want me
to go ask him that? - Please. - Can you just stay
here for a minute. - Find out if he's
lying, please. - Alright, just wait
for me, one second, right here, okay? (crickets chirping) - [Kamie] He said
he needs to leave. - [Nev] Did you
talk to him at all? - [Kamie] Yeah, I did,
but he doesn't wanna... - Hey, just really
fast, is it true? You said at the very end, right before you guys started
fighting that you are Adonis. - I am Adonis. - That's true? - That's true. - So, you made the profile? - Yes. - And it's been you talking
to him the whole time? Why did you do that? - I needed facts. - In terms of him like cheating? - Cheating on me, talking to
other people behind my back. I just needed facts. - [Nev] I'd like
to talk about this and try to help you guys. I don't know if right now
is the time to do that. Are you willing to meet
up with us tomorrow? - Tomorrow, yeah, I
just need time to just process everything.
- Okay, fine. So, you should go and we'll talk hopefully tomorrow
and meet up again. - Okay. - Alright. (dramatic music) - Nev, was he lying? - I don't think so. I just asked him. He said, that is, he made the profile. (crickets chirping) - [Nev] We have a
bit of a drive, but, it's good, you'll get to se LA. - [Elle] LA! Yeah! Are you nervous? - Scared and nervous. - Scervous. - Scervous. I just want answers. (tense music) - [Nev] Alright, pretty close. - There it is. - This one? - Yeah. - Nice little house. (Nev mumbling) - Alright, let's do it.
- Let's go. - [Nev] You guys
wanna hang here? (dramatic music) (Nev knocking on door) (door creaking open) Hello. Hi. - [Alice] Hi. - [Nev] I'm Nev. - [Alice] I'm very nervous. (Alice chuckling) She's out there? - [Nev] She's out here. Say hello. (door creaking shut) - Hi. - Hey. - How are you? - What was the big deal? How are you? - I'm a little anxious and
nervous, but I'm better now. - Absolutely, also
the same for me. (Alice chuckling) - Okay, well - - Hi. - Yeah, this is Elle. - Hi. - I'm Alice.
- And I'm Nev. - It's nice to meet you
again, nice to meet you. - We're glad to be
here, but also, I think curious and somewhat confused. - I'm also a little
confused and like, I didn't wanna do this. I was concerned that she
called you in the first place. 'Cause I was like, when
you talk to somebody and then they don't
trust who you are, it made me feel anxious. - I get that. It wasn't that I didn't
trust you, but ... - You needed to make sure that - - Yeah, you're real before
I gave you all of my heart. - It just like hurt my
feelings a little bit. - Okay, okay. I'm just gonna jump in. So then, where does it come in that you aren't
able to video chat? - I just didn't think
there was that much of a lack of faith in me. I didn't think that it was like she needed to verify
who I was over FaceTime. I thought she just wanted to, so it was low-urgency for
me, you know what I mean? When I'm talking to a
person, I would really just rather talk instead
of focusing on how I look. - I completely understand. I'm not trying to blame you. I understand your
anxiety over all of this. - But, just like one
little video or something? - I'm not trying to
defend her on this side, but I kind of do
understand, 'cause we live in completely
different time zones. - You guys, two hours.
- A two hour difference. - Yeah, two hours. - I mean, I don't know,
I've just never been, like we don't even
talk on the phone. - Why did you block
her on Facebook? - I got incredibly anxious
about this whole thing. Like, I have my own
anxieties as well. - Yeah, sure. - And I just felt like all
of this didn't mean as much because of the fact that
she didn't trust who I was. - We spoke to your
friend Maddie. - Mm-hmm, yeah. - And asked her if the phone
number that Nique has for you is the same number she has for
you, and she said it's not. - Yeah, I have
two phone numbers. So, one for like the people
that I know in real life and one for the people
that I meet on role-play. It helps me keep
things organized. - Okay, well, I have other questions,
but at the same time, I like don't wanna front-load
this, you guys just met. - Yeah.
- Yeah. - So, maybe we should
just like kinda check in? So, if you guys could go talk, we could talk just for a minute and just kinda
like go over stuff? - Gotcha. - [Nev] Cool. So, I'll go sit
with you over here. - Okay. How do you feel? - A lot better. - You feel a lot better? - Yeah. I'm kind of like
mostly satisfied with the answers she
had to the questions, 'cause I kinda do
understand most of them. - Yeah, but I just, can I
be totally honest with you? - Yeah. - It just feels (beep) weird. Yeah, it's exciting. She's her, she's real,
she's nice, you know? But, at the same time, I
mean, you wrote to the show because there's a whole
year where she spent kind of avoiding
being real with you. And now that we're here, it's
just like, "oh yeah, yeah. Just water under the
bridge, never happened, never happened, never happened." I'm sensing something
that's not genuine. - [Nev] What do you think? (Alice chuckling) - It's okay. She's really sweet. I'm, like, also very
nervous, you know? - What has been your impression
of this relationship? - I love her, I
think she's like, I used to be romantically
interested in her and we used a flirt a lot. And then I stopped
feeling that way, and without
addressing it really. I just kinda thought
it was mutual because of with her relationship with Princess and everything. - Well, at least from
what Nique told us, she has very strong
feelings for you. - Yeah. - When I was saying, I don't feel like TV's
the best place for this. I meant it's probably
not the best place for me to tell her that like I
don't have romantic feelings. - Right. I just think it'd
be helpful for her if you were very clear. - Remember, this whole thing,
Nique, this is for you. This is your time to question,
what were her intentions? - There's still some things
that I want and need to know. - Yeah. Should I go ask
her to talk to you? - Yeah. - There's a couple questions
she wanted to ask you. Do you wanna go talk to her? - Yeah, yeah, that
would be fine. Can I come in? - [Nique] Yeah. - [Elle] What'd you
guys talk about? - She was attracted physically
to Nique at the beginning, but then she felt like it just sort of turned
into a friendship. The main reason she didn't
wanna come on the show is 'cause didn't wanna have
to tell Nique to her face, like, hey I'm not into you. (dramatic music) - I've been asking
you constantly to
come down to Texas. But you denying each
time made me feel like you didn't wanna see me. - I definitely
wanted to see you. It's just because of your
relationship with Princess I thought it wouldn't
hurt your feelings if I didn't make
it down to Texas. I didn't know you
were actively seeking other romantic
polyamorous relationships. I just didn't think that it was as big of
an issue as it was. I should have listened
to what you were saying, and actually taken what you were saying to heart. - I do wanna eventually come
to California for school. If you're still in the area, would you wanna be in an
actual relationship with me? - I don't think that's
what I'm looking for. But, you know, there's so
much possible in a few years, you know, you're not gonna
come down for a while, so. - Yeah. That makes me feel
a little bit better. There's still some time left. ♪ It's safe to say
it's been a hard year ♪ Do you wanna go back over there? - [Alice] Yeah. - [Nev] How'd it go? - We did get a lot
of things cleared up. Possibly in the future, if I am able to come
down to California, it is a possibility for
a romantic relationship. - [Nev] Really? - Yeah. ♪ So it's not easy to see ♪ - Well, do you want to just
leave it for the moment, then we can come back
later or tomorrow? - Yeah. - Yeah. - Okay. - Bye. ♪ You let the light in ♪ - I feel like today did not
go as well as it could have. A lot of what I said was
being misinterpreted, and I didn't really correct her, because I didn't want
to embarrass her. In retrospect, I should
have made things clearer. Hopefully it'll be
better tomorrow. - [Nev] This is it. We're here. Well, this is the street. - Whoo! - So yeah, it's gonna
be right around here. - [Tiana] Ohh, mm, mm, mmm. - [Aisha] This looks familiar. - Really? - Yeah. - [Max] Have you
been here before? - It feels so familiar. - [Max] Why does
this feel familiar? - Well, that looks a
like a shop, right? - [Aisha] Oh my God. - [Max] What? - This is Ricky G's shop. Ricky G raps, and he's
my baby daddy's cousin. He works here. - In this shop? - [Aisha] In this shop, yes. I knew it was familiar
'cause I remember bringing my kid's dad here. - There's someone in there. I can see someone. - [Max] The garage
is like half open. - [Nev] Yeah, there's
definitely someone in there. You don't know
this guy, Ricky G? - I don't know Ricky G. - You know in the mornings, he does a song for the
radio in the mornings. - So, it would make sense
that Ricky G knows - - [Aisha] A rapper. - [Nev] Yeah,
Tipsytwists or whatever. - It would make sense,
yeah, 'cause he raps. - Wow. - [Nev] Wow. Alright, well, let's do it then. (dramatic music) - [Tiana] It's crazy that you
say you've been here, like. - Oh my God, just
don't be scared. - [Nev] I can hear him in there. I see someone in there. - Oh my God. (creepy music) - Stay open minded. - [Nev] Hello? - What's up? - [Nev] Hey man. - What the (beep) Are you serious? Trez, really? You been behind this
the whole (beep) time? - Why y'all bring her? - Wait, who is Trez? - That's my baby daddy. What you mean who is that? How the (beep) could
you do this to me? - No, that's no. - Trez! - No, are y'all in on this? - What you mean in on? What you really think I'm
finna set you up like that? What the (beep)? - No, somebody in on this.
- You already know I ain't even do
(beep) like this. - Clearly, this is not
something that you guys were in on together, so let's not let this
get between you guys. - No, it's gonna be between us, 'cause who's Trez? - You don't know this guy but apparently they
had a kid together. - So, you have a child? - [Trez] Yeah. - Wow. - Man, I'm through
with this (beep). - Wow. - [Aisha] I don't want
nothin else to do with this. I'm ready to go. I'm (beep) ready to go. - That was messy. Why did y'all bring
my baby mama, man? - The whole (beep) time he
been doing this (beep) to her. - I had no idea that that
was what was happening here. Hold on a second. - It's like, I really
don't believe that. - So, obviously this is awkward. It's turning into a
much bigger situation than we could have anticipated. - [Max] So, that's Aisha's ... I'm gonna go talk to Aisha. - Yeah, let's figure this out - The whole (beep) time. The whole (beep) time. You sat there and
you lied to her! And then when it comes to me
getting into a relationship with somebody, you
come and you run away! But you don't want me to be
with nobody else but you! - [Nev] Hold on,
hold on, hold on. - No, what do you mean,
I need an explanation! What the (beep)! - [Nev] Let's not
make this into - - [Aisha] You done fought
all my ex-boyfriends, and you done did all
this (beep) and then you had this lie going on
for three (beep) years. - Wasn't 'sposed
to be like that. It wasn't 'sposed to
be like that at all. - [Aisha] What you
mean it wasn't 'sposed to be like that, Trez? - It wasn't 'sposed to
be like that at all. - It's crazy, but I'm the
one who's going through this and y'all arguing. - You done ran off
all my ex-boyfriends, you don't want me to
be with nobody but you. - [Trez] You got a boyfriend. - Man, I'm so over this (beep). I can't believe
you did this to me. - It wasn't like that. - [Nev] Hold on a
second, hold on a second. - Take me home! - This is obviously
some drama between them that we didn't know
it was going on. - That I shouldn't be put in. - [Max] Step in the car
with me for a second. - [Aisha] Oh my Goodness,
I cannot believe this (beep) is
happening right now. The whole (beep) time. - Why have you
been talking to her with this other guy's picture for the last three years and
avoiding her all this time? - I met her through her. I ain't want it to be like this. I ain't want it to be messy. I didn't want it to
be no messy situation. - Wow. - That's my kid's dad. - [Max] Which kid? - My son, my seven year old son. I can't keep no boyfriend, 'cause every time I get
into a relationship, here he come running them away. He don't want me to be
with nobody else but him. But every time I turn around, it's a new (beep)
bitch in the picture. - So, you met because of
Aisha, and you liked her. - Yeah. - But you couldn't
really pursue her because of your
previous relationship? - [Trez] Yeah. - I don't even know who
he is, I never seen him. - We met at a party about
three years ago, October. And so, we had, it was a
little Halloween party. - Do you remember being
here for Halloween a couple years ago? - That was right before
I moved to Washington. - We wasn't even really
properly introduced, but I thought, I kinda thought
we liked each other. - [Nev] So, you were into her - - It wasn't even
'sposed to be like this. I was just, really just
trying to holla at you. - That (beep). That's really (beep).
- [Trez] I'm sorry, I'm sorry. I'm sorry.
- [Tiana] Wow. - It wasn't 'sposed
to go this long. I was going to come right
out and tell you who I was. I was gonna come right
out and tell you who I was off the bat. - And then it hurt me 'cause
that's my friend Ti-Ti. You know how many times
this girl done told me she done fell in love with
the person she's texting on the phone? And come find out
it's my baby daddy? Now she looking at me like I
got something to do with it. Like, come on now. - You know, we brought Aisha
because they're good friends. - Yeah. - [Nev] And Aisha's sort
of been there for her this whole time.
- (beep), listen man. - And I understand that the
whole reason you wanted to sort of use this fake
name was to avoid this mess.
- Exactly. It happened anyway.
- [Nev] Maybe you didn't think things through because, I mean,
eventually she, you know, she was gonna find out. - I was gonna tell her,
I was gonna tell her. It wasn't never
supposed to go this far. Especially when they started
getting close, you know. (beep) just seemed
like I had to keep on stretching the lie out. - [Aisha] He helps me, he
takes care of my other kids that's not his. But the fact that - - I don't wanna talk to him. - It's not just no boy, that's not just no boyfriend
that I've been with for a year and a half. I have been dealing
with this man for almost eight or nine years. - Here I am hiding my daughter. He saying he got multiple kids. - He has eight kids.
- Like what kinda (beep) is this? - Had you ever - - TiTi, I feel like
I owe you an apology, but at the same time,
I knew nothing of this. - I'm in love with who? - My baby daddy. You're in love
with my son's dad. - [Max] Let's go check in on
Kailani, see how she's doing. (phone ringing) - Oh.
- Oh, what? - We're getting -
where's the phone? - Oh, it's Kailani, hello? - [Kailani] Sam just called me. He told me he was on his way. - On his way to where? - [Kailani] He took an Uber and he's driving
towards my house. - [Max] Jesus.
- Okay, well, we're just leaving the hotel, so we'll just get
over there quickly. - [Kailani] I really don't
want to meet him alone. - [Nev] No, no, no,
we'll be there soon. - [Kailani] Okay. - [Nev] Bye. Whoa! All of a sudden, he's Uber-ing? - [Max] That's
weird, that's weird. - We better get there fast. - I mean, he's on his way there. - If he gets there before us
we could be in big trouble. I wish we had a siren. - I know, we need
a Catfish siren. - [Nev] Put up on the roof. (dramatic music) We got here pretty quick. (Nev knocking on the door) - [Max] Kailani, is he here? - No. - [Max] Okay. - Oh my god, you scared me. - [Max] We thought maybe he
would get here before us. - [Kailani] Okay, so -
- [Max] How you doing? - Oh my god, like I'm
really nervous now. - [Max] So, what did he say? - He said I'm on my way. I'm taking an Uber
to come see you. I'm driving to your
house right now. - An Uber from where?
- From where? - He didn't tell
me where he was. - Just I'm in an Uber. - He's like I'm in an Uber. - [Nev] Okay, wait,
so, hold on a second. Let's sit down and go over this. Were you like, what? - Yeah. I mean, I was shocked. I told him I talked to Dominic. He was just like, okay. Like, he didn't care. - He wasn't trying
to explain or say, I really have feelings for you, or anything like that? - No, just that he wants to
see me and he's on his way. - That's alarming. If he was being a dick
and being aggressive and wasn't apologizing,
and was like, I'm on my way to see you,
I know where you live. Like, that's not good. - It's a little creepy. - [Max] Yeah. - Yeah. - We don't know
anything about this guy. - Right. - Seriously, this is scary. He knows your address
because you sent him - - He sent me letters
and things in the mail. - [Max] You wanna go outside? - [Nev] Yeah. - [Max] It's just frightening
that he knows where you live. - [Nev] I'm just
gonna look and see if anyone's coming
down the street. It's been a few minutes. - Oh, wait here's an Uber, guys. - [Nev] Is that an Uber? - [Max] That is an Uber. It's stopping. I think this is him, guys. Someone's getting out. - [Nev] Someone's getting out. - [Max] Sam? Sam? - [Catfish] Yeah. - [Max] Do you know this person? - No. - [Max] Who are you? - I'm Sam. - [Max] Yeah, okay. - Yeah. - [Max] And where are you from? - Monterey. - You are from Monterey.
- Yeah. - [Nev] Okay. And how old are you? - I'm 19. - So, that stuff was true. - [Sam] Yeah. - [Max] Did you go
to school with Dom? - No. - Do you know him? - [Sam] Yeah, I've been around
him through mutual friends. - But you've never
actually met him? - No. - [Max] And how long have you
been pretending to be him? - Pretty much just a year. - [Max] Just a year? - Yeah. - So, what that you
told me is true? - Pretty much,
basically everything, just, I'm not the
person in the pictures. - Why don't you
kind of just tell us your side of this and just kind of take us back and kind of explain
how this happened, how you guys met.
- How you started the profile. - I mean, this isn't
an excuse, but like, in high school I got
made fun of a lot 'cause I have feminine features. So, I wanted to know
like if I was different, more manly-looking
and everything, like, how would people
accept me differently? - [Max] What was your
intention with Kailani? - I never actually thought
it would get that far. - You knew what she
was going through with a guy who had lied
to her and led her on and deceived her and sort
of put her through hell. - Yeah. - And while yes, you were
there and supportive, you knew that eventually she would find out and that it would only
hurt her even more. - And that's why, like, I
couldn't really tell her, you know, like I didn't, I didn't know how to tell her, on top of everything else
that she's been going through. - You've been leading
me on this whole time? - No, I actually got really
strong feelings for you. - What about Adriana? You got real feelings
for her, also? - Adriana wasn't
anything compared to how I talk to Kailani. - And what about Melvin? - It was just sort of like
testing, I guess, the waters. But, I don't, I don't do that. - Have you ever had a
relationship with a man? - No. I never meant to hurt you, because I really
do care about you. I really do. I do love you. - It's really hard
for me to believe that when you were telling Adriana that you cared
about her as well. - But, I cared about
her as like a friend. Like, I don't even
know her that long. - I mean, you don't even
know her in person either. - [Sam] Yeah, but like,
I don't have feelings for her like that. - I'm gonna go inside with
Kailani for a second and chat. Sort of check in. Give you a second also to like, cause I know this is a lot, so let's just take two seconds, sort of reset. Do you want to stand out here? Just hang for a second. - Sure, yeah, yeah.
- Alright. Just give us a minute. Do you wanna sit here? - [Kailani] Yeah. (Nev sighing) - [Nev] It's a little confusing. He's been telling these lies and avoiding this
issue for so long now. He's just not comfortable
saying what's true. - He knew what I
was going through, but yet he couldn't
just tell me. But, when I called him
going through my divorce he continued to make me
believe that that was him. - [Nev] So, that's messed
up, that he kept lying. (dramatic music) - [Max] How you doin? - [Sam] Scared. It's 'cause I know I hurt her. (Sam sniffling) - You really love her? - Yeah. I never wanted to hurt her, even though I knew what
I was doing was wrong. Yeah, like. (Sam crying) - [Max] So, I think the
best thing to do now is to go our separate ways, process this, and
then meet up tomorrow. Is that cool? - Yeah. - [Nev] Good to meet
you, appreciate it. - [Sam] Nice to meet you too. (Sam sighing)
