MEET NERO WOLFE (1936)
Video Statistics and Information
Channel: evanlewis1836
Views: 240,548
Rating: undefined out of 5
Keywords: Nero Wolfe, Mystery films, Rex Stout
Id: fHCoB_zrOE4
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 71min 23sec (4283 seconds)
Published: Thu Apr 02 2020
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.
What is perhaps most interesting about this particular adaptation is how much they keep from the books as well as how much they change.
Wolfe is still supercilious. So too is he fat and a shut in. He also keeps his mania for orchids.
However, this version of Wolfe is more gregarious, as well as more of a penny pincher.
It is perhaps Archie who undergoes the biggest change. While it might be said that he's still a ladies man, he's very much all about a single lady. What's more, this version of the character has none of the suave nature that he does in the books, but is rather a crude 'everyman,' more along the lines of Fred.
And then there's Mazie! A brand new character who, while not out of place in the genre, sticks out in a Nero Wolfe story like a sore thumb.
Which goes to the core of the issue with the film. The entire tone is very much in keeping with the light mystery genre of the time, but does not suit Nero Wolfe. There's a Thin Man-esque vibe to the entire proceeding that doesn't fit this intellectual property. Comparing it to the 2001 series is like looking at the property through some kind of funhouse mirror.
It's like watching some weird off brand version of Nero, rather than the genuine article itself.