Illustrator VS Inkscape: A Complete Comparison

[Music] one of the most common questions i receive on this channel is how inkscape compares to illustrator and if one is better than the other the two applications are very similar and have a lot in common but despite that there's still enough differences between them to be a worthwhile discussion in this video i'm going to break all of that down and go over some of the advantages and disadvantages of both illustrator and inkscape and before we get started i'd just like to address any potential bias as someone who earns their living teaching people how to use open source software like inkscape it wouldn't be unreasonable for you to assume that i'm approaching this with some kind of bias or agenda but i can assure you that i'm going to be as fair and objective as possible and for what it's worth i do have another channel for illustrator tutorials so it's not like i don't have a vested interest in that software as well in my opinion both applications are actually quite similar and equally capable it's not like the comparison you would make between something like photoshop and where as much as i love photoshop is clearly more extensive and rightly so photoshop is the flagship product of a 100 billion dollar corporation this is by no means an indictment on the team but when it comes to illustrator versus inkscape there's not nearly as much disparity between the two programs hardly any in fact let's break this down a little further first and foremost the thing that i love most about inkscape is its low barrier to entry illustrator is sold on a yearly subscription-based pricing model whereas inkscape is just completely free it's made by a team of passionate volunteers who built it as a labor of love and the reason why i think that's so important doesn't have as much to do with the money as it does with how accessible that makes it inkscape opens the door a little wider for hobbyists and anyone who may have a passing interest in vector design who may not be able to justify spending money on something they're not quite sure they'll like just yet this actually describes me at one point in time when i first wanted to start learning about vector design over 10 years ago i couldn't afford adobe illustrator this was before they had their monthly subscription model and back then i believe it cost somewhere in the ballpark of six hundred dollars just to buy a copy of it not only did i not have that kind of money sitting around i certainly couldn't justify spending that much on something that was at the time just a hobby inkscape was my foot in the door to the graphic design world and without having it as a free alternative i might not have ever realized just how much i enjoy design and i might not have ever pursued it as a career either because of this i can't help but wonder how many others are in the same position i was in over 10 years ago how many future graphic designers are out there who will one day be creating great work and providing real value to the world because of free applications like inkscape and that allowed them to test the waters first one big advantage inkscape has is that it's far less demanding in terms of hardware you can run inkscape relatively well on some low end consumer grade computers which is something that certainly can't be said for illustrator as of the date of this video adobe's recommended hardware specifications for running illustrator are a multi-core processor 16 gigabytes of memory a gpu with 4 gigabytes of vram inkscape on the other hand runs just fine on much less than that in fact the first computer i ever used inkscape with was a refurbished e-machines that i got from ebay for less than 200 it didn't exactly run inkscape with ease but it did run well enough for me to be productive with it and if you compare that to 2020 standards the technology has come far enough that pretty much any consumer grade laptop should run inkscape relatively well this reinforces my previous point about inkscape having a lower barrier to entry if you're a casual user who just wants to experiment with vector design not only do you not have to purchase software but you won't have to purchase expensive components either assuming what you have isn't too outdated you should be able to hit the ground running with inkscape right away another advantage inkscape has is that it's available on all three operating systems which is something that can't be said for illustrator you can run illustrator on windows and mac but if you're a linux user then you're out of luck but that's okay because inkscape is here for you in fact inkscape seems to run better in a linux environment if you go back and watch some of my older videos on this channel you'll see that i'm a former ubuntu user myself and inkscape ran just fine in this section i'm going to get into some of the features and functionality in inkscape that i really like starting with gradients if there's one thing i can't stand about illustrator it's working with gradients it just feels so needlessly complicated and counterintuitive inkscape on the other hand makes it easy you can edit the gradients directly on the canvas add and remove stops change colors and move the handles around easily it doesn't even take much time to learn how it works because it all just feels so intuitive i don't understand why illustrator doesn't use a similar approach i can't think of a single scenario in which their method of working with gradients is more productive another thing i like about inkscape is the edit paths by nodes tool it's a single tool that allows you to edit the nodes of an object otherwise known as anchor points in illustrator in every conceivable way illustrator allows you to edit the anchor points but for whatever reason is divided up among several tools there's the direct selection tool the anchor points tool the add anchor points tool the remove anchor points tool inkscape lets you do all of these things with just a single tool and it's far more efficient finally the last thing i want to talk about is canvas navigation navigating around the canvas in inkscape is just easier all you have to do is press down the mouse wheel and move the mouse around in illustrator you have to press down the space bar and then click and drag your mouse it requires an extra click and it also requires an extra hand in inkscape you can navigate around the canvas with just one hand i know that sounds like a silly comparison to make but it's really not when you think about it in terms of an eight-hour workday these little things do add up in this section i'm going to talk a little bit about what i like better about illustrator first and foremost adobe software is the industry standard if you want to be employed in the graphic design industry whether it be by a studio an agency a media company or even a print shop they're most likely going to require you to be proficient with the adobe family of software which includes illustrator so learning how to use something as prominent as illustrator can give you an enormous advantage even if you don't plan on ever becoming employed as a designer it is good to know that you have that option to fall back on as a plan b as far as inkscape goes i've never heard of an employer that requires you to know inkscape nor have i ever seen it listed as a job requirement you can still be a freelancer as an inkscape user but if you want to gain employment as a designer you're going to need to know the adobe suite another thing i really like about illustrator is that there's a lot more support and documentation widely available online so if you're running into any kind of problems or technical issues you can probably find a solution relatively easy even if you can't just reach out to their support team and ask you are a paying customer after all inkscape on the other hand is supported by volunteers and independent creators like myself we're not yet as big of a community as the illustrator community is so there's been many occasions where i've had some kind of weird glitch or error message in inkscape and couldn't find any fixes or explanations for it i've been working to change that by creating a lot of articles and videos that address some of these common problems inkscape users have but i'm only one person and there's only so much i can do personally one benefit you'll certainly enjoy as an illustrator user is how well it translates across the other adobe applications once you have a basic understanding of how illustrator works it becomes much easier to learn photoshop or premiere pro because a lot of the basic functions are the same not only that but all of these applications work really well with each other you can export a layered psd file from illustrator and open it with photoshop with no cross-platform compatibility issues you can also do the same with creating pads in photoshop to be worked on further in illustrator later on that's not to say that you can't work cross-platform with inkscape and other open source applications like and blender you just won't have that same ease of use and seamless compatibility that you get with the adobe suite in this section i'm going to talk about some of the features that i really like in illustrator as opposed to inkscape the first of which would be the shape builder tool which is my personal favorite tool in illustrator the shape builder tool is kind of like a live path effect that allows you to perform multiple path operations at once and directly on the canvas the closest you can get to something like that in inkscape would be if you were to combine all of the objects together and then do a division path operation with another object kind of like what i did in my tutorial about creating a golden ratio logo then you could just delete the unwanted objects individually it's still not as good as the shape builder tool though so hopefully inkscape will introduce something similar in the future another thing i really like about working with illustrator is the envelope distort feature this pretty much allows you to take one object and make it fit the shape of another object i find this to be really useful for working with text and warping it to fit other objects and shapes there's even a handy list of presets that can be used with ease the closest thing we have to something like that in inkscape would be the perspective tool the bend tool and the lattice deformation path effect they're useful but they're not nearly as versatile as illustrator's envelope distort feature the final reason why i really like working with illustrator is that it saves me a lot of time in the production phase of a design project where you have to produce all of the final files and formats this is where the batch export feature really comes in handy it allows you to export multiple objects in multiple different file formats all at once compare that to inkscape where you have to save all of those files and formats individually one by one it takes a lot more time inkscape does have a batch export feature but it's only for png files illustrator allows you to batch export a variety of different formats the important question here isn't which software is better it's which one is better for you i don't think one is objectively better than the other so this is something that needs to be based on your own personal needs inkscape would be the better option for you if you're just curious about vector design and want to give it a try there's really no need to commit to software licensing and costly hardware upgrades just so you can dabble around with illustrator give inkscape a try first then if you really like it and want to get more serious about your design work later on you can always move on to illustrator later once you know how to use inkscape you can learn illustrator in no time they both function very similarly inkscape would also be the better option for you if you're a web designer an app developer or anyone who may occasionally need some vector designs as an ancillary part of their work for example let's say you're a web designer and you need to quickly put together some menu icons for a page you're designing inkscape would be perfect for you same for app developers if you just need to design app icons splash screens and various other user interface you'd be throwing your money away by purchasing illustrator inkscape can do all of that just fine the same goes for anyone else who may do some other kind of remote work online like youtubers bloggers instagram influencers digital marketers so on and so forth if graphic design is not what you do specifically but rather an ancillary part of your work inkscape is the perfect option for you licensing adobe software just to design some google display ads would be overkill you can do all of that with inkscape inkscape would also be the better option for you if you work with the cnc plasma cutter and need to work with vector designs for custom steel and wood signs for example same with cutting plotters like cricut purchasing illustrator for this sort of work would not only be unnecessary but it wouldn't even make your life any easier vector design in this context is so basic that you'll never need anything more complex than inkscape finally if you want to get started as a freelance designer but you don't yet have the money for illustrator and the hardware necessary for optimal performance inkscape is more than enough to get you started like i mentioned earlier proficiency with the adobe creative suite is often a job requirement when seeking employment but if you want to be a freelancer then it doesn't matter which tool you use the clients who hire you don't care whether you're using illustrator or inkscape they just care about whether or not you can solve their problems i've been a freelancer for over eight years and have designed logos for thousands of happy clients using inkscape and i can count on one hand the number of times i've been asked what software i'll be using to create their logo and even then they were just asking because they were curious it's not like they ran away and discussed after i said inkscape if you're serious about a career as a graphic designer and you'd like to seek employment in this field someday you should absolutely focus on learning illustrator over inkscape like i mentioned earlier adobe software is the industry standard and it doesn't look like that's going to change anytime soon and i'll say the same for freelancers as well yes you can get away with using inkscape as a freelancer but if you can afford illustrator and it's practical for you to license a copy of it you absolutely should there's just too many issues you'll run into down the line like outputting your work in a cmyk color format and compatibility issues when working with files and templates that were created by other designers using adobe software there's workarounds for these things but it's easier to just avoid these problems in the first place illustrator is also a great option if you're already paying for the adobe creative suite for example let's say you're a youtuber who regularly edits their videos with premiere pro or a photographer who uses photoshop to touch up their photos if you're already paying for an adobe subscription then yeah get your money's worth and use illustrator the same applies for students i know a lot of schools supply their students with free copies of adobe software so if that's the case for you then give it a try and see if you like it it's not like you have anything to lose one final point i'd like to make is that illustrator and inkscape are just tools and a tool will only ever be as good as the person using it a talented designer can make a better logo with crayons and a napkin than a beginner with the latest greatest software running on a supercomputer it's not the tools that matter it's the person using the tools that matters so try not to overthink this and before i close this video out i'd just like to plug my inkscape master class it's a collection of over 50 videos where i go through every single tool and feature in inkscape and i explain what it is and demonstrate how it works i'll have a link in the description if you're interested in learning more about inkscape and if you'd like to learn more about illustrator maybe check out my other channel for illustrator tutorials i've been putting a lot of work into that channel lately and really trying to ramp things up over there if you have any questions leave a comment below and as always thanks for watching you

Channel: Logos By Nick

Views: 323,111

Rating: 4.9515643 out of 5

Keywords: illustrator vs inkscape, logos by nick, logosbynick, nick saporito

Id: 3TXX10LdrhA

Length: 15min 5sec (905 seconds)

Published: Fri May 01 2020