unfortunately, bridgerton fumbled season 3

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments
Captions
- [Mina] This video is brought to you by  Squarespace, an all-in-one platform for   building a brand and growing your business  online. Hello, my beautiful doves. My name   is Mina Le and on this channel I talk about  fashion, media, and the culture. And today I   thought I would do a review video of "Bridgerton"  season three because I haven't done one of those   in a while. Spoilers I didn't love it, which is  actually devastating as a "Bridgerton" season   two truther. I even read the book "Romancing  Mr. Bridgerton" in anticipation for this season,   which honestly I didn't even like either. So we'll  get into that in a bit. I just realized when I was   prepping my script that I haven't actually made  a movie or TV show review in a really long time,   at first to stand in solidarity with the Hollywood  strikes last year, but the strikes have been over   for a bit now and I just got into this rhythm of  writing more like research dense videos, and I   feel like once I started exclusively making these  kind of research videos, it was harder to be like,   okay, now I'm gonna do something fun and a little  brainless. But you know, I've covered "Bridgerton"   season one and two in the past, so I thought I  would continue with season three and see how it   feels to reintroduce these kind of videos back on  the channel. "Bridgerton" season two aired March,   2022, so it's been two years. Obviously the  strike put the release of season three on pause,   and because of the aftermath, Netflix  is slowly rolling out their shows,   breaking apart one season into two. The first  aired in May and the second aired in June. Let's   quickly recap what happened last season so that  we're all on the same page because once again   it's been a while. Anthony Bridgerton, AKA Hot,  sexy yearner, head of Household, Viscount Anthony   Bridgerton gets married to ultra babe, gorgeous,  beautiful Kate Sharma. There's stories sort of   like enemies to lovers, eldest child syndrome,  selflessness, and unlike season one's Daphne   and Simon story, they're pretty chaste until the  end, building up the sense of like sexual tension   throughout the season. This is my preferred model  as a period drama enthusiast. I love a slow burn,   but I know that "Bridgerton" entered the zeitgeist  as this like sexy raunchy bodice ripper show,   so I noticed that people who loved season one  didn't really vibe with season two and vice versa.   As for the other characters, the most important  info from season two that I'll be referring to   in this video is that Colin Bridgerton comes back  from traveling abroad at the start of the season,   Queen Charlotte accuses Eloise Bridgerton of being  Lady Whistledown and basically threatens to ruin   her life. Penelope Featherington, who is actually  Lady Whistledown, decides to write something   scandalous about Eloise to save Eloise from the  Queen's spite. Eloise finds out the truth and ends   the friendship, feeling betrayed that Penelope  has kept this pretty large thing a secret, and   also that she's exposed her secrets to the ton and  while she's already down, Penelope cannot catch a   break. She overhears her crush Colin saying to  a group of bros that he would never court her, - I would never dream of  courting Penelope Featherington,   not in your wildest fantasies, five. - And that's what you missed on "Bridgerton"  season two. Squarespace makes website design   simple and easy, even if you can't code,  even if you're design aesthetic is shaky.   Squarespace offers all these tools like pre-made  templates, a drag and drop technology called   fluid engine and custom color palettes to  help you out. They also provide powerful   built-in analytics so you can track who's  visiting your site and more with page views,   traffic sources, time on site, most  read content, audience geography,   et cetera. Most people want a personal website to  build relationships with their page viewers and   Squarespace aid that goal further by offering  email campaigns, you can easily collect email   subscribers on your site and build connections  through regular email updates with fun templates,   of course. Check out squarespace.com for a  free trial and when you're ready to launch,   go to squarespace.com/Minale to get 10% off your  first purchase of a website or a domain. I loved   season two so much as I said, I thought it  was the perfect amount of frivolous fun,   drama, steamy romance, and so I was genuinely  really excited about season three. However,   if you weren't aware, the "Bridgerton" series is  based on the books that each center of Bridgerton   siblings love story. The first two seasons  follow the first two books, but season three   skips over Benedict's story to the fourth book,  which centers Colin, the new "Bridgerton" show   runner Jess Brownell explained the decision.  "We've been watching Pen's crush and seeing   how oblivious Colin is to it the past two seasons.  That's a dynamic that you can only play out for so   long before something has to change. This really  felt like the right time to lean into what's been   set up with them. On the Benedict side, he's  such a fun character, and such a fan favorite   that we are really excited to play with him for a  little bit more and let him have more fun before   he settles down. So the love trope that Colin and  Penelope are supposed to play into is the friends   to lovers trope. But the problem is that because  of the structure of the show, there's really not   a lot of friendship we get to witness between the  two of them leading up to this season. It more or   less felt like Penelope had a school girl crush  on Colin and he was just mainly oblivious to it. - I was not exactly lonely on my travels. I  did begin a real conversation with someone,   someone I had known for a very long time, myself. - Yourself? - Most of their interactions were also  chaperoned or interrupted by Eloise. - And I finally found you. - You always do. - You've been back a matter of  hours yet you're already in my way. - Penelope apparently wrote  him letters during his travels. - You read and replied to more  of my letters than anyone else. - I suppose I did. But we don't read the  correspondences between them either, so there's   not that much to work with. Each season has just  been so focused on developing the storyline of the   main couple that the other characters aren't given  much space to develop their own relationships,   which was fine for seasons one and two because  Daphmon and Kanthony were not slow burn friends   to stories, but for Polin there's a palpable  history that we the audience are missing. - Do   you remember when we first met. And you were so  very charming. And I think I know why. Because   we were children. I honestly think they should  have kept on with Benedict's story for season   three and then during his season intersperse  more Penelope and Colin with Colin being a   bit more emotionally mature and receptive to  Penelope's interest in him so that we can like   start seeing the vision of them as a couple.  But let's get into the play by play of this   season. At the beginning of season three, Eloise  has completely dropped Penelope as a friend,   moving on with Cressida Cowper, the  ton's resident mean girl. This is like   a major diss because Cressida has also been  bullying Penelope for the past two seasons. - How convenient. - [Mina] Colin has been traveling  again and returns as this Casanova,   which makes absolutely no sense because he already  went traveling last summer. Like if anything,   this should have been his first time traveling,  but I'm like, what's so different about Greece   round two? He's been there before, came back  still as a pastel colored goof. What's changed   about this trip in particular? It's also a little  cringe how much they try to pitch this new Colin   to us. His first scene is him changing his  shirt so we get a good look at the material   to say the least with his brothers saying  stuff like traveling has changed you so much. - I must know who are you? What  have you done with our brother? - To imply we're about to see him be out of  character for this season, but it's fine,   just roll with it, because Greece. Colin also  gets essentially Netflix's version of a fan cam,   basically a montage that puts him in the  best light possible as this charming,   flirty eligible bachelor that all the girls in the  ton are swooning over, the pirate esque duster,   new tan, and hairdo obviously help. We also  see him in these like random threesomes out   of brothel that I think were supposed to read  as him being like sexually experienced. I also   think because some of the criticisms from  season two was the lack of raunchiness,   they were try to cram in some extra sex while  the audience waited for Pollen to get together. - Same time tomorrow? - Perhaps. - Either way these scenes were so  unwatchably bland. Yeah, I was just,   I was cringing. So I think it's like really  obvious. I don't love what they did with   Colin's character. I think his suave devil  may care attitude recalls Simon in season one,   which we already had. Like we already have  this male, this type of male character,   this archetype. ♪ Nasty girl, nasty ♪ And also  I didn't even buy it, especially because in the   past seasons we've seen Colin be like goofy,  gullible, kind of awkward compared to Anthony   and Benedict. ♪ And let the cat and toads go round  ♪ ♪ And then the cat, and then the cat ♪ And by   the fourth book Colin is pretty insecure and  is undergoing an existential crisis about the   meaning of his life. So I honestly would've  loved for them to explore that side of his   character instead of like remolding him into  what they think women want a leading man to be. - I oiled my way right in, that was an olive joke. - As for Penelope, she decides she's  going to use her Whistledown money to   get a new wardrobe because she's tired of being  single and wearing yellow and can we blame her? - I do not wish to see a citrus color ever again. - [Mina] She debuts her new jewel toned green  dress at the ball with period drama leading lady,   aka incredibly historically inaccurate long  hairdo and she stuns. I also love like you can   see some like copper within the green dress,  like there's a lot of dimension in the dress,   which brings out her hair color really  nicely, but unfortunately for her, even   though there's this outward glow up, she's still  incredibly awkward. So even though some suitors   come to her, she basically chases  them away with her personality. - What a striking gown you have on you. - You as well, my Lord, not not the gown part. - As just a costume note, I really don't like the  sheer gloves, which feel very early 2010s prom and   I think cheapens the whole look. And also I don't  love the bold glamour filter makeup, which again,   it's giving 2010s, like over the past year  or so, I feel like makeup trends have skewed   towards clean beauty, which is actually really  in line with regency period typical makeup. So   going for something simpler would actually be  both appealing to modern and traditional beauty   standards. In an interview with Vulture costume  designer, John Glazer justifies this decision by   saying it's Penelope's first attempt at something  new. So it was a little off and not quite right,   it was too far out of her comfort zone. So  I get it's supposed to be a little too much,   but I think this was just way too much. We could  have achieved the same effect just by the dress   color alone because we never see Penelope wearing  a color this bold or mature ever again. Anyways,   I don't really wanna talk too much about the  costumes because Bridgerton likes to do their   own thing. Clearly the show's designers  have always taken creative liberties,   but I noticed this season the costumes skewed  way more Disney fantasy for some reason. Like   Cressida Cowper's outfits were super maximal  and tackier than they've ever been in the past. Like she's fully giving Cinderella's  evil stepsister and I understand her   costume journey is supposed to represent her  increasing desperation on the marriage market,   but some of these silhouettes were cartoonish  to the point of distraction. It also doesn't   really make sense that her dad would let her  go to balls wearing these outfits in the first   place since every time he's on screen  he's like super rigid and controlling. - You are not to be seen with  that Bridgerton girl any longer. - I mean, look at their home. This is not a  home that supports the puffy sleeve agenda. - It's more like a more  Mausoleum in here, isn't it? - Colin Bridgerton also looks like Captain  Hook from "Once Upon A Time." Assistant   costume designer, Dougie Hawks said of Colin's  look, "I wanted to make him daring, dashing,   and dangerous. Those were the three elements I  wanted to bring into his costume." None of these   things are what I associate with Colin Bridgerton,  and so maybe it's partially the costumes,   but maybe it's partially also the story because he  ended up just reading to me as like a cosplayer.   I wasn't buying it. Glazer told Essence something  interesting about the overall direction in the   season's costumes. "So the audience has  watched the show and we didn't have to   hold to each family's color palette as much as  we did before. Now we can expand our colors,   we can expand our textures, we can help to enhance  the characters without using certain colors that   aren't correct for them. So we were able to design  things that were more in tune with the actual   person and the character that they were showing  us." I'm fine with the color palettes changing and   the incorporation of more textures, but I do think  they went a little too crazy and maximalist, they   were just so many flowers and bows and it made  everything look so much tackier like they just   raided Joanne's Fabric or like Michael's Craft  Store or something. And also again, if they wanted   the costumes to read more modern, fashion has  been skewing minimal with quiet luxury and slinky   nineties silhouettes coming back. So pairing  down like the trimmings and extra elements would   actually look better to our eyes right now, then  you know, whatever was going on here, this stuffy   tweeds Spencer and Francesca wears in particular  haunts me in my sleep. I also don't think that all   the costumes necessarily reflect the characters  that well anyway. For example, Eloise like,   don't get me wrong, I did really like some of  Eloise dresses aside from the, thank you Norman,   aside from the droopy muffs that looked like bath  towels that she was carrying around. But you know,   I really loved her more men's wear adjacent looks  in previous seasons, which felt more in line with   her character. She claims that she's undergoing a  conformity phase at the beginning of the season. - Perhaps my tastes have changed. - But it doesn't really make sense  because at the same time she keeps   swearing off marriage. So why conform  if you still don't wanna participate. - And can you imagine all the spare time there   would be if we did not always  have to think about marriage? - The costume designers are probably just  following along with the script they were given,   so I can't blame them, but this whole Eloise  makeover made very little sense to me. Also   doesn't happen in the books, so they just  threw that in there. I will say that I did   f heavy with Queen Charlotte's wigs, which  I thought were delightfully over the top and   fun in a way that corresponds with her character,  especially the ice sculpture one. It still drives   me crazy that she's wearing 30-year-old fashion  trends as a monarch, but I digress. You know,   we can't win with everything. So back to the  story. The first few episodes are Colin taking   on Penelope as a "She's All That" project.  He's going to teach her how to snag a husband. - I'm the perfect person to practice on. You  don't have to be embarrassed, you know me. - I thought these lessons would take up more of  the show because theoretically they're a good   opportunity to build up the intimacy between the  two of them, but the lessons end pretty quickly   after like one intimate moment. Again, the pacing  of the show was just driving me crazy. Also,   because they're friends, I would've loved  to see more casual banter between the two   of them. Instead, their conversations  are mostly like serious and dramatic,   especially in the second half of the show. Also,  I should add, the reason he volunteers to teach   Penelope is because he feels guilty  that she overheard him dissing her. - I overheard you, telling everyone how you  would never ever court Penelope Featherington. - Which by the way, he never really  addresses why he did that. Like in the books,   Penelope is actually 28 and Colin is 33  by the time they get together. So she's   been on the shelf for a while. She's like  actually verging into spinster territory. - I'm 27 years old, I have no money, and no  prospects. I'm already a burden to my parents. - And the thing that she overheard him say was  years ago, so it's like excused as just him   being immature and silly at the time. Also in the  books leading up to that moment, his mother had   been pressuring him to get with Penelope and  he's tired of hearing about it because he is   not ready to be married and he's venting not  to some random guys that he's friends with,   but to Anthony and Benedict. But in the  show, because they rushed the timeline,   I feel like it's harder for me to believe that  he can go from, I would never court this girl,   to I would die for her, I love her so much,  that quickly. There's a pivotal moment when   Penelope reads his travel diary and he gets  flustered and upset and accidentally cuts his   hand trying to take it back. Penelope  then wraps his hand at a bandage and   the leads to this tender moment between the  two of them. The scene happens in the book,   but it's also a little different. So in the  show, the passage Penelope reads is quite sexual. - [Speaker] In those moments, alone, as my fingers  trace freckles from cheek to collarbone. In the   book she reads a poetic G-rated passage. I get  that "Bridgerton" has a horny reputation to   uphold, but I also think that changing the content  of the passage can make it seem like Colin was   embarrassed she read something so sensual when the  point is that she literally just read his writing   period, which he doesn't think is very good. He's  very insecure about it. This is such a major issue   for Colin in the book. It actually drives his  dislike for Penelope's Lady Whistledown project.   He doesn't care about like gossip or whatever.  He's just jealous that Penelope has the balls   to publish her writing and he doesn't. - Loser.  - But the show scraps the writing insecurities   probably because it felt lowkey misogynistic  in the book and it was annoying that Colin's   problems are like all made up in his head, like  he has the capabilities to publish his writing,   but he just won't. It's not interesting and it  doesn't make him sympathetic to audiences either.   I think what they could have done to update  the story for 2024 sensibilities is to make   him more awkward as well. Like he clearly did  care about external validation because that's   the reason that's implied in the show, why he  was insulting Penelope among his guy friends.   I think this could have been like a nice  coming of age story for the both of them,   but because Colin does his growing off camera  while traveling, this sees it as mostly   Penelope's story with Colin as like a one note  side character. He also virtually always has the   upper hand of the relationship like he's  privileged as a rich desirable man. His   family is wonderful and supportive and for the  majority of the show, Penelope has always been   the one pursuing him. So the relationship  feels really imbalanced with Penelope   and us basically just waiting for Colin to  finally admit himself that he's interested in her. - Because I love you. - Are you sure? - Are we sure? As Catherine Van Arondonk  writes in her review of the show for Vulture,   "Colin has ample resources, the social standing to  survive a scandal and almost no responsibilities.   He's the most desired bachelor of the season. He's  doing great. So when the inevitable fallout of   Penelope's secret identity finally reaches Colin,  the betrayal and sadness that should feel equal on   each side instead feels obnoxiously lopsided.  Ideally, when two romantic leads clash,   the audience should be able to sympathize with  both parties understanding whatever perspective is   keeping them apart, even if they'll clearly work  it out. But because Colin has so little growth   over the course of the season, the viewer is  mostly waiting for him to get over himself." Also,   Penelope has done so much for Colin like writing  him letters and telling him he's so talented, - Your writing, it's very good. - So when she dares to advocate for herself  for once with her Whistledown column and he   antagonizes her, it feels annoying,  controlling, borderline misogynistic. - Are you going to stop publishing? - I do not know. - Let us get through this wedding and then  we will decide what this marriage will be. - Get away from her! - By the way, I think I should clarify. I  don't really fuck with the overlooked woman   pining over a hot man trope. It's actually  more annoying in the book because every time   it shifts to Penelope's POV, it's her moping  about how Colin couldn't possibly love her. It   also takes a lot longer in the book for Collin to  realize he's in love with Penelope. But you know,   we're in simp boy summer low key with  "Challengers" and the please, please,   please video being strong in the zeitgeist.  So yeah, I'm just really not in the mindset   to see a woman yearning harder for a man than  he does for her, you know? I did cry like a   faucet though when Penelope asked Colin to kiss  her because I'm a human and I have feelings. - But I am nearly on the shelf and I have never  been kissed and I'm not certain I ever will be. - But Penelope, we deserve better. To raise  the stakes, we introduce Lord Debling,   who is this dashing wealthy lord who loves  nature and he takes a liking to Penelope. - Well done. - For being a fool? - For stepping away from the herd. - And also sort of looks like a teddy bear graham  cracker. He also doesn't care about gossip and   also would smash. I really liked Lord Debling.  I thought he was so sweet and honestly I liked   his scenes with the Penelope more than Collin's  scenes with Penelope. I'm sorry, shoot me. Lord   Debling saved her from getting knocked over by  a hot air balloon that was pretty swoon worthy. - Miss Featherington. - He's chivalrous, he's multifaceted, and he's  a man who knows himself. We can't say the same   about Colin Bridgerton. Apparently the reason why  Colin takes so long to recognize he loves Penelope   is because he expects love to feel like getting  struck by a lightning bolt. So he asked his mother   for advice and she tells him that her relationship  with his father was actually a friendship first. - But I thought you believed the best  foundation for great love was friendship. - Indeed I do. It is how your father and I began. - But then when she's giving  advice to her daughter Francesca,   she tells her that her relationship  was surprising and forceful. - You know, when I first met your father, I  could barely speak my own name. I was so taken   by him I thought that that is what love must be  like for everyone. Surprising, forceful, quick. - Like what is the truth Violet? So in my  opinion, repression, because you're trying to   uphold your family reputation and decenter your  own needs and wants, a la Anthony Bridgerton.   Incredibly based romantic, sexy. Repression,  because you have no emotional intelligence,   incredibly lame. Lord Debling's existence  is literally only to make Colin jealous.   I'm serious he literally disappears after  Penelope and Colin get together. Like what   happened to him? Like is he still single? Is he  still looking? The pivotal moment is that Colin   sees Debling and Penelope together at the ball  and he interrupts them mid-dance and botches the   entire proposal because he just can't stand the  idea that Penelope is gonna marry someone else. - You cannot marry that man. - And then he f'ed her in the horse carriage  afterwards as if that's supposed to make up   for it. Maybe I'm just old, but nothing about  this was romantic to me, it was sexy, sure,   but definitely not romantic. Like Brittany  Broski mentioned this on her podcast. It's   like when your ex comes barking back, only  when he finds out you're with a new man,   like it's too late. Also, could we not have  publicly embarrassed everyone by throwing a   tantrum in the middle of a dance? Like could  we not have confessed our feelings later in   private like civilized people? That's the  first half of the season. The second half   deals with the Lady Whistledown persona.  Eloise puts pressure on Penelope to tell   Colin, who for no justifiable reason has a  newfound sworn hatred of Lady Whistledown. - I will make sure it is her life that is ruined. - I say not justifiable because he didn't actually  care about Lady Whistledown the previous seasons   and also he's a man like why do you as a man  care so much about gossip stay in your business? - You did not read Lady Whistledown. - I do not. - Colin finds out says he'll never forgive her. - I will never forgive you. - But still marries Penelope anyway because  he is a man of honor. And then the next few   episodes are whiplash of him going back  and forth between being in love and then   being annoyed. Like they would literally fight  and then I guess he would get lost in her eyes   or something and then start making out with her. - You've been putting yourself in danger,  living this double life all along. - But then they'd be back to being tense again the  next day with him sleeping on the sate. Speaking   of, I know his back must feel crazy after sleeping  on that sate, like his legs are definitely hanging   off the arm. Can we not afford anything else in  this Bridgerton household? Can we not afford a   longer couch? Queen Charlotte fueled by her one  sided beef also announces that anyone who can   unveil Lady Whistledown will receive 5,000  pounds from her. Cressida Cowper, desperate   for money to get away from her oppressive  father, claims to be Whistledown herself. - Today I bring you much gossip from about  the many lands near and far, far and wide.   She publishes a letter just to prove it and it  is scathing towards the Bridgertons because this   follows a fight between her and Eloise and you  know, she was feeling, I guess a little upset. - [Speaker] Perhaps the family  confuses love with lust. - And also Cressida's mother has one  side of beef with the Bridgertons,   but Penelope who hates Cressida cannot  rest with her taking the credit and   therefore writes a letter as well just to  say Cressida is in fact not Lady Whistledown. - [Speaker] And I cannot tolerate a lie. - Queen Charlotte then suspects Whistledown  is one of the Bridgertons because the second   letter came out to discredit  all the anti Bridgerton claims. - Only when the Cowper girl  publishes lies about this very family   suddenly Whistledown rushes to print. - Which continuity wise doesn't make  sense because Lady Whistledown has   published scandalous things  about the Bridgertons before. - [Queen] Is this new character the  real him or simply a ploy for attention. - So logically doesn't make any sense. In the  final episode at the ball, Penelope unveils   herself, apologizes for some of the things that  she's written and promises to do better with her   pen. Queen Charlotte forgives her, allows her  to keep writing, because there's literally no   other way for the plot to go. Colin and  Eloise also forgive her. I don't know,   it just felt like a cop out, like it didn't feel  rewarding for me as a viewer. Also in the book   it's actually Colin who devises the plan to reveal  Penelope as Lady Whistledown in front of the ton,   but he introduces her with this like heartfelt  speech about how proud of her he is that catches   Penelope off guard and reaffirms her love for  him. I guess they wanted Penelope to have the   agency to put herself in the spotlight, which I  can respect, but the unfortunate thing is like   the relationship suffers because of that.  Cressida then gets shipped off to her aunt   in Wales and we skip ahead in the future where  Penelope and her sisters have all given birth   to new babies and Colin has published his book.  Penelope also continues to write Lady Whistledown,   which doesn't make logistical sense since the  only reason she was able to overhear so much   gossip in the first place is because people  didn't care about her. Like now that everyone   knows she's Lady Whistledown, who is going to  say anything scandalous with her around? I'm   also wondering if Nicola Cochlan, I learned  that's how her name is pronounced the other   day. I apologize for previous mispronunciations,  but I wonder if she'll be contracted to provide   Lady Whistledown's voiceover every  season now instead of Julie Andrews - [Penelope] As we begin this  next part of our journey- - And like I obviously want the most success  for Nicola because I'm obsessed with her and   if you haven't seen "Derry Girls," you absolutely  need to run, don't walk. So I obviously want her   career to blow up even more and for her to like do  other projects outside of Bridgerton. But I think   without Lady Whistledown or Penelope in this  case, the show loses its structure completely.   Like every episode is bracketed by voiceovers  from Lady Whistledown that explained to us,   the audience, what's going on in the show. Lady  Whistledown was also a major part of the series'   initial marketing. It would just be really strange  to introduce a new format without her, but I guess   you know, we'll have to wait and see. The main  problem with the season for me, aside from my own   romance taste veering away from the polytropes and  Colin's entire character annoying me, is that they   broke away from the format of centering the main  couple and instead tried to do the whole ensemble   cast format by going back and forth between many  different stories, which would've been okay if   the stories were interesting, but many of them  were not. For example, the Madrich family finds   out their son has inherited the Kent estate  and they basically undergo non-real problems,   aka the woes of adjusting to rich people life.  It's just incredibly boring and unnecessary.   It would've been different if the ton was more  judgmental about their status change and there   was like an actual struggle to be accepted, but  all their problems like exist in their own heads.   And while I love Anthony and Kate, they also  sort of just exist as fan service in the season.   At the end of the show they announced they're  going to India, but Kate says she's pregnant,   and I think that's like a crazy idea to go on a  months long journey by ship as a pregnant woman   in the 19th century. It also doesn't make any  sense because Anthony is a Viscount. So he's in   charge of managing the Bridgerton estate and he's  also pretty hardass about it. So it's also like   out of character for him to be like, okay, bye for  the next several years. I don't live under a rock,   okay, like I'm sure the India plot line is  literally just to serve as an out for the actor   so they don't have to come back while still giving  the audience an explanation for why they're gone.   Because when Reggie Jean Page left the show, it  was kind of off putting for fans since there was   like no reason for him to be absent. Phoebe  Dynevor also didn't show up in season three,   which I'm not gonna lie, I knew she wasn't  coming back ahead of time, but it was still   really distracting for me that Daphne Bridgerton  was not at her brother or sister's wedding,   especially when she allegedly lives like not  too far away. I also wanna clarify that I don't   fault any actor who decides not to return.  A cameo every now and then would be lovely,   but I can understand why it's difficult going from  like number one on the call sheet to a guest spot.   Any good agent would be like, you're not doing  that, especially if there's other projects that   are trying to cast you that might conflict with  Bridgerton's production schedule. I actually   clocked this when I first heard the direction  that "Bridgerton" was taking with centering new   characters each season. It's just like a recipe  for actors to leave and I wonder how it's going to   affect the show's viewership in the future. Like  it's sort of emotional whiplash to see characters   that you spent hours investing in just disappear  completely. I wonder if this is why the series has   taken a more ensemble approach so that we can  start emotionally attaching to side characters   in the case of the main ones leaving. So this is  not to say that I don't like an ensemble format,   like I did really enjoy the Gilded Age and I think  that is like a perfect example of an ensemble   story because every character gets like a lot of  spotlight and there's not one story that really   dominates, but I think it'll be difficult for  "Bridgerton" to adjust to that because all their   marketing is literally about the main couple.  You know, even despite the season giving Pollen   less screen time than the previous couples, like  all the marketing was about Pollen. But anyway,   back to other things I didn't like in the plot,  Lady Danbury's brother Marcus is introduced to   become Violet Bridgerton's new boo, which is  fine, but then there's this like low stakes   drama between Lady Danbury and Marcus that's not  properly fleshed out and just takes up screen   time. Benedict gets swept into a twosome and then  a threesome unleashing his bisexual awakening that   everyone in the audience already saw coming. This  was fun, I love to see that queer representation,   but lowkey it wasn't spicy enough, like not enough  tension, not enough taboo, not enough anything.   Sorry, my standards are just really high now.  Like "Challengers" was just hot off the press. - I'd let her f me with a racket. - So in the wise words of Tasha Duncan, come on.  I realize this review has been very negative and I   don't wanna completely pan the season, like there  were a few plot lines I did like. For example,   I liked that Cressida Cowper's character gets  fleshed out more. In the book, she's just like   a run of the mill one dimensional villain.  Her original story is that she gets married,   but her husband turns out to be poor, which is why  she's after money now. In the show, she's trying   to get money to break away from her terrible  family and live independently. This new arc   makes her way more sympathetic to the point where  I actually got annoyed with Eloise just dropping   her as a friend, and that scene when Colin didn't  understand that she's not as privileged as him. - You take for granted that you will  always have your family support. - Actually, Colin pissed me off a lot during  the scene because his character is giving,   I don't care about a woman's struggles unless  I'm attracted to them. Like Anthony, god tier. - I'm a gentleman. - Anthony is the type to make sure his wife's  friends make it all home safely. Colin,   I'm not so sure about. In the end Cressida did I  get shipped off to Wales, so that was sort of like   an anti climactic end to her story. I do feel  like she might come back in a later season as a   new evolved person, but you know, that to me again  feels a little lazy. It's once again using travel   as a way to develop a character without having to  actually write that development. But who knows,   maybe we'll follow Cressida in Wales. I also  really love Portia Featherington a lot and   her changing relationship with Penelope over this  season. Previously, Portia had overlooked Penelope   and made jabbing remarks at her expense. So it  feels really rewarding to see her struggle with   saying the right thing now. Like even when she  says something hurtful, you see the remorse and   confusion in her face like she thought she was  helping, but clearly she didn't. But finally,   Porsche and Penelope learned to understand  each other, which I think is, you know,   really touching. I really enjoyed their scenes  together. I also was very interested in Eloise   and Penelope's dynamic this season. Like this  was the love story I was actually most invested   in. It was lovely to see the nuances of how  Eloise still cared for Penelope all season. - Oh, how mortifying. I'm so clumsy.  I thought we did not like Penelope. - What you did was cruel and unnecessary. - But just like wasn't ready to forgive her until  the end. And if I'm allowed to speak, they should   have been the endgame couple. Like it goes back  to that quote I read earlier about how like   it's ideal for in a conflict between a romantic  couple, like even if they're wrong in some way,   it's important for the audience to understand each  person's position. And for Colin and Penelope,   we don't really understand any of Colin's  decisions, but for Eloise and Penelope like   that is the perfect conflict where it's like these  two girls like hurt each other so much where you   can see why the friendship is not working out  between them, but you still want it to work out   because they still like love each other deep  down. All in all, I watched the whole thing,   so I liked it enough and I get it's hard to follow  the Magnum opus of Kanthony. I also think that   because of the two year break between seasons two  and three, there were plot points that I didn't   remember and had to look up, which kind of took me  out of it. For example, the whole cousin Jack scam   that was referred to multiple times had completely  left my short term memory storage. Also, the fact   that Penelope wrote about Eloise's friendship  with Theo in Lady Whistledown, which was the whole   reason for their fallout is only hinted at, I feel  like that should have been like reestablished more   firmly because I feel like when you take such  a long break between seasons, it's difficult   to expect everyone to remember all the plot points  covered before and it's also unrealistic to expect   everyone's going to rewatch the previous seasons  in preparation for this one. Like there's just   too many TV shows, there's not enough time, like  people are not gonna do that. Apparently season   four also won't be coming out for another two  years, so I'm hoping that they'll keep this all   in mind. For now I am planning to keep watching  because Benedict is one of my favorite characters. - Does the lady return your affection? - Not yet. And she would've  done if it were not for the- - The sister. Do you do this every night? - Oh, did you come to admonish me? - [Benedict] I only need to- - He's got the leading man's sauce. ♪ You want it  ♪ ♪ Ride it ♪ ♪ Let's do it ♪ But I'm not gonna   lie, I do get turned off by long breaks because  it ruins the momentum of the show, like I just   want shows to go back to a yearly format. Like  is that too much to ask? Let's not get fancy.   I don't need CGI or wigs with moving swans in  them. I just want consistency and that's why   "The Bear" will always come up top. Anyway, this  is the end. Let me know in the comments what you   thought about "Bridgerton" season three, if you  agreed with me or disagreed with me or anything,   love to hear it. Thank you all so much for  watching and I'll see you next time. Okay, bye.
Info
Channel: Mina Le
Views: 673,881
Rating: undefined out of 5
Keywords: bridgerton, polin, colin bridgerton, penelope featherington, nicola coughlan, luke newton, shonda rhimes, shondaland, netflix, julia quinn, anthony bridgerton, daphne bridgerton, benedict bridgerton, eloise bridgerton, jess brownell, commentary, review, recap, video essay, mina le, kate sharma, kanthony, costume, historical accuracy
Id: qSFcXtl9WyU
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 35min 46sec (2146 seconds)
Published: Tue Jun 25 2024
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.