Taxi Trouble in St. Louis
Video Statistics and Information
Channel: Martin Pauly
Views: 29,370
Rating: undefined out of 5
Keywords: st. louis, STL, KSTL, Lambert International, St. Louis Lambert, st. louis airport, taxi trouble, trouble, flying, pilot, poor performance, cockpit view, taxi, taxiing, large airport, class bravo, flight training, multi engine training, pilot training, recurring training, cockpit video, pilot magic, pilots eye, cockpit landing, cockpit view landing, flight training videos
Id: 0qqMFycuJAg
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 17min 45sec (1065 seconds)
Published: Sat May 11 2019
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.
Love your videos. No snappy distracting music, chock full of instruction, good maps and lots of ATC banter which I need right now as I am just venturing into Class D and Flight Following. Great stuff, thank you for taking the time to post.
So note from a controller about your critique of ACT regarding the SW aircraft (And this is all my opinion/preferences). It sounds like ground was decently busy. A hold short requires the GC to make two transmissions one for you to hold and then another for you to continue, while a give way only requires one, the give way. The GC was saving about 6-10 second of radio time by giving you the give way. Also looking at the video the stop you had to make to give way was short so if they gave the hold you would either be waiting longer than needed or they would be coming back to you almost right after you finished your read back.
The GC did try to distinguish the SW aircraft by stating that it would be left to right on L. Now the aircraft was rolling out then and a clearer transmission would be "give way to the SW aircraft rolling out on 30R exiting at L" (but that is also slightly longer than just left to right at L) and also there is the minor issue (that I also sometimes make) of stating where and AC will be when the transmission is finished rather than where it is when the transmission is started.
My advise back to you is if you are given a give way at a point treat it as a hold short of that point until you know the traffic is past. In this case with the confusion, and this is just my opinion/preference, would be for you to hold short of L and query, something like this:
AC: ACID, give way to the SW at L, I don't have him in sight.
GC: ACID, He is rolling out 30r
AC: ACID, In sight
Much shorter and concise then the controller not getting an immediate read back, seeing you still rolling sightly forward, and having to reissue the instruction in full again.
And once again this just my opinion/preference. I have not worked a B (yet), but I do work at an airport that has fairly complex ground movements and can get quite busy.
We all have bad days sometimes, right? I sure had one going into St. Louis Lambert International (STL) in the Bonanza a while ago. I bet my taxi from the runway to the FBO did not impress the ground controller. In the spirit of learning, let me replay for you what happened, and see what I could have done better.
The bottom line is: making (occasional) mistakes is part of life, but we should seek to learn from them.
Iām shocked they made you land out on that far runway. When I had a job flying a Meridian into STL weekly I always requested 30R for the turn off right down there by kilo out of the way and just up the hill to signature. Seemed like that was the norm for them to do for private aircraft
No flight through the arch. Clickbait
That controller kept rapid firing instructions at you like he was working rush hour at ORD, and was getting irritated when you didn't immediately pick up on the pace like you were a 20,000 hour airline pilot. The problems were all his creation. You did fine.
My best advice to avoid this in the future is the magic word "unfamiliar." Tell them you are unfamiliar. They should slow down and give you clearer instructions, if not downright progressive. It's their job. Don't feel bad for asking them to do it. Specifically ask for progressive if you need it.