[instrumental music] <i> My name's Chloe.</i> <i> I'm 20.</i> <i> I'm an art student at Wells
College in Bradford, New York.</i> <i> I don't remember the first time</i> <i> I picked up a brush
and tried to paint.</i> <i> There's a lot about being litte</i> <i> that I just can't seem
to remember.</i> <i> My first day of school.</i> <i> When I learned to ride a bike.</i> <i> My eighth birthday.</i> <i> All things that I know happened
but I can't seem to access the.</i> [instrumental music] <i> I've lived in this town
my whole life.</i> <i> I've walked across this bridge
maybe a thousand times.</i> <i> But...I don't know
many people here.</i> [instrumental music] <i> It's hard to tell who
to trust sometimes.</i> <i> That all changed when
the dream started.</i> <i> The dream began to
unlock...everything.</i> [instrumental music] [engine idling] [tires squeal] [instrumental music] [tires squeal] [loud gasp] [panting] [Instrumental music] <i> What I'm about to tell you is
the story according to me.</i> <i> And it's tricky when you don't
know if your own story has</i> <i> a reliable author.</i> Today we're going to
discuss the works of post-impressionist painter,
Vincent van Gogh. <i> The dream was just
the start of it.</i> <i> It felt like a warning.</i> <i> And there was really no one
I could talk to about it</i> <i> who would understand.</i> <i> I couldn't trust anyone with i.</i> <i> No one except my friend
Rebecca.</i> <i> But she didn't understand
everything.</i> -It's happening more and more.
-It's always the same truck? I think so. But this time it was
chasing you? Maybe it's a premonition. Or maybe you're worried
about something. Your fall showcase project
perhaps? Right, like the truck represents
my art professors just looming in the shadows
waiting to run me down with their opinions. Don't laugh. You do put a lot of pressure
on yourself. You're right. That must be it. First semester anxiety. -Thanks for the diagnosis.
-Ahh, not so fast. -What else?
-What else what? How've your headaches been? Headaches are fine. You'd tell me if they weren't
fine though, right? Of course, I tell you
everything. You better. [instrumental music] <i> Like many of you,
I have a few secrets.</i> <i> And I've become good
at hiding them.</i> <i> He had secrets too.</i> <i> There was something about him
that seemed...broken.</i> <i> The walking wounded can
sense it on each other.</i> <i> Something happened to him.</i> <i> His confidence.</i> <i> His serenity.</i> <i> Or his faith.</i> <i> There were definitely scars
under his skin</i> <i> and they were leading him to m.</i> [instrumental music] About ten years ago they
started a restoration but they ran out of money. You can see a good number
of them have cracks and are no longer
secured to the floor. Well, the wood's fine. Yeah, there's some cracks but, I mean, the structure's
good overall. Good, because we don't have
the budget to replace very much. Nah, I wouldn't do that. Just get somebody in here to
swap out these angle irons. Maybe even replace
the cleats too. As far as the cracks, just throw
some colored epoxy in there. It's gonna look better
than fresh wood patches. When do you want to start? Me? Nah, you've got to get
yourself a pro. Um, thing is I sort of already
told the trustees you'd do it. And that you'd give us
a great deal. It's not my problem,
big brother. Josh, you'd be doing me
a huge favor. We both know you can do it. Never met a more gifted guy
in my life. Yeah, nice try. Look, you got a church full
of people ready to help you out. Say the word. Right. Okay. Thank you, Josh. Oh - almost forgot. Calls are still coming for you
at the house. Got one from the Global
Missions Institute. They'd love to set up
an interview. Thanks. You going to call? Probably not. [instrumental music] -Have a nice day.
-Thanks. <i> I moved out on my own
a few months ago.</i> <i> With school, it seemed
the right thing to do.</i> <i> But really, my mom
and I haven't been</i> <i> on the same page for some time.</i> <i> Her need for me to need her
and my refusal to do so,</i> <i> it had us moving in
different directions.</i> <i> Two strangers living on
different frequencies.</i> Hey, Chloe. Mom? I know, I know, showing up
at work is not cool. But I've been trying to get
a hold of you and, well, I get worried about
you when I don't hear from you. I'm fine, Mom. See? All in one piece. How's school? Okay. Well, maybe we can
grab a bite to eat once you finish up. I wish I could but I really
have to work on my showcase project tonight. Well, I'm glad that
everything is going okay. Maybe you could come by
this weekend and we can do
something together. I miss you. Miss you too, Mom. [bell chimes] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] Hey Josh, I woke up this morning and I just had this song
in my head and it made me think
of you and me. So do me a favor and just never
stop seeing with your heart. [acoustic guitar music] [humming] ♪ All my life I've
waited for this. ♪ ♪ To move out and grow up ♪ ♪ and not be a kid,
but I'm done... ♪ My sister died doing
something that she loved... helping people in a country where walking three miles
for three gallons of water was an everyday occurrence. She had such an amazing spirit;
her infectious smile, caring personality
and her devotion to God, impacted all that knew her. And now, through
this scholarship, she will impact many more
for years to come. Thank you. [applause] [instrumental music] I always liked this one. Your first year at Columbia. I liked your speech. It's really difficult
to talk about. But it honors Hannah and it will
make a difference, which is what she
always wanted to do. Got to keep looking forward,
right? Yeah. Did you really cancel
an interview with Project Hope? It wasn't the right timing. Timing? You loved interning with them
last year. I always get the sense that you're still trying
to figure it all out. It's not your fault. Yep, I'm still Hannah's
annoying little sister. Especially when it comes to you. [instrumental music] [instrumental music] <i> (whispering) You saw
what happened.</i> What's wrong with you? <i> (whispering) You saw
what happened.</i> Get off me! <i> (whispering) You saw...</i> Get off! [heartbeats and eerie music] Aahh! [panting] No, no. Aahh! ♪ Surrender your word ♪ ♪ Uncover your heart ♪ [cell phone buzzes] [phone beeps] <i> Hey Josh, it's Mark.</i> <i> Uh, you snuck out before
I could catch you,</i> <i> but we're having a cookout
on Saturday.</i> <i> I asked Hannah's sister Brooke
to come by.</i> <i> Let me know if you can make it.</i> [tires squeal] [instrumental music] Hey! Hey... are you okay? You're shivering. Look, did somebody
do this to you? You're freezing. Listen, my name is Josh. Look at me. Is there
somebody else out here? Okay, I'm going to call 911,
everything's going to be okay. We gotta get you
off this road. What is your name? [instrumental music] [voice over PA] We'll need to ask her
a few questions in a minute. That shouldn't be a problem. <i> Dr. Isaac dial zero.</i> Josh? I'm Sgt. Stanford. You're the one that found her? Yeah. She's an art student
up at the college. That's paint all over her,
not blood. [Josh sighs] Now the last thing she
remembers is working late in one of the studios up there. So what happened? If she knows, she's not saying. Did she say anything to you? No. Nothing that made any sense. (phone rings) Excuse me. Yeah, Stanford. Uh huh. [door opens] Hey. So sorry, I tried to get over
as soon as I could. How did you know I was here? You called me. Don't you remember? You said you'd tell me
if there was ever a problem. There hasn't been. I've been okay. You're okay for a little while,
but it's getting pretty clear that these blackouts
aren't just gonna go away. I think it's time you talked
to your mom about this. Chloe, it's heartbreaking to
watch this happen to you. I can see that you're scared
but I won't leave you. If you talk to someone
about this, I will stay with you
through all of it. No. Well, you're going to have
to think of something or they're going
to keep you here. [knocking] You up for a few more questions? I'll be right outside. Campus security gave me a call. Said the art room you were in
was pretty messed up. What happened up there? I didn't do anything wrong. Let me ask you something,
if we were to run a drug test, what's gonna pop up? I didn't take anything,
okay, I'm not on drugs. You're gonna have to give me
something. The docs here want to put you
on mental health arrest. Chloe, I'm on your side. Why don't you let me help you? I've been working late a lot. I haven't been getting
much sleep. So, you're telling me this is
sleep deprivation? Hmm mm. Nice try. This school is just
so competitive that I need to be my best
all the time. Because everyone else
is so perfect. And, I just, I just don't think
my work measures up. You on a scholarship? I am. And it was really hard to get. And I really don't want
to lose it. [instrumental music] <i> It's a challenge finding
the right balance</i> <i> to stay one step ahead
in moments like this.</i> <i> There is always some real truth
under the truth you tell.</i> <i> But, even if I could understand
what happened,</i> <i> even if I had the words
to explain it,</i> <i> I couldn't trust anyone with i.</i> [rattles doorknob] It's a mess in there. Campus security talk to you yet? I really just need to get
my project back. Your project? It's ruined. [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] She went to Bradford. In your class? The year after me. She was always kind of
a loner, by choice. I mean, she didn't call too much
attention to herself. I don't remember her...
at all. Well, bet you won't
forget her now. How's it looking? Like I'm stuck doing
all the cooking. Sounds like Josh didn't get
much attention today. Mark, you better give
baby brother a hug. Just got off the phone. The board gave your quote
a thumbs up. You can start on the benches
any time. I know what you're
doing, Mark. What's that? The benches. It's not going to work. You think with me spending
all this time in the church that I'm going to start
coming back into things. Go on. I don't want to
disappoint you, brother. You can never disappoint me. I just don't like seeing you
hurting like this. I don't care if you don't
like it. It's not about you. Josh, you're right. I'm sorry. Dinner's ready! Lord God, we thank You
for all the gifts You give us each day. We thank You even when we
can't understand things, You are still in control. Give us faith to hold fast
to what we know is true... <i> A lot of people tell you
to let your secrets out</i> <i> so they don't have
power over you.</i> <i> I don't know.</i> <i> Maybe I just never knew anyone
I trusted that much.</i> <i> More often than not,
when I gave myself away</i> <i> it came back to hurt me.</i> <i> When a secret's out,
then a part of you is out.</i> <i> It's something that belongs
to others now.</i> <i> And you don't control
the darkness anymore.</i> [wind blowing] <i> (whispering) You saw.</i> [wind blowing] <i> You saw what happened.</i> [screams] <i> (whispering) You've seen it.</i> [eerie music] [eerie music] [eerie music] [eerie music] [papers rustling] [eerie music] [eerie music] I think it's a premonition. Stop. I think this is saying that
something bad is going to happen to you. It's just a bad dream. Yes, a dream about you! Okay... I'm listening. I think that these drawings
are saying that something tragic is
going to happen. Okay, well, then we need
to talk to someone. Who? I think I know, and just
hear me out. He's one of the pastors
at my church. His name is Mark.
He's a great guy. He's a great listener.
He's... helpful. Are you serious? Like that's who you
came up with? I get it, but haven't you
ever wondered what it would be like
to feel safe? To feel like you really matter? Just think about it. Either it helps or we're back
where we started. I'll meet you there
after my shift. Living out your faith is
so important. It's not easy. Never forget that when you're
going through suffering... nothing can separate you
from God's love. Put your hand up if you've
ever been sad before. Look around. Everyone's hand is up. Everyone goes through
hard times. Know that in each one
of those times when you went through
difficulty, God was with you. Each and every one of you. Always, especially during
the most difficult times. Remember that.
Know that. Take confidence in it.
I sure do. [Josh sighs] [instrumental music] ♪ It's hard to understand
this life we're living ♪ ♪ More down than up, more lost
than found these days. ♪ ♪ And everybody's searching
for the reasons ♪ ♪ of a pain and shame,
it just won't go away ♪ <i> Have you ever wondered if
God was really out there?</i> <i> Like I said, things usually
ended very bad for me</i> <i> when I put my faith
in someone else.</i> <i> And that's what led me
to my wall.</i> <i> I'd been hiding my secrets
here for so long,</i> <i> but my situation never seemed
to get any better.</i> <i> Maybe Rebecca was right.</i> <i> Maybe it was time to try
something else.</i> ♪ Be with us now ♪ ♪ If love can conquer
every fear, ♪ ♪ please wash away
these tears. ♪ ♪ Be with us now ♪♪ [instrumental music] Hey. Hey. How you doing? Good. Everything okay? Yeah, I'm just waiting
for somebody. Well, I'm glad you're
feeling better. -Josh?
-Yeah. Do you know Rebecca? Rebecca? I don't think so. We're meeting with Pastor Mark. What, tonight? Well, there's no one left
in the church... Pastor Mark's not here? No. Hey, do you have a phone? Maybe you can call her? N..no, that's fine. I think I know where
she might be. But... [street noises] [door closes] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] Help you, honey? Yeah uh...is Rebecca here? Um, I'm not sure. There's a table of kids
around the corner. Maybe she's back there. [instrumental music] Uh...did she have to work late? -Who's that?
-Rebecca. I'm sorry, sweetie, I don't know
who you're talking about. Is she not back there
with those kids? No. She's a waitress here. Are you sure you have
the right place? Yes, Rebecca. Everything okay? She's looking for someone
named, Rebecca that she says works here. Ain't nobody named Rebecca
work here. Okay, did she set you guys up
for this? Will you tell her that I went
to the church? Okay? I waited there for her. Honey, there is nobody here
named Rebecca. [instrumental music] Will you stop saying that! Of course, there's
a Rebecca here. She works here! I don't know what you want me
to tell you, sweetie. -There's no one here.
-Stop calling me "sweetie"! Okay, either you get out of here
or I'm calling the cops. You know what?
Go ahead. Uh look, maybe we better
go outside. They won't tell me
where Rebecca is. Okay, then I'll help you
find Rebecca. Lola, do not call the cops. -Josh, you know her?
-Yes. You need to get her
out of here. You need to relax. Chloe, Rebecca's not here and they're going
to call the cops. and I'll help you find her but
we need to get out of here. [instrumental music] Chloe! We don't need any crazy
people in here. You call the cops. Hey! -Hey, slow down.
-Get away from me! I'm just trying to help you. I don't need your help, okay.
I need to find Rebecca and something's
happened to her and they all know it. I told her that something
was going to happen. Why don't we try this? Tell me where she lives
and we'll go to my truck and I will take you there. She, um...
Why can't I remember? Okay, look, you're confused,
it's okay to be confused. I'm not confused, okay
so stop treating me like a baby! I'm not treating you
like a baby! Just tell me. Does she live in town because wherever you want
to go, I'll take you. [siren blasts] Oh no. [instrumental music] Miss? Hold it right there. We got a call that you were
a little upset. [instrumental music] [papers rustling] This is her? Yeah, I talked to the owner
of the diner. He said nobody named Rebecca
worked there right now. She was at the hospital
the other night when you came in. She was? She was in the room when
you came to talk to me. Chloe, no one was in that
hospital room with you. [sighs] How long have you
been seeing these? I've been seeing them in pieces
for a while now. What, are you going to put me
under mental health arrest? That's not up to me. I'm just here trying to sort
through all this out right now. I'm going to show you a picture
and I want you to tell me if it looks like your friend,
Rebecca Cole. That her? Yes. -Where is she?
-Just calm down. No. What happened to her? -Where did she go?
-Just one thing at a time. How did you meet Rebecca,
do you remember? At the diner. My mom and I used to go
and she would wait on us. -The girl in that picture?
-Yes. -You're positive.
-Yes. -And you became friends?
-Where is she? Chloe, you're right. Rebecca worked at
the Parkside Diner. But she went missing
12 years ago. That can't be true. You were a little girl. Maybe you don't remember. I'm going to take you over
to the hospital and some doctors are going
to take a look at you. You mean the Psych Ward. You been there before? Once. When you were little? Yeah. I want you to sit tight. You can hang on to that
if you want. [chair scrapes] (sighs) Sorry to
keep you waiting. [deep sigh] I thought things were
getting better for her. You kid yourself. She hasn't been
returning my calls. I'm thinking she's so busy,
you know, caught up in school. Hmm. So this is the first time something like this
has happened? No. This is more progressive. When she was eight years old, she started having
these episodes. She called them blackouts. And the doctors, they said
it was some kind of amnesia. Maybe um, maybe stress related, or triggered by some kind
of food allergy, you know, something that she eventually
would grow out of. All the things the doctors say when they don't know
what else to say, right? Hmm. And you want to believe them because you don't know
what else to believe. You don't want to believe that
there's something deeper and darker going on
with your daughter. Did she ever get extensive
professional help? Yeah. But she didn't want
to open up to him. She became more and more
guarded over the years. You attend church at Riverside? Yeah. So Chloe would know Pastor Mark
from there? -Sure.
-Hmm. When Chloe was a little girl, it wasn't a really good time
for me. There's a lot of things
that I did that, uh, that I'm not proud of. And actually, there's a lot
that I really don't remember. It's okay. [sniffles] [traffic sounds] [Jukebox playing in background] -Hey.
-Hey. My friend Julie works
at the hospital. She said they took Chloe
over there. Do you think she's hallucinating
all this? I don't know. Rebecca Cole. I remember all that like
it was yesterday. I completely forgot that
she worked at the diner. [phone ringing] Oh, it's Julie. Hey. What? Wait what? No, hang on, you're breaking up. [instrumental music] Okay, I didn't do
anything wrong. I was just trying to find
my friend! I need you to stop moving
for me, okay? Have you taken anything tonight? -No!
-Tell me so I can help you. Yeah, I just need to find
my friend! Hey, hey, hey! -She's just a little confused.
-Come on, Miss. -This isn't necessary.
-Hold on. Please help me. You're not going
to believe this. Chloe ran off. They were holding her
at the ER and when no one was looking,
she just slipped out. The whole police department
is on the search. [sighs] [instrumental music] <i> When I was little, I used
to live this fantasy story.</i> <i> I'd play in a field of
wildflowers, feeling free.</i> <i> Safe.</i> <i> Imagining I could be
like that someday.</i> <i> But really...the feeling
never lasted very long.</i> <i> There was always something
pulling me back.</i> [instrumental music] [instrumental music] <i> I know it's crazy.</i> <i> I can't explain Rebecca.</i> <i> Even now, it's impossible
for me to understand.</i> <i> But there was a reason
she came to me.</i> <i> A reason for all of it.</i> <i> And I had to find out why.</i> <i> Before everyone found me.</i> [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [drill running] You okay? Why wouldn't I be? After last night, just thought
I'd check in. Yeah, I'm fine. [drill running] [sighs] [crickets chirping] [drill whirring] Hey. A lot of people are
looking for you. I used to go to church here. Yeah? Me, too. They told me Rebecca vanished. Yeah, I know. I don't get what's
happening to me. And I don't understand what
happened to Rebecca. Is it really true? Yeah. I don't want to go back
to that hospital. You don't have to go
to the hospital. Why don't we just do this? Can you sit and talk for awhile?
Can you do that? I'll stand here. You can talk. (chuckles) Okay. I want to be someone
you can trust, Chloe. I don't know if I can do that. Come on. Do you know what
happened to her? No. Not really. Nobody does.
She just disappeared. Don't you remember? It was a big deal in town
when it happened. I don't feel very well. Where's the bathroom? Oh, it's just downstairs. [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [toilet flushes] [instrumental music] [water running] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] <i> (whispering) You saw.</i> [light fixture buzzes] <i> (whispering) You saw
what happened.</i> <i> You saw what he did.</i> [gasps] [dramatic music] <i> (whispering) You saw
what he did,</i> <i> you saw what happened.</i> <i> You saw.</i> <i> You saw what he did,
you saw what happened.</i> [eerie music] <i> You saw what happened.</i> [door squeaks] Rebecca? <i> (whispering) Chloe.</i> [eerie music] Rebecca! Rebecca...wait! [eerie music] Rebecca. <i> Rebecca!</i> <i> (whispering) You saw
what he did.</i> <i> -I'm not done talking.
-You just leave me alone!</i> <i> (whispering) You saw
what he did.</i> <i> You saw what happened.</i> I told you! Get off me! [screams] This is the place. <i> (whispering) You saw
what he did.</i> <i> You saw what happened.</i> [eerie music] [gasps] You saw. I saw. [eerie music] Chloe! Hey. [instrumental music] This is where it happened. Maybe we should go back. I saw. I think I saw it happen
and I just didn't remember. Well then, let's go tell them. They won't listen to me. Here. Somebody killed her. Chloe. [instrumental music] You should have called me
the minute you saw her. Sir, I have no real excuse other than I think there's
more going on here. Maybe she's connected to Rebecca Cole's
disappearance somehow. What do you mean? Maybe she saw someone kill her. [scoffs] Look, Sgt. Stanford,
all I'm saying is maybe you should get someone to
go to the woods and search them. The ones along the river. Did you know that
Rebecca Cole came from a pretty tough situation? -No.
-Yeah. Foster kid. Bounced from one place
to another. Ran away a lot, didn't stay
in one place for too long. She was arrested a few times,
spent a year in juvie. The job at the diner, she got
through a work release program set up by the state. Sir, don't all runaways
eventually turn up some place? Not all the time. Chloe is a troubled girl, Josh. I don't think she knows what
she's saying half the time. If you see her again,
you call me. Okay. I'm serious. [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [car lock chirp] Mom? Chloe? [gate squeaks] I think I have some
answers. I think I know what happened
to Rebecca. Honey... No, I think I saw it happen. I just blacked it out. Okay. Let me just take you back
to the hospital, okay, and we'll get it all sorted out. They're not going
to believe me. You don't even believe me. Chloe I just...I just want
to help you. But I feel like you don't
want me to. Anything that I do,
I do because I love you. And I just want you to trust me,
that's all, just trust me. It hurts me to see you
hurting, okay? Let's go home. No outsiders if that's
what you want. We can talk about all of it. Come on, Chloe. I can't. I can't. Chloe, stop! [footsteps running away] [sighs] [birds chirping] [brush rustling] [metal clanging] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [metal clanging] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [truck engine] [doorbell chimes] -Hi.
-Hi. Are you from the cable company? Mrs. Sutton, I'm Josh Griffin. We spoke on the phone earlier. I told you, there's not
much I have to say. Right. I was just hoping that maybe
if we talked face to face... I'm waiting for the man
to come and fix my TV. Missed half my programs
already today. Maybe we could talk
while you're waiting. Do you know anything
about cable? When Rebecca's caseworker
approached us about her. She said she'd be
a handful... She had a lot of trouble
in her other homes. She never gave us
any trouble though. She kept to herself a lot. You know, the news articles never said anything
about her parents. Well, they wouldn't. She never really knew them. I had a lot of kids through
my house in those days and they all had their problems, but she seemed at peace
with herself. That run-away business just
never made sense to me. I kept her stuff. Do you want to see? Come on, you're doing
no good back there. Yeah, I tried. I never knew what
to do with this. I never had one of my kids
leave and not come back. She made friends at work. They had a Bible study
at school. One of the girls in her class
invited her to the meetings. May I? [vehicle approaches] There he is. Excuse me. <i> I read somewhere that
your mind protects you</i> <i> from certain things.</i> <i> Especially when you're little.</i> <i> And sometimes it only lets
you know about them</i> <i> when you're ready.</i> <i> The curtain drops and memories
can come flooding back.</i> <i> It was that thought that
led me back here.</i> [thunder rumbles] <i> This place and I are
forever connected now.</i> Come on, Rebecca,
let me give you a ride. Are you drunk? No. Yes, you are.
You're drunk again. Come on, you'll get soaked. Rebecca? Would you leave me alone? What, I'm not good enough
to give you a ride? I'm not interested.
Okay? I'm not done talking. Would you just leave me alone?! Don't talk to me like that. Get off me! What's wrong with you?
Get of me! [screams] [body thuds] [grunting] [dramatic music] [footsteps] [labored breathing] [labored breathing] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] Hey, Josh. Hi, Lola. I hear the cops are looking
for your friend. Yeah. You know, I had no idea that Rebecca she was talking
about the other night was Rebecca Cole. Yeah. You knew her, huh? Sure. Some of us around here
are lifers, you know. -Thanks, Lola.
-Yeah. Hey, you find your girl yet? Nope. Police told us to keep
a look out for her, but she hadn't been around. Hey, what's wrong with her? I'm not sure. Hey, thanks. Thought that was your truck. I understand you've been
searching down by the river. You'll have to let this one go,
Josh. Why? The police afraid I'm going
to find something? Easy, brother. It ain't healthy. Plus they can't let you dig
out there, it's town land. -Hey, Pastor.
-Hi, Lola. -Coffee?
-Sure. I stopped by Rebecca Cole's
foster mom's house. She still had a box of some
of her old things. Some pictures, jewelry, books.
Her Bible. She said Rebecca had just joined
the Bible study at school. Okay? "Faith is the substance
of things hoped for, evidence of things not seen." That verse was highlighted
in her Bible. It's a verse of hope,
Mark, you know that. There were dozens highlighted
just like that. So, what are you saying? She was healing, not hurting. She was having the best year
of her life. Sometimes you don't see
the whole picture, Josh. You can be on top of the world
the one minute and the bottom can fall out
in the next. You of all people
should know that. Don't make this about Hannah. Josh, I'm sorry. But I can't help but wonder
if it is about her. Here's the truth. The police gave up on Rebecca. They saw her as a troubled kid
and they filed her away. Josh, please. Sit and talk a bit. What's the point? [sighs] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] <i> Sometimes when you decide
not to give up on something,</i> <i> it drives you to pursue it
obsessively.</i> [metal clanging] <i> It makes you risk everything.</i> [metal clanging] <i> You look for answers.</i> <i> You look for hope.</i> [instrumental music] <i> There's probably a million
lost explorers</i> <i> for every one who
finds an answer.</i> [water sloshes] <i> Then something comes along
that you didn't expect.</i> <i> And suddenly...</i> [dramatic instrumental music] [thud] <i> You realize you're
on the right path.</i> Josh? Josh? You okay? I was up on the bridge
and I saw you. What happened? Somebody...somebody
came up behind me. Okay, okay.
Can you stand? I'm fine. [grunts] Okay. Okay, sit still for a sec. My watch. Don't move. All right, just... Maybe you should go
to the hospital. No. What were you doing down here? I believe you, Chloe. [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] It's gotta be the one. You sure? It's the same. What about the guy? You think you can recognize him? I mean, if he was
right in front of you, could you pick him out? I don't know. [instrumental music] [horn honks] -Hey.
-What's up? I gotta ask you something. -Are you okay?
-Yeah, I'm fine. Look, I was with
Rebecca's foster mom and she gave me this old photo
of you two. I remember this. Look at Rebecca. You see that old truck
in the background? You don't know whose truck
that is by chance, do you? A customer maybe? Looks like Matt Barnes'
old truck. I'm not sure, why you asking? -Who's Matt?
-He's the night cook. He was there yesterday
when you were in. I'm pretty sure he had
a truck like that before he bought his bike. Is he at the restaurant? No, he's got the weekends off. He's sleeping. Does he live in town? Out on Trimmer Road. Where on Trimmer? Gray house past the tracks. Are you sure everything's okay? What do you want with
an old truck anyway? It's a long story. Thanks, Lola. Josh... [instrumental music] You okay? They say God can heal
your broken heart. But I've never felt Him. He's always seemed
so far away. [instrumental music] I think someone hurt you
very much. Is that true? You can trust me. I know. You can trust me, Chloe. I know! [instrumental music] I never knew my father. As long as I can remember,
it was just my mom and me. She dated a few guys. Some of them were very nice. Some of them
weren't so nice. [sniffs] I-I didn't like being around
when they were home. Especially when my mom
wasn't there. So I would go and hang
down by the river. Under the bridge. Does your mom know? [scoffs] That is not on you. How do you know? It's not on you. (tearfully) How do you know? You did nothing wrong. It's not on you.
It's not on you. [sobbing] [sobbing] It's okay. It's okay. Now I need you
to listen to me. I think I know who drives
that truck. So I think we need
to take a ride. Okay? Can you do that for me? (sighs) Yeah. Okay. [suspenseful music] <i> This probably would not
make sense to most people.</i> <i> Visiting the house of a man
you think murdered your friend.</i> <i> But when you've run
out of options...</i> <i> your choices become
more desperate.</i> Are you sure you're okay
with this? [suspenseful music] [suspenseful music] [suspenseful music] If you want to hang back,
it's okay. [suspenseful music] [knocking] Let's go see if there's
anything out back. [suspenseful music] [suspenseful music] [knocking] [material flapping] [knocking] [suspenseful music] [knocking] [footsteps approaching] I don't think anyone's around. You looking for something? Look, I knocked. No one answered. What are you doing here? All I wanted to do was ask you
about a photo that I found. (screams) Aah! What? [distorted sounds] Aren't the cops looking for you? [instrumental music] It was you. What's she saying? [scream] I saw you. What are you saying? You killed her. What? You killed her! (screams) Aah! -Killed who?
-She's just a little confused... No, I'm not confused! -What are you saying?
-You killed her! I saw it! -Let's go.
-I saw you! It was you! It was you! Get off my property!
I'm going to call the cops! [panting] Don't ever come back here! [gravel crunching] [panting] Well, I think it's time
you told the police. Think you're ready for that? Yeah. [typing] -Sarge.
-Yeah. This kid Josh Griffin's
on his way in. Said something about how
this girl Chloe Morey just identified a guy named
Matt Barnes, as someone who killed
Rebecca Cole. (sighs) I got this. You got people scratching
their heads, Josh. Sgt. Stanford, I can explain. Save it.
Chloe, out of the truck. Look, this Barnes guy,
he had something to do with Rebecca Cole's
disappearance. You gotta listen to what
Chloe's saying. Chloe doesn't know
what she's saying. That's the problem, Josh. She doesn't know what
she seeing either. Don't you get that by now? Don't make me ask you again
get out of the truck! Come on. You interfere with this again,
I'll arrest you. Now go home. [instrumental music] [instrumental music] I heard what happened. I forgot how fast news
travels around here. Josh. Josh, I'm not really sure
what to say anymore. I'm trying to understand. [instrumental music] [instrumental music] You ever feel like God
failed you? If I'm honest, yeah. Sometimes I feel that He has. Especially when it makes
no sense. We're all human, Josh. It's okay to be angry. I am so beyond angry, brother. Hannah wasn't keen
on Tanzania. But I convinced her
to go overseas. When she got sick, we were... we were too far from anything
to get her help. I just don't get it. We were doing good work. God's work. [sobbing] I get it. But I believe that
He'll turn this into a greater purpose for you. But not in our time, Josh. In His time. His time. [sniffles] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] You hungry? Can I get you something to eat? You want to tell me
why you ran off? All right. I'm going to take you
to the hospital. Are you sure there's nothing
more you want to say? There's somebody here
who wants to see you. Hey, baby. [instrumental music] We don't have to talk about it
if you don't want to. No matter what, I'm not going
to leave you. Okay. <i> Part of me wanted to tell her
everything I knew.</i> [box thuds] <i> I wish I felt safe enough.</i> <i> It's a powerless feeling</i> <i> when you don't trust
your own thoughts.</i> <i> Even if I could figure out</i> <i> the exact mix of fact
and fiction,</i> <i> I wasn't going to tell anyone.</i> [instrumental music] <i> But just when I thought
I was about to lose it all,</i> <i> one more thing happened
that I can't explain.</i> <i> And it changed everything.</i> <i> It saved my life.</i> Is everything okay? Matt Barnes. That's a name that
hasn't popped up on my radar in years. But it popped up once back
when he was...younger. Before he started working
at the diner. Sexual assault charge. That was... 14 years ago. Even then....he had that,
that 'LOST SOUL' tattoo. [motorcycle revs] Why don't we take a ride
to the bridge and you can show me
what you think happened. Are you up for that? Yeah. [shoveling dirt] Whatcha doing? [instrumental music] Looking for something. Same thing you were looking
for on my property earlier? Nope. I found that. I'm looking for something else. That girl, she's got you
all twisted around. Yet you're here. You worried about something? Well, maybe I'm worried
about you. A lot of bad things happen
in these woods. People fall down, slip,
hit their head real hard. Real easy to end up face down
in that river. Yeah, I'm sure you know
all about that. There is nothing out here, Josh. She saw you. She's an eyewitness. She's crazy. And ain't nobody believe
what she says. So please, Josh, go home. I believe her. And as soon as I find Rebecca,
wherever you put her, a lot of other people
are gonna... [grunts] [tense music] [grunting] [punches landing] [groaning] Hey! What's going on down there? [grunts] (coughs) You're not gonna
find nothing! [footsteps] -Was that Barnes?
-Yeah. <i> Yeah, dispatch this is Stanfor.</i> <i> I need a couple of units out
at the Trimmer Road Bridge.</i> <i> Need to track down
a possible suspect</i> <i> who ran off into the woods,
white male...</i> [police radio noises] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] What if they don't find her? They'll find her. [instrumental music] Maybe it's time someone
else knew the truth. [instrumental music] Mom. I need to tell you something. Okay. <i> Josh was right.</i> <i> I was punishing her
with my silence.</i> <i> And it needed to end.</i> ♪ Come take my hand... ♪ <i> So that the healing could begi.</i> ♪ Come hold me close ♪ This is where I used to
come sometimes. This is where I felt safe. Safe from what? Chloe, you can feel
safe with me. I want you to feel safe. [instrumental music] ♪ I want to say... ♪ I never said this... ♪ Fix me, fix me... ♪ But there were times... ♪ Fix all the pieces
of my heart ♪ While you were away... [shuddering breath] ♪ Fix me, fix me,
fix all the pieces of my heart ♪ ♪ with pieces of my scars ♪ Anything? Nothing yet. How they doing? [instrumental music] [sobs] I didn't want to hurt you. Hurt me? -I let you down.
-No. I let this happen. Please don't say that. Don't feel that. Okay? You didn't know.
You didn't know. Oh, Chloe. (crying) I'm so sorry. I'm so sorry. Guys, got something
over here! Something's got them curious. ♪ Fix me, fix me,
fix all the pieces... ♪ Guys, over here! [instrumental music] ♪ With pieces of my scars. ♪ [instrumental music] [instrumental music] Found something? Where's Chloe? [instrumental music] Does this look familiar? [instrumental music] (whispers) It was Rebecca's. I'm so sorry I didn't
believe you. I'll see you later. I've got to go find Matt Barnes. It's a good thing you didn't
give up on her, little brother. [instrumental music] You're going to be okay, Chloe. ♪ Fix me, fix me... ♪ [instrumental music] <i> Two days later, they
arrested Matt Barnes</i> <i> for the murder of Rebecca Cole.</i> <i> Her remains were found just
a few feet away from her cross.</i> <i> The psychologist that
interviewed me said</i> <i> that I'd probably had been</i> <i> gathering clues about him
for years.</i> <i> That while my mind blocked out
the memory of what happened,</i> <i> it was also taking inventory
of everything about him.</i> <i> They said that my testimony
would make it</i> <i> an open and shut case.</i> <i> I hope that's true.</i> [instrumental music] ♪ Rising up from the ash ♪ ♪ It's a place that I never
thought I'd get back from ♪ ♪ It's taken everything I have
to find my way back home ♪ ♪ Something's telling me ♪ Because I've stumbled,
I'm unworthy ♪ ♪ All the things I've done, ♪ ♪ I am still loved
and I can overcome ♪ ♪ I've gotta make a change,
I've gotta make a... ♪♪ Hey, Mom. Hey. Thought you might want
some company for lunch. Sure. Is everything okay? Yeah, I'm all caught up
on my school work. Um, look. It's an invite to the student
showcase. [instrumental music] How are you doing, Mom? I'll be better once I know
you are. I'm not there yet... and I don't know how long
it's going to take me. But I'm not going to let this
own me or define me. And I don't want it to own you
or define you either. We need to make this
a new start for both of us. I want that too. ♪ Gotta make a change
Gotta make a change ♪ Shall we go? I think this is going to be
really good. I think so too. [instrumental music] Everybody's loving
your work, Josh. Really, really nice. Well, that's good. Here's the rest of my bill. Sticking around for service? Nah, got a date with a shower. Tomorrow then. Josh, I was wrong to push you
so hard to open up. As a pastor, I'm supposed
to take the, "I'm here for you if you
need me" approach, but it was hard seeing you
hurting like that. It's okay. I get it. You're my brother. Same rules don't apply. Time for you to do your thing,
Pastor. [instrumental music] Josh? Thought I might find you here. How you doing? You look good. I feel good. Thank you. You're welcome. No, thank you...
for believing in me. You had the eyes to see
the truth when no one else did. Who was it that taught you to
see with your heart like that? I'm beginning to understand
that sometimes you have to hit rock bottom
before you can see the top. Yeah. [instrumental music] You really think faith can play
a part in healing someone? Yeah. <i> My name is Chloe.</i> <i> I'm 20.</i> <i> I still have a hard time</i> <i> letting people get
too close to me.</i> <i> But each day I get better.</i> <i> And I'm open to trusting more,</i> <i> trusting that things will
work out for me.</i> <i> That all my scars
will start to fade.</i> <i> And then perhaps as they fade,
I'll be set free.</i> <i> I'll finally feel free.</i> [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] [instrumental music] ♪ I woke up today
a different way, ♪ ♪ I think it's time to lift
my head up from this bed, ♪ ♪ get right to living life ♪ ♪ Season change and the greens
are turning brown ♪ ♪ Winter wind is blowing in,
falling leaves all around ♪ ♪ Aah, ahh, ahhh, ahhh
Ah, ah ♪ ♪ Mmm mm ♪ ♪ The last few years have been
full of tears and pain ♪ ♪ Lost so many people
that I love ♪ ♪ Time will never
feel the same ♪ ♪ Accepting they're gone is
just so hard to believe, ♪ ♪ but life goes on and on,
regardless of what I need ♪ ♪ Free... ♪ ♪ I wanna be free ♪ ♪ I get this smile from wearing
memories on my sleeve ♪ ♪ from all the laughter
I have shared ♪ ♪ with those who had to leave ♪ ♪ Its reflections keep alive ♪ ♪ what I'm sure of
the way we were ♪ ♪ My romance is unaffected
by the light ♪ ♪ that's been shed
upon yesterdays ♪ ♪ and the tapestry
of my life ♪ ♪ It's not the future
I'm afraid to step into, ♪ ♪ it's letting go of what used
to be, it's letting go of you ♪ ♪ Free... ♪ ♪ I wanna be free ♪ ♪ I wanna be free ♪ ♪ The past is not our future ♪ ♪ There's a new day
at the door ♪ ♪ There's hope in this destiny ♪ ♪ that one day we'll be free ♪ ♪ Free... ♪ ♪ One day we'll be free ♪ ♪ One day we'll be free ♪♪
