What's this I hear about you
have a boyfriend? Is it true? And what? Yeah, it's true.
And what? So, what about us? It's nothing with you. This is Ashanti. Ashanti. Okay. You know Chitara,
obviously. Yes, I do. How old are you? 18. So, you're a little younger. Mm-hmm (affirmative).
Yes, like ... what? A couple years younger,
four. Yeah. Okay. Why? Why what? Why do all of this? I tried to break it off.
I tried. I tried to reveal myself
to you plenty of times. Not once did you ever say,
"I'm lying to you," because when we had- Because I didn't know
how to say it. I opened the window
plenty of times. Plenty of times,
but it's not something I can just automatically
get out and tell you. I opened the door when we had
the conversation about Catfish. You opened the door. What did you say? I said ... What did I say?
I said, "I'm not-" "I'm not catfishing." Because that's my way
of telling. I couldn't lie to you.
Even though I was lying, I wasn't able to fully
come out to you, even though you opened
the door you so call said. I didn't think it would be
that big of a deal. I kind of thought that you knew,
but I didn't really- How am I supposed to know?
I just assumed that you did. How? After I broke it off with ...
Even if- Well, when I broke up
in September- Even if you assumed
that she knew you weren't being
totally honest- Mm-hmm
(affirmative). Which she was suspicious of,
of course, at times. Yeah, I know she was suspicious. There was no way for her to have
known who you actually were. So, the only way
that she would've known that is if you had said,
"Look, I want to talk to you." The only thing you had to do
was say and be honest with me up front,
"I am not who I say I am. I am not 22.
I am 18." Okay. This (bleep) that you're doing
is a dangerous game, real talk. I don't do it anymore. You're the last one,
I'm telling you. I put that on everything. I'ma chalk all this up
to the fact that you're 18. When did you turn 18? I turned 18 October. You just turned 18. Just turned (bleep). Yeah, just turned 18
in October. So, this is weeks
of recently turning 18? Yeah. You have some serious
growing up and maturing to do, because this whole (bleep)
is all (bleep) up. Obviously. I'm 18, I've got
a lot of things to learn. I think it's- She (bleep) just turned 18. Duh, we just established
that a couple minutes ago. I'm not talking to you. I'm having conversation
with myself. Okay. Have a conversation
with yourself. Dismissed. Bitch, don't (bleep)
do that to me. Did she just call me a bitch? I'm done. I'm done.
Whoa, whoa, whoa. Relax. Did you just call me a bitch? You can just go.
You can just go. Did she just call me a bitch? Oh, no. No, no, no, no, no, no. Hi.
How are you doing? Good. Nev. Hi.
Hi. What's your name? Brian.
Brian. Hi.
This is Jenn. Hi. We brought her from Iowa,
just like I said we would. It comes as a bit of a shock,
I think, for Jenn and also us that you're not the guy
that we saw in the pictures and your name's also not Skylar. Yeah. I basically
pretended to be Skylar, because I never wanted it
to reach that point where she would know who I am. So, let me just get this
straight. Do you have true feelings
for Jennifer? I don't have any emotional
feelings towards her. I would never be able to have a
romantic relationship with her. Then why the (bleep)
are we here? Well, she's actually not
the only girl that I spoke to. I felt like out
of all the girls, this is the perfect time.
This is the perfect girl to finally come clean
to and end Skylar. What are you ever hoping to gain from all of these
half true friendships that you have online?
What's the point? I wanted to brush up my game.
It's just something I do. You understand
this all makes you look like a huge (bleep), right? Yeah, yeah. Because I don't really
give a (bleep) that you wanted
to come clean and set the story straight
for all of the other girls that you're being
a (bleep) to. Why did I bring this awesome,
amazing girl from Iowa so that you could clear
your conscience? Because I feel like
it's good for her to finally know the truth. You could've told her that
on the phone through, right? Yeah, but in a way
I wanted to end Skylar. I feel like by telling Jenn
who I am, that ends Skylar. Right, but that's all about you. That's you taking care
of your business and not really caring about how
that's effecting someone else. It's kind of selfish. Yeah, a little bit. I don't really care anymore. So, you're literally fishing
and hooking girls, and then just kind of
tossing them back into the ocean
with scars. Yeah. I would stop
speaking to them. Are you sorry? Or, do you feel like you kind of
didn't do anything wrong here? I don't know if I'm sorry,
but it is what it is. I was giving her a gift
of being in that relationship. You were giving her a gift? Yeah. I mean, she was happy.
I know I was leading her on, but I knew it would
never be permanent. How do we know
this is truly over, because you don't really seem
to give a (bleep). It's not fun anymore,
at this point, to have something
going just to know that it's going to come
to an end for me, as bad as something
like this is. There's something really odd
and off about the way you're
talking about everything. It's not that you're overcome
with guilt by the sheer pain and embarrassment
that you're causing these girls, it's about the fact
that you don't want to get into a relationship that you know
you're going to have to end. None of it had to do with,
"I'm hurting a lot of people and that makes me
feel terrible inside." I thought that was ...
because it's obvious that I'm hurting these people,
I know that. It's obvious that you're hurting
these people, but it's not- Then why do it though? It's not obvious that
you care about that. Honestly, I don't think
you even have feelings. That's how I feel. I think that's how we all feel. I do. I don't believe in anything
you have to say. I really don't. Right, which leads me
to my next thing, which is there's only
one way to tell if you're sorry. That's by stopping. Yeah, you're right.
You're 100 percent right. Prove me right. Okay. All right.
So, we'll just be in touch and let you know about
maybe meeting back up. Thanks, guys. All right. See you later. Miss you all. Wait, what'd you say at the end?
"Miss you all?" Yeah. What is that?
That just sounded like a joke. Did you really say,
"Miss you all?" Like a playful ...
Was that not a playful remark? No, like 'I miss you'. Did you just completely
forget everything we just said to you
about you appearing like a total (bleep)
head, and then as we're leaving
you make a gistful remark? "Miss you all?" No. Dude, you really seem
like a huge (bleep) head. Yeah.
So, think about that. Working on it. That's ... Thank you. Nailed it. Hey, bro. How's it going? My name is Kelsey.
I'm Adam the Gambler. Oh, wow. So, what's
your end game here? Just to have fun with you, man.
That was it. You know, it was a game.
It's over now. So, this is all just fun
and games. Yeah, really it is.
Yeah. Is there something else
more meaningful that you think
you proved with this? No. There's no deeper meaning
to any of this. Whose pictures are you using? Actually, a girl
I know from high school. Do you have a job?
Are you in school? Yeah, this is like my job
right now. I'll go here,
I'll time the jackpot. So, I'll just do whatever
I want on my phone, time the jackpot, win about $60
for the night, go home. How do you know you're going
to win the jackpot? I have an algorithm, you see. I count the number
of people in here, right? Then, I have all
the times on my phone. I can even show you that. I have all the times
that they've ever gone off. He's rigged it. Yeah. In between jackpots,
there's a transition period where you're waiting
for the thing. I login here, pretend to be
Kelsey, talk to him a while. It's just something to do
to pass the time. Did you create that psychology
group to lure people in, to then mess with them and carry
on fake relationships with? You know, I took advantage of
the fact that I had this group. Yeah, "Let's add this other
account of mine in there and let's see who we can
mess with." You know? How many people do you think
you've catfished? I would say about maybe 30, 40,
around there. It's just interesting
to me and fun. Is your relationship
with Ellie something that you even care about?
Or, are you just using her? Oh, no. I care about Ellie.
You know, she's my girlfriend. It's not a cover up,
or anything like that. I have genuine feelings
for her. I've talked to Ellie before.
Sweet girl. Amazing girl. What in the (bleep) world makes you think you're
getting anywhere with that? I can justify anything.
I can justify anything. How'd you like my (bleep) pic? That was interesting.
Thank you for sending it to me. I really want that
on my computer. Do you (bleep) get yourself
off to this (bleep)? No, I deleted it quickly after. Did you just wake up
this morning and say, "You know what?
I want to play a bad guy on TV. I just want to be
the worst version of myself that I can be?"
Is that what you decided? Yeah. That was what I ... I mean, is this really
who you are right now? This is really who I am.
I'm the joker. I mean ... This is the kind of loser
that gives our show a bad name. I mean, are we
really sitting here and giving him any air time? I'm the king of catfishes,
right? No, you're not. I am. I'm the king catfish. You're really not. I am. I'm done here. I'm done.
I'm done. It's just a big waste.
That's all. I mean, I kind of expected
this as a scenario here, something like this. That it's some kind of
internet troll of some sort. You live and you learn, and you won't make
the same mistake twice. Is that the reaction
you were hoping for? No. No, it's not actually. I was really hoping
that you'd get really angry. I wanted to boil you, but it
didn't seem to happen that way. That's too bad. I can understand you think
you're this sort of mastermind, but it's going to be
a long and boring and sort of meaningful life. I have a good job, a good life,
I'm happy with myself. Fine. I can say that. I can manipulate this fool
right here and say that
I'm happy with myself. That's (bleep) pitiful, man.
It's pitiful. Obviously, you understand
why we're here. You admitted that
you created this profile. So, we were hoping to hear
a little bit more about that. I was bored with my life, so I
wanted to be someone else. Right. The whole Jacqueline thing
was like Miley/Hannah. Tracy by day, on the internet
I was Jacqueline by night. Is that Hannah Montana?
Is that how it works? Yeah. That's how I did
everything. I come home from school, bang,
I'm Jacqueline, not Tracy anymore. How old were you
when you started doing that? I was 14, in middle school. So, now you're about 20? 20 today. 20 today, that's right. Yeah.
That's right, your birthday. What could you do as Jacqueline
that you couldn't do as Tracy? Oh, my gosh. I don't know. As Jacqueline,
I could talk to anyone I wanted and bully people,
and stuff. It comes back to
when people bullied me, so I have to bully
other people to get revenge. But why take out what people
do to you on other people who didn't do anything to you? Because they bullied me, too. People, they're like,
"You're fake. You're fake." But you were fake. But you were fake. But they didn't know that. A lot of people don't like
Falesha, because they associate her
with your (bleep) up profile. I really don't like Falesha.
I think she deserves it. She thinks she's a model
and she thinks she's all that. I'm still mad at her.
Jacqueline was popular. She had all that popularity
and Falesha ruined it. That's why I don't
really like her. Should I apologize
for ruining that, because I am sincerely sorry. Jacqueline
was like a real person. Well, she wasn't a real person.
I was the real person. Do you take drugs?
I am not on drugs. I've never took a drug
in my life. I'm just naturally
happy and hyper. Just out of curiosity, I was wondering why you seem
so proud of this? Because I created Jacqueline
and I'm proud of creating her. I'm proud of it.
It really helped me. When I got to bully
people online, I felt so tough. This is relatively pointless,
what's going on right here. Am I done with her? Yeah. I mean,
we're done for now. We're all done for now. All right, good.
Falesha, are you going to say 'happy birthday'?
That was so much fun. Hello. Hi, we're looking
for Cassandra. Yeah, this is her.
How did you get my address? It wasn't that hard actually. Okay. So, you're Zoe? Yeah. Okay. Obviously, you know
I am Craig. Yeah, I'm fully aware. This is my sister, Mariah. Yeah. I imagine you know
why we're here. You've been pretending
to be this girl, Zoe, online now
for quite some time. We were hoping to see
if you had an explanation, or some excuse,
or anything you wanted to say. I don't got no excuse. What was your purpose?
Why? It was just a joke
and it just got out of hand. But what you've done. You know how many times
I contemplated in my mind like, "Am I (bleep) crazy?" You don't have to sit there
and tell me what I've done, because I'm fully aware
of what I've done. But why? What'd you get from it? It was just a game, a joke.
I put people on blast basically. Put people on blast? To get revenge on them? I wouldn't say revenge ...
just mess with people. We just spent the last
three days talking to people whose relationships
and lives you've ruined. Like a whole community,
a whole ... Yeah, I know. My life, too. Yours? Yeah. Yours, too. You made me lose trust
with people. You made me
break up relationships that I had with some
of my closest friends, even you I thought was a close
friend of mine at the time. I'll just keep it real with you
about your friends, I really didn't feel bad. None of those people
did anything to you, right? No, not really. You know, you stabbed me in the
heart plenty of times playing me, lying to me,
and I still stood by your side. Yeah. There's no explanation
for it. You've done some nasty (bleep).
Why? Yes, I know I have. But ... Well, there is
an explanation for it somewhere. Okay. What is ... I truthfully just did it ... it just got out of hand.
I did it for fun. I'm not going to lie,
I made some- So, pretty much it got you off? Did you have feelings for Craig? No. Oh, my gosh. Remy? Yeah. I'm Nev. I'm Elle. How are you doing? Hey. How's it going? This is Angel.
Is your real name Remy? No, it's not my real name. What is your real name? I don't want to say it. You're really not going
to tell us your name? Nah. Should we just call you
Remy then, I guess? Yeah, you can call me Remy. You guys already know
each other? Mm-mm. Oh, okay. How much of the story
that you told her was true? I mean, everything except
for who I am. So, your girlfriend
is a real person? Yeah, I've got a girlfriend
for real. Then, why are you messing
with people on Plenty of Fish? I don't get it. It wasn't for a relationship. It was more like a ...
It was a joke to me. I made an account to see
how long it would take somebody to figure out that it was fake. That's a weird hobby. It was just something to do
in my downtime. So, I imagine you talk
to lots of people. Nah, it was just her.
She was the first one to reply. I mean, you guys talked
all the time. There had to be
something real in that. Nah, it wasn't. Obviously if you have
a girlfriend, you're not going
to come on TV and say that you had
feelings for her, but I think it's very clear
based on the fact that you were talking
as much as you were that you guys had
a relationship. You can tell me
whatever you want, but you can't pretend
for the three months that you guys were talking it
never meant something to you. It really didn't. Yeah, I've heard you say that
already, but I don't believe it. I basically talked to you like
I talk to my best friend. I'm telling you things
that nobody else knows, like I go through enough. Then, for someone
to just sit here and tell me that it's a game
to you, it's not funny. I also don't believe that you
have no feelings towards her. No offense.
You may be a good liar, but I don't think
you're that great of an actor. Something is real. I can see you kind of squirming.
I know you feel bad. I feel bad a little bit, but not enough for me
to sit here and apologize and tell her I'm wrong
for everything I did. So, you wouldn't
apologize for that? No. Really? Don't you think it's
pretty (bleep) up to be like, "I want to help you
take care of your baby. I want to be there?" I never took it as we're in
a committed relationship. She just wasn't catching
on quick enough. Right, but if the game
was to mess with people, you would've just moved on. Nah, it was interesting to see
her come around the house and not find me. I'd be sitting inside
a car somewhere else. Where'd you get the D.
Jackson profile from? Found it on Facebook. You found some random person?
Yeah. You sent her the kid's
real profile, a different name, a different
Snapchat, lives in Chicago. I mean, that's a first. That's daring,
you sent her the real profile. I don't know.
I didn't take it serious. I thought it was funny. What made you change your mind about coming
and meeting up today? Who wouldn't want to be on TV?
It's once in a lifetime. Okay. I think that's it then. Your part of the story
I think is over. All right. Hello.
Hi. Oh, my God. Alicia? Yeah. We came here, obviously,
to introduce you to Aaliyah. You guys know
each other, clearly. You don't have anything to say? All I have to say, girl,
if I wanted to meet you ... we stay in the same city,
I would've made that happen. So, you didn't want to meet me? No, I don't. What's this I hear
about you have a boyfriend? Is it true? And what? Yeah, it's true.
And what? So, what about us? It's nothing with you. What you mean, "It's nothing?" Oh, my God. I done sent you money,
I done bought you a phone. And? It was a lie. What? Like, you embarrassed me. You embarrassed yourself
by doing all of this. You could've been told me this. I talk to you every day,
you couldn't tell me, but now you're doing this? I didn't want to hurt
your feelings. But it's okay to hurt them now? You wanted this, so you got it. What did you want? I guess I got what I wanted. What was that? Whatever you gave me. I need all that back.
What about your job? You was my job. It's not that you might
have feelings? Do you know you ruined my life? No, I don't. No, I don't.
Girl, whatever. You ain't even got a job, like
you're not even worth my time. Whatever. Okay then.
So, why are you here? Do you know how much time
you wasted? If I'm not worth your time,
why are you here? Why are y'all here then? Because obviously
I thought you loved me. Well, you thought wrong.
