Scam or science? How not to get fooled (Marketplace)

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments
Captions
>> Asha: This is your Marketplace. You first saw him on Dragons' Den. >> And I've developed a technology to help people's backs get better. >> Asha: Promoting a product that blew them away. >> That was unbelievable. >> Asha: We put his $80 clips to the test. Science or snake oil? >> I'm not really feeling a whole lot. >> And restaurant secrets. Who's getting your tips? >> It's really not fair. >> I see it as wage theft. >> Undercover dining on your Marketplace. [ ♪♪ ] >> Asha: There's a new treatment inside this chiropractic clinic. And if it works, it could be revolutionary. But that's a big if. [ ♪♪ ] >> Asha: And it all comment down to some tiny clips. [ ♪♪ ] >> Asha: Mark Metus invented them, calls them Neuro Connect. >> Asha: He says they can help fix our Marketplace staffer's hip. >> Asha: That metal plate he's using is just a bigger version of the clip. It gets the treatment going. The clips, he says, can keep it going. [ ♪♪ ] >> Tonight, on Dragons' Den. >> Asha: That's right. The little wonders got their national debut on the CBC. >> Next up, a duo from Collingwood, Ontario. >> Asha: When Metus and his sidekick pitched their product, they came looking for a hundred thousand dragon dollars. >> Our product is Neuro Connect. >> Asha: And they came armed with impressive claims. >> I'm a chiropractor and I developed a technology to help people's backs get better and stay better. The devices I have developed are with a team of physicists and they change the atomic structure of the components of these devices to cause the nervous system to respond when you're wearing them. And as a result, the muscles work better and the joints work better as well. >> Asha: To prove his point, Metus experiments on the dragons. >> Reach up like you're just reaching up onto a shelf. >> Okay. >> Asha: You gotta wonder, though, is this really science or showmanship? He clips on his invention. >> And now, you'll see how much stronger you are. >> That's crazy. >> Asha: Stronger and supposedly more balanced. The clips can cost 40 to 120 bucks. That's got the dragons' attention. >> If it works, it's a game changer. >> If this is real, and I don't deny that it is, why are you only looking for the money you're looking for? This could be worth a fortune. >> Seems too good to be true. >> Asha: Sceptical but interested. >> It does. I get a lot of looks when I test people. >> Asha: More than looks. We got lots of angry emails from viewers. Like this... Bill Nuvo wrote, too, he believes the dragons were scammed. >> Pick a card, any card. >> Asha: He should know. He happens to be a magician. >> This is what you do. This is absolute amazing, don't take your eyes off this. Here we go, using the power of the mind. [ ♪♪ ] >> Asha: And knows how sleight of hand can give the illusion of truth. [ Applause ] >> Asha: So this is where they film Dragons' Den. It's not set up right now, but you get the picture. >> Deceptive, eh? >> Asha: It's very deceptive. TV magic. >> Yeah, yeah, yeah, for sure. >> Asha: Why did you email Marketplace? >> I was awestruck, and, like, just, I was completely befuddled that-- how the dragons were fooled so easily. As magicians, we're kind of what's called 'honest liars', we're paid to lie to people. You know we're deceiving you, but what I saw was deception without people knowing that they were being deceived. >> Asha: It could be a common magician's trick and it's called misdirection. >> I don't believe this. >> This seems way too good to be true. >> Yeah. >> It's actually like a parlour trick. Way back in the day, snake oil salesmen used to use these tricks to fool people into believing that, you know, whatever pill that they were being sold was giving them strength or, you know, making them feel better. Put your arm up. >> Asha: Yeah. Bill has his own explanation of how the dragons could have been fooled. >> See how easy that-- that is to go down. >> Asha: Right. >> Then you did the thing he posted, put the clip on. >> Asha: Yeah. >> You can see, like, I'm putting a lot more pressure on you. >> Asha: Right. >> And sometimes when you do it the second time, you're resisting a lot more. But if I do it-- switch the angle to towards your body or more specifically towards your foot. >> Asha: I can resist more. >> You can resist, and I can even-- >> Asha: Yeah. >> It's something as simple as that. >> Asha: So you say he was playing tricks on the dragons. >> I do. I do. [ ♪♪ ] >> Asha: Was it a magic trick or is there any science to it? Check out his website. There's an illusion of science. But there's no credible, proper studies of his clips to be found. In fact, no studies at all. Just a long list of testimonials. Belief that's hard to dispute. Oh, and there's his arm test again. But the kicker here? >> And we don't know absolutely how it works, we just know that it works. >> Asha: Metus doesn't even know how it works. So we go searching for experts who might. [ ♪♪ ] >> Asha: Is there any chance these clips could be more than parlour tricks? Hey, Eric. >> How's it going? >> Asha: Good. So you're gonna clip me up? >> Clipping you up. >> Asha: Alright. Professor Kei Masani specializes in brain function and rehabilitation. The perfect guy for our experiment. We're gonna test Neuro Connect against name tag clips, and no clips at all. I have no idea which one I'm wearing, neither does Kei. [ ♪♪ ] >> Put your arms like this. And stare in the mark. Try not to move head like this. >> Asha: Okay. >> Arm like this. Just stand there for two more minutes. >> Asha: Kei says these tests are more scientific, more controlled than Metus' arm test. Can I sing? >> No. No use for that. >> Asha: All in all... Kei tests ten of us for improved balance and maintaining strength. >> Do this as much as you can. >> Asha: As much force as I can? >> Yeah, yeah, yeah. >> Asha: Can the subtle waves of energy actually optimize it? >> Right. 15.7. >> Asha: Is that the strongest you've ever seen? >> Well, not... [ Laughter ] >> Asha: Hardly. I'm pulling almost 16 kilograms. This guy? >> 54.7. >> Asha: Almost 55. While Kei works his magic, we ask chemical engineer Christopher Yip for help, too. He tested Q-Ray for us years ago for ionization. Found it was nonsense. Could he now test for quantum entanglement? >> I need evidence to prove that this is a true effect, we run the right controls and do the statistics and really prove the cause and effect. >> Asha: In other words, not really. In fact, Einstein called quantum entanglement spooky. It's complex. Not well understood. >> Even within physics, people are trying to understand this process. I think you can do a lot more on your own to improve your balance. >> Asha: So you don't think that these clips do any of that? >> It would be highly sceptical. >> Asha: Is he right? We spent the day testing these $80 Neuro Connect clips, these generic name tag type clips. >> Yeah, we did. >> Asha: And no clips at all. >> So we found there's no statistical difference among the three conditions. >> Asha: Nothing? >> No clear difference. >> Asha: Wow. So were Metus' clips just money clips to the dragons? >> Hey, you guys, we bought some paperclips and some spray for a hundred thousand dollars, I don't know what we just did there. >> Asha: We take our results to the dragons. Viewers e-mailed us. >> Yep. >> Asha: They thought the clips were kind of scammy. >> Scammy? Ooh, that's a bad word. >> Asha: And the inventor. >> I'm not going to give up just because you say I have to have science. [ ♪♪ ] >> Asha: How not to get fooled on your Marketplace. >> Walk forward on to one leg and reach up like you're just reaching up onto a shelf. >> Asha: We're putting this chiropractor's invention to the test. >> Developed a technology to help people's backs get better and stay better. >> Asha: A magical clip that could have the dragons tricked. They're impressed with Mark Metus' claims and his award from the PGA. >> We won the pinnacle award, the best new invention in golf. >> Asha: It's what helped land Metus on CBC's Dragons' Den. >> Let's see it, I can't wait. >> The best new invention in golf. >> Asha: He experiments on Joe Mimran. >> I understand, Joe, you're a golfer? >> Yeah, yeah. Use the term loosely. [ Laughter ] >> Okay. So get into your normal swing position. >> Right. >> Asha: Here's before the hundred buck clip. Joe seems unsteady. >> Greg's going to put the clips on to your ankles. We'll do your pant leg actually. >> Asha: Here's after. >> If there's a flow of energy between the three clips. >> Wow. >> Asha: The impression is Joe's more stable. >> And resist as I push and he's rock solid now. >> Just 'cause of the clips? >> So the technology as I say was developed by physicists and it creates a phenomena called quantum entanglement. >> Asha: Five of the six dragons, including Joe, buy in. There's still details to hammer out, though, and in the end, the deal falls through. But to many, the damage was done. Metus had the Dragons' endorsement so why did they fall for it in the first place? >> You know, golfers are the most gullible consumers in the world. >> Asha: I can imagine. >> So I was like, I was hooked. >> Asha: You guys were sceptical at first. >> Yep. >> Asha: Take me through that process. >> It's a bit of an auction that goes on. And you get caught up in the moment. And there was all of this sort of science behind it, right, the mumbo jumbo of the science. You know, we di-- I don't mind sometimes falling for it, you know, it's like it's -- I guess it's business romance. >> Asha: Along with the romance, a confession. >> I did go golfing with the Neuro Clips on me. >> Asha: On you, and you did it the way he told you to put it. >> Oh, I was very careful. And I have to tell you I did it three days in a row. >> Asha: Really? >> Yeah, and my game did not improve one bit. Okay? [ Laughter ] >> Asha: We've talked to experts, we've done some tests. >> Yep. >> Asha: There's nothing-- >> Nothing. >> Asha: --to the clips. And? >> My chequebook was closed anyway so I'm safe. >> Asha: Viewers e-mailed us. >> Yep. >> Asha: They thought the clips were kind of scammy. >> Scammy. Ooh, that's a bad word. >> Asha: One viewer said that they can't believe the dragons fell for it. >> Right. >> Asha: What do you think of that? >> But we didn't make the investment in the end, right? So, you know, we may seem gullible, but I can assure you we are not gullible. >> Asha: So it was good for the investor but not the consumer. Do you take that into consideration when you're deciding what to do? >> Yeah, I mean-- I think-- Listen, nobody wants to sell a product that's not living up to its claims. [ ♪♪ ] >> Asha: Still, Metus' sales have been soaring since his debut in the den, over a hundred grand worth. [ ♪♪ ] >> Asha: I want to meet the man behind the invention. Hi, Mark, nice to meet you. >> Nice to meet you, too. >> Asha: Though Metus says he's been warned not to talk to us, he decides to anyway. With an entourage of supporters and that camera guy, too. You knew you'd get some flak from your appearance. Why did you think that? >> Well, it's very unusual science. >> Asha: You said in your own videos, you're not quite sure how it works, it just does. Shouldn't you, though, as the inventor know how it works? >> If I said I knew, I'd be lying. I'm gain-- >> Asha: Why is that, though? >> I'm gaining knowledge-- because it is a very strange science, the whole quantum physics area is very strange. I can only tell if something works if it changes something. >> Asha: Huh? We test his clips against name tag clips and no clips at all with ten people. We found no difference. Metus doesn't agree with our method but has no credible studies of his own to share. Why not? >> Because there has never been an opportunity for me to do that. >> Asha: How come? >> Well, because we're in the middle of one stage of research and then we'll move on to another stage of research. >> Asha: Those are the answers I keep getting from you, that it's coming, you're working on it, we're researching it. But it's not quite there. Why are you selling these products then? >> Because they're helping people. Every day, they help people. And that is my justification and for those it doesn't help, they can-- they send it back, and we give their money back. >> Asha: Meantime, someone's blown the whistle on Metus and the products he's been peddling. He's on Health Canada's radar for making unapproved claims. See this balance clip? He's not selling it for now, but the rest? Apparently, no probs. They're still being sold. Some people say you're a snake oil salesman. >> Well, everybody has an opinion. And that's quite all right. >> Asha: Now, what to do with all these clips. So you're a fashion guru. >> Yeah. >> Asha: Joe Mimran launched Club Monaco, Joe Fresh. Maybe he has some ideas. We don't know what to do with these clips, because they don't even work, so... >> Right, so, that's the other thing. >> Asha: Do you think that would be a fashion accessory? >> No. >> Asha: What? Come on! Like, can't we throw them on your scarf there? >> He could have done them like a nice tie clip, but you don't wear ties going golfing and look, it's going to ruin your panne velvet here. >> Asha: Oh, you can clip-- Oh, wow. All in the name of Marketplace. >> Restaurant secrets, who's getting your tips? [ ♪♪ ] >> Get more Marketplace, sign up for our weekly newsletter at CBC.ca/marketplace. ♪ ♪ >> Tip-out tactics on your Marketplace. [ ♪♪ ] >> So, ready to go into restaurants? >> I'm ready. >> All right. >> We're going out for dinner under cover. >> Recording. >> Recording. >> Heading into some of your favourite chains to see what servers will dish out but where your money's really going. >> Who's rights? >> Worker's rights! >> Our story begins with the rage over minimum wage. The fight being heard across Canada. Since Ontario raised the minimum wage, some companies are cutting paid breaks and reducing benefits. >> I'm here today because of the gross treatment of these workers are getting in the wake of a long overdue wage increase. >> Now dozens of servers are telling us about another tactic called the tip-out. >> I'll get the jerk chicken, please. You know, most restaurants have a tip-out policy, a common practice where servers share not a portion of their tips but a percentage of everything they sell. But as the minimum wage has been hiked, some employers are hiking the tip-out, too, taking money from the servers and giving it to the other staff. >> It's really not fair. >> Grace Ford works at a family dining chain in Alberta. >> Walk me through this. You make minimum wage. >> Yes, I do. It's 13.60 right now. >> What do people in the kitchen make? >> From what I know, there's $15 an hour to $32 an hour. >> So why do you have to give some of your money to them if they're making more of an hourly wage than you are? >> They want to make more money as we begin to make more money but since, you know, times are hard and my boss cannot afford to pay them more money, he's going to take more money out of my total sales and food for the day instead of giving them a higher wage. >> That sounds to me like you're subsidizing your employer. >> Yeah, it does feel like it. >> Grace forks over 4% of all the food she sells but that's about to increase to 5%. Just in the past week, how much have you tipped out? >> I've tipped out $413.62. >> So even if she doesn't get tipped, she's still on the hook to pay that percentage to the restaurant. >> I am a little frustrated. There's days where I work 12 hours and I still, you know, I give out $80 that I've worked all day for. >> Money Grace is saving to go to nursing school. >> Hard-earned money that I have sweat and almost cried over through the past week working for that just kind of disappears into thin air. >> She's not alone but she's one of the few people willing to go public. So to find out how widespread this is, we're checking out some popular chains. First up, a Kelsey's location in Ontario. We're protecting the identity of servers who could lose their jobs for speaking up. >> Same story at Sunset Grill. And when we head into Moxie's. >> It's like a wild west out there. >> Deena Ladd has been fighting for worker's rights for over two decades. >> No restaurant owner should be using tips to compensate for the minimum wage. >> She says the tip-out tactic is unfair. >> If they are trying to recruit that money to pay other people or to cover other costs, then that needs to get challenged and we need to make sure that people know about it. >> Because it's happening almost everywhere we visit. [ ♪♪ ] >> At Eastside Mario's. >> And at The Keg. [ ♪♪ ] >> Seven of Canada's most popular restaurant chains have increased their tip-outs since the minimum wage hike. What it looks like is that employers are giving a raise to people in the kitchen but the employer isn't paying for it, the servers are paying for it? >> If I was a restaurant owner, I'd be sitting down with my staff and I would be creating a fair tip pool that is not taking it out on servers and that is ensuring that everybody feels that it's a fair process. [ ♪♪ ] >> That's what Ivan Gedz has done. As a restaurant owner, he knows the business is tough, money tight but he doesn't want to take it out on his workers. You increase your minimum wage here up to 16 bucks without increasing the tip-outs. Why did you do it that way? >> Because we felt that some of the models that we're seeing elsewhere is a little bit of robbing Peter to pay Paul. When we make decisions here, our-- my staff know exactly how much money I make. When we make strategic decisions they're involved in that process. >> Some of the restaurants are doubling their tip-outs. What do you think of that? >> Am I allowed to swear on CBC? >> You can try, sure. >> I think they're full of shit. >> Now why do you say that? >> It's not fair. It's, uh-- being implemented in that manner, it's being pushed down their throats, it's not being done with consultation. You know, from a purely capitalist perspective, it's just poor business. It makes no sense. >> The chains we visit won't tell us why they're tip-outs have increased, but they do say their policies are fair and transparent and tip-outs are a way to recognize the efforts of the entire team. >> Who's rights? >> Worker's rights! >> But these protestors aren't buying that message. >> I feel that it's just another tactic design to negatively impact those workers. >> I see it as wage theft really. I mean, these workers, you know, they don't make very much, they're already struggling to make ends meet and, you know, with that tip-out percentage going up, it's just taking more money out of workers' pockets. >> What do you think about the tip-out policy at these major restaurant chains? Join the conversation on Facebook and Twitter. [ ♪♪ ] >> You know, there's a -- a major, major issue that I think has to be addressed. [ ♪♪ ] >> Asha: Exposing telecom sales tactics. >> I'm not getting what they're promising. >> We were guaranteed a price. I don't want to hear the excuse. >> Asha: Find out how not to get duped at the door. [ ♪♪ ]
Info
Channel: CBC News
Views: 254,163
Rating: 4.7820382 out of 5
Keywords: Scam, science, fooled, chiropractor, Dragons' Den, investors, endorsing, unproven cure, metal, ache, strength
Id: P-Kl0XkZuCw
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 22min 26sec (1346 seconds)
Published: Fri Feb 02 2018
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.