Deepfakes: Is This Video Even Real? | NYT Opinion

Hello. Today I’m going to be talking to you about a new technology that’s affecting famous people. Remember when Obama called Trump a dipshit? "Complete dipshit." Or the time Kim Kardashian rapped, "Because I’m always half naked"? Or when Arnold Schwarzenegger impersonated himself? "Get out of there! There's a bomb in there! Get out!" Deepfake. Deepfake. Deepfake. This is a deepfake, too. I’m not Adele. But I am an expert in online manipulation. So deepfakes is a term that is used to describe video or audio files that have been created using artificial intelligence. My favorite is probably Lisa Vanderpump. It started as a very basic face-swapping technology. And now it’s turned into film-level C.G.I. There’s been this huge explosion of, “Oh my goodness, we can't trust anything.” Yes, deepfakes are eerily dystopian. And they’re only going to get more realistic and cheaper to make. But the panic around them is overblown. In fact, the alarmist hype is possibly more dangerous than the technology itself. Let me break this down. First, what everyone is freaking out about is actually not new. It's a much older phenomenon that I like to call the weaponization of context or shallowfakes with Photoshop and video editing software. There's so many needs. How about the time Nancy Pelosi appeared to be drunk while giving a speech? "But you never know. "But this president of the United States." Turns out that video was just slowed down at 75%. "It was very, very, very, very, very strange." You can have a really simplistic piece of misleading content that can do huge damage. For example, in the lead-up to the midterms, we saw lots of imagery around this caravan of people who were moving towards the U.S. This photo was shared with captions demonizing the so-called migrant caravan at the U.S.-Mexico border in 2018. But a reverse image search showed it was actually Pakistani refugees in Greece. You don't need deepfakes' A.I. technology to manipulate emotions or to spread misinformation. This brings me to my second point: What we should be really worried about is the liar's dividend. The lies and actions people will get away with by exploiting widespread skepticism to their own advantage. So, remember the "Access Hollywood" tape that emerged a few weeks before the 2016 election? "When you're a star, they let you do it. "You can do anything." "Whatever you want." Around that time. Trump apologized, but then more recently he's actually said, I’m not sure if I actually said that. When anything can be fake it becomes much easier for the guilty to dismiss the truth as fake. What really keeps me awake at night is less the technology. It's how we as a society respond to the idea that we can't trust what we see or what we hear. So if we are fearmongering, if we are hyperbolic, if we are waving our hands in the air, that itself can be part of the problem. You can see where this road leads. As public trust in institutions like the media, education and elections dwindles, then democracy itself becomes unsustainable. The way that we respond to this serious issue is critical. Partly this is the platforms thinking very seriously about what they do with this type of content, how they label this kind of content. Partly is the public recognizing their own responsibility. And if you don't know 100%, hand on heart, “This is true,” please don't share, because it's not worth the risk.

Channel: The New York Times

Views: 874,886

Rating: 4.8882937 out of 5

Keywords: opinion, what is a deepfake?, should I be worried about deepfakes?, how can I tell if a video is a deepfake?, what are deepfakes?, what are signs of a deepfake?, why are deepfakes concerning?, what can we do about deepfakes?, what is the problem with deepfakes?, what problems do deepfakes cause?, deepfakes, reddit, youtube, facebook, elections 2020, obama, claire wardle, adele

Id: 1OqFY_2JE1c

Length: 3min 39sec (219 seconds)

Published: Wed Aug 14 2019

Reddit Comments

[u/Ezzy77]

Love the part where she says "they'll become more affordable"...like more FREE? :P