Anastasia's dresses are surprisingly historically accurate

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments
Captions
Good morning my beautiful doves! If you haven't immediately  noticed, I have a new backdrop. Yes, I've finally settled down  into a new apartment in Brooklyn   and I guess if you haven't been following my  Instagram rants about my housing situation,   you're probably a little bit confused because  I had announced that I had moved into a new   apartment a couple videos ago. But basically what  ended up happening is that my landlord was awful   and she kicked us out the same month that we  moved in, and I'm still not sure if it was legal,   but me and my roommate scrambled to find new  housing and we found this place, and in the end,   this place is the nicest apartment I've ever  lived in, so I'm really excited about it. I'm still in the midst of  decorating so I guess I'm not fully   settled in yet but i definitely want to  give an apartment tour at some point,   maybe in like a month, because I  don't really have much furniture... I personally am only interested  in buying secondhand furniture or   used furniture and I know my roommate is  really into building their own furniture,   so it's going to take a little bit longer  for us to get camera ready. But I'll show   you a couple things in my room really  quickly because I'm just that excited. Don't mind the mess in the background,  but i'm most proud of this antique gold   mirror that I found off of craigslist last  week. I just love how the gold looks against   the white walls and especially how the ornate  frame looks against the cool molding details   I have on my walls. I put the frame off center  because of just the way that the molding is, but   i'm planning to put up some cast iron hooks  on this side so I can hang up all my bonnets. I also got this vintage carriage bench that is  just holding some of my books for now. But i   bought this and I was really excited because  I wanted a little bit of a reading nook here   by my window, because I just always wanted to  have a reading spot by a window. I need to sew a   tufted bench cushion for this because it is a  bit of a peculiar shape here and the only person   on Etsy that I found that could sew tufted bench  cushions for a reasonable price is booked up till   April... so I'm taking matters into my own hands. Thank you, thank you very much. So this is my bed and the lighting is kind of ass  right now but my mom got it--well technically the   bed is an antique from Italy--and my mom bought  it off of this 98 year old woman who lived near us   for like 100 dollars, which is crazy. It has  this brass hardware and an off-white/ivory   frame/metal thing - I don't know. It is missing  one of these things. It should go here but   it's whatever, it adds to the character I guess.  Anyway I just wanted to give a little bit of a   life update but as I promised in the title: Today  we're going to be talking about Anastasia the 1997   Don Bluth animated movie based on the tragic  legacy of the real life Grand Duchess Anastasia. I think that's how you  pronounce her name correctly. Throughout this video, I'm going to be using  "Anastasia" when I talk about this movie,   "Anastasia" when i'm talking about the real-life  person, and "Anya" when I'm talking about the   main character, because she does go by  "Anya" for most of the movie. I was very   obsessed with this movie growing up. Anya was  one of my favorite girl heroines of the time. "You broke my nose." "Men are such babies." I love Meg Ryan who is Anya's voice actress,   and I thought Dimitri, the  love interest, was super cute. "Anya I'm just trying to help, all right?" "Dimitri, do you really think I'm royalty? "You know I do." "Then stop bossing me around!" Shipped these two really hard. So you can imagine how totally bummed I was   when in middle school I found  out that the real life Anastasia died and she and her entire family were violently  stabbed to death in a dark basement... and then i kind of realized how messed up it is  to make a children's movie based on this tragedy. Anyways... I was re-watching this movie for this video  and I feel like just knowing the real story   made some of the family sequences a lot  more disturbing. I just kept thinking   about how they were all violently murdered,  even in this alternative Don Bluth universe   the rest of the children were killed and  this was just never addressed in the movie.   It was just completely like... "well, forget  about it," because it's a children's movie,   which brings us to once again the  question: Why is this a children's movie? But with all that aside I thought it'd  be fun to dive into the clothing of   early 20th century Russia. First things  first, I would absolutely not be able to   make this video without the help of Anna,  Jane, and Maia. I posted a cry for help   on my IG stories a couple days ago and these  three people just really came through helping me   scour the Russian side of the web to find image  resources and translating Russian texts for me,   so everyone let's say, "Thank you Anna,  Jane, and Maia!" ("You go, girl.") So the movie Anastasia takes place in St.  Petersburg, Russia. Anya is eight years old   in the first scene, which takes place in 1916. We  first see her at a ball celebrating the Romanov   Tercentenary, aka the 300th anniversary of Romanov  rule, so fact check: Anastasia was born in 1901,   so she would have been 15 in 1916. Also there  was no ball in 1916 at the Winter Palace,   the Romanov Tercentenary ball took place in  1913 at the Nobleman's Assembly, not in the   Winter Palace. The last big ball that was housed  at the winter palace was in October 1904 and after   that it only hosted formal ceremonies. Other  historical things to note: the Romanov family   was actually massacred in 1918, the movie's  villain Rasputin had no hand in their deaths,   and St. Petersburg was not called  "St. Petersburg" at the time. In 1914,   the city was changed to Petrograd and in 1924,  the city name was changed again to Leningrad.   So the song "A Rumor in St. Petersburg"  should really be "A Rumor in Leningrad." I guess that doesn't have the same ring to it. I've decided to break down three of Anya's  looks in the movie. You might be surprised   by the three I've picked. She does  wear a lot of different outfits,   more so than most animated movie protagonists,  but I wanted to focus more specifically on the   Russian outfits. So I'm actually not going  to be talking about the Parisian outfits.   Just know that her Parisian outfits are not very  accurate to 1920s fashion and that's pretty easy   to tell based on silhouette alone. Let's start  with the first ball gown she wears. Anya wears   a robe for the Romanov Tercentenary ball that  looks to be based on traditional 17th century   aristocratic clothing. The robe is of a teal  blue color with wide sleeves, a cape-like collar,   gold embellishments, and a matching  round headdress called a "kokoshnik." That might be a wrong  pronunciation. I'm very sorry. Also, this kind of collar was originally worn by  Byzantine clergy but Russian clergy and nobility   started wearing them for formal occasions in  the late 10th century when Christianity was   introduced to Russia. In reality, Anya did  not attend the Romanov Tercentenary ball,   she was not old enough. The only Romanov children  who were in attendance were Olga and Tatiana. Also   after doing some research, I realized the ball  in the movie actually looks to be based on the   1903 ball, which was held to celebrate the 200th  anniversary of the founding of St. Petersburg.   This ball was a costume ball and  the theme was 17th century Russia,   or more specifically, the reign of Tsar Alexei  Mikhailovich. All guests were expected to dress   in traditional historical attire. There's not too  much information on the 1913 ball. Some sites out   there say that it was also a costume ball, but I  don't think that was true. I found a painting by   Dmitri Kardovsky depicting the ball scene, and if  we look closely, we can see that all the guests   are wearing standard court dress. With that said  in 1903, the Russian court went really hard at the   event. Court ladies wore embroidered sundresses  and jewels kokoshniks and gentlemen wore decorated   caftans and boyer-style fur hats. The Empress  Dowager Maria Feodorovna was also in attendance,   and her animated outfit looks to be based on  the costume that she wore to this ball. You   can see the resemblance in the wide collar, the  pointed headdress, and the veil in the back. The   animated version is obviously less detailed but I  understand that because of animation technology it   would have been unreasonably difficult to decorate  the dress with all the jewels she actually wore   in the movie. Tsar Nicholas II is wearing  a pretty standard military inspired outfit,   which he kind of did wear in real life. According  to Russian Splendor: Sumptuous Fashions of the   Russian Court, "for ceremonial occasions, Nicky  usually wore a light blue attaman uniform with a   diamond Saint Andrews star and a diamond Order of  Saint Andrew hanging on the Saint Andrew chain."   For those of you who are a little bit  confused about the whole Saint Andrew thing,   the Order of Saint Andrew was established in  1698 by Peter the Great in honor of Saint Andrew,   Jesus's first apostle and the patron saint of  Russia. The order of Saint Andrew is used to award   prominent people and statesmen. Instead of this  outfit, I kind of wish they went the full mile   and put him in the Alexei Mikhailovich  costume he actually wore to the ball.   It was recorded as being raspberry  colored with gold and silver embroidery,   and before any animators tell me that it's  unrealistic to do that, yes I understand the   costume is very elaborate, but if we look at the  Dowager Empress in the way that she is dressed:   her silhouette is kind of just the same as her  real life dress, and I think if they just did   something where the design was shaped like what  Tsar Nicholas II was wearing, then that would   have been better. Because Anastasia wasn't in  attendance, I think the animators based her robe   on the robe of Countess Elisabeth Cheremetew. You  can see the resemblance in the white collar and   the color blue with gold embroidery. The kokoshnik  looks to actually be based on a real kokoshnik   that Anastasia is depicted wearing with her  court gown in 1910. So for historical accuracy,   considering Anastasia wasn't in attendance  and because there was no actual ball in 1916,   it's kind of hard to rate. But if she was an  older character and attending the 1903 ball,   then this design would be really good. The second  dress I want to talk about is this blue dress that   Dimitri gives Anya on the boat on the way to  Paris. I will point out that there was a bit   of an animation goof here because at first you see  the dress has a white trim, but then when she puts   it on there's no more trim. Anyways, this dress is  not accurate for the 1920s. The 1920s had a very   tubular silhouette, and by the mid-20s, the hem  had risen to just below the knee. But i actually   don't want to talk about what a 1920s accurate  version of this dress would be, I'd rather talk   about what i would have advised the animation team  to do when designing this dress. Anastasia and her   sisters were often photographed wearing these  very pastel or lily white Edwardian dresses.   These white dresses are known as lingerie dresses  sometimes called lawn dresses. Unlike the name,   lingerie dresses were actual garments, not  undergarments. These dresses were very popular   all over Europe and America among younger  women. They were very delicate, lightweight,   and normally made of cotton. Lingerie dresses  were either white or off-white and featured   embroidery in set lacing and pin tucking. And  not to sound like a better con man than Dimitri,   because i'm sure Dimitri has conned many a people,  and I have conned no one... If I was a con man   trying to convince the Dowager Empress that this  woman I presented her is indeed Anastasia, then   I would have had her dressed like the way  that Anastasia was dressed before she died. Oh excuse me, I mean when she went missing. "I am so much happier now that i'm dead." "Technically missing." Finally let's talk about Anya's court  gown--probably what you all clicked on   to hear me talk about. I love this dress so much.  It's probably one of my favorite animated dresses   of all time. Is that crazy for me to say? But  yeah I think so, and the best part is that   it's probably going to be as accurate as is going  to get to the real thing for 90s 2D animation.   If you look up images of the real Anastasia or  any of her sisters or really any female member   of the royal family you'll see that they're all  wearing open shoulder gowns with these wide slit   hanging sleeves and a satin sash. The tiara  she's wearing is called a kokoshinik tiara.   It's basically just a tiara that is inspired  by the kokoshinik shape. What's interesting   about 19th and 20th century Russian court gowns is  that they had a very distinctive style compared to   other European court gowns. This was absolutely  purposeful, but it wasn't always like this.   From 1700 to 1724, Peter the Great had issued  a series of dress reforms with the intention of   moving away from Russian costume and towards  Saxon, German and French forms of dress.   People initially resisted these clothing changes,  so decrees were often repeated, they hung up   stuffed animals wearing clothing samples at city  gates. and on a less fun note, disobedience was   often punished with fines or even capital  punishment sometimes. We started to see more   relaxation in these rules after his reign, and  Catherine the Great actually tried to reintroduce   Russian dress. In 1791, the magazine called "The  Magazine of English, French and German Fashion,"   reported that for big balls like when celebrating  coronations or Christian holidays and for visits   to noble and honorable houses, the ladies  would wear Russian dresses of obyar, which is   a moire fabric with golden or silver pattern, and  double taffetas decorated with silks and jewels. If I fooled you into thinking I  was reading Russian... I didn't.   That was a translation offered  to me by Jane. Thank you, Jane. But it wasn't till the 19th century that Tsar  Nicholas I decided to officially bring back   traditional costumes. On February 27th 1834,  Nicholas I published an official statement   that detailed new court dress guidelines. Some  things that were in this document include how   ladies of the state were supposed to wear green  velvet dresses with gold embroidery and how all   ladies who came into court were supposed to  wear a kokoshnik with a white veil. Looking   at some examples, we can see how the Russian court  gowns were a hybrid of 1830s French romantic-style   dresses and traditional Russian styles. The gown  that Anya wears is of the typical Russian court   gown design in the early 20th century. Her gown  has three components: the bodice, the underskirt,   and the overgarment that had a train. I will say  though that because of her rank, her train should   be very long. The overgarment was typically made  of velvet and adorned with jewels, embroidery,   sequins, and pearls. The underskirt was made of  white silk or satin and embroidered with foliate   designs in gold or silver thread. The bodices  were also made of velvet with brocade or satin. So I hope you're seeing a theme here:  lots of gold and silver embroidery. The sleeves are definitely the most unique  part of the dress and were actually inspired   by "hanging sleeves" in 16th and 17th  century traditional Russian clothing. Clothing culture 1350 to 1650 by Catherine  Richardson mentions two traditional Russian   garments with "hanging sleeves." The first is a  "letnik." We can see how the sleeves are very long   and only sewn together about half their length  so the end of the sleeves are hanging freely.   There's also another garment that was worn  as outerwear called a "telogreya." It had   extra long hanging "fake" sleeves. According to  Elizabeth Mackey's report on Russian court dress,   the official look was designed to make the Russian  imperial court look distinct from other European   courts "to demonstrate both the authority of the  tsar over the nobility and the unity that he and   his court felt with the people." These dresses  were so very expensive and show how the Russian   imperial family expressed power through dress.  For context, Empress Alexandra spent 996 pounds   on her coronation gown when the average cost for a  British court gown was 300 pounds. In conclusion,   I think that the animation team did a spectacular  job when it came to designing Russian court gowns,   not so much for the rest of the fashions  depicted in the movie. But overall,   compared to other animated movies of the time,  this was just really good. Also this entire   movie was completely historically inaccurate  anyway, so i think it is kind of funny that   the one thing that they did choose to skew on the  side of accuracy on were the Russian court gowns. That's all I have for today.  Thank you so much for watching!   I'll see you all next time hopefully  with more decor in the background.
Info
Channel: Mina Le
Views: 427,689
Rating: 4.9704585 out of 5
Keywords: anastasia, 20th century fox, anastasia romanov, romanov family, anastasia 1997, don bluth, animation, historical accuracy, historically accurate, disney princess, russian history, russian fashion history, fashion history, costume analysis, dress history, nicholas ii
Id: NLwdGWfy0YU
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 17min 43sec (1063 seconds)
Published: Thu Jan 14 2021
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.