<i> - Shelton was
the most inspiring person</i>■ <i> that you will ever meet.</i> <i> - Good kid.
Good son.</i> <i> - Shelton Sanders.</i> <i> - I've always trusted
what he would tell me.</i> <i> - When Shelton went missing,
it was very strange.</i> <i> - Everyone felt like
it was probably foul play.</i> <i> - Whether or not he killed
Shelton, like, I don't know,</i> <i> but I really thought he knew
more than what he was saying.</i> <i> - Is there such a thing</i> <i> as an accidental death
in South Carolina?</i> <i> - If you did not
get rid of a body,</i> <i> you wouldn't
have asked that question.</i> <i> [dramatic music]</i> <i> ♪</i>■ - On the night
of June 19, 2001, Shelton Sanders,
a promising 25-year-old
college student at the University
of South Carolina, called his mother and said
he would be home late. He never made it home. Authorities initially
believed he just ran off and there was nothing
to worry about, but his family immediately
knew something was wrong and began reaching out
to those who knew him. Shelton's mysterious
disappearance would eventually go from
a missing person's case to a full-fledged
homicide investigation. <i> [somber music]</i> <i> ♪</i>■ <i> - Shelton was a very active
little fella.</i> <i> Even at six years old,</i> <i> getting ready to get started
with kindergarten.</i> You know, he was just really
curious about different things and so we just said, "Is this
boy going to be a scientist?" <i> And he became
a outgoing young man.</i> <i> Liked to study and liked
to do things right.</i> <i> He was my right hand
even at 12 years old</i> <i> because he wanted to make sure
everything is kept clean.</i> - We had a little job
at the church where we cut the church's
grass at the cemetery. <i> He didn't mind working.</i> Good kid.
Good son. - Shelton was the most
inspiring person that you will ever meet.
He was my role model. <i> Shelton was patient.</i> <i> Shelton was loved
by his community,</i> <i> by his family, his friends.</i> <i> - I first met Shelton
in high school.</i> He was a very humble guy, but he was really outgoing. He was the guy who would say, <i> "Hey, look, let's go
have a day trip.</i> <i> Let's go to the beach."</i> <i> And when it comes
to cookouts, you know,</i> <i> Shelton was
the main one to say,</i> <i> "Hey, man, you know,
let's all get together.</i> <i> Let's have a cookout."</i> - Woo-woof! - Shelton wanted
to get married. Shelton wanted
to have children. <i> He also talked about
owning his own distribution</i> <i> and raising cattle.</i> <i> He's a fanatic fan
of the Dallas Cowboys,</i> <i> so he would want to go
to the Super Bowl</i> <i> all the time to see them.</i> <i> So that was his dreams.
That's a little about Shelton.</i> <i> - He just seemed,
you know, just to fit.</i> He was just a great guy and
that's why I chose Shelton as my--to be the best man
at the wedding. <i> - Shelton went to school
at USC,</i> <i> University of South Carolina,</i> and his major was
information technology. Shelton was getting ready to
graduate in December of 2001. Unfortunately, Shelton's life
was cut down short six months
outside of his graduation. <i> [dramatic musical sting]</i> <i> - On the night
he didn't come home,</i> <i> he was commuting
back and forth</i> <i> from the University
of South Carolina.</i> <i> He communicated to his mother
that he would be a little late</i> <i> 'cause one of his friends
is getting married.</i> <i> He was the designated person
in that group</i> that was assigned
responsibility of going out and looking for a suitable place
to have a bachelor's party. <i> - I've always trusted
what he would tell me</i> <i> and usually when
he tell me things,</i> <i> I mean, that's exactly
what it would be</i> because that's what he was
taught as he was growing up. Tell the truth.
Do what you're supposed to do. Get back home. <i> [clock ticking]</i> <i> - Quarter to 12,
I was awakened in a dream</i> <i> with Shelton
screaming out to me.</i> A very loud scream. So I immediately got up. <i> We began to make phone calls
and to check</i> to see whether
he would answer his phone and there was no answer. - So when Shelton went missing,
it was very strange. My dad was concerned that
the car wasn't outside. My mom was distraught trying to
figure out what was going on. It wasn't like Shelton
to not come home. <i> - The next morning,
very early,</i> <i> we began to make phone calls
trying to find out,</i> has anybody seen him
or his whereabouts. Of course...nothing. - My dad started making calls
to law enforcement. Have they heard anything? <i> Started calling
highway patrolmen</i> <i> to see if Shelton had
got into a car accident</i> <i> and didn't make it home.</i> <i> My dad instructed
my younger brother</i> to make phone calls to
Shelton's known friends that he knew of
to get the details <i> about where Shelton was
on June 19th.</i> <i> - After calling the hospitals,</i> <i> calling the law enforcement,</i> it just became so frustrating
and teary eyes and... <i> calling family members
to try to get</i> <i> some kind of consolation,</i> <i> trying to get
some kind of relief.</i> <i> - My dad, at that time,
was told by law enforcement</i> <i> that he couldn't make official
missing person's report</i> <i> until after 48 hours.</i> So law enforcement
kind of told him, like, "Look, you gotta give it time.
He's an adult, <i> so let's just wait around to
see if we hear from him."</i> - When Shelton disappeared, his family, I believe,
knew immediately that there was a problem, that this was not like Shelton. <i> His friends even got out
and searched.</i> <i> They drove the way
Shelton would go home</i> <i> from Columbia that night.</i> <i> - We rode those highways,
you know, looking for Shelton.</i> <i> 521, 261, I-20.</i> <i> I thought Shelton was on the
side of the road somewhere,</i> and I say that because
Shelton was an erratic driver. Like, he drove kind of fast. <i> He wasn't the most careful
when he was driving.</i> - There are cases where people,
good people, you know, leave or run off
without any explanation. That wasn't this case. <i> Their son wasn't like that.</i> <i> Their son came home every day.</i> <i> Their son was
a really good citizen.</i> <i> He didn't fit the profile.</i> - Ooh.
- Big man. - Okay.
- [groans] - And they started making calls
of who he was last seen with and who did he go to scout
these hotel rooms with, and that's when we learned that
it was with Mark Richardson. <i> [dramatic chords]</i> - Mark was really defensive. <i> "Why is everybody calling me?"</i> You know, and it's like,
"Well, you know, we're just calling 'cause, like, you were
the last one he was with." <i> ♪</i>■ <i> [dramatic music]</i> - Judge William Sanders'
search for his son began the moment
Shelton didn't come home. Leading the charge
before the police got involved, Shelton's family
retraced his steps to the last person
he was seen with-- Mark Richardson. <i> ♪</i>■ <i> - Our younger son, Edwin,
discovered that Shelton</i> <i> had met with a fella</i> <i> by the name of Mark Richardson
that evening.</i> <i> ♪</i>■ And he said that when Shelton was about to go
and check on these hotels, <i> he had another mutual friend
that was gonna go with him</i> <i> but backed out
at the last moment.</i> <i> And Mark Richardson decided
that he would go with Shelton.</i> - I met Mark Richardson
probably around '93 at the University of
South Carolina. <i> He did not stay on campus.</i> <i> He stayed off campus,
so he used to come out</i> <i> and hang out with us
in the dorm rooms.</i> <i> Initially,
Mark was a funny guy.</i> He was, uh, kind of reserved until you really
got to know him and then he just kind of
blossomed and just came out. <i> - I asked my son Edwin
to get Mark Richardson</i> on the phone
and would he talk with me. He went berserk! <i> Yeah, he said--</i> said some very
nasty things to me. <i> I told him then that I was
not accusing him of anything.</i> <i> ♪</i>■ <i> We were seeking information
as to Shelton's whereabouts</i> and, well, it got to the point
where I thought <i> that it was best that
we end the phone conversation.</i> - Well, my dad
being a magistrate judge and being in the military, <i> he's been around
a lot of people</i> <i> and his intuition is spot-on.</i> - And one of the things that
I found odd when I called Mark <i> was Mark was really defensive.</i> <i> "Why is everybody calling me?"</i> You know, and it's like, "Well,
you know, we're just calling 'cause, like, you were
the last one he was with." <i> - The next day,
my son called him again.</i> <i> And this time the young fella</i> had a completely
360 degree attitude <i> and he said this time,</i> <i> "Mr. Sanders,
why don't I do this.</i> <i> "I'll just come over
to you all's house</i> <i> and speak with you."</i> - Mark Richardson
was on the way to our house. <i> My father made a phone call
to Sheriff Anthony Dennis,</i> <i> at the time he was a deputy,</i> <i> to inform him that,
"Mark Richardson</i> <i> "is on the way to our house to
give us his side of the story</i> <i> "about what took place
that night.</i> "I would like law enforcement
to come out here to our house "to assist us just in case of
anything unexpectedly happens, <i> we'll have, like, backup
or law enforcement on site."</i> <i> My dad did record
the conversation</i> <i> that they initially had
in the living room.</i> <i> - Mark said, "We went scouting
for hotel rooms</i> <i> "and after that,
we came back to my house.</i> <i> "And Shelton said that
he had to go back home</i> <i> to Rembert, South Carolina."</i> And by that time,
the law enforcement had already came in the door, and they had their own
separate conversation. <i> - Shelton Sanders
was reported missing</i> <i> to the Sumter County
Sheriff's Department.</i> <i> They kept the case.</i> I do remember that
was a point of contention between the Richland County
Sheriff's Department and Sumter County
Sheriff's Department <i> because we felt
the last place he was seen</i> <i> should be where
the jurisdiction lies</i> <i> as it relates
to the investigation.</i> <i> - Sumter County
law enforcement</i> talked to the neighbors
of Mark Richardson and they said on that
Tuesday night, June 19th, they heard three gunshots--
pow, pow, pow. <i> [three gunshots]</i> <i> - When he heard the gunshots,</i> <i> he came outside
onto his porch,</i> looked, and saw Mark Richardson
standing next to a vehicle. <i> He asked him,
"What was that noise?"</i> <i> Mark says to him,</i> "Don't worry about that.
That was my car backfiring." Well, it was three shots
in a row, so I don't know of any vehicle
that will backfire-- That stood out to me. <i> - Sumter County
Sheriff's Department</i> <i> dropped the ball completely
on this case.</i> <i> My dad gave them
all kind of materials,</i> names of people that could
possibly help with the case, and Sumter County
Sheriff's Department <i> lost the information.</i> - They just went down
the wrong path when it comes to it being
"drug related." You know, African American
college graduates, <i> they had no more fun than</i> <i> the average college student
here in this country.</i> <i> Maybe one or two associates</i> <i> may have been involved
in some marijuana,</i> but it--I can't speak for why
they went down that direction. I just know that
what they needed to focus on <i> was primarily here
in Columbia, South Carolina.</i> <i> - Now, as an 11-year-old,</i> <i> I really didn't know much
about what was going on.</i> I just remember
my mom crying a lot, my dad being out,
searching for my brother. <i> - I searched out his friends,</i> <i> his acquaintances
in Columbia University,</i> <i> talked with people
that may have known him</i> <i> or may have heard something.</i> I spoke to hundreds of people. <i> I went in places where
I shouldn't have gone.</i> <i> You know, I went in
woods--wooded areas.</i> <i> I went into areas
where bodies of water was.</i> <i> Dangerous.</i> - We held out that hope... that hope that we would
just hear something. <i> Every morning
or every evening,</i> <i> looking down that driveway
to see whether</i> <i> that white car will show up--</i> <i> I just kept hoping.</i> <i> - I ran into Mark
at a restaurant.</i> <i> I'll never forget, 'cause
I hadn't seen him since 2001.</i> As soon as we got to talking,
the first thing he says is, "And have they found
Shelton's car yet?" <i> He didn't ask about Shelton</i> <i> or wonder
what happened to Shelton.</i> <i> It was just the car.
"Have they found the car yet?"</i> <i> ♪</i>■ <i> - Everyone described
Mark Richardson</i> <i> as someone that would
shift on them emotionally</i> in mid-stream of
a conversation, <i> and they knew
that something was wrong.</i> <i> [dramatic music]</i> - Shelton Sanders had now been
missing for nearly two years. The Sumter County
Sheriff's Office had yet to make an arrest,
and the case was cold. But on April 26, 2003, a deputy from the Richland
County Sheriff's Department made a discovery that would
blow the case wide open. <i> - 2003, I was working
as the on call investigator</i> <i> for the Richland County
Sheriff Department.</i> <i> A deputy had received
a phone call</i> about some young people
hanging out in the parking lot around a white Oldsmobile,
and they were drinking. <i> - When law enforcement
came out</i> <i> to this particular
apartment complex,</i> <i> Greenbrier Apartments,
they saw the Oldsmobile,</i> <i> they ran the license plate
off of that Oldsmobile</i> and connected to the missing
person's case of Shelton. <i> - It had been months in
between his disappearance</i> <i> and when his car was found.</i> <i> The car was backed into
a parking space</i> <i> in the parking lot.</i> At that point, you know,
everyone felt like this was probably foul play and it turned it,
at that point, clearly, into a criminal investigation. <i> - I showed up.</i> <i> Immediately treated
the vehicle</i> <i> and where it was parked
as a murder crime scene.</i> <i> Calling the necessary
personnel to come</i> and start processing
the vehicle. <i> - Shelton's car was found
in Richland County,</i> so at that point,
the jurisdiction is eventually turned over to our department, <i> and Sergeant McDaniels
picked up the case.</i> <i> - When we learned that
Deputy McDaniels</i> would be in charge, I just said, "Thank you, Lord."
[chuckles] <i> - When they did find
Shelton's car</i> <i> in the apartment complex,</i> that then kind of started to
change how I started feeling about whether Mark Richardson
had anything to do with this. - After we took
the case over in 2003, there was a two-prong strategy
to conduct the investigation. <i> One was to
reinterview everyone.</i> <i> The other one was to see</i> <i> what the phone records
could tell us.</i> <i> When interviewing
the mutual friends</i> <i> of both Mark Richardson
and Shelton Sanders,</i> <i> I began to notice</i> <i> that everyone
described Mark Richardson</i> <i> as someone that would shift
on them emotionally</i> <i> in mid-stream
of a conversation,</i> <i> and they knew
that something was wrong.</i> <i> Each of them had their own
story about an instance</i> <i> where Mark had engaged them
out of the blue</i> <i> and would accuse them
of trying to hurt him.</i> - Mark was a totally
different person from 1993, <i> from when I first met Mark.</i> <i> As the year
started to progress,</i> <i> Mark changed from being
a reserved, outgoing</i> <i> to more of a paranoid
type guy.</i> <i> - Sergeant Kevin Baker was
responsible for identifying</i> <i> Mark Richadson's phone records
off of a tower</i> <i> that we know
was positioned within</i> <i> very close proximity
to where the car was found.</i> <i> We were able to
confront him on that.</i> He came into the Richland
County Sheriff's Department, <i> and myself and Sergeant Baker
began to interview him.</i> <i> "Why was your phone hitting
off of a cell phone tower</i> <i> that was in close proximity
to where the car was parked?"</i> <i> ♪</i>■ <i> He said that he was
picked up by a prostitute</i> <i> and that she actually
had a car</i> <i> and drove him out
in that direction.</i> <i> He told us the name
of a potential prostitute,</i> <i> and Sergeant Baker
went to go run that down.</i> <i> I don't know
too many prostitutes</i> that have their own vehicle
and pick up their own johns. <i> And so that didn't
make sense.</i> <i> - At some point
during the interview,</i> Richardson said, "Let me ask you
a hypothetical question. <i> "Is there such a thing</i> <i> as an accidental death
in South Carolina?"</i> - He puts his face
in his hands like this and he says, "How do I explain
getting rid of a body?" <i> I could tell that
he was struggling with</i> <i> telling the truth and
giving us a confession on it.</i> At that point, Sergeant Baker
came back into the room. I said, "Let me update you
on where we are." <i> And I went through
a whole spiel</i> <i> about how he asked a question,</i> <i> "How do I explain
getting rid of a body?"</i> <i> He said, "I didn't say that."</i> <i> - It's not enough
to bring charges</i> just alone on that statement, but when you look at the other
evidence involved in the case, <i> you know, all those things
tend to show guilt.</i> <i> - I'd stand on the arrest</i> <i> and the probable cause
wholeheartedly</i> based on the witness testimony
of his behavior, <i> based on the triangularization
of his records,</i> <i> putting him right next to
where the car was located,</i> <i> based on his own testimony
that he was in fact</i> <i> the last person to be seen
with Shelton Sanders,</i> and also, based on
his indirect admission of "How do I explain
getting rid of a body?" <i> - I was sitting in my room</i> <i> and Mark Richardson's face
come across the screen.</i> And I saw Mark Richardson
being charged for the shooting death
of Shelton Sanders. And at that moment,
I was very relieved <i> that we finally had a path
to justice, at that time.</i> - Have you heard from Shelton?
- Have not heard from my son. - Each year
that he doesn't call, <i> showing that
he was not alive.</i> <i> [dramatic music]</i> - Nearly seven years after
Shelton Sanders' disappearance, the trial for his murder began. And although the State's case was built on
circumstantial evidence, solicitor Barney Giese
believed it would be enough to convince the jury
that Shelton was killed by his friend Mark Richardson. <i> ♪</i>■ - I want to recognize
the attorneys for their opening statements, and I invite
your close attention. Solicitor, you're recognized. - May it please the court,
Your Honor. - Yes, sir. - June 19, 2001, Shelton Sanders did not get home that night. Shelton Sanders, for the last 2,492 days, has never contacted nor been seen by anyone. There's a reason for that. State submits Shelton Sanders is dead. There can be no other reason. And he's not here today,
the State submits, because
of the action of one man. And it was a man,
ladies and gentlemen, who, that night, murdered the victim here in Columbia... and then disposed of his body. He's in the courtroom. He's the defendant, Mark Richardson. <i> - As the lead investigator,</i> <i> I sat at the solicitor's table
throughout the entire trial.</i> It was being videotaped and, you know,
it was pretty intense, <i> but I felt strong about it.</i> - What this case is about, as you have learned, the prosecution is contending that this is a murder case. We contend that this is
a missing person's case, <i> that Shelton Sanders
has disappeared.</i> <i> There will not be
a single person</i> <i> to come into this courtroom</i> to tell you that they witnessed Mark Richardson
kill Shelton Sanders. This part about my client
disposed of the body-- see if one witness
comes in here and testifies to you that they saw my client
dispose of the body, they knew when
he disposed of the body, they knew where
he disposed of the body. There's a difference
between proof and speculation. <i> - Anytime you try
a murder case,</i> <i> it's hard, okay?</i> In this case, it's even harder because, you know, you have
to clear that first hurdle. <i> And that first hurdle is
showing that Shelton Sanders</i> <i> was actually dead
and deceased.</i> <i> - Have you seen Shelton
or celebrated a birthday</i> or holiday with him
since June 19, 2001? - No, sir.
Only his absence, sir. - Has he called you?
- No, sir. - And since June 19, 2001 has any bill come in
on any Visa or credit card showing that Shelton Sanders
has bought anything? - No, sir. - Nothing?
- Nothing. - So each year
that he doesn't call, each year that he doesn't
use the credit card, each year that, you know, that
he's just lost and not around, <i> you know, to me,
was circumstantial evidence</i> <i> showing that he was not alive.</i> - Since June 19, 2001,
10:44 p.m., Mrs. Sanders, have you heard from Shelton? - Have not heard from my son. - It was heartbreaking to me seeing my mother
become emotional, <i> my father giving details
as best as he could.</i> <i> [somber music]</i> - Robert Busby. - Good afternoon, Mr. Busby.
- Good afternoon. <i> - Well, there are a lot of
different ways</i> <i> to try a murder case.</i> In this case, you know,
we could show that there was a gunshot,
Mr. Richardson was involved, and then you show
that Shelton is dead. What time did y'all
get to your house? - Um, probably around 11. - Where did y'all go
in the house? - We went upstairs,
where I stay at. <i> - And did anything
unusual happen</i> <i> once y'all were up there?</i> - When we were up there, we heard, like, three shots firing,
one right after another. And I went to the door and then I went downstairs. <i> Outside in the yard
and I looked over,</i> <i> and I saw a fella
in the backyard.</i> <i> And he said,
"Everything's all right.</i> <i> My car was just backfiring."</i> And then I went back upstairs
and went back in the house. And that was it. - "Everything's all right.
My car was just backfiring." - Right. It wasn't--it wasn't like
a car backfiring to me. <i> - When reinterviewing
Mark Richardson's neighbor,</i> his statement became
very important to me as it relates to what happened
on the night that Shelton Sanders
was killed by Mark Richardson. - Did you tell
the investigator, "I tried to look over
at the neighbor's yard." - No, I looked over
when I came down. I looked over. - And how many people
did you see? - One. - Did you see a gun?
- No. - Did you see a body?
- No. - Did you see blood?
- No. - Did you see a car?
- Yeah, there was a car. - What color was it? - It was dark,
so I don't remember. It could've been light
or it could've been dark. - It was too dark to tell. - It was too dark to tell,
yes. - And were there bushes... <i> that obstructed your view?</i> <i> - Yes.</i> - So you couldn't
see over very well. - Not real good, no. <i> ♪</i>■ - The year 2000,
spring of 2001, like, how often
would you see Shelton Sanders? - Well, during that time, I would see Shelton
pretty frequently 'cause me and Shelton,
you know, still hung out a lot at the [murmurs]. - In addition to seeing him, would you also
keep in contact with him? - That's right.
- And how would that work? - You know, either call him
or we'd all get together, you know, at one
of our friend's house. - At some point,
in this group of friends, did you notice a change
in somebody's personality? - Yeah. Yeah, sure did. - And who was that? - Uh, it was Mark. Mark Richardson. Testifying was one of the hardest things
I've ever had to do. And seeing Mark there,
knowing that he is on trial <i> for the murder of
one of our closest friends...</i> - What types of things
would he say to you? - Well, some of the things
would be like, a lot of people were, uh... a lot of people were always
looking at him, a lot of people were, uh, maybe out to get him,
so to speak. But it was just more that
everybody was against him. <i> - Mental health became
an issue in the trial itself.</i> <i> There's testimony
that Mr. Richardson</i> had been acting
very strangely just in this very period of time about when
Shelton went missing. - Mark, he would go in and out. He would go in and out. Sometimes he would act normal, sometimes he would not
act normal. - We have a group of friends, <i> all of them educated,</i> <i> all of them have
love for each other.</i> <i> They weren't at odds
with Mark Richardson.</i> - Tell the judge again. What were the words that
the defendant said to you in the apartment of Hampton?
Hampton Park Apartments. You said spring or summer
of August... - Correct. 2000.
- 2000. - Uh, he essentially said that
he heard voices in his head telling him that he needed
to get his friends before they got him. <i> - And I believe that
on the night in question,</i> <i> Mark Richardson allowed those
voices to get the best of him,</i> and he perceived
Shelton Sanders as an immediate threat. <i> [three gunshots]</i> - He said, "Is there a such
thing as an accidental death in the state
of South Carolina?" <i> If you did not
get rid of a body,</i> <i> you would not ask
that question.</i> Especially while you're in <i> the headquarters of
a law enforcement agency.</i> <i> ♪</i>■ <i> [dramatic music]</i> - The jury had heard convincing
testimony from friends that Mark was acting strange
and hearing voices. To wrap up their case,
the State would call detectives to testify and
present their evidence, but it was the rigorous
cross-examination of these witnesses by defense attorney
I.S. Leevy Johnson that appeared to turn the tide
in the trial. <i> [edgy music]</i> - I want to turn your
attention to June the 26th. Did you and
Investigator Burnish travel to Columbia,
South Carolina? - Yes, we did.
- What was the purpose of you going to speak
to Mark Richardson? - We went to interview him because he was last seen
with Shelton Sanders. - Did Mark Richardson
say anything to y'all? - Yes, he did.
The first statement he made, he said,
"I didn't kill anybody." - At that point,
had you advised him that you were there
on a homicide? - Well, when he made
that statement I said, "We're here about your friend
Shelton Sanders who's missing." - And again, this is
on June the 26th of 2001 and at this point,
Shelton Sanders was considered missing.
- That's correct. - He was asked if he owned
a gun and he said, yes. He owned a
Glock .45 caliber handgun. - At that point, did you
request anything of him? - We asked if he'd allow us
to go inside and look at his residence. - And what did
he indicate to you? <i> - He told us, "You can look,
but you can't search."</i> - What did he tell you as you
were leaving the residence? - He told us not to come back
without a warrant. - Once you'd gotten
the search warrant, where did y'all go? <i> - We went to
Mr. Richardson's residence.</i> <i> - You searched specifically.
What were y'all searching for?</i> - The Glock
.45 caliber handgun. - And were you able
to recover it? - Yes, we were. So you searched... and how about did you search Mark's car? - I did not. No, sir.
- Was it there? - It was there, yes,
'cause he drove up in it. - He drove up in the car. Did anyone search his car?
- I don't recall. - If you had searched the car and found some body fluids
and fingerprints, some hair follicles
or something connecting Shelton with the inside
of the car. Isn't that right?
- Yes, sir. - And under the circumstances, <i> if Shelton had been shot</i> <i> and had been transported
in that car after being shot,</i> might've had some blood in it. Anybody check for that?
- I don't know. - What did you find that was incriminating
to indicate that Shelton Sanders
was murdered - They didn't find anything. <i> - I do recall during
the trial testimony from</i> <i> the Sumter County Sheriff
Department investigators</i> that were involved in it
thinking, like, "Please get to what we did beginning in 2003
for the jury." - Call your next witness. - May I please call?
- Yes, ma'am. - The State calls
Sergeant Shawn McDaniels. - And so it was at that time that we began to create
the proper theme. - What was significant to you at this point
in your investigation? As far as Mark Richardson's
cell phones. - Where he was located
when he used his cell phone on the night of June 19, 2001. The cell phone was actually
hitting off of-- between this one and this one. - And what is located directly
between those two? - Greenbrier Apartments. <i> We felt the triangularization
of his phone records</i> <i> where the car is located--
pretty strong.</i> We put you right next to the
car, and we find the car. <i> The initial interview, again,
that was pretty strong.</i> He said, "Is there a such thing
as an accidental death in the state
of South Carolina?" And I, at that point,
told him that there was. He put his face down
in his hands and when he came back up
and he stated, "How can I--how can I explain
getting rid of a body?" <i> If you did not
get rid of a body,</i> <i> you would not ask
that question.</i> Especially while
you're in the headquarters of a law enforcement agency. - Other than you... and Mr. Baker claiming that
Mark said these things to you, what independent proof do
y'all have that that happened? <i> - Other than me and
Sergeant Baker, nothing, sir.</i> <i> - Are you telling us</i> that the Richland County
Sheriff's Department doesn't have any equipment
that could accurately preserve your question
and his answer? - No, it is not common practice for us to record
our interviews. - And the reason it is not
used, Mr. McDaniels, is exactly what's happening
in this case because it allowed this
almighty sheriff department to come into court and pit y'all against
little Mark Richardson. Isn't that right? - That is incorrect, sir. <i> I.S. Leevy Johnson, you know,
is good at what he does.</i> <i> I have to give him credit.</i> I have to give credit
where it's due. He's--he comes off
very well to a jury. <i> But when you couple those
facts that we presented</i> <i> to get the warrant, I felt
pretty strong about it.</i> - Ladies and gentlemen,
please give me your attention. <i> The fact that the defendant
elected not to testify</i> <i> is not a factor to be
considered by you in any way</i> in your deliberations
and in your consideration on the question of whether
he is guilty or not guilty. <i> - There's always
two sides to a story</i> <i> and we wanted to hear
the other side,</i> but we could not compel him
to take the stand himself. His lawyer wouldn't allow it. <i> - Murders do not occur
in a vacuum.</i> There is something
that is always left at a murder scene. You just cannot walk away
from a murder scene without leaving
some evidence behind. Some physical evidence. Have y'all noticed
that not a single expert came in here to testify that they found any... any evidence
of a forensic nature? No blood found anywhere.
No DNA. I submit to you,
ladies and gentlemen of jury, that that speaks volumes about the lack of evidence
in this case. Well, there's this beautiful
commercial about Burger King. "Where's the beef?
Where's the beef?" The question in this case
is where's the proof? <i> - Mark's defense attorney</i> made the prosecution's case really questionable. <i> He poked holes
in the whole case.</i> - Mr. Johnson said
there's no evidence that this happened. No forensic evidence. Time destroys
forensic evidence, but it doesn't destroy
cell phone records and cell phone towers. State submits this... condemns him. On June the 20th, that first call was made on his cell phone. <i> He goes to Pisgah Church.</i> <i> Out of this vast world
we live in,</i> <i> that's not a coincidence.</i> <i> There's a reason why
he hit off Pisgah Church</i> <i> and that's because
he had driven that car</i> <i> to Greenbrier Apartments
and left it.</i> No beef, Mr. Johnson? That's beef. That's a hamburger. That's a Whopper. <i> ♪</i>■ <i> It's the worst time
of any trial.</i> <i> You've done everything
you can do,</i> <i> and the jury has it.</i> And you know,
the longer they're out, a lot of times,
at least in South Carolina, <i> the less chance you have
of getting a conviction.</i> <i> I've always thought.</i> <i> ♪</i>■ - All right.
Thank you. Mr. foreman, I received a note. - It's almost unexplainable.
This is just--wow. <i> [dramatic music]</i> - The family and friends
of Shelton Sanders were anxious but hopeful as they awaited
the jury's decision. A guilty verdict
would bring them justice and they hoped closure. <i> ♪</i>■ <i> - Mr. foreman, I received
a note from the jury</i> <i> that reads that
"We cannot come</i> to a unanimous decision
on this case." Is that the report of the jury? All right, then, uh, the court declares a mistrial in the case. <i> - My heart dropped
to my stomach</i> <i> 'cause I didn't know
what was going on.</i> I knew it wasn't
a guilty verdict. At that time, I didn't even
know what a hung jury meant, <i> and so I looked at my parents</i> <i> and I saw their reaction</i> <i> and I knew that
was a time to be sad.</i> - This is almost unexplainable. This is just--wow. <i> There were tears and,
"I can't believe this."</i> <i> - I really thought
if he was convicted</i> it would be one step closer to
finding Shelton's remains. <i> ♪</i>■ <i> - Based on my observation,</i> <i> the case ended up
in a hung jury</i> <i> primarily based on race.</i> <i> And the reason
why I say that is</i> the eight people who believed that he was guilty were white. <i> The four people</i> <i> who believed that he wasn't
were Black.</i> <i> The foreman was
a young Black man</i> <i> who, clearly,</i> <i> based on his post-interview
with the media,</i> <i> he had internalized the facts</i> <i> so much to the point
where he put himself</i> in the shoes
of Mark Richardson. That is not what we're
supposed to do as a juror. <i> - You feel down about it,</i> <i> but I specifically,
in this case,</i> <i> because of the Sanders' family</i> <i> and what great people
they were,</i> <i> I really, in this case,
felt for them.</i> <i> I hoped I could convict him</i> <i> and then we might, you know,</i> somehow get
Shelton's whereabouts-- his body back. But that wasn't gonna happen. <i> - There's something there
that we haven't found yet</i> that's going to
bring a conclusion, that is gonna help us
find the answers that we need, answers to give to the family. <i> Answers to resolve the case.</i> <i> Answers to bring it
to prosecution.</i> <i> It's a puzzle that
needs to be solved.</i> <i> ♪</i>■ <i> - In February of 2018,</i> I don't know what it was. I woke up one morning,
and I thought about Shelton. <i> And I said, "My brother has
been gone for 17 years,</i> <i> "and my parents
have not had closure.</i> <i> "Me, as a sibling,
and my other two brothers</i> <i> "have not had closure.
You know what?</i> "I'm 28 years old. I need to get up
and do something about it." I started to hire
private investigators, reaching out to psychics, <i> reaching out to different
news outlets and media.</i> - All that was want
is to find out where his remains is. Where he can finally, finally come home. - Then we can have
a proper burial, and that would be
a big thing for me. <i> - I did the billboards,
the yard signs for Shelton,</i> <i> the flyers...</i> just reaching out to
the sheriff's department, the attorney general
here in South Carolina, and I just started having weekly law enforcement
meetings keeping them on track. <i> This is what
needs to be done still.</i> <i> This is what
we should be doing.</i> - Our unit got involved
in Shelton's case in 2021. <i> Ms. Sanders,
Shelton's sister Wilveria,</i> <i> had sent a letter
to the sheriff.</i> <i> Our task now is
to find Shelton's remains,</i> <i> get him back home,</i> <i> and in finding his remains,</i> <i> that we are able to locate
more evidence.</i> At this point, we are not ruling anybody out
as a suspect. <i> - I don't know
what happened to Mark.</i> <i> Once the court case
was over with,</i> I think he may have
moved around a little bit, but I have no idea. I have no contact
with Mark at all. <i> - I think Mark Richardson,
without a doubt,</i> is the one responsible for
taking the life of his friend. <i> - In my opinion,
at this point,</i> I have seen nothing
that has changed my opinion that Mark Richardson
has committed the offense. - I've written five letters. One to Mark Richardson
himself <i> and to his entire family.</i> <i> I wrote them all a letter</i> <i> telling him that we,
as a family,</i> <i> as the Sanders family,
we forgive him for</i> <i> what he did with Shelton and</i> <i> he can just tell us what
he did with the remains.</i> <i> He can call our tip line.</i> <i> My private investigator</i> <i> actually hand delivered
that letter.</i> <i> - Whether or not
he killed Shelton,</i> like, I don't know, but I really thought he knew
more than what he was saying. <i> ♪</i>■ - We had the wonderful
opportunity, and the sad opportunity
all at the same time, <i> of being part of
a celebration of Shelton</i> <i> in June of 2021</i> <i> which was
his 20th year anniversary.</i> - The worst part--not knowing. Not knowing where or what
could've happened to Shelton. <i> I miss that boy so much.</i> - I'm of the opinion that, uh, one day, maybe not in our lifetime, <i> but the truth will surface.</i> <i> I have faith
that that will happen.</i> - I do believe we will find
his remains at some point because we're not gonna
stop looking. - So we're going on 21 years... w-with nothing. <i> Uh, in your mind,
you're really, really hopeful.</i> <i> I just want so much
for the family,</i> <i> and I want this
for his sister.</i> <i> - For the first time
in my life,</i> I finally feel that
we're moving closer to justice and that we're going to
soon get closure and that we will finally bring
Shelton to a resting spot <i> in our home.</i> <i> ♪</i>■ - The search for
Shelton continues. The Cold Case Unit
is investigating and they say they are
following leads, but as of this taping, Shelton Sanders
has not been found. I'm Tamron Hall.
Thanks for watching "Someone They Knew." <i> [somber music]</i>