Real vs Fake Piano - Can Pianists Tell? (w/ Daniel Thrasher, Marcus Veltri, Joe Jenkins)

real fake reel you just like laughed at my that's like the equivalent of like laughing in my face i'm laughing because i i got the exact opposite that's why that is really funny welcome back to another daily video my name is joe from room official and today we're going to figure out what does the real piano sound like what does a fake piano sound like and here with me to figure this out i have daniel thrasher joe jenkins and marcus valtteri three of the most prolific pianists are you guys good at hearing the difference between real and fake pianos daniel i think i can do it okay how about you joe i'm not big on dish to piano so i really i probably can't tell the difference okay how about you marcus i should know what i'm doing but i don't totally everybody ready this is the first one three two one let's go [Music] [Applause] [Music] okay oh okay do we all say at the same time or i think we got to go one at a time i guess we gotta go one at a time and we can't discuss but let's first just get our scores down i'm gonna say fake i don't know why it feels digital or like a sample thing to me right now i thought the opposite so i don't want to go next that's fine i have no idea that's the thing yeah me too that's tough i heard like the essence of what it was i felt like the piano guys felt like one of their videos where they record on a yamaha that might actually be what it is so i know those guys they generally record on yamaha grants but they also work with clavinovo a lot which is this instrument here so i don't know all that talking just for nothing i'm gonna guess acoustic because of the distance okay i'm gonna go acoustic as well the polyphony sounded great it's not like it was handling the notes really well so i'm gonna go acoustic what does it sound like when it doesn't handle polyphony well notes will cut out that's what happens okay joe i feel like i might know who's playing i think it might be peter bentz i think that might be where the sample is from to be honest and i know he does acoustic so i have i'm gonna go acoustic i'm not 100 sure it is him but anyway okay here we go correct what's real and it was peter no everyone gets a point but poor joel i love peter pence if you don't know who that is go check him out he's insane check out his version of bad by michael jackson next sample [Music] what do you think digital 100 digital for sure yeah that's a nord preset i know i thought i played that sample yesterday on my nord like i swear to god it's called amber upright i think yeah i knew that one too what do you think joel to me this sounded fake yeah there was some like resonance that i didn't felt sounded exactly right like it didn't stack right did everyone say fake i don't like the word fake i like the word digital i think we're gonna have fake in the titles you gotta say real or fake bro okay so this whole video started when marcus had bought a new expensive digital piano on twitter and joe you came in and what did you write it was me actually so i saw that he got a nord stage three and i was like no why did you get that instead of the nord grand the nord grand has great key action and then joe chimed in over here and i said well why do you why are either of you buying nords electric pianos you users buy an acoustic piano they sound much about joe it's because i want more than one sound on my keyboard yeah but you don't want a real sound you don't get that with it no i'm totally kidding it's like surround sound 4.0 whatever authentic always wins i agree i disagree i think i disagree as well there's so much passion here already i can't wait for this video okay this is going to be really great okay let's have a look fake let's go spit fire audio soft piano it's completely free but it's not knows it's not nord no [Music] you can hear the hammer action in there which i really that's a good that's a really good sample you know where else you can hear a hammer action daniel on an acoustic piano here's the score next one let's do it okay time to judge daniel i know where this is from okay you can't talk if you know where it's from okay then the others need to guess first yeah it's digital yeah i think it's digital and daniel you say what i think it is not real and where is it from i think it's from a flowkey tutorial which i know is on a clavinova because i've been to their headquarters in germany maybe it's not it i could be totally wrong i love the specific guesses yeah you're like this was uploaded in the fall of 2018 [Laughter] i want to go against you guys i'll never catch up otherwise i'm gonna say it's real it sounds so bad so i feel like the researcher must have like chosen it on purpose to have like a bad piano sound it's a good point okay let's see i am falling behind the pianist here who would have thought okay next one one of the two following clips is a very famous jazz trio playing and one is completely made up by sampled instruments can you tell which is real that is next level this might be embarrassing let's go [Music] [Music] [ __ ] [Music] what do you think guys i got it okay i think i got it too got a little bit of intuition but i'm still not confident at all i'm not confident oh i bet that diamond's confident because it is broken over thing again i swear to god i was in the factory when this keyboard was being manufactured i know the ins and outs okay daniel doesn't go first again because he knows weirdly specific things that is always wrong so far okay uh marcus oh no this is my least confident one i was thinking b sounded real i hope i don't look like a clown here oh my god joe what are you saying i thought the opposite mark is making me a second guess i love it i like that get in the way of what i thought so i'm gonna say acoustic first okay i'll go ahead and say that i think the b is real because it's very hard to sample the type of drumming they're doing with the brushes that's very very hard to get right okay daniel i think b is definitely digital and i'll say this i was listening to the boost because it's hard to get a really good bass frequency at stand upright face in the first sample the bass one eu it was like pitch bending a little bit the second one was way too like consistent okay guys let's see this is the really funny one i'm so scared i'm with the non-pianist a was real wow wow yes that was embarrassing as an ex-jazz drummer i feel really bad i just gonna give us the score we got marcus at three points joe at four points daniel had four points me at one point i am doing amazing is this piano real or fake fellas what do you think fellas i was leaning towards real just sounding great uh daniel this one's hard it's either genuine acoustic or it's keyscape it almost sounds fake i'm gonna go with fake oh my god i can't believe it the expert himself you're throwing okay joe i genuinely don't know it could be either way but i was leaning towards acoustic it's not where i lose the lead but i think acoustic dude if i'm wrong on this like i don't even know anymore i'll put it down as fake as well i don't know okay let's see real yes what was that daniel the keyscape 5.0 50 000 i don't know it's great and you can get it to sound just like that if joe wins you could talk so much to us now about acoustic pianos dude you'll never hear the end of it next who wants a guest not me please my instinct says acoustic what are you saying oh my god my instinct went digital until like there's a bit kind of halfway through it where it started getting a bit louder at that point i was thinking acoustic i mean i think it's fake i'm going fake with joe if it is digital it's rousseau playing this anyone else wants to make a really specific guess i want more really specific guesses it was like someone told you when you were younger daniel your answers aren't specific enough i'm sorry danny i'm gonna i'm gonna go against you here i'm gonna go fake but i've i've been wrong with almost all of them so far so now you guys who said fake are probably wrong as well okay let's see real daniel i'm back on top baby wait i'm actually curious what the score is okay let's check the score so marcus you got four points joey's got five daniel's five joel has six wait okay all right i'll try to get to the end someone's a little off i got one okay let's continue keep going let's do this i cannot believe this is real if this is real not not a chance i quit i'm deleting my channel if this is real what do you guys think for the first like two seconds i thought it was real but i do i think yeah it's gonna be fun uh marcus oh yeah that was completely fake for sure daniel it sounds like one of those tutorials one of those anesthesia okay fake yamaha stage piano okay everyone got a point guys let's keep going is this piano real or fake guys [Music] now that was the best cover of in the end i have ever heard daniel real or fake i'm gonna guess fake because the bass frequencies don't stay around as long as they should if you're doing that on an acoustic piano it'd be hitting that wood for for a lot longer but it just cuts out immediately joe real or fake i think it's going to be fake i can't articulate my thoughts as well as daniel and marcus cameron but i'm just gonna gut feeling here i think it's fake okay marcus let's go digital for sure it could be real and just poorly played i guess let's see i think it's fake everyone went digital oh my god no way what i was like a hundred percent sure that that was gonna be fake that was the first time we were all wrong yeah that was mental yeah let's keep going you will now hear three different adaptations of the same piece quickly cut between each other any number of these could be real or fake take a guess on each one okay let's do this guys [Music] okay got some good vsts for that one i mean i guess technically they could all be real yeah i think they could all possibly be real definitely when i listened to c just at the end it was i kind of want to change my answer but this is what i originally wrote down uh real fake real i'm laughing because i i got the exact opposite that's why that is really funny daniel should i put you down for the opposite fake real fake yeah digital real digital and joe what you got i wasn't sure about b but i put real for the first two and fake for the last one oh wow interesting i had the exact same as joe real real fake which usually means that sorry joe you're probably wrong since since it's me we're talking about it let's see fake fake real wow i was completely wrong is there a point yeah me too okay so the score is marcus seven points joe six points daniel seven points joel eight points i meant to say too [Music] that was beautifully played whether it's really fake like yes wow that was great i thought it sounded digital to me but i definitely had a tough time i could probably go either way but i'm probably gonna go digital my gut said digital but then again i have been wrong so i'm gonna go with acoustic okay very cool daniel it's a real piano because those mids are really hard to do it's either a real piano or it's a nord white brand interesting i said fake because if i feel like i don't know like it's exactly the middle i'm gonna go fake okay let's check keyscape there we go i have that me and marcus get a point each i'm on a losing streak now is this piano real or fake we know the drill let's do it fellas real or fake real it's real i think i was leaning towards real it's not like they didn't record the audio like the best way possible so if it's a vst it'd be like recorded perfectly so i don't know there's a thing called like reamping where you would record with like a vlc and then you play it in the room and you mic up the the room oh wow that would be so next level if that's what happened that would be very a big brain okay uh so everyone marcus real or fake fake joe uh real daniel do you think it's fake marcus oh wait oh wait sorry wait thank you daniel yes real daniel yeah i'm a guest acoustic too it seems so pointless to make a vst sound like this let's check real nice one point to everyone next one is this piano really fake [Music] oh my god that sounded so good okay marcus um i'm gonna go real i think it's fake okay daniel digital i think it's a nord white crayon you just keep guessing it so you get it i was gonna say real but i'm gonna say digital now okay fake nor dwight graham he did it fellas so marcus nine point joe eight points daniel nine points joel five points now i'm catching up phillips next one you will now hear two pieces back to back one of them is played on a real piano and one isn't can you tell which is which what do you think fellas b is real and then a is the vst or fake yeah i'm i'm going to go say i want to say b is fake and a is real i'm gonna go with fake first one real second one let's have a look yes that's it sorry daniel let's see yeah marcus is at 10 points joe is at nine points daniel's at nine points joel is at one point now i'm at six next one okay i feel like i'm leaning more acoustic you will get acoustic joe i'm gonna go with my gut instinct i'm saying it's acoustic and daniel yeah okay i think i'm gonna just just to catch up now not just to catch up i believe this i believe it's digital let's see fake oh nice vienna imperial wait some roomy you're the only one that got a point yeah i got a point i'm actually catching up a little bit this is great i love this song okay fellas that one's hard i think fake i thought it was real you guys want to say why i have no idea got instinct it was just played really well the low end sounded very rich and full so uh daniel real or fake i'm gonna guess uh digital i put digits all down as well oh i'm alone your loans either you're kind of like semi-clutching the win here or it's gonna be real tight now let's have a look real next one there are no next ones it's time for the final score marcus 11 points joe nine points daniel nine points joel 20 points it's done it's finished amazing congrats to you guys too well that was kind of an epic like last round you guys all would have won it would have been a three-way tie that would have been crazy oh yeah you're right i felt like i got to know you guys better i know now that daniel went to germany i want to do this again that was fun man yeah that was fun yeah dude okay click here for the other people's channels here for more music commentary videos and i will see you tomorrow in another daily video hey guys what do you think about the challenge that's pretty tough it was very tough

Channel: RoomieOfficial

Views: 957,753

Rating: 4.9811707 out of 5

Keywords:

Id: OBBRYyuzOm0

Length: 16min 37sec (997 seconds)

Published: Thu Oct 22 2020