>>> IT IS NOW UP TO DONALD TRUMP TO EARN THE VOTES OF THOSE IN OUR PARTY AND BEYOND IT DID NOT SUPPORT HIM. AND I HOPE HE DOESN'T. AT ITS BEST, POLITICS IS ABOUT WRINGING PEOPLE INTO YOUR CAUSE, NOT TURNING THEM AWAY. >>> WELCOME BACK TO "AMERICA DECIDES." DOES DONALD TRUMP HAVE A NIKKI HALEY PROBLEM? EVEN THOUGH HALEY HAS BEEN OUT OF THE RACE FOR MONTHS, SHE CAPTURED NEARLY 22% OF THE VOTE IN TUESDAY'S INDIANA REPUBLICAN PRIMARY, AND THAT FOLLOWS OTHER PRIMARIES IN WHICH SHE HAS RECEIVED A SIGNIFICANT SHARE OF THE VOTE. LET'S BRING IN OUR POLITICAL PANEL, JEWEL PARADE -- JEWEL PAIN, AND DEMOCRATIC STRATEGIST, AND OLIVIA SERVED AS A SPOKESPERSON FOR NIKKI HALEY'S PRESIDENTIAL CAMPAIGN. GREAT TO SEE YOU BOTH. OLIVIA, I WILL SHARE WITH YOU GIVEN THOSE NUMBERS WE ARE SEEING. DOES THAT SURPRISE YOU THAT SHE IS STILL GETTING THIS RELATIVELY BIG PORTION OF THE VOTE? >> NO IT DOES NOT SURPRISE ME, AND THIS IS TIMELY. LOOK, I THINK WE HAVE SEEN THIS IN STATE AFTER STATE. SHE CONTINUES TO GET 15, 17, 20, THIS WEEK IN INDIANA, 22% OF THE VOTE, AND I THINK IT IS BECAUSE VOTERS ARE SHOWING AGAIN AND AGAIN THAT THEY ARE DISSATISFIED WITH THE CHOICES THEY HAVE OF THE TOP OF THE TICKET, THAT THEY WERE LOOKING FOR AN ALTERNATIVE, AND I THINK MORE THAN ANYTHING THE LESSON HERE IS THAT THIS IS A QUESTION OF WHAT ARE JOE BIDEN AND WHAT ARE DONALD TRUMP GOING TO DO WITH THIS INFORMATION, RIGHT? WHAT DID THEY CARE ABOUT? WHAT ARE THEY TALKING ABOUT? AT THE END OF THE DAY, IT IS UP TO BOTH CANDIDATES TO EARN THE VOTE OF THOSE WHO SUPPORT HER. I THINK WHICHEVER CANDIDATE WORKS HARDER TO DO THAT WILL ULTIMATELY BE THE CANDIDATE THAT WINS IN NOVEMBER. >> JOAL, WE WERE JUST TALKING TO THE BIDEN CAMPAIGN ABOUT THE OUTREACH THEY ARE MAKING, BUT IS THAT REALISTIC THAT THOSE VOTERS COULD COME OVER TO JOE BIDEN, OR DO THEY STAY HOME? >> I THINK IT IS REALISTIC THAT A CERTAIN NUMBER OF THOSE VOTERS ARE VIABLE FOR PRESIDENT BIDEN. AS WE WERE TALKING, JUST LOOKING AT SOME OF THE SOUND THAT YOU WERE TEEING UP, WE WERE TALKING ABOUT THE IMPORTANCE OF COALITION BUILDING. THAT IS THE NAME OF THE GAME, WHO IS GOING TO BE ABLE TO PUT THEIR COALITION BACK TOGETHER BETTER. IS TRUMP ABLE TO PUT A 2016 LINK COALITION BACK TOGETHER THAT WAS WAITING FOR HIM, OR CAN JOE BIDEN DO A 2020 COALITION REDUX THAT WAS A WINNING COALITION FOR HIM. I THINK THE MATH SUGGESTS THAT JOE BIDEN WILL NEED A COUPLE OF THOSE VOTERS TO COME IN FROM THE NIKKI HALEY COLUMN, TO AT LEAST BE OPEN TO HIM. ALSO IMPORTANT, HOW MANY RESOURCES DO THE TRUMP CAMPAIGN USED TO DEFEND THOSE KINDS OF VOTERS THAT SHOULD BE EASILY FITTING IN THAT COALITION, AND THAT IS ANOTHER THING THAT THE CAMPAIGNS HAVE TO CONSIDER. WE MAKE >> MAYBE NOT WINNING THEM BUT PUTTING PRESSURE ON THE OTHER SIDE. >> FORCED THE TRUMP CAMPAIGN TO SPEND SOME RESOURCES. >> OLIVIA, THE BIG QUESTION IS WHETHER NIKKI HALEY IS GOING TO ENDORSE IN THIS RACE. I MEAN, SHE SAID WHEN SHE BOWED OUT OF COURSE THAT TRUMP HAVE TO EARN HER VOTE. HAS HE DONE ANYTHING TO EARN HER VOTE SO FAR? >> I WANT TO JUST BE CLEAR, I NO LONGER SPEAK FOR HER AND I NO LONGER WORK FOR HER. I THINK THE IRONY OF ALL OF THIS IS THAT NOT MUCH HAS CHANGED SINCE SHE MADE THOSE COMMENTS. I GET THE INTRIGUE WITH WHAT IS SHE GOING TO DO NEXT, WHO IS SHE GOING TO ENDORSE AND WHATNOT. ULTIMATELY THAT IS A DECISION THAT ONLY NIKKI HALEY CAN MAKE. I THINK RIGHT NOW SHE IS ENJOYING HER LIFE. HER HUSBAND WAS SERVING OVERSEAS AND IS NOW BACK. YOU KNOW, WE SHALL SEE. I THINK THE BIGGER QUESTION IS GOING BACK TO MY FIRST POINT, WHICH IS WHAT ARE TRUMP AND BIDEN GOING TO DO TO EARN HER VOTERS. IF WE KNOW ONE THING TO BE TRUE , THIS RACE IN NOVEMBER IS GOING TO BE A TOSSUP. IT IS GOING TO BE A NAILBITER. AND WHOMEVER WORKS TO EARN IT, THE NIKKI VOTER WILL BE THE ONE WHO WINS. I THINK THE QUESTION IS MORE ON WHAT ARE THEY GOING TO DO, NOT WHAT IS NIKKI GOING TO DO. >> ARE BATTLED GROUND STATE POLLING SHOWS A TIGHT RACE IN THESE BIG STATES. I DO WANT TO TALK A LITTLE BIT ABOUT SOME OF TRUMP'S LATEST COMMENTS. YOU KNOW, HE HAS BEEN IN THE COURTROOM A WEEK OF COURSE, BUT HE DOES HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO COME OUT AND SPEAK, AND HE WAS OFFERING CRITICISMS OF BIDEN AND HIS DECISION ON WEAPONS TO ISRAEL. I WANT TO PLAY A BIT OF SOUND FROM HIM AND GET YOUR THOUGHTS ON THE OTHER SIDE. >> WHAT BIDEN IS DOING WITH RESPECT TO ISRAEL IS DISGRACEFUL . IF ANY JEWISH PERSON VOTED FOR JOE BIDEN THEY SHOULD BE ASHAMED OF THEMSELVES. HE HAS TOTALLY ABANDONED ISRAEL , AND NOBODY CAN. >> JOEL , I WILL START WITH YOU. WHAT YOU MAKE OF THOSE COMMENTS? >> HOT POLITICAL TIP, YOU AND I SHOULD START HER OWN CONSULTING FIRM RIGHT NOW. DON'T BE SHAMING VOTERS. YOU SHOULD NOT BE SHAMING VOTERS. IF YOU WANT TO BRING SOMEONE IN YOUR COALITION, YOU HAVE TO DO MORE THAN WHAT THEY SHOULD DO BASED ON YOUR PROJECTION OF WHAT THEIR WORLDVIEW SHOULD BE. I THINK THE PRESIDENT IS OFFERING HIM UP BY THE WAY, A VISION OF THE WORLD THAT I WOULD IMAGINE THAT SOME NIKKI HALEY VOTERS AGREE WITH, THAT THEY MIGHT DISAGREE WITH WHAT PRESIDENT BIDEN DID OVER THE LAST FEW DAYS. I CAN TELL YOU ON BIDEN'S SIDE , HE DID A LOT OF WORK TO START TO MEND SOME FENCES WITHIN HIS PROGRESSIVE COALITION. A LOT OF PROGRESSIVE GROUPS WERE REALLY DISAPPOINTED WITH HOW PRESIDENT BIDEN HAS -- I THINK THEY FEEL LIKE HE HAS BEEN UNBALANCED IN HIS ADMINISTRATION OF THE SITUATION IN GAZA. I THINK THEY FEEL A LOT BETTER OVER THE LAST 24 TO 36 HOURS THAN THEY DID PREVIOUSLY BASED ON THE FACT THAT THE PRESIDENT IS ACTUALLY SHOWING SOME ABILITY TO USE SOME LEVERAGE TO PRESSURE NETANYAHU. >> THAT IS INTERESTING, BECAUSE AS YOU BOTH KNOW, EVERYWHERE THERE ARE PROTESTS EVERYWHERE, BUT ALSO I WAS COVERING PARIS LAST WEEK WHEN SHE WAS IN FLORIDA COVERING ABORTION, AND THERE WERE PROTESTS OUTSIDE THE EVENT. AS MUCH AS THE BIDEN CAMPAIGN WANTS TO TURN THE PAGE , THEY ARE FACING THESE PROTESTS OVER AND OVER AGAIN. OLIVIA, I AM CURIOUS WHAT YOU MAKE OF THE FORMER PRESIDENT'S COMMENTS. >> I THINK THIS IS A TYPICAL CASE OF TRUMP GETTING IN HIS OWN WAY AND BEING HIS OWN WORST ENEMY. I THINK THAT BIDEN'S RECENT ACTIONS TOWARDS ISRAEL , THE CRITICISM COULD BE WARRANTED. GALLOTTO VOTERS, NOT JUST REPUBLICAN BUT MODERATE MIDDLE- OF-THE-ROAD VOTERS WANT TO SEE AMERICA STAND WITH OUR ALLY ISRAEL. OBVIOUSLY, I DO NOT CONDONE HIS COMMENTS THERE. I THINK, YOU KNOW, BROADLY SPEAKING, THE TEMPERATURE IS WAY UP IN THIS COUNTRY AND WE'VE GOT TO TURN DOWN THIS DIVISIVE RHETORIC. IT IS NOT HELPFUL. TO YOUR POINT, VOTERS DON'T WANT TO BE TOLD WHAT TO THINK ABOUT HOW TO LIVE, HOW TO VOTE. THIS
