Joan of Arc Was Far From The Holy Figure She's Portrayed As

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments
Captions
She may be the most famous person to ever get burned at the stake, but do you really know everything there is to know about Joan of Arc? Joan of Arc, or la Pucelle as she preferred to be called, was one of the most iconic and brilliant female soldiers of all time. And there's a whole lot more to her rags to riches to rags story than you'd probably ever realize. Today, we're exploring the real story of Joan of Arc. But before we get started, be sure to subscribe to the Weird History channel. Oh, and one more thing. Leave a comment and let us know what famous historical women you would like to hear about. OK, it's time to travel back in time to the fantastically twisted time of Joan of Arc. You know you're an icon in the making when a world-famous wizard predicts your emergence onto the international stage. Merlin, the legendary wizard who counseled King Arthur, had predicted a maiden would come out of an ancient forest to rescue France. And Joan certainly delivered on that. And it wasn't just Merlin. Other prophecies were circulating at the time that a virgin from Lorraine, Joan's hometown in France, would come and save France from England. The prophetess Marie of Avignon claimed a woman in armor would save France. Was it a coincidence or was Joan of Arc, a woman who loves armor, destined to live out the life she did? Living out of prophecy from the Merlin is a pretty cool way to carve out a path for yourself. We all know Joan of Arc was burned at the stake by the English, but what if she wasn't? Some scholars theorize that it was at least possible that a substitute maiden could have been burned in Joan's place, with Joan assuming a new identity after the fact. After her death, it became a tradition for women to essentially cosplay as Joan and claim to be her. Scholars are pretty sure they were all fake, but one woman stood out, Claude des Armoises. In one version of this history, Claude was a real-life wife and mother who was supported by Joan of Arc's real-life brothers. They supposedly recognized her at first sight as their sister and Claude assumed that identity in order to gain their support. The story goes she didn't last long in the role of Joan, and eventually confessed her guilt. However in the alternate version of this tale, Claude is the identity the real Joan took on after the bait and switch at the stake. What a baller move, Joan. But unfortunately, Joan wasn't perfect. With all that warfare, she was bound to have a skeleton or two in her closet, like maybe the time when-- While Joan was devoutly religious and pious during her entire life, she did accidentally associate with some shady characters. One of Joan's most trusted and important soldiers was this guy, Gilles de Rais. Gilles, who was said to have been guilty of torture, rape, murdering hundreds of kids in a dungeon, and worshipping the devil, led Joan's troops and also aided Joan when she was injured at Orléans. Joan may have had a direct phone line to God, but the girl was a mess when it came to picking friends. I mean, the guy was also probably one of the first ever recorded serial killers. You can do better, Joan. Was Joan's ascension from poor maiden to friend of the royals a case of nepotism? Probably not, but some have said she had really intense kingly connections, so much so that she was actually a secret royal lovechild. Ah, scandal! One theory suggests Joan wasn't born a peasant girl, but she was really Charles the VII's illegitimate half-sister cousin, the child of his mother-- the famously licentious Queen Isabeau of Bavaria-- and her lover, his uncle, Louis, duke of Orléans. Talk about a tangled web of incest drama. It's like Game of Thrones with a better final season. Some say this was supposedly the reason Joan was able to pick out the dauphin from amongst a bunch of his courtiers upon meeting him for the first time. Sadly for conspiracy theorists, this probably wasn't true. These dramatic rumors do make for some seriously salacious 13th century tabloid fodder though. Can you imagine the headlines? When she hit puberty, Joan began to hear saints speaking to her. They told her to be pious and eventually to save France from the English. At the time, she was considered a saint receiving the word of God. But by today's standards, Joan was afflicted with something a lot less heavenly. Modern scientists have posthumously diagnosed Joan with conditions like schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or a specific kind of epilepsy to explain her hearing voices. Although considering no modern doctor ever got a chance to meet Joan, it's hard to say officially just what was going on in that head of hers. Aside from mental illness, some modern scholars have suggested that she suffered from bovine tuberculosis, postulating that the consumption of unpasteurized milk could have given Joan brain lesions. When all else fails, blame it on the bad milk. Joan definitely had all the right friends in all the right places, and there's likely a reason for that. Some say the powerful royal Duchess Yolande of Aragon, later Anjou, used Joan as a political and propaganda tool to push the future King Charles the VII's agenda. You see, Yolande was Charles' mother-in-law and a big advocate for him to take power over the English and his rival, the Duke of Burgundy. Perhaps, Yolande knew that the people would feel inspired by Joan's story of God telling her to save France from England. It's said that Yolande used Joan for propaganda to get her way or maybe the royals just liked Joan a whole lot. Maybe it's because she found ways to win them over, like the time she caught onto one of Charles' cheeky little royal pranks. It must have been boring being a member of the French royal family in 1429 because Charles, the heir to the throne, was certainly up to some weird behavior when Joan met him in the March of that year. Obeying the voices in her head, Joan schlepped all the way to his court in Chinon. But when she got there, someone else was sitting on his throne. As a bit of a prank perhaps, Charles had chosen to blend in with the crowd and had a friend take up residence in the royal chair. But there was no fooling Joan of Arc. Joan of smarts was able to pick Charles out of the crowd and address him directly, even as he was in his commoner disguise. Her powers of intuition were so strong that their attempted prank on what they thought was a naive country girl fell completely flat on its face. If you've been watching this and thinking, Joan of Arc sounds cool, she might be someone I'd like to be friends with, you might want to think again. Joan of Arc may have been a fierce warrior and vessel for heavenly messages, but she was kind of judgey. Truth be told, unless you were a devout Christian that fell directly in line with all of her beliefs, she probably wouldn't want to sit at the same lunch table as you. Despite her status as a young virginal female prophetess warrior, Joan wasn't too kind to other marginalized Christians, whom she deemed heretics. In a letter she dictated to a scribe, she condemned the Hussites, a group historians describe as proto-Protestants. She dubbed them followers of a disgraceful and unlawful superstition. Joan would rant about them saying, you persecute and plan to overthrow and destroy this faith which God Almighty, the Son, and the Holy Spirit have raised, founded, exalted, and enlightened a thousand ways through a thousand miracles. Joan went so far as to say that if she wasn't so busy fighting the English, she'd drop everything and fight them herself. In that same letter, Joan insulted Muslims and their faith. Joan, you need to calm down. Puberty is a rough time for all of us, but Joan of Arc had an especially tumultuous go of it. At the same time her friends' and peers' bodies were changing, Joan started hearing voices of some saints and an archangel. She was only 12 or 13. And you thought your middle school experience was humiliating. On top of dealing with normal puberty, Joan had to try and make sense of these new and strange feelings. Joan was literally receiving directives to lead an army to victory from the voices in her head. That's almost as confounding picking out your first deodorant. Did the rush of hormones cause her to hear voices? Well, it's noteworthy that the first thing they ever told her was that she shouldn't pursue a man, but she remain a single virgin instead. Clearly, her preteen hormones were not ready for that first kiss anytime soon. Most teens are moody, but Joan was, let's just say, a bit of a hurricane. Joan's teenage tendency toward anger revealed itself through her moral righteousness as she took it out on the adult male soldiers she was leading. If you've ever met a teenage hall monitor with a bone to pick, Joan would blow them out of the water. Some say that while leading her troops, she'd forbid any and all swearing or failure to attend mass. What a narc. Joan drove mistresses and prostitutes out of the camp with her sword. Once when a Scottish dude confessed to eating stolen meat, she attempted to slap him in retribution. Rather than just going by Joan, this warrior woman dubbed herself la Pucelle, best translated from French as the maid or the girl. In fact, she favored that nickname instead of her regular name, perhaps because of its religious connotations. She loved associations with purity, especially with regards to her own virginity and the Virgin Mary. Also Joan probably liked the moniker because it distinguished her from many of the other women hanging around soldiers, a.k.a. prostitutes, or maybe she just didn't really like the name Joan. Joan of Arc's mysterious path to martyrdom and sainthood is one filled with intrigue, conspiracies, and magical portents. From the voices in her head that may or may not have been the most prescient form of mental illness in history to Merlin's prediction of her coming, Joan of Arc is one of the most intriguing figures of the Middle Ages. So was it God? Was it magic? Was it mental illness or did the girl just want an excuse to boss a bunch of adult male soldiers around? Either way, it's clear that her place in history is cemented eternally for a reason. While the British may have burned her body at the stake when she refused to confess, her story is a candle that will burn on forever. What do you think of Joan of Arc? Let us know in the comments below. And while you're at it, check out some of these other videos from our Weird History.
Info
Channel: Weird History
Views: 754,325
Rating: 4.134593 out of 5
Keywords: Joan of Arc, Saint Joan of Arc, Holy Figure, French Saint, weird history, Martyr, French Martyr, Historical, French History, 100 Years War, Claude Des Armoises, Gilles Des Rais, Charles VII, Queen Isabeau of Bavaria, Queen Isabeau, Yolande of Aragon, La Pucelle, Stake, Burned at the Stake, France, French Women, Strong Women, Female Soldier, Today I learned, Alternate History Hub, Ranker, Ranker.com
Id: ceQ_cmzxeKE
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 10min 14sec (614 seconds)
Published: Sun Aug 18 2019
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.