Game Theory: Who Will Survive [CENSORED] Virus?
Video Statistics and Information
Channel: The Game Theorists
Views: 3,455,739
Rating: 4.3100634 out of 5
Keywords: mario, princess peach, witcher, the witcher, witcher 3, kirby, donkey kong, god of war, doctor mario, doctor mario trailer, kratos, eggman, doctor eggman, sonic, sonic the hedgehog, solid snake, metal gear solid, wario, link, zelda, breath of the wild, breath of the wild 2, luigi, pandemic, the science of pandemics, virus, facial hair, the science of facial hair.beards, mustache, beard, matpat beard, matpat shave, game theorists, game theory, gtlive
Id: eDhGnub97h4
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 17min 56sec (1076 seconds)
Published: Sat Mar 14 2020
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.
Welcome to /r/GameTheorists!
Make sure to read the rules and we also have a discord!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Please like this here and at the comment under the original video if you find it there. I’ve never asked for this, and asking for likes with this comment would probably get me a lot of trouble, but this video just contains some misleading info that might cost someone their lives.
Matt, I've always loved your work, and I've always had faith in your research, but this video is... misleading, to say the least.
Let's talk about three things.
That is, indeed, true. The virus does work that way, *BUT* , it is not that simple as "someone's in the front and I'm in the back so I'm safe". NOPE.
A plane is an enclosed environment where people make a ton of contact with each other. If the person at the front row is infected with unknown deadly virus X, the person at the back could easily be in grave danger because they are serviced by the same flight attendant. In fact, there's already reports of a flight attendant who unknowingly was infected serving over 20 rows of passengers, which means the 20 rows of passengers have all been exposed to the virus. So while in an ideal situation, yes, you won't get infected by the passenger in the front row if you sit at the back, the real world just doesn't operate like that.
I know you quoted that example from an expert, but planes (and cruise ships) are actually really high-risk locations, and it could mislead some of your viewers into a false sense of security when you just quote him like that.
Again, it is true that surgical masks are ineffective when compared to N95, but “completely” is a misleading word. You quoted the Center for Disease Control (which I assume is a US organization), that “a surgical mask does not provide the wearer with a reliable level of protection from inhaling smaller airborne particles and is not considered respiratory protection” and “leakage occurs around the edge of the mask when the user inhales”. While both of those statements are true, that is not the full story. Yes, a surgical mask can’t prevent you from breathing in the virus in air particles, but you know what it can protect you from? Droplets. If someone coughs near you, or if you’re coughing next to someone, a surgical mask largely reduces the possibility of you getting in contact with droplets or just coughing droplets onto people. In short, it at least stops you from easily coughing the virus out on other people through droplets like shooting a canon, that minor difference could actually save someone’s life.
In regions like Hong Kong and Taiwan (which both had some terrible experience with SARS), doctors actually recommend wearing the average population to wear surgical masks and educates people how to wear them properly immediately after the outbreak. Most of the population wears a mask when going out. And, though foreign experts doubt it makes any differences, the virus just simply spreads significantly slower than in Italy and the UK. The first case in Hong Kong was discovered on 23/1/2020, and up to 15/3/2020, there are 148 discovered cases, 4 deaths and 84 recovered, In Italy, the first case was discovered in 31/1/2020, and up to 15/3/2020, there are 24,747 cases. Yes, you can say that this is not a fair and scientific comparison, that there are so many different factors affecting the spread of the virus. But to say the least, you cannot ignore the high possibility that the practice of wearing surgical masks could have helped reduce the number of discovered cases.
In this time of crisis, people from China, Hong Kong, Taiwan and other Asia cities and countries are already under serious pressure when coming to wearing face masks in Western countries. Asians were reported to be beat up and called “virus” by British people in the UK, my parents actually got yelled at and demanded to take off their masks in NZ… I mean, we respect anyone’s beliefs that face masks are not that great of a protection, but saying that it is “completely” useless is not only wrong, but also adds to the pressure of discrimination. A lot of Asian people are now giving up something we believe is effective, and are well-informed on how to use properly, just because people will see us as “infected” or laugh about how we’re overreacting or stupid, because people they trust in, like you, told them “it’s *completely* ineffective”. I know you have no ill intentions, Matt, but I just want to tell you that face masks just might be *a bit more* effective than you said in the video. Anyway, I won’t tell anyone to wear it if they don’t believe in this, just not hate on someone that does so. BTW, don’t going stocking N95s in your garage, leave them to your doctors and nurses, they need those to save your life while protecting themselves.
I know you’re trying to comfort people and stop people from over-panicking Matt, but when talking about how the news medias are inflating the story, you’re kinda also misleading people here. Let’s talk about the statistics.
“Overall, China CDC found, 2.3% of confirmed cases died.(3.4% as of March 3)”, which makes the mortality rate lower than SARS (9.6%), with the fatality rate being 14.8% in people 80 or older. That is, indeed, the numbers China CDC gave out, but I really doubt those numbers when you base your entire argument on that one country only. You see… I didn’t mention the number of deaths caused by the virus in Italy, right? Well, if the statistics China gave out was accurate, with 24,747 confirmed cases, there should be around 487 deaths, but the number of deaths in Italy is actually 1,809, raising the fatality rate in that country to 7.3%. The numbers of confirmed cases in the world’s currently third most infected country, Iraq, is 13,938, and 724 of the cases are reported dead, which makes the fatality rate 5.2%. Now, I’m not saying that China’s lying or anything……butttttt, the statistics from every country is… inconsistent. Data was collected in different ways, some countries don’t even allow people with symptoms of infecting the virus to go check anymore, and some don’t count people who died before receiving medical assistance into the confirmed cases, so the numbers, in this case, are not that likely to be accurate.
But you know a number that we should be aware of tho? The number of confirmed cases around the globe. Up to this moment, there are more than 169,358 confirmed cases around the world, you know how many cases there were for SARS, the way more deadly virus that Matpat mentioned for reference, had? 8,096. SARS spread around the world for 10 months, and 8,096 people were infected. The virus that shall not be named had spread for only 4 months, and we have 169,358 cases already, that’s almost 21 times more than SARS. So even with a lower fatality rate, a lot more people had died, and will die, from this virus, not to mention suffer from lung problems even after they recovered.
I know, Matt, that you’re trying to be positive, and encourage people to stop panicking because of the virus. I also know, that writing all of this is possibly meaningless. Not a lot of people will read through this long comment, and those who do will probably hate on me for ruining the fun and making people more scared. But you know what? It’s better to be informed and extra cautious and live, than be blissful and misled and dead. I have nothing against a light-hearted video that lightens up people’s lives in a difficult situation, in fact, I saw the title and clicked in here with a smile, expecting to see a educating and funny video. Instead, this video left me uncomfortable. Hoping that by writing this long comment, that some of the people who watched this video, could at least be more alerted.
You’re a internet celebrity, Matt. A lot of teenagers and even adults look up to you, and they will trust you, without doing that much research themselves. But, in this case, you are Olaf, just like you said in you recent Frozen 2 theory. You put out a video that is half truth, and half misleading, and unlike “water has memory”, your video might create beliefs that cause people their health or life. I beg you, please be more cautious when doing research about a possibly deadly virus, find multiple resources, don’t brush off details that people should know.
And if anyone did in fact read this whole comment - the virus that shall not be named is dangerous, please be careful, Stay healthy.
This is not a theory.
Sincerely,
A game theorist
Yeah this is in pretty poor fucking taste. Lost some respect for you here, Matt.
The text on the front of the hoodie only says "But that's just a theory" in Japanese. I only noticed because if it said "Game Theory" it would have to use katakana and I didnt see any on the front.
This theory is in poor tastes to be honest. MatPat said before (plus it's obvious) that he will always do theories on current trends. Fidget spinners, Baby Yoda, Paul brothers, bad movies, Fortnite, Minecraft, Avengers, etc. It makes sense because those are what get searched and bring in ad revenue. But milking Coronavirus? Really MatPat? The whole world is on shut down and you are trying to get views over it? COVID-19 has NOTHING to do with either of your channels. At least demonetize it or donate all earnings to coronavirus research.
I have been watching GT for 6 years at this point and i'm just disappointed in the GT team. They had six people working on this video and this still ended up on Youtube. MatPat has done stupid things in the past but this is past the line. It would be so different if you made a video about the dangers of Covid-19 and how to stay safe. But this just seems like your trying to monetize peoples deaths. At the very least you should respond to the criticism.
How many of the people complaining of the video actually watched it? The vast majority of the video is talking about the virus itself, how it works, transmission, prevention, statistics medical professionals find the most noteworthy, etc. You can't sit here and call something tasteless without actually watching the damn thing..
MatPat made the right call to not only give us an entertaining video, but to also secretly tell us how to survive this new potential plague.
This is the worst theory since Sans is Ness. This one is in the worst taste possible. I like MatPat, but man is he dumb sometimes.