Australia's China Problem

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments

I agree with the conclusion of this video, we need to diversify our economy! That's why we should be investing in renewables, high speed broadband for the digital era, a trust fund for our amazing mineral wealth to be funded back into public projects, and so on. I can't wait for our level-headed government to adopt these reasonable policies :)

👍︎︎ 30 👤︎︎ u/country-blue 📅︎︎ Nov 20 2019 đź—«︎ replies

Australia = Big Hong Kong

👍︎︎ 62 👤︎︎ u/kettal 📅︎︎ Nov 20 2019 đź—«︎ replies

How good is outside economic reliance?

👍︎︎ 40 👤︎︎ u/timetotom 📅︎︎ Nov 19 2019 đź—«︎ replies

Start learning Mandarin. When China invade the US will pretend ANZUS doesn't exist.

👍︎︎ 43 👤︎︎ u/whatsthestatusjattus 📅︎︎ Nov 20 2019 đź—«︎ replies

Economic-f******-diversity.

It's not just good economic management but it also prevents foreign dependencies like this. If you can describe yourself as a "mining town" or a "farming town" or a "public service town" that's not a mark of pride. That's a problem. When the industry goes pear shaped for whatever reason, and no matter what industry you're talking about it will go pear shaped at some point, the entire town suffers. When the coal mine in a coal mining town closes down or even just slows down for whatever reason (or a farming town whenever there's a drought), the entire region is suddenly in big trouble. It might not be the only game in town, it might not even be the largest company in town but if a single industry - particularly an export industry vulnerable to foreign forces outside the local's control - contributes a significant portion of the town's economy when that slows down or stops for any reason or no reason in particular, that's bad. Scale that up to a goddamn continent and that's our current economic situation.

Australia has gotten very rich off what is objectively a very silly strategy. Economic diversity is the name of the game. When one industry booms you take the money from that, through taxes or other methods, and invest it into other local industries. For example, our high salaries mean our mines are highly automated. We're world leaders in automation in that regard. Sure would be nice if we had an incentive to take that technology and apply it to, for example, manufacturing - a couple grants for automation in that field would achieve that. Alternatively, we have lots of coal and lots of iron ore. Might be a good idea to give an incentive to companies to take those components and make steel instead of shipping them off individually - a simple tax on exported unprocessed ore would achieve that.

Our export economy is very reliant on on a very select set of industries and there's very little in the works to diversity that. There's some noise about increasing export of rare earth metals and lithium ore, but that's not so much diversification as it is increasing the amount of raw ore we ship offshore to be refined somewhere else, and every state wants to export hydrogen but that's about it. Unrefined ore, education and small hydrogen deals with Korea and Japan does not for a diverse export economy make.

👍︎︎ 7 👤︎︎ u/Uzziya-S 📅︎︎ Nov 20 2019 đź—«︎ replies

I"m just happy he pronounced Melbourne and Canberra unlike any other normal American like Melborn and Can-berra.

Is it true that China mocked Morrison? Seems counter-intuitive since they kinda support the Libs and their conservative stuff.

👍︎︎ 15 👤︎︎ u/Goonred 📅︎︎ Nov 20 2019 đź—«︎ replies

Hey it's Wendover! I wonder how many references to airplanes he can sneak into this one :)

👍︎︎ 13 👤︎︎ u/DoctorRimJob 📅︎︎ Nov 20 2019 đź—«︎ replies

Came here to post this. Really cool video. I knew education was a large export for us but wasn’t aware just how large. This may be a great way not only to boost the economy but also influence Chinese ideologies? Shame the government cut education spending.

👍︎︎ 9 👤︎︎ u/Samwall5 📅︎︎ Nov 20 2019 đź—«︎ replies

One of the craziest things about the coalition is that they've managed to convince everyday Australians that a budget surplus is everything while ignoring the biggest risk to the Australian economy: diversification.

We have a country that digs holes for China, builds overpriced apartments for China to buy, and trains Chinese citizens. That's. It.

Incredibly risky structure but they just keep banging on about how a surplus will save us.

👍︎︎ 3 👤︎︎ u/turing-complete 📅︎︎ Nov 20 2019 đź—«︎ replies
Captions
This video is made possible by Shopify—the platform behind Wendover and thousands of others’ e-commerce businesses. Among the many former British colonies that have grown into some of the world’s most developed countries, Australia is unique. Specifically, its economy has developed into something unlike that of any other, and a big player in the story of that economy is China… for better or worse. To understand China’s role in Australia and the problem this poses down under, one has to start in a very different place—the United States. If it were not for the US, Australia might not exist. Prior to the American Revolutionary War, Britain would primarily send their prisoners to the American colonies when sentenced to transportation. Once the colonies became the independent country of the United States, Britain needed to find a new place to put their convicts and for that, they chose what is now Sydney. The first fleet of convicts who arrived in Botany Bay were the origins of what is now the country of Australia, and they might not have made the long trek to there if not for the founding of the United States. Beyond just this, the history of Australia and the history of the US are eerily similar and interlinked. The two country’s foundings are offset from each other by 180 years, but parallel significantly. Australia is almost the exact same size as the contiguous United States, and even has similar dimensions to the US. Both nations include similarly diverse landscapes and climates, and both started in the east. They then each expanded west, taking over indigenous land, largely fueled by the discovery of gold and its subsequent mining. While the scale is obviously quite different, both nations were quite isolated by distance to the European world, although close to a number of other European colonies. Both nations started with their small British populations but then grew primarily through immigration from English-speaking countries, secondly through immigration from non English-speaking European countries, and thirdly through immigration from the rest of the world. They even share the same story in the founding of their capital cities—they each built a planned city in a central location between their two major population centers as to not favor one over the other. The similarities go on and on, but the point is that Australia and the US were largely dealt the same cards, but got vastly different results The US quickly developed into one of the most politically, economically, and socially powerfully countries on earth with a population well over 300 million. Australia, however, never grew into more than a small, regional power, with a small population of just 25 million. Now, Australia is no doubt a highly successful nation. It’s among the world’s most wealthy countries, the world’s most developed countries, it has one of the world’s lowest unemployment rates, one of the world’s lowest poverty rates, and is one of the highest scoring in the world happiness index. What the country is definitively not, though, is a superpower. While you can never forget the role of pure chance, given the similar starting position of both countries, the first thing one has to look at for a reason behind this is Australia’s geography. Despite their similar sizes, what differentiates Australia from the US is its desolation. About 35% of the landmass is considered desert, which generally cannot sustain large population centers. There are of course exceptions to this, most notably in the Middle East where huge cities such as Dubai, Doha, and Riyadh sprung up in the middle of deserts, but each of these largely developed as a result of oil booms in their respective countries. While the deserts of Australia do have oil deposits, none of these are at a similar scale to those of the Middle East, have not been significantly exploited, and, in addition, it’s largely Perth, on the western coast, that has emerged as a hub for oil, rather than an inland city. With limited arable land and a harsh climate, the inland of Australia just isn’t conducive to most human life. That results in a fairly striking population density map. Just five major population centers have emerged—Brisbane, Sydney, Melbourne, Adelaide, and Perth. Each of these is directly on the coast. The largest city in Australia that’s not directly on the coast, in fact, is Canberra—the capital—which has a population of just 400,000 and was a planned city, meaning its development cannot be a perfect indicator for the viability of inland life in Australia. Even then, it sits a mere 70 miles or 115 kilometers from the coast. If you’re talking about population centers that are significantly offset from the coast, in the outback, as it’s called, the largest would probably be Alice Springs—a northern territory town of just 24,000. This desolation can be further exemplified by the country’s road network. The primary highway linking the population centers of Brisbane, Sydney, Melbourne, and Adelaide to Perth is just a single, two-lane road, traversing the southern coast of the country. The same is the case for the Stuart highway which serves as the primary link from the south coast to the north coast up the center of the country—it too is just a two-lane road. What this all means is that much of Australia’s land just doesn’t lend itself to the development of large-scale human settlements, leaving it fairly empty. Australia’s vastness served a crucial role in developing it into one of the world’s wealthiest economies, though. The country is now the world’s largest exporter of minerals. It has huge amounts of coal, iron, lead, diamonds, gold, uranium, and more, mostly in its vast, open, outback. That means that the primary economic activity in Australia’s interior is mining, and with natural resources making up a majority of the country’s exports, it were these minerals that played a major part in growing Australia into a wealthy economy. They also cemented who Australia’s economic partners would be. Nearly 30% of Australia’s exports go to China, primarily driven by China’s significant demand for minerals. China, in fact, in the number one spot, buys more from Australia than the number two, three, and four countries combined—Japan, the US, and South Korea. Beyond just Chinese companies buying minerals from Australian mining companies to use in their factories, there are also sizable amounts of investment coming in from Chinese companies. Overall, it’s safe to say that the Australian mining sector would not be what it is without China, but Australia also relies on the billion people up north to act as customers for another crucial aspect of their economy—education. As strange as it might sound, universities, which in most cases are non-profits, form a sizable part of the Australian economy as Australian universities are some of the most successful in the world at attracting international students. The country is home to about 875,000 international students across all types of schools. Now, of course, remember, the entire population of Australia is only about 25 million. What that means is that, in the entire country, 1 out of every 28 people are international students. Of these international students, the highest proportion, by far, are Chinese, at 30%. That represents a quarter of a million Chinese students studying in Australia. On the flip side, that means that at any given time, 1 out of every 5,000 Chinese people are studying in Australia. Within universities, Chinese make up 10% of the average student body, however, considering they tend to cluster together, certain universities have far higher proportions. At UNSW the proportion is 23%, at the University of Sydney, it’s 24%, and numbers are similar at other hotspots. All in all, these Chinese students contribute more than about $10 billion a year to the Australian economy. There are also plenty of other sectors that play a part of China’s huge economic influence in Australia such as tourism, manufacturing, services, and more. Given how much the two economies are interlinked, therefore, as China has risen, so too has Australia. This link to the success of one of the biggest economic success stories ever has helped Australia earn an impressive record. It has gone 28 years, since 1991, without a recession. While the rest of world struggled through the Asian Financial crisis, the collapse of the dot-com bubble, and the Great Recession, Australia just kept on going with quarter after quarter after quarter of economic growth. By most measures, in modern history, no developed country has ever gone such a long period without a recession. But this all, of course, has a flip side. Such heavy economic reliance on a country that politically, Australia doesn’t always agree with is dangerous. An Australian-Chinese trade war would certainly cause a lot more damage down under than up north. At the same time, there are quite a few efforts by China to influence Australia. China has made plenty of attempts to tip politics in the country in their favor. As one, small example, Chinese Communist Party run or affiliated WeChat accounts, a popular social network in China, released posts critical and mocking of Australian politician and current prime minister Scott Morrison in the run-up to the May, 2019 Australian election. Beyond that, the Chinese government has been known to unofficially sponsor certain pro-China, ethnically-Chinese candidates for various Australian offices through a variety of methods. In media, China has been known to impart vast control over Chinese-language outlets in Australia and responds harshly to criticism through defamation lawsuits and more. On university campuses, the Chinese Communist Party is known to have vast amounts of influence, with accusations that the government has built spy networks within Australian universities to monitor Chinese students and their political views. In one instance, a Chinese student studying in Brisbane participated in a rally supporting the anti-Beijing protests in Hong Kong, and days later, the student's family back in China were visited by the authorities. There is a very clear but unspoken threat by China to Australia—if you make things difficult for us politically, we’ll make things difficult for you economically. How things typically work in China is that, in order to achieve business success, even when running a fully private company, one needs to be cosy with the Chinese Communist Party that runs the government. Therefore, even if a Chinese company is fully private, it knows that it needs to act in a way that aligns with China’s politics. Of course, while some of China’s tools of economic warfare are more traditional, like tariffs, a lot of its influence stems from the actions of the private sector. Any private Chinese company knows that, if Australia suddenly took a hard pro Hong Kong independence stance, for example, the CCP might not be happy about continued business with the country. Australia’s therefore in a tricky spot where it’s a western country socially and politically, but in many ways, an eastern country economically. As a result, taking a political stance against any actions by China comes at a much higher cost than that of a less economically linked country. Australia quite literally cannot afford to lose China. A trade-war with China on the scale of the US’ would devastate the Australian economy. China no doubt has done wonders for Australia, but the point is that too much reliance on any economy, no matter how strong that economy may be, is a risky strategy. When that strong economy is run by a foreign government that can adjust its flows in an instant, that’s even riskier. According to one study run by the Reserve Bank of Australia, if China’s GDP contracted by just 5%, that would result in Australia’s GDP falling by 2.5%. That is a clear-cut case of economic reliance, so, if Australia wants to keep up its unprecedented period of economic growth irregardless of how China’s doing, diversification is crucial. I know a lot of Wendover Productions viewers are the type of people who already run or would like to run their own businesses, and one of the fastest growing industries out there is, of course, e-commerce. Traditionally, starting any sort of business that involves selling physical goods required a ton of work to build out the infrastructure necessary to do that, there was a huge barrier to entry, but nowadays, it’s super simple, especially thanks to platforms like Shopify. Shopify now powers more than a million online businesses meaning you’ve almost certainly bought something through Shopify, but on the merchant side, it makes setting up, marketing, running, and managing your business easy. I, of course, know since it’s what I’ve used for ages to run my Wendover Productions merch store. Shopify has all the tools you need, fantastic customer service, and really works as a partner to independent business owners, so if you want to start or move your business to Shopify, head over to shopify.com/Wendover and try it for free for 14 days, no credit card required.
Info
Channel: Wendover Productions
Views: 4,763,354
Rating: 4.7969341 out of 5
Keywords: australia, china, geopolitics, politics, relations, international relations, ir, geography, international, world, economics, economy, econ, money, trade, wendover productions, wendover, explainer, video essay
Id: 5SDUm1bx7Zc
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 12min 10sec (730 seconds)
Published: Tue Nov 19 2019
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.