Why Did Edward Hopper Paint This Clown?

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments
Captions
Two and a half years ago, I made  a video on Jan Matejko’s Stanczyk.   That video blew up and, in two weeks, we  went from 30,000 to 100,000 subscribers.   I’ll make a proper video to celebrate, but  for now, welcome to all the new comers,   thank you so much for subscribing  and I’m glad you enjoy these videos. But what if I told you there’s a sadder  clown than Jan Matejko’s Stanczyk? Sad clowns make for extremely strong and  melancholic imagery. I won’t go into the whole   sad clown paradox, so you can watch the video  I made on Stanczyk if you want to know more. What I do want to show you is a modern  sad clown, made about a century ago.   It was made by a 32 year old artist who would  only get his first gallery show a decade   later, at the age of 42. This artist would later  make a name for himself painting cityscapes,   buildings and, what I personally love him  for, lonely figures. These lonely figures are   presented in very intimate scenes. The subjects  don’t know we’re watching them, they feel alone,   they’re often lost in thought, our disconnection  from them reinforces their own disconnection,   their isolation, their alienation. We’re voyeurs,  we shouldn’t be seeing this person in this state,   they’re vulnerable, yet that’s what  pulls our gazes towards these paintings. The artist behind these paintings is  Edward Hopper and, if you don’t know him,   you probably know his 1942 Nighthawks. We are  still voyeurs, people are still isolated and   alienated, we are still as disconnected to the  subjects as they are disconnected from themselves. Hopper was already quite  successful when he made Nighthawks,   9 years prior to its completion,  he had a retrospective at the MoMa. But let’s go back to 1914. At a time when Edward  Hopper wasn’t commercially successful. He just   came back from a trip to Paris, ambitiously  looking for a breakthrough in America. As his biographer Gail Levin put it, Soir Bleu was  one of his boldest projects, his magnum opus. It   was his biggest artwork to date, being 183 by  91 cm. Levin would even say that Soir Bleu was   “for Hopper’s development what seven years before,  Les Demoiselles d’Avignon had been for Picasso”. It’s a French scene, with a French title.  Soir Bleu or, Blue Evening. The title already   prefigures the painting’s melancholy. The French  scene is, obviously, set in a café. You can see   a bourgeois couple, a woman standing, a man  from the military with fancy épaulettes,   a bohemian artist and this man  which, in a sketch made by Hopper,   was labelled a mackerel, or a pimp, meaning  that the lady could be a sex-worker. All of these characters have their own costumes  and styles, their own signifiers and codes,   yet none of them interact with each other. It’s  like they all showed up to a party, they dressed   up, yet no one is talking to eachother. Hopper is  portraying loneliness, not by showing physically   lonely people, but by showing disconnected  people, people who are alienated from each other. But, more crucially, there’s the main character,   the man that makes, to me, this painting  even more striking than Hopper’s Nighthawks,   the sad clown. Dressed in blinding white,  from the costume to the makeup he’s wearing,   the clown grabs our attention. He’s  smoking a cigarette melancholically,   looking in front of him with an empty stare,  similar to the one Matejko would portrait in 1862. The story doesn’t end there. The painting  gains additional meaning and somberness through   Levin’s interpretation. She says that there’s  a chance Hopper identifies with the clown as an   artist. Like a clown, an artist can often perform  for an audience. A clown, without an audience,   can struggle with a sense of purpose. An artist,  without an audience, can live a similar struggle. This painting was an important one for Hopper, not  only because it was his biggest to date, not only   because it was his Demoiselles d’Avignon, not  only because he was personally connected to it,   but because this, he had hoped,  would be his breakthrough.   No longer will he be a clown without a spectator. When his Soir Bleu was exhibited  alongside another of his paintings,   New York Corner, critics answered: ““Edward Hopper  is not quite successful with his ‘Soir Bleu’,   a group of hardened Parisian absinthe drinkers,  but he is entirely so with his ‘New York Corner’;   and again, “in Edward Hopper’s ‘New  York Corner’, there is a completeness   of expression that is scarcely discoverable  in his ambitious fantasy, ‘Soir Bleu’.”” His ambitious fantasy was a failure. The  clown was not able to make his audience laugh.   Hopper would roll up the canvas, store it, and  never revisited it. It would never be shown during   his life time. He would never paint a French  scene again. He would never paint a clown again. What I find fascinating about this  painting is that it’s made by one of   the most successful American artists, and  I’d argue that it triumphs, in many ways,   his Nighthawks, yet it’s not widely recognized,  at least not as much as I think it should be. I’d argue that Edward Hopper made himself  vulnerable by creating his ambitious   and personal Soir Bleu, and that  its shutting down must have been   quite disheartening considering that  it made him nearly disown the work. However, and I’m sure you can agree on  this, it’s possible that Hopper simply   hadn’t found his audience yet because, to  many people today, this work is strikingly   incisive in its melancholic personification of  alienation. I’d like to know what you think.   Hopper is mostly known for Nighthawks,  yet, do you prefer it to Soir Bleu;   Do you find them both equally  enjoyable; or do you prefer Soir Bleu? I’m really interested in seeing if there’s  a consensus here on any of those answers.
Info
Channel: The Canvas
Views: 1,193,286
Rating: undefined out of 5
Keywords: documentary, painting, analysis, meaning, explained, Art, History, Art History, The Canvas, Canvas, Artist, edward Hopper, edward hopper paintings, edward hopper documentary, soir bleu painting, soir bleu (detail) 1914 edward hopper, edward hopper soir bleu print, edward hopper soir bleu 1914, edward hopper soir bleu, soir bleu edward hopper
Id: osJPtHSUniA
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 6min 39sec (399 seconds)
Published: Sun Aug 07 2022
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.