We could build this huge Space Station in 6 months
Video Statistics and Information
Channel: Gateway Spaceport LLC
Views: 970,787
Rating: undefined out of 5
Keywords: spacex, elon musk, musk, nasa, spacestation, iss, esa, jaxa, star trek, star wars, virgin galactic, apollo, armstrong, aldrin, international space station, space shuttle, starship, super heavy, falcon, dragon, orbital reef, axiom, oac, orbital assembly, gateway spaceport, voyager station, gateway foundation, john blincow, offworld industries, mars, moon, jupiter
Id: s-XlWP4Q4Ds
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 28min 11sec (1691 seconds)
Published: Sat Apr 30 2022
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.
As much as I want to see this happen and wish them the best of luck, this presentation has no substance. A great concept, but nothing more and not presented in much detail other than a machine that builds a rotating ring using pre fabricated panels. And theoretical build times.
This would require dozens of high power welders operating simultaneously. Getting that kind of power on earth requires industrial scale architecture, nothing is mentioned beyond using a solar farm for that in the video. Would be curious to know if someone more knowledge could paint a picture about how big a farm exactly? How will the energy be transmitted to the machine? Can't simply be built on top of it.
And what about the elevator shafts? Have stress simulations been done? Simply welding panels together to form a ring without an inner support structure is going to have all sorts of hot spots for stress once pressurized, and I'd think the connecting sections to the elevators would need way more complicated structural support than the machines shown could create. Not to mention the forces involved once rotating - again no support structure is shown. Those welded panels better be HELLA STRONG.
Not saying these problems can't be solved but at least show some test hardware or something.
This strikes me as an advertisement, and this guy is a patent troll. There's really no indication he spent time figuring out the engineering complexities on how to make it work, just the high level concepts. Yet with those patents he can threaten to sue.
I hate it when people use big words like revolutionary or powerful etc without explaining why. Give us some of the science and engineering behind it. I also hate that one of his first words is patented. It feels like heβs trying to put some substance behind empty patent to later get some free money in the future.
I heard heβs setting up a monorail in Springfield.
Jokes aside, all this dude was able to provide was wildly ambitious promises, cool looking sci-fi concept art, and sparkling talk about βbig dreamsβ that raised a lot of red flags for me.
Nothing against him, and he might be genuine, but keep an eye out if he starts asking for money.
This dude had a company that was (and is still trying) doing exacly this (stations with artificial gravity), then one day he dissapeared from the company, and now he says he is starting a new one. His ideas are really interesting, but he dosn't give me much confident to run a company
Yeah, not sure what it is but his style is so cringe. I have seen his previous videos and they are all in this cringe style. Maybe itβs his voice. Maybe itβs how he talks in the first person all the time. He seems like he would be a good cult leader. For some reason, my snake oil alarm bells go off like crazy with this guy.
The only reason for a large rotating torus is long-term habitation for hundreds of people. For a traveler making a pit-stop on the way to the Moon or Mars while Starship refuels, you can survive zero-G for a few days or weeks just fine. You'll be in zero-G all the way to Mars in any event, and in 1/26th gravity on the Moon, so a short time at higher equivalent acceleration seems wasted effort.
What's the economic point of long-term habitation in space, if not for science and industry? For both of those you need a working environment in microgravity. I didn't see that described at all in that giant rotating torus, only the hab area. Sure, a handful of rich people might enjoy the Hilton LEO, but the rest of us would rather go to Hawai'i. ;-)
This is as beneficial as reading a science fiction novel.
Yeah they won't be flying this basically ever. Plus orbital infrastructure is only profitable if you have microgravity anyways