Triumph Bonneville GEARBOX FAILURES! The truth about TRIUMPH!
Video Statistics and Information
Channel: stuart fillingham
Views: 72,957
Rating: 4.7664123 out of 5
Keywords: triumph, t120, bonneville, motorcycle, motorbike, gearbox failure, common faults, gearbox issues, faulty gearbox, stuck in gear, triumph customer service, broken down, speed twin, street twin, scrambler, bobber, thruxton, street cup
Id: rlnsYYypEps
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 34min 0sec (2040 seconds)
Published: Tue Dec 08 2020
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.
Stuart Fillingham really does not like Triumph. He is a staunch champion of the Royal Enfield brand. All bikes can have problems, the Triumph one mentioned is no worst than any other bike out there, most reviewers rate the build quality of the modern Triumph brand second to non.
Go ahead and purchase the bike you want (2020 T100 in your case) and enjoy.
Yeah, I've got a recommendation for you:
Don't let a click-bait youtube video form YOUR opinion.
I know a TON of people on Bonnies, and have never heard anything about the over exaggerated claims in this dude's video.
Also, first 4 min of the video is the guy asking for patreon, but then also chirping about the people who don't give him money for a 2nd month? "I'm sorry, and you are?" ...
This guy has been making videos with his T100 and/or T120 for years. I thought they were pretty good when I was first looking into my T120 and reviewing accessories. However, his videos are long and drawn out with just enough “controversy” to people watching and interacting.
He’s working, not making truly honest informed videos, even if there are nuggets of good info. Haven’t watched his videos for a while after noticing that. Even more evident now seeing the first few minutes talking about his Patreon and donations.
I've never heard of this problem - I have a 2015 T100 and it's been a dream from a maintenance perspective. If you look around the internet for problems with something, you WILL find people with problems, and it will seem like it's common because everyone with said problem will flock to the OP.
Buy the bike if you like it and keep a budget for repairs/maintenance like you should be doing anyway.
I have a 2017 T100 and my gearbox just failed a couple of weeks ago. The bike has less than 3000 miles on it. Fortunately, I was on a straight road and approaching a light that was still 200 yards away when I tried to gear down and could not get below 3rd. Had I been trying to exit the highway at speed and coming onto a sharp ramp it could have been a bigger problem. People can say all bikes have problems, and not be wrong, but the gear box failing with hardly any miles is dangerous and ridiculous.
I can’t make heads or tails of this situation and I’ve been following it for a while. There are definitely reports of gearbox problems with LC T120s on Triumph forums, but not as many as I would expect for a series-wide manufacturing error. After all “LC Bonneville” includes all the different variants as well, and if you check the 2019 service bulletin with the new shifting mechanism, it was built into all the Bonneville variants. So if that is the root of the issue, then it did/does affect quite a few bikes.
Is it an isolated thing or is it a common problem? The single most vocal person on this question is Fillingham himself. Is that because he’s got his finger on the pulse? Or is he truly hunting ghosts? His negative interactions with Triumph (flakiness and caginess, if his descriptions are true) could be construed as suspect, but they could just not want to deal with him (he doesn’t seem to be the easiest person to get along with, tbh). If I recall correctly, they did offer to check his bike for him, which they would only do if they were checking for something specific, I think.
While he’s undeniably on team Royal Enfield now, he was quite smitten with his T120 in a LOT of his early videos. I don’t think he’s got an axe to grind, but rather is disillusioned by the whole situation, even though he’s not personally affected. I can appreciate the sentiment even if it is a bit self-aggrandizing.
To be honest, the whole thing leaves a sour taste in my mouth. I bought a 2019 Speedmaster with a 4-year warranty, and while I can’t find any reports of LC Speedmaster gearbox problems, it’s still going to be in the back of my mind when I’m out riding. That’s not a good feeling and Triumph should be taking steps to ensure its customers don’t feel that way.
Triumph could come out and categorically deny any potential problems with the gearbox, but they don’t. Is it because they’re afraid of the financial ramifications (recall), or because there’s truly nothing sinister going on? Whatever the case, it’s clear that Triumph could do more to be transparent here.
It's a problem with the liquid cooled Bonnie's. My shifter has been destroyed internally twice. Once because of a minor lateral bump on something, once because I don't know how. In one case I limped it to the dealer in 4th gear, the other time it needed to be carried off on a truck.
So Stuart is right that Triumph doesn't have a lasting fix and they haven't provided evidence that they've done a gearbox redesign.
However, anecdotal evidence isn't enough to determine frequency of occurrence.
I have a 2017 T100, almost at 30,000 kms with no issues at all! When it goes back on the road in the spring it will get new tyres, brake pads and front rotor. For the 1st 2 years I used it for 100 km round trip to work and back 5 days a week, now I'm retired and still ride long distances weekly (not in snow and cold, Canada).
Werid I had a 15 t100 and that had a crisp transmission. Same with my street triple.