Overview of Third-Party Movements: ETA, Miyota, Seiko & More (A Comprehensive Guide 2021)
Video Statistics and Information
Channel: Teddy Baldassarre
Views: 358,076
Rating: 4.9414501 out of 5
Keywords: teddy baldassarre, teddy watch, hodinkee, talking watches, watch movements, vintage watches, caliber, teddy baldassarre guide, watch education, watch guide, watch movement guide, guide to third party movements, eta, sellita, miyota, stp, eta 2824, eta 2892, sellita sw200, sellita sw300, miyota 8215, valjoux 7750, miyota 9015, watch collector, watch collecting guide, best watches under 1000, best watches under 2000, best watches under 3000, best affordable watches, seiko
Id: V_jwDLhT9hQ
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 28min 47sec (1727 seconds)
Published: Wed Mar 24 2021
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.
I don't always agree with the guy, but he's putting himself out there and making content which is more than I can say for myself. Good stuff.
T/Bulbasaur
Teddy is a good reviewer, and someone who I respect a fair bit. Watches are subjective, and while he and I donβt always align, heβs cool and makes his videos fun and accessible.
For me, a watch with a third-party movement isnβt a bad thing at all. Lots of companies make them, and if a small, boutique company wants to make watches but doesnβt want to invest the time and money in developing the movement, I can see why this is a good option.
Even my newest Timex Marlin that I bought myself for Christmas has a Miyota movement. The counterweight is very jerky, and I hate that about it, but it keeps good time and runs well. So I canβt hate on it too much.
Fair play from me.
This is a great video.
Researching movements can be hard and dense and when I first became interested in watches wasn't something I was remotely familiar with. On forums and here, people have very strong feelings and judgments about movements but it's kind of all over the place. One person says the NH35 is "terrible" while another calls it a "workhorse and reliable." One person swears by a sellita movement and the next person swears off the same movement. It can be confusing. It's also confusing to know how much weight should I be putting into the movement at all? I recall seeing a watch I really liked, read a lot of reviews and comments about it and one person called the Miyota 8000 series movement a deal breaker and that really stuck with me - 1 person out of hundreds of comments; most people didn't seem to mind it but for him/her, it was so aggravating they would never even consider watch.
Not only that, but I will venture a guess that most people discussing movements on a forum are not watchmakers and have limited first hand practical knowledge of any movement. People with strong opinions probably had an anecdotal bad experience which biased their view of the movement in general.
Overall, the video is very informative and digestible.
T E D D Y B
This is a wonderful video put together by a famous watch reviewer on YouTube. I respect the fact that he took the time to put all this together which by no means, if youβve ever done video production, is an easy task.
I would expect the research time you put into this took about a month and then script and post editing was an additional week, minimum.
I always wondered about third-party movements different references, their advantages and disadvantages, possibly who else uses them and why? Many of those questions are answered in this roughly 30 minute video.
The movement not being "in-house" was actually a selling point when I was buying my IWC Mark XVIII because I wanted something reliable and cheap to service. There are tons of great third party movements and shouldn't be scoffed at by watch guys
I gotta give Ted credit, he's putting out good stuff and has his own shop up and running, so he is doing his thing. His videos are getting a bit addicting, I kinda look for what's next from him in terms of moving from Seiko 5 to Vacheron in his reviews and great content. Hats off.