Nuclear Waste Disposal in USA - Dr. James Conca @ TEAC11

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments
Captions
Pass this hunk of salt around so you can see it  when you get it. Look up at a light and see the   square bubbles. They are crystallographically  trapped 270 million year old seawater,   and we have extracted DNA and other  biologicals from it. The DNA is viable.   So this is Permian Park kind of neat stuff.  This is hailing the bacteria, no big deal,   but it's a testament to how good this rock is in  isolating anything in it from the environment. I'll send it around now. Jim do you want to take  it? All right. But hold it up to the light and   see the little crystallographically trapped  270 million year old seawater. All right. So   with that in mind, there are four categories of  nuclear waste in the United States. Different   than Europe and a lot of the other parts of  the world because we have so much bomb waste. This is spent nuclear fuel. You all recognize  that. That's what we worry about most. There's   the Hanford tank waste. The high level waste. High  level waste is only bomb waste. All right. It's   only comes from the first two processing steps in  making a bomb. So we happen to have a lot of that.   What's interesting is that most  of that is no longer high level. 00;01;17;15 - 00;01;41;23 Unknown  Then we have transuranic waste. The other type  of bomb waste. It's stuff that comes from the   following three process steps during the making  of a bomb. So it's just where it comes from,   not what it is. Then we have a lot of low level  waste, which is mainly dirt and other junk,   but does not require deep geologic  disposal. So the first three:   spent nuclear fuel, high level  waste and transuranic waste require deep geologic disposal by law. You must  use deep geologic disposal. And so when you talk   about high level waste in two ways, again, they're  both bomb waste. So when you when you have a   weapons reactor not in power reactor, because it  won't work with a power reactor, but a weapons   reactor like we had up in Hanford, like  Russia and and a few others around the world. You take your spent fuel out of the reactor.  Within six months, it cannot stay in the reactor   more than six months. So you start breeding in  neutron poisons like plutonium-240 and Pu-242   that you cannot separate from Pu-239, so your  bomb will be a dud and you do not want your bomb   to be a dud. If you ever try to use a nuclear  weapon and it's a dud: Bad! It's good to know. So, so anyway, so when you take it out  of the weapons reactor within six months   and you subject it to, this processing in order  to remove the plutonium and recover and purify   uranium as well. This is it. So the first two  steps, this is where the high level waste goes   into those tanks. 177 single shell tanks in  Hanford, most of them are high level waste. Some are TRU waste. So over the next three steps,  it goes into the transuranic waste, which is about   20 of these and about 155 of those. Okay. Now, the  funny thing, that’s happened in the last 50 years   is that the high level waste is no longer high  level. We took out about half of the cesium and   strontium from those tanks in the eighties, and  the others have been through 1 to 2 decay lives. 00;03;25;02 - 00;03;59;16 Unknown  So there is nothing in the high level waste tanks  that is high level anymore at Hanford! None. Not   a drop. Nothing exceeds 1 curie per liter. And  the greater the Class C cut off is 4 curve per   liter for cesium-137 and seven curie per liter for  strontium-90. It's the fission products that make   everything hot. Okay. So that being said, just  about the day I was born, 1957, National Academy   of Sciences came out with a very nice report  that the Atomic Energy Commission had asked them. They said, you know, Shippingport  is just starting up. We made a lot   of bomb waste. We got a lot of this  junk it is weird. Not much of it,   but it's weird. What should we do with it?  Now, Academy of Sciences said, put it in,   salt. The nice thing about salt is that  it creeps closed. It's a hard rock. I'm sorry. It's a soft rock. But if I threw  that at your head, it would hurt. Okay,   but it's a soft rock geologically, so  under pressure, under 150 bar pressure   of a half mile depth, it will creep closed.  So that unit will not sustain an opening,   a fracture of a room. And you cut a room.  It will not sustain an opening period. It will collapse. It's nature's great  trash compactor. It's kind of funny and   it works well. Also, the mining industry, which  started in Carlsbad, German miners in the 1880s,   mining for potassium chloride, they knew exactly  how to cut with WIPP. In fact DOE came they’ve   been kicked out of places, you know, as usual  and Carlsbad comes up way we we'll take it. And we said, what? And they said, Oh, yeah, we  know how to do this piece cake. And it was a   piece of cake. It is a piece of cake from a mining  perspective. So it takes a billion years for water   to move an inch in this rock. That's an upper  limit. Those are the kind of measurements I do. But then things changed. Things changed  in the in the seventies. EPA was formed.   They established these four categories.  First for nuclear waste. And then we did   this weird thing. You know, again, we we're  not going to reprocess or anything. And so   someone had the ear of Jim Schlesinger,  who was the first secretary of energy,   his great economist, who was not a  scientist but was a great economist. And they said, we might change our minds.  We want to get this back out in 50 years   if we change our minds. Well, of course  you stop someone on the street and say   we're going to get this back. I want to spend  billions of dollars putting it a half mile   below the earth in something that's going  to last a million years or so or more. But we might change your mind and get it back  out. So the would say: Are you nuts? You don't   throw it away. So that's that's the big issue.  But we decided we're going to throw it away and   we want to get it back out. So it's kind of  like a revolving door at a department store   which is incompatible with  permanent geologic disposal. So salts out. The salt is permanent,  creeps closed relatively fast.   So we're going to go to a hard rock because the  hard rock will stay open for 50 years. So that's   why we went to hard rock. Not a good idea.  However TRU waste is kind of a weird thing   that nobody knew what it was about. It silently  kept on and went into the salt as it should be. Since then, a lot has happened. Again,   most of the high level waste is not  high level waste, which is interesting.   So that begs the question: Why are we vitrified  it? If it is not high level waste? Expensive.   Make it expensive, right? Great job  program. Excellent jobs program. I   love it. But the state requires they decided  glass was best because France does glass. And of course we must we must echo France, even  though it's not warranted. So, 1957, onward to   the seventies. Now, there were 17 candidate sites  for a high level nuclear fuel repository. They   were supposed to be two sites, two repositories,  because, of course, when you split the risk,   the risk goes down right. This is the best  statisticians in Congress came up with that. So was that political risk? Maybe between two they  could get one. Yes. Right. So they said, okay,   east, we're going to do the east and north of the  south and west. So we'll split it and everyone   will be happy. All right. Well, there's not  enough waste to justify two repositories anyway.   And of course, when you split it and you put it  in the wrong rock, your risk goes up quite a bit. So then by 1982, the Nuclear Waste  Policy Act came into being and they   had narrowed the sites to three. Right?  And one was Yucca mountain, Nevada. You   all recognize that? Hanford, Washington,  where I'm at. And Deaf Smith County, Texas.   Okay. Who was speaker of the House in 1987? Yes.  Got Jim Wright from Texas. Well, Texas was out. Who was House Majority Leader Tom Foley. Tom  Foley. I like him in general. But yeah. From   Hanford, Washington. So there was this new junior  just elected named Harry Reid and they said,   Harry, it's yours. I'm not kidding.  I'm not kidding. That was the decision,   period. Right now, they kind of missed it.  Missed the point because Harry Reid was a boxer. Did you know that? Reid was a professional  boxer? And then he headed the Nevada Gaming   Commission and drove out the mobs. So he  was not a lightweight. He was tough. And   of course, he became majority leader,  ironically. He basically told Obama,   if you want my help in the Senate,  you're going to kill Yucca Mountain. And that's okay. Because Yucca Mountain  is a lousy place and I'll get into why.   So 2009, Yucca mountain was halted. He created  the Blue Ribbon Commission to take its place. A   great commission. I don't want to go into  that in detail, but if anyone does later,   let me know. ...went on to develop a  new strategy. $1,000,000,000 later. Yeah. Now, never say because it's not true.  Never say that we wasted $12 billion on   Yucca Mountain because only 12, actually.  So $12 billion? No, because 10 billion of   that good information that we'll use anywhere.  Corrosion studies, transportation, I mean, all   of it is transferable except about 2 billion over  30 years, which is it's not even one B-1 bomber. So that’s nothing to get excited about.  Yucca mountain is a highly fractured   oxidizing variably saturated dual porosity  hydrologic system that sits on the edge   of the Las Vegas Shear Zone. Now, which of  those words inspires confidence? Okay. It's   not. It's a terrible rock and it's a horrible  rock. In fact, the rock does nothing for you. There's absolutely nothing for you. And  the whole point of deep geologic disposal   is to pick a rock that does everything for  you. All you have to do is meet department   transportation requirements to get it there.  This doesn't do that. So we had to come up   with seven engineered barriers to re-engineer  around the fact that we picked the wrong rock. That was one of my... I'm a barrier guy. Really   proud of the work we did. Wonderful  stuff. Great science, wrong rock.   So, unknown to most, transuranic waste (bomb  waste) continued on into the salt as planned.   And WIPP has been a brilliant success. If you want  to talk more later about the little leak they had, it wasn’t really a leak. No one was  contaminated. The equivalent of 100   smoke detectors was released into a community that  has 10,000 smoke detectors all the time. Not a big   deal. Now, WIPP is built and designed for  everything. Remember that? It was built and   designed for everything. It was only permitted  later for transuranic waste. So it was just   a political, bureaucratic decision that said  only defense transuranic waste could go there. 1992, 16 square miles was set aside by the  Land Withdrawal Act, and when WIPP is done,   it'll be immediately, maybe one or two square  miles, plenty of room for everything else. Now,   this is what it looks like. There are four  shafts into the underground air intake air   exit. Salt handling and waste handling. Then  there are horizontal corridors called drifts. This is mining technology and each one  of these is a panel. And each panel has   seven rooms. Each room is a football field  in length. Right. It's only 30 feet wide and   13 feet high to accommodate the packages.  Right now we are almost full. The original   mission of WIPP is almost done. It is ten years  ahead of schedule and $1,000,000,000 under budget. Now tell me what federal program is ahead of  schedule and under budget by even a dollar?   None. Okay. Because it's the right rock. The  right rock. I'm a geologist. It's all about   the rock. Right? You choose the right rocks.  Easy, simple, cheap. You use the wrong rock.   Very bad takes forever. And you never have  enough money. Now, why is this rock there? Well, that rock. I'm sending  around, everyone has seen it, right?   Almost everyone. Okay. So during the Permian  time, the western edge of the proto-Pacific   was off the coast of Yukon, Arizona. There was  a little a bunch of fingers of the Pacific that   came up into south east New Mexico, west  Texas. And because of tectonic reasons,   it kept getting shut off and then it would  evaporate and then tectonics would flow again. It flowed very slow, blah, blah, blah. 30 million  years of depositing salt, 6000 feet of salt,   of which the top 2000 like that, that it  passed aroun. It is pure. It's wonderful.   You can actually make Marguerita salt out of it.  It's actually I did that for the BRC. General   Scowcroft thought that was the funniest thing  you'd ever seen. Alison McFarland was not pleased. So I wasn't serious enough. If you look into the  light and you see little square bubbles in there,   there was a fluid inclusions,  crystallographically trapped,   270 million year old seawater.  And from that we have isolated   DNA. It's viable. Bacterial husks. Cellulosics  from degraded cell walls, things like that.   It's only halophellic bacteria because as  this thing was evaporating, it became briny. And the only thing they can live in brine  are brine shrimp and halophellic bacteria.   So nothing much happened in the last 200  million years to halophellic bacteria,   they're still the same. But this is a testament  to how isolating this rock is. Biomolecules   don't last that long. Generally they are  thermallitically split or degraded because   the rocks get buried deep enough, so they go  up above 41 degrees C and the reason you don't   want to go above 41 degrees C if you have a fever,  everyone gets really excited when you get to 105   because at 109 your DNA begins to unwind and  your enzymes begin to unwind at 109 degrees Fahrenheit. So they really like that when  you get close to that. So same thing here.   So this rock was never buried deep enough to  go above that temperature. Radiolitically,   this is pure salt. There's no NORM in it.  There's no naturally occurring radioactive   material. There's no uranium, thorium or anything  else in it. So there's nothing to degrade this   over time, and that's why it's still there. So, again, an excellent testament to  the isolating powers of this rock,   because it's geologically a soft rock. No  blasting no one ever gets hurt. And you just   have these these Marriot continuous miners with  tungsten carbide, tungsten carbide fingers. We   just drill this out. It goes up the salt mining  shaft, gets dumped outside the repository.   Here's what it looks like. That is pure salt. The lighting's weird, it looks dark, but  it's pure salt. And that's Wendell Weart.   You remember Wendell? The father of  WIPP. This began operation in 1999.   But it started taking high activity waste. Now  this is waste. It's up to 23 curie per liter   and there is no high level waste left  at Hanford over one Curie per liter. So this is hot. Okay. And the 13 to 23 core four  liter cutoff was to handle the reprocessed waste,   right? That's why we chose that number. And  this is a 72 B cask. It's just what you would   haul any high level waste or spent fuel bundle  or a military grade material in. So the hot   stuff gets moved around in this highly shielded  transport cask down into the underground and then   gets robotically plunged into a robotically  cut 14 foot deep borehole and then it gets   robotically shoved in there and then gets plugged  with a four foot metal wrapped cement plug. It's really quite neat. And when you do that  and all the walls with the hot waste, then you   go back in and fill the rest of the waste with  the it's not low level, it's transuranic waste.   So is it mainly plutonium, americium, uranium,  neptunium and stuff like that. It's the actinides.   And so this is what it looks like. So if I took you down there and I used to take  people down there, Jim Clyburn came down there,   bunch of others, and they’re standing and looking  at it and go: God, this is great! Why aren't we   doing this for everything? And I said, Well,  that's your job. So anyway, so this guy here   is standing in front of the easily shielded alpha  and beta, and the hot stuff is behind him and he's   standing there getting 1 tenth of the dose that  we're all getting here right now. 1/10 the dose. And he's standing in front of nuclear waste,  including relatively high activity. And that's   because, of course, it's a half mile below  the earth. So most of the cosmic rays are   shielded out. It's easy to shield this  stuff. There's no NORM. It's all pure   salt. So there's no uranium around him.  So, yeah, he's getting a tenth we are. In fact, the biggest dose he's getting  is from the potato chips for lunch.   So again, when working for 23 years,  but 150,000 cubic meters, about 700,000,   55 gallon drum equivalents, all you  have to do is put the waste into a   container that fits in the shipping  container. You have to meet department   transportation requirements. That's it,  right? You canister doesn't have to last. At Yucca Mountain the canister has to last. So we  got super copper canisters and have to have the   vitrified the waste because the rock does nothing  for you. 22 storage sites are clean. Rocky Flats   is in WIPP. It's just kind of funny. One minor   released and it was quite minor and DOE  freaked out, and the state freaked out. We had a plan to clean it up in three months  at $30 million and it took three years and   $500 million. Unnecessary. But that's okay.  It's right. So here's what it looks like.   EPA requires one engineer barrier. They  don't believe the earth is good enough,   so they require one engineer barrier.  So we came up with powdered MgO. It absorbs Plutonium, it absorbs CO2, absorbs  water. Really great stuff. It forms a soil   cement. So this is in powdered bags, these  side bags we we got rid of before we actually   started to dispose of anything. But when the  ceiling comes down and the walls come in,   it breaks those sacs on top and it falls  around it. It's actually kind of neat. It's cheap. Very cheap. So this is what happens  in 10 to 15 years. It is closing and it's back to   what it was before, well over a thousand years.  But it's amazing. So if you know anything about   the properties, you know, flow properties,  diffusion coefficient, hydraulic connectivity,   these are very low numbers. Okay. Very hard  to measure actually, when they're this low. In fact, the diffusion coefficient is pretty much the crystalline diffusion coefficient of hydrogen.   Now it's the properties of the rock that matter.  It's all about the rock. So porosity and it's   mainly these unconnected square fluid inclusions.  The pH is ideal. It's the minimum transport for   plutonium and water. The EH is perfect. It's  the most reducing groundwater in America. And you want it reducing because then nothing  moves. Plutonium doesn't move, uranium doesn't   move. Technicium doesn't move. It doesn't move.  If it's reducing. Now, the thermal conductivity   is about five times that of the tough, so  you can load it up with p a lot higher than   any else. And this annealing, this creep closure  works at least the sixth part of the temperature. So it works better the hotter the waste.   Again, you cannot manufacture a rock this  good. So what you're given is essentially   a 200 million year design life. Performance  life. At Yucca Mountain we had to struggle for   10,000 years and then they raised it to 100,000  years and we said: We can't do that. It's not   going to happen. But yeah, so you’re just given it  by this rock. 200 million years, so you don't need   engineered barriers, although we have to have one  by law, you know, the waste form is irrelevant. It doesn't matter whether it's glass grout junk,   as long as the department of transportation  requirements require less than 1% free   liquid. So as long as it's dry, it's good.  It doesn't matter what it is. You don't need   the cladding to persist, only the canister to  persist. No adverse temperature effects and the   fluid inclusion migration is irrelevant. Although  you will hear from the Germans that it matters. It's because their salt sucks. It's all about the  salt. Excuse me. That was not called for. So the   way to solve this is a 16 square mile set aside  by the Land Withdrawal Act and WIPP, still, again,   ten years ahead of schedule. Boom. Under budget.  And there's the footprint of the original mission.   Now, if you want to put,  say, high level waste there.   And put spent fuel in interim storage  nearby, this is what your footprint is. Then if you decide to put spent  nuclear fuel in there and you are   supplying 40% of our energy needs by the  year 2100, this is all the space you need.   Now, I should say the 16 square mile set  aside was just an arbitrary number. There's   10,000 square miles of this unit. All  right? 10,000 square miles. We only need 16. Interm storage is great. The canisters work for  about 160 years at least. And if something happens   to a canister you put into a new canister. This  is not rocket science. And again, you're going   to use this waste hopefully in something fast  reactors. You're going to recycle whatever Curio   is a perfect segway for this. And then there's  Deep Borehole. You've heard of Deep borehole. Took me a while to come around, but I like  it. And one reason I like it is it gets all   the congressional delegations really upset.  Why do you think that? You can do it in any   state. So suddenly, you know, New York can  have it. But if you're if you're three miles,   you know, four or five kilometers into the crust,  there is no mechanism to get it back out unless   it goes through, you know, plate tectonics,  cycling, and that's millions of miles of year. So there's no way to get this back out. So it  doesn't matter where you put it the country. As   long as you avoid a magma chamber. Okay. So  every state that has nuclear waste can have   its own deep borehole disposal. And they  have been crying for decades that no, no,   this is going to leave the state  it needs to go someplace else. So this got them upset, but  it is brilliant. However, the   waste package matters because if you're  going to put down whole fuel assemblies,   that's a tough drill for five kilometers. But  it's not if it's a foot. So this is really where   advanced reactor waste is perfect because you  can pick your shape of your container, right? You can put molten-salt waste. You can  put fast reactor waste. Doesn't matter.   You can make your packages tall and thin  and then you don't spend so much drilling   a five kilometer hole. Now you've heard of  Deep Isolation out of Berkeley. They put a   little curve thing in here. They put a  plumber's trap. This great, I love it. It’s a plumber’s trap, which  is brilliant. Because again,   the only way out is the borehole. But of course,  if you see a ball decently for five kilometers,   there's no way they could get it out. But, you  know, this is great. So things will never get out   of that hole. We have talking drill rigs now, you  know that? I should have a picture of one here. We have walkie drill rigs. When you're finished  fracking and drilling, it picks itself up and   it walks to the next site. I love it from  science fiction, but it's horrible from an   environmental standpoint because it's too  easy to get oil and gas out of the ground. Now, in each one of these walking drill rigs  can go, you know, 18,000 feet. It can have 12   stringers off a single well. It's just too easy to  get fossil fuel out of the ground now. And so to   say, we're going to stop that without something to  take its place like nuclear... is insane. I mean,   it's like putting a, you know, two bowls in  front of children, one's apples and one's candy. And you say, I leave the room now,  but you can only eat the apples.   Nope, its too easy to get fossil fuel out of the  ground. This is a deep boreholes test hole that   they did work perfectly. But notice it's tall  and thin. Perfect for the cesium capsules up   at Hanford or for this. But WIPP’s good for  everything. So that's another thing so it   mean I don't want to spend you know more about  this than I do but I mean the pebble's great. You know, the new ANEEL fuel, great. It's much  smaller than a traditional fuel bundle. But yeah,   anything you can get to a tall and thin  shape is ideal for borehole disposal. Again,   you just have to satisfy Department  of Transportation requirements,   either the 72B cask or the TRU pack two or  three cask. And you just get it down there. It doesn't matter how you get  it there. As long as you meet   Department of Transportation requirements.  So there's only a few possible outcomes for   our nuclear waste disposal program. I hate to  say it because only a couple of things. One,   TRU it continues on into WIPP which is  permitted in licensed for transuranic   waste so all the TRU waste we have goes there,  but WIPP is only permitted for defense waste. If you start making TRU from Curio  you have to change the permit.   How difficult is that? Yeah, it  could be a mess. But you know,   I like to say when human law comes up against  natural law, who wins? Okay, now, otherwise we   would outlaw volcanoes and tornadoes and stuff. So  defense waste, so transuraniuc high level waste. If you redefine high level waste that’s  transuranic and low level as it actually is,   we're working on that. Finally get some headway.  Then transuranic goes to WIPP. The high level   waste goes to one of the four repositories  of America. We have for low level waste.   Commercial waste, you put an interim  storage so we get our act together. Then you either burn it in new reactors,  Curio’s right there. And then that waste   goes either into WIPP if you expand WIPP’s  mission, or it goes to the deep borehole,   or you can have a second salt repository.  Because we have a lot of salt.   A lot of salt. A lot of good salt.  Better than the rest of the world. Don't put it in domal salt because domes are  moving. All right? Domes of die and appear.   They have vertical spline fractures  that leak meteoric water into them.   Any questions? What's holding up the WIPP  from taking SNF. Oh, the state of New Mexico   of course. Repeat the question for the internet.  What is holding up WIPP from expanding to take   all waste like it was originally designed?  It's the state of New Mexico and interests   like the oil industry and things like  that. Oh it will destroy the oil industry. No it won’t. It has nothing to do with  it. Will not interfere at all. Oil is   at 10 to 18000 feet and WIPP is at  2000 feet. There really is no real   problem. But every time we talk  about expanding WIPP’s mission,   everyone in New Mexico cries, oh, you lied  to us. It's like, no, we didn't lie to you. You changed it. We didn't. It was supposed  to be everything. It was supposed to be all   nuclear waste of any type. WIPP was  designed and built for that. And you   said just just transuranic. How hard would  it be to get a Alberta politician through   The WIPP? Like if they were going to actually  get someone, oh, yeah. Oh, you're a foreigner. 45 days, you know, the usual. I'm a retired senior reactor operator. What you think about sub-seabed disposal? Sub-seabed is the best way to do it. You don't even have to drill a well. You just go to a trench. Which are thousands of feet deep. There's thousands of feet of muck, highly  reducing, highly soft, very impermeable to   water. And you just drop your your package down.  We even designed it so that we could use the the   penetrators we developed for Vietnam. It just  goes down and it's gone forever. Dragged into   the into the mantle. Brilliant. Perfect.  Cheap. Easy... but international waters. That's it. Just say that it's  over. So revaluation 2025. Yeah.   What the seabed. Yeah, but it's the same thing.  International waters. Oh, you'll have an Exxon   Valdez guy that will run into the Philippines.  Yeah, but it is the best. The best method,   without question. What are the interests of  foreign nations or what we represent with that. Oh, you can't well blow them  out of the water? I dunno.   But you know, you really can't. But they won't.  They won't. See, the thing is, we have more waste   than anyone else, right? I'm not sure what  Russia does with some of theirs, but. They   put it in the Arctic. Yeah, yeah. They kind of  do that. No, most nations don't have enough. I mean, there's there's France, there's Japan,  there's us, there’s Russia and then maybe England.   But all the rest don't have enough reactors to  really warrant a lot of activity. So there are   14 nations that have got together to form the  Aureus Group in Europe that only have a few   reactors. And they said, okay, we're going to  work on one repository for the 14 countries and   that's as close as you're going to get to that  kind of thing, which is actually quite good. First thing that came to mind is... Is  the opposition to using WIPP for spent   nuclear fuel more so on a local level,  not in my backyard kind of deal? Oh God,   no. The farther away you are from it, the more  you hate it. So everyone around WIPP loves it.   And because WIPP has been so successful,  it's, you know, this is a mining community. Mining is dangerous. People die. No one's  ever died at WIPP because DOE doesn’t try   make money on it. Okay. So you have good air. If  you're a miner you know what that means. 425,000   cubic feet per minute of airflow. It's like,   my God, in the commercial mines,  you don't get anywhere near that. Sometimes it's the air quality is terrible and  you have to ride with the back of the ceiling   right over your head. You're driving like this.  Whereas WIPP is beautiful. You mentioned that   as long as you're using the DoT approved  transportation, it'd be all right. I've   heard in the past that that's one of the big  showstoppers of a central... It’s transportation, I know we've never had a problem with  transportation. We have put this stuff   over millions and millions of miles  of road. Never had a problem. People   even know what's going through  it. Usually. So transportation   isn't a problem. Okay. Oh, yes. Okay, perfect.  So, yeah, perfect safety record. Just it's   just. But is there a way, like politically,  if you start by going across state lines? Yes. See, the thing is, the feds control RAD.  The feds control radiological material. The   states have no say in it at all. Okay. That's  why the first shipment WIPP was all RAD and no   RECRA The states have control over RECRA,  which is, you know, toxic chemicals like   lead and mercury and dioxin and stuff. They  have to issue a permit to get on the road. So DOE’s always worried about, you know, making  the states mad because they'll pull their permit.   But in the end, if anyone has a:  What about the waste? You say:   Piece of cake. We know what to do with it.   We're already doing it with a lot of waste. We  know where to put it. We know how much it costs. We're just not allowed to do it.   And one more short, short one here. Just wondering  if you could briefly comments on the geology of   our Oncolo facility at our Canadian Sites’s  earth Yeah, they're all good sites. I mean,   they're deep enough in the crust and they're  in tight, you know, granitic material. And   it's not as good as salt, but, you know, it  doesn't have to be perfect kind of thing. Yeah, and they're good and there's not a lot  of waste. Absolutely. So and spent fuel is easy   because spent fuel is not leaky. Not like the junk  in the tanks at Hanford. You leak a lot of crap.   I'm surprised they're not all leaking. The  design life of those tanks was 15 years. I mean, what were you going to do with a million  gallons of high level waste after 15 years? So   yeah, I'm just surprised. And all, almost  all the ones leaking are transatlantic waste   tanks. The not the high level things. I'm just  saying. All right. Thank you. Thank you, Jim.
Info
Channel: gordonmcdowell
Views: 5,965
Rating: undefined out of 5
Keywords: Nuclear Waste Disposal, Dr. James Conca, WIPP, The WIPP, salt, geological repository, TEAC11
Id: B6no0FmPk84
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 35min 0sec (2100 seconds)
Published: Mon Nov 28 2022
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.