Noah in the Bible and the Qur'an | Jack Miles

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments
Captions
- Hello there. Do you like stories? I certainly do. And if you do too, I invite you to join me as we visit one of the world's most famous stories, the story of a great flood (thunder rumbling) and of the man who survived it. A mean named Noah. Flood stories appear in a great many ancient myths. We're going to look at the story as told in two sacred scriptures that you may have heard of. One is the Bible, the other is the Qur'an. Jews and Christians who read the Bible don't always know that there is a Noah story in the Qur'an. Muslims, who know the Noah story from the Qur'an sometimes forget that a Noah story is also told in the Bible. Which version is correct? Muslims favor the Qur'an's version, Jews and Christians favor the Bible's version but why fight about it? Both versions are interesting and it's fun to compare them. So let's get started. Both stories begin with God. And God is angry. In the Bible, God is angry that the human race, which he himself created, has grown wicked. In the Qur'an, God is angry that Noah's nation is worshiping false gods instead of him. In both the Bible and the Qur'an, God intends to send an annihilating flood against the humans who have so offended him. But here the differences begin. In the Bible, Noah never says a word. All he does is silently build the boat that the world now calls Noah's ark. In the Qur'an, Noah does a great deal of talking. He warns his people that if they continue their idolatrous ways, God will surely destroy them. But if they repent and beginning worshiping Him alone, He will not only spare them but also enrich them with many blessing. In the Qur'an, just as in the Bible, Noah builds an ark. But in the Qur'an, unlike the Bible, people mock him for doing so. Noah tells them in effect, he who laughs last laughs best. As noted already, the biblical Noah never speaks at all. In the Bible, no one but Noah is warned of the coming flood and no one survives except Noah, his family and the animals he has brought onboard the ark two by two. In the Qur'an, by contrast, a few of Noah's people do heed his warning and they are saved, along with Noah's family and with again, the animals. In the Qur'an alone, Noah has a recalcitrant son who refuses to come onboard. If there's to be a flood, he says he'll just go up on a high mountain and wait it out. Noah makes one plaintiff plea to God on his son's behalf but God is unmoved. Noah's true family is now to be those who worship the one true God. Noah's son must die with the other unbelievers in God's punishing flood. In the Bible, Noah has three sons and all make it onboard the ark. Later, the three do get in trouble with God but that's another story entirely. In the Bible, after the flood waters recede, God gives Noah the rainbow as the sign that he will never again destroy the whole world by flood. In the Qur'an, although the flood has not destroyed the whole world, Noah beseeches God to make the world safe for his believers by making it uninhabitable for unbelievers. I think we can agree that in both versions of Noah's story, God is a fearsome figure. I myself find him more fearsome in the biblical version because the biblical flood comes without warning and without the option of repentance. Yet in the Qur'an, God's main and endlessly repeated threat is not flood but eternal punishment in the flames of hell. In the biblical Noah story, hell is never mentioned. And here, friends, our brief double visit to the Bible and the Qur'an must end. If you've enjoyed it, let me assure you that there's more where this came from. Adam and Eve, Abraham, Moses, Joseph, even Jesus and Mary. They all appear in both scriptures. The similarities are clear and the differences, well, the differences are fascinating. If you'd like to do more comparative reading, I invite you to read my little book, "God in the Qur'an." One of the great blessings of our life here in the United States is that we are all free to read each other's scriptures. And some of us are happily starting to do exactly that. Thank you. I am Jack Miles for the Emir Stein Center. And if you liked this video, hey, please share it with a friend or two. (lively music) - [Narrator] If you wanna see more content like this, make sure to like, share, subscribe and hit the bell notification so you don't miss any new videos.
Info
Channel: Emir-Stein Center
Views: 611,963
Rating: undefined out of 5
Keywords: Prophet Noah, Noah, Bible, Qur'an, Torah, Judaism, Christianity, Islam, flood story, Noah's flood, Noah's Ark, Biblical flood, mount ararat, creationism, creation, God, Genesis
Id: 4vq5no4hxcw
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 6min 12sec (372 seconds)
Published: Fri Sep 18 2020
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.