before I forget since this is in aid of legislation perhaps it will still not register in regard to the duplicate of copies perhaps I do not know if we have any law requiring requiring the government's the agencies to duplicates always perhaps this could be one of our revised legislation wherein we should require all government agencies that they must always have copies of all the transactions so that there will be no reason that we can reconnect back drop included in the English that provision that each in the polkas arm again it is part of the internal control system of an agency a good internal control system to Tory pain but it is not right that's a problem there is no law keeping them your honor if you were to have a strong and a good internal control system you should yes no I'm not someone else we could know this could be one of those that we can this is this is in aid of legislation additionally I know all government agencies internal control unit you who records everything okay there is a transaction the question mr. chairman Commissioner that is why in the preparation of the Watchers there are under the original pipe cap oh yeah thank you very much well you know Costner is I read that it is the first is a certified local government province or province in the country in the bottom Ironmen governor yes or the first stop the bottom ISO certified auto cavite certified very early on their front line tax collection what does it mean mum to be ISO certified is always say an internationally recognised seal of quality management thought well the government has transparency in its transactions right that's correct it's to be transparent and predictable so if I win all sorta who wants to come to the capital and say Nobunaga's Toshio adding Paris tobacco in 2020 the problem should be able to furnish me that in the Buddha yes Kodama this way I'm surprised that we will do our best and everything and tell your accountant treasurer as stated by the Kenya educators madam treasurer or accountant in five copies of the Bowser who - which officers are just five copies distributed in terminal control or dukkha you are the provincial accountant so you do not keep a copy of a every transaction departure good morning sir actually if there are extra copies we have to keep it sir but then as I have said during the previous hearings young is on I mean three years and requirement per week and this post-classical we have to accumulate everything lapa kahramana and one thing Mercier very personal capital you known [Music] mm [Music] [Music] you keep one treasurer you keep a copy all right okay check your microphone I think there are not five copies that are being maintained the only two one is for accounting to be applicable and the original your honor so you're saying that in your office the provincial treasurer's office you don't have these particulars of all the money that you spent [Music] - which is being maintained by the cashier and also we also have the same record book for disbursement your honor it's just lanessa but yet I will keep track of operations available and everything how can you certify as to the availability of funds as to appropriation if you do not have supporting documents or a complete data bank morning your honor in our office we have registry of the transactions remember we've been asking you to bring us a copy of those and you said you will give us copies where are they treasurer you Mayan Tristram can you give us copies we requested you over and over again but you have not submitted any it's a cash book new mission a bit we will look at the color that should be the boy I think that there is a submission I'm not just socially or because that's what is maintained by the cashier your honor not asking here too deep - violation of the law a document should be kept where it is supposed to be kept you cannot remove down from the place where it is supposed to be kept but you can produce copies purchase requests to produce order to voters the funds requested by this particular resolution assign juniper Coulomb payroll with regard to the vulture submitted to us supposed to be this should certified capelin you keep the original 22 sacks of documents we can already start asking questions and other items in years 2011 and then don't break down this pact with the 2010 322 million 2011 204 million 2012 235 million and then 2016 460 million cumulative squ item Aslam like continuing so 322 million and receipts in 2010 is 300 million now if you look at the second column appropriation [Music] [Music] [Music] [Music] [Music] this is startling because in 2000 in a liquid audit report because that should come out in the audit report of Jack sitting unliquidated amounts observations and unliquidated advances which include the 18 point six million about the eighteen point six million so mum when you submit to us currently give the specifics popular market diamond parenting Posada pero clearly angle Meccano you a nurse Makana unliquidated and then total con apparently the polythene order we can do it but in every column total power we can see how much is unused in terms of seven one seven one funds McCann in Augustus but cannon Whomper u n-- Augustus pero hindi mallika D okay one during the last feeding the records it will appear that page 45 of our minutes the governor said I'm absolutely shocked kaylynn investigan car got Belinda marring Manny re imagine it was a teen that was the statement of the governor about the field jabs fake field jabs to Tirana Secretariat we know Mom what action have you taken regarding this shocking revelations of the was not using fake fill jobs documents and fairness we actually issued immediately after the August 31 hearing a memo constituting an investigation and they are due to report are shortly were they given a time frame rental apartment I recall I think it was sixty days maybe finished a piece of this visit nobody has been placed and preventive suspension at this point nothing was recommended yet by the group that was constituted to investigate and nobody has been charged nothing yet there are no findings as yet because if I were the chief executive and we fill jobs which is the repository of all these documents state that in transactions of my department of my province the buck used spurious documents then I would for prudence please everybody there on preventive suspension I would formally charged them with serious misconduct gross neglect of duty or dishonesty because of this one statement of Pilsner nagamma document Perrin wampa they are placed away from their respective positions because if they still continue to have be the provincial accountant Sheila perineum provincial budget official seal Iranian provincial treasurer and mr. or miss amber than comparing Priscilla in fact Noreen minami-san borough was your fidelity band renewed again I renewed sorry I think so but it was surrendered that I've nowhere no the governor heard testimony from mr. Castro initially this would deny that he was she was the one who actually received the money in the paper or in the name of mr. Castro Purusha Abdul Hamid and then the provincial treasurer admitted here also nanami re a human Reza Treasury official and an astronomic check a in the name of other persons and that's in Burma by odd in fact that we have also testimony here that in the case of this precast concrete nika's advance along September in a buyer in Langdon Ferrari or when one said Ben Mullen and una pelea para develop our in disciplinary action Samuel a parameter Oh Magoo gula Paul Tapatio that these things are happening they recommended to you for cash advances in denominator gamma John Casablancas according to their testimony casita Babu Babu young design were imposing last evening gentleman yes the Box secretary opinion no mum peace upon June a team back reconstituted Bachna as of June 22 yatta so dot if I own so Hindi Naren human adapting ba and Aldo dial until an unqualified nough people eaten talaga phonemic reliable Nong Elan okay in the window finally we asked you last time madam to assure an accountant of your transactions for multi cubs in 2010 have you checked miss battalion Tripoli testimony ahi tuna deli see mr. Mike Chua in 2010 and 2000-2010 so we ask you to check all your previous purchases for multi Cubs but however with the co because we had already submitted the virtues of the commission and purchase multi Cubs in this about December 2010 or January 2011 nothing about your man Jenna pasa central off but you say say hint or not in your honor we are not asking you to give us the original self bowel hair employee-owned you keep the originals when they give us capiche para pannonica to Aleppo NATO Guggenheim in young Magan on paramagnets matagalpa marathon now Putin now overtaken a boy who'd been overtaken by this at the resolution we would want to wind up already this one we will do that your honor may we also ask what happened to our mr. Mike - I know I'm not certain he left several weeks ago for Singapore because they failed to serve the subpoena did you not inform him mum that this committee is interested to hear his side because his name was mentioned here mr. Perron Dean among Camilla goes up recently so Hindi column con la bolita and I you subpoena me did you ask the Bureau of Immigration to serve the subpoena we have a letter that we submitted or rather sent to Commissioner Jaime Miranti for him to serve the invitation for mr. monk Chua and miss Aaron Mendoza to attend for them to attend the committee hearing today so maybe not do we have a center tip from the Bureau of Immigration representing Commissioner Amy Moore NT up to this moment will about our young not hang up now letter of response from Commissioner Moore ent but we will follow up immediately mr. speaker mr. chairman in the absence of mr. Markkula again and we cannot locate him I move that we issue a show cause order to the gentleman to explain his absence in our hearings so mr. chair including including likewise mr. chair thank you for the reminder the motion is for the both of them mark - I'm Eileen Mendoza any objection there being none a show cause order will be issued for mr. moxuan and miss Erin Mendoza for them to appear to this committee and in addition included in the Shockers order this is a subpoena after lease office orders and subpoena for them to explain why they should not be cited for contempt opinion I would just like to make some comments and questions regarding the the document submitted to this community by Khoa mentioned earlier by Congress so this is the report on the share from the tobacco excise tax of the locust not the provincial government we just like to note that even though the year 2000 is not covered in the resolution fired by congressman as he now and myself but I would just like to observe that in the case of the year 2000 we have quite a bit of information from Goa so for example appropriated 3 million but it should also be noted that there was continuing appropriations first of all could could we clarify just a term continuing appropriations not subject to budget II which is used in this document may be the kurakin clarify that your honor and so far as I know continual continuing appropriation will be used in the next year's insuring years considering that the excise tax involves trust funds your honor and that they can be used for the succeeding years I know it is here the year 2000 an amount of 155 million was appropriated of which 100.3 million was obligated or used and fifty four point six million was unused or unliquidated but here we have a breakdown of the total utilization of the fans so for example so that 100 the 100 million 100 point 3 million was used for the following concrete pavement improvement of provincial roads thirty-eight point thirty six point eight million damaged canal lining system asari drainage canal lining system five million construction of reinforced concrete deck girder bridges five point nine point six million small water impounding dam projects five point nine million the bet revetment for flood control slope protection river control six point six million construction of communal irrigation system and so on four point eight million project improvements of others such as parks daycare centers etc thirty point 1 million box culverts eight hundred six thousand and dikes 488 me Towson okay so at the progeny in a pen beside to you for a start young person a team Makita Milazzo at micelle office provincial government no but maybe this question first is Toccoa subsequently after the year 2000 from from 2001 onwards at least in your report well on upon Battaglia regarding the even the most basic information about how these amounts will use very proven on you're older Michael Dippolito sorry partner no data store appropriations probably the auditor who prepared this got the data in the information from the annual audit reports prepared by the previous auditors and she was not able to verify okay mr. chair even if you know we've heard the response from the governor that we no longer have the original document in their possession perform from 2010 per bar is it possible I mean even just initially for for this committee to be provided with the Chairman we will comply to the best of our ability in fact to excise tax not even God knows not the government quality organic a basic name for my show anybody mana projector and Anatomy Tonito reports that this committee now you want matter for one hundred forty seven point four million that inappropriate and that more detailed documents and information on how the P I need funds [Music] nah no that a delicacy you mean upon get nappy I me program well on a manga no non 2015 na da lawanda er a una una eunsuh provincial UPI me was a generic brand name that I beanie guy semana request none Matsuzaka at our genome Atlanteans official later or nagging specificness capital expressed bug social services manga i but ii babirusa youth services and 4-h club and so on Akala wah nam 2014 that bob ocasion irr or you mem only be me guy in an NPA Atkin Ella and Kathryn on cinnamon and DBM nom 2015 the mock submit muna language Taha nama projects DBM he approved nila at Solomon illa llah Bassam para hindi na automatic release cattle at noon that day so Callaghan wallah MPI amino 2015 10 shall government resolutions appropriating 78 million of the excise tax funds for for PM e in 2010 and 2011 mem on Appropriations Paris appeai me pero us a state that he dementia who aligned a project or program could be param branding Lama for para began empanadas new mana release neon cuz a special fan Gong ra7 171 indicia ba Hagen and regular budget and Provenza so II do not prefer 2015 sorry sorry yeah I meant 2013 sorry 2013 PO sorry Maron Panem 2013 and d2 massive ice go back to my SP Casa Cielo nama Mahalo an appropriations ordinance column co-parent a POW in MPI me die looking very specific night but even really say but it was externally pulanana got a request boo salmon well today advice no more may appropriations that you know a good morning with regards to the year 2013 I don't think I cannot remember that there's PME appropriations way back then so kale important occur on an appropriations 20 2011 2011 2012 to the best of my my men would help my memory will recall it from what year 2010 to 2016 yes you're the excise tax yes your honor Thank You mr. chair representative Castro good morning mr. chair maganda omega post acting lahat I'm such a very different end of my report I am this from the emptying MPE mr. chairman for the time guests from the NP we have not invited a representative from India Pune meirin dimple sonnet I own a guest from the MTA Kisei sir our a 7 1 7 Maron personal obligation code may produce a manatorian [Music] [Music] 1 1 2 6 so we will invite them for the next experience the whole am seven one seven one I owe you a special know a special friend controller disability and an SPF special education friend no no no expenses the own conveyor goddammit Antonito I met her on login' and resolution and padam met Ali Baba oh you struck you know my resolutions the Hat so mr. Martello mr. chair you I think sabor some provincial board process so now you know maybe not the deepest Ras have been one seven one other possibility lies no Pandu nothing vice governor mr. chair yes we make the appropriations and from there we deliberate on the merit of the Appropriations bed one in seven years Your Honor mr. bloom record cutting provincial board know at Pune param padam eaten knock on door NATO are a seven one seven one it it's it depends on the Appropriations Your Honor if it's there on and on what it is allocated for a pony caninus in the sabe star formation and Oh deep now a new alum copia I'm Commission on audit resolution its operation the motion is sure by probe representative Gonzalez is recognized Thank You Man good morning madam governor second hearing parent of impending question regarding one she the pill jabs the stock top one number two big question to whom is on a per young PGI in cinah populating summer goodman stitcher yes oh my god treasurer thou shalt you had no latest is o team with the EQ my mom the Quality Management review representative with the Cayman can I ask what's the chairman of that it used to be the provincial administrator Apple Windle Chua who came here the last time the first time so he's not around mom so a visit around our departmental heads are involved here in the is Oh eleventy broken bucket now how long do you you assignment you know regarding is whole department head are you conducting your quarterly or did its Department mom yes that's correct and in fact we just upgraded in the last year for a higher level of ISO what is oh mama you well now I know that we started with the 2009 and have upgraded change no ma'am I saw all in for 9001 to 2018 so are you one that rings yes no piece of programming in 2009 and the latest let me check though yes ma'am thank you I love new Mount Ida by putting out the Nagato in people Panama da-da-ding da-da-ding I sou was no team um 2012 or 2013 7 2012 mom LM Panera in procurement natin Amana trucks at Malibu he kills I think not only on is okay as a procurement mama many job thank you madam governor Madame web rhetorical beautiful pipe enough in you is or in deepening our young men class advance in deepening are a young pacification of being Molino po technique is oppa tayo this is a procedural meaning to say if that is by administration healed issue Persia pio pio quantum anomalous at the rock Mesa bus stop we on say some compañía oh sorry some departamento Yin PO in a plane up in not only in private sector but also in government sector you can power all departmental on Iassogna pasa la cause a procedural plan we have to follow the procedure in building poor but a person beeping man conversion tell me purchase request boot i/o in po India Pune kita me PR Pattaya medium biood bow and prions eyes oh the Pope is or can be formatted in apply a support you is o an app important deeply Olivia Pope is a business ISO international NGO should agree to the poor and the poor solution now chairman and the members of good government in public accountability it would not be important people Agha you is oh so you improve dr. Manhattan and D to push our we step you put ISO in apply water during the bidding your honor you poor Somalis a building I also remember Pasha [Music] [Music] then procurement namely public art 9184 just in quick response to its actually is 900 1 9:08 we got it in 2013 after the procurement of the mini trucks and we have since been upgraded in February - 9 0 0 1 2015 thank you madam are you conducting the the edit button governor Poe as we are doing the quarterly or it religiously possible by the Warner not by prototype to Poona OD u OD limbaugh was a planning because maintenance because our instruction you are auditing each other they're deported people Yong Yong is or international [Music] you can approve my you Peter Hindi Panetta McMahon we've been asking all of this question that we deadly but when you come here you improve a lot for a very busy boom and shanigan unit because we have been asking you about this we asked you before about PMA correct yes your honor and you had not even bothered to check I [Music] [Music] [Applause] yes the annual investment program you know gunam peanut butter unknown they are Hindi liudmila histone octamer tourists transport segment on Vienna I began Sumitra pocket applause malabon PAH I mean Athena Tawana a IP emerald rains Marhaba say hon not be na dhanam Bourassa rh seven one seven one number one two for you livelihood you far too margin you know some company Louisiana to appropriate those funds for this for purposes mandated by law but what this uncouple illusion has been doing is to give it to you as a lump sum in a baja legume others to stun the opponent away so there is killed under the negation of legislative powers here or a lump sum fund given to the PMA and b'hala NASA governor Onaga the winner on Italian upon some good amp and elegant in appropriate amount in violation of seven one seven one because segment one seven one gives you the guidelines as to how you should appropriate the money but you appropriated lump sum and give it to the governor company away and moms happy new up to 2012 I will show you mom you're a IP for 2014 which you furnish to us this is the CY 2014 annual investment program a IP by program projects activity I refer you to section page 24 new program NATO the city to Panipat babichenko poodle deposit a opinion a gala hypo a IP reference code 3000 s 25 program project activity description program an economy an economy ax at equal area open parentheses P ami implementing agency office of the governor the amount is 300 million pesos general apollomon upon details at OPM wizard in page can you show this to mr. engineer available SIL approximate Natori now giving lump sum phone a discretionary fund upon available in the annual investor program there is an item of 300 million for PMA without specifics and then the Sangguniang Panlalawigan complicit lee also throws money into that program without specific insurance either recipients include hamper diligent but not appropriate pattaya no money shall be paid out of the Treasury pattern another poem in a valid name Supreme Court Danza that the Indians are hungry so purple spinach sama-sama Yuma savings at New Zealand embark on program ana dub hindi roopa dental violation per annum separation of powers because it is the legislative that appropriates it is the governor that enforces the appropriation piranha le potato or mr. Attila can you look at your a a piano Kunigal evasion Maribyrnong d'Italia 100 kilometers a 300 million and under French code poor your honor is 3000 s 25 an economy Attica Lohia funding poetry hundred million at seven one seven one branch jump or eaten at upon but a spa vanilla cable and a tongue requirement nap kaylynn appropriateness and Guney and the locals and guna and the amounts but what has been happening is the sanguinary region with the approval of the governor gives the amount in full or lump sum to her program will an apology slip action after that so bahala na po you burn a door upon Sonya Gina gamut that lambda and then hindi naman permission and Liliana this is 2013 in 2000 2012 than on depois this is a preparation 60 thus 2012 appropriating at about the amount of 230 million six hundred fifty thousand eight hundred seventy passers from the province's year from tobacco excise tax are a seven one seven one for the program on eco-hula nama Mayan Palace economy Attica lujah sign I am America's on December 4 2012 signed by this appropriation ordinance shall take effect upon approval beste inappropriate 232 million six hundred three thousand eight 581 pesos to OPI me tobacco excise taxes front splitter but you treat them as lump sum punch you transfer them to the P I mean like a parapet Amato Allah about poem but a style ambitous for Sheena Sabina the apartment and paper commit and then pero pupae inappropriate no in approved Amanda Coburn or a beanie beginning along sir governor companies' Adam Eaton human donor and dimple Nam 2011 previous years among the put a lien for Kundun books unum pass of Nando gallons at the ball there were two appropriations are Polly in 2012 the first one I read is six state thus 2012 this is a prior provincial appropriation ordinance 55 - 2012 an ordinance appropriating the amount of seventy 1 million three hundred eighty six thousand four hundred twenty one pesos for the program and Oh number Mayan Palace economía Attica lujah approved by the governor i'ma balco's and Jen Mari 29 2012 gonna lop oh very still buy appropriated the amount of 71 million three hundred eighty six thousand four hundred twenty one pesos from the provinces share from tobacco excise tax are a seven twenty seven 1cy calendar year 2011 amounting to seventy million pesos I'll just round the figures and 1.1 million representing the provinces share in Burnley pin examiner young barely Achara seven one seven one button believe minimal Longman 1.1 million seven one seven one is seventy point two million for the program for P Amina and then section to this ordinance shall take effect upon approval in a prod Nick open also approved NATO appropriation metal without this angry and even knowing where the money will be spent on you because you are parent amoeba some grass of appropriate come in and buy billion that as a PD groom that's it India India Papa say indeed alphabetical seen Adrienne Sangha the meet engine and a breathing mask ippo presidental and Pilipinas shown in the property lump sum appropriation seven and nine among in ago a new sample Eluga noble ojos Norte so madam commissioner pocket example human basis delve an eternal ordinary inappropriate Nalanda is mr. Franco never questioned or any of this can you pour on Kauai you should have questioned in your annual audit report recently what is the basis of this man is being spent some William panel region you cannot do that you are not appropriating the amounts in a whole dance with our a seven one seven one because you are simply passing it to the governor so the governor now has no not even any parameters alumni operator in mock delegate and legislative powers if the delegate has guidelines implementing rules and regulations Stephanie beginning dum-dum million rapido say some cow a ball and a pusher whom I know and a big Sabine and program P I me in fact like the governor said in the economy an acronym occur in Lanyon hundreds of millions for an analogy no to a non-existing entity or non-existing program in accordance of the words of the governor del well an ample legal basis there is no legislative basis there is no executive order creating for this one for this program yet the Sangguniang Panlalawigan blindly appropriate the amount for this P I mean with the governor request for disapprobation mr. West governor because that is what happens I know because I read also the folders of my daughter if I have the time who is a member of the San Juan de la Vega and the governor writes to you and requests for the appropriation some your honors for this one I think yes it was requested resulted you got burned requested Campanella Wiegand allocation mom and Papa Gaga Madonna Louise empanada deputies and in Puna need a patch and Santelli if we began 18 in 200 million Jan and Paris attacks on Young Saeng da Gama Tinian Sao Paulo and Aslam go back a technibond Indian thank you mr 2kay before a recognized center tapped in you may acknowledge the presence of Representative Doral banner the third vice chairman representative Ron Schara representative Don Gonzalez said that 15 years now recognize mr. chair thank you before the Honorable pina speaks I have some I was just going through the documents I only saw now presented by the majority leader it might be of interest to the Honorable tenure and the Honorable Casilla in your quest so let me just go through some of the details that I noticed mr. chair if I may I am trying to reconcile the report purportedly given by madam vicente de la cruz unfortunately she is not here but madam commissioner again has a copy and so i'm trying to reconcile it and now with what the majority leader has shared some things are becoming quite clear for example if we look at 2012 madam commissioner I use you as the foil we can see that the receipt of provincial government of Ilocos Norte of each share amounted to 235 million pesos this was for 2012 and if we put it against the now the resolution now this is the appropriation ordinance number 20 1206 8 it transfers not from 235 million that was received in 2012 it transfers 230 million almost the whole amount was transferred into the PIAA program so now it's becoming quite clear we are trying to trace so this has been a problem from the start the documentation so now slowly from 7 1 7 1 ma'am it was transferred and obviously they're quite good at their accounting because there is also another appropriation ordinance here from 2012 dealing with 71 million left over from 2011 so it says from the sale of the provincial share of tobacco excise tax in 2011 so in 2012 they got the 235 they received as a 20 clubs share the analysis P I'm a Benelli camper in Mullane a 1 9 2011 and then the 2013 appropriation ordinance as read by the majority leader September 27 verse 30 2013 but it appropriates 78 million from the 7th to 7 1 7 1 share also 2011 so they know they're keeping some sort of a usage like an ATM they have a running balance of unused amounts and then they just keep growing from it at their discretion so imagine 2012 they put from the top 20 that they took it out put it in P I me they took some out of the leftover of 2011 out of the share of 2011 so I think they're keeping books also regarding this and this will be a guide to us as to what happened not to help the farmer stimulus and a pen pal I mean share like the pond up and possibly I'm a I'm a proba so I hope this also enlightens and this will all come to light when we go through the timelines of all the documents you have mr. chair I think as to why the amount being appropriated is 2 years old because the DBM is delayed in releasing shares of the problem so it happens like in 2013 they just received the share for 2011 in fact today register knee test that we received vice-governor madam governor what seers have been received from 7 1 7 1 well Appa Yakka as I recall we had the 2013 complete I'm not certain if 2014 has been remitted in toto at home 2014 in the cosa Corrado completo by own or album by I think since we approved the syntaxes think only 2013 sorry I know in a proven attendance in taxes the DBM has been holding this year's del segundo Lulu la silla Holopainen ma hua because they argue they stand to get so much more because our sin taxes our sin taxes now I think has a total collection of hundred ten billion and if fifteen percent goes to them that's 15 billion for one year alone and Lu Malakian the while Arcanum allocate this way I think that's the research mr. chair the I was going to prepare the proposals at the proper time during the hearing but regarding now for this particular instance regarding the share of the DBM could we ask now the DBM for the detailed list of the dates of the releases to the provincial government of in authority of its share of the seven one seven one and to be asked our committee secretary now to collate the bangle matinee on your beta releases and the amounts against the appropriate appropriation ordinances so that we can see the timeline the timelines are very important to us an appropriate time I was going to ask also that the committee Secretariat they order to prepare a timeline regarding the purchases of the vehicles and of the five transactions that we are undergoing because already we can begin to see a pattern once we examine it not as individual documents but as we look at it comprehensively for example as the majority leader says as soon as seven one seven one is released for that particular time soon will follow and denies appropriating OPI me so let us look at the dates so we will need the output of the DBM regarding that and likewise I will say it now can the committee secretary already prepare the matrix or timeline regarding the prepurchase of vehicles and the fiber transactions because we can already see from there certain dates are not followed or it is too much of a coincidence that the checks for example in the purchases is said by mr. Fabian go he met with mr. mark Toa a cash advance was made of a certain amount the next day according to mr. go and he showed us a check and a deposit deposit was made by mr. cha the subsequent date that the cash advance is released as opposed to the testimony that this were paid to the supplier of the vehicles as they were delivered it is too much of a coincidence so regarding this cordially committee secretary prepared timelines regarding 7 1 7 1 releases by the DBM versus appropriation ordinances by PTIN and then maybe our colleagues will begin to see now some light at the end of the tunnel Thank You mr. chair your instructions the last time we had actually already prepared the detailed list of releases for Aloha's north day we were informed that the farmer transmittal letter was just saying but we will provide the committee with an advance copy of the documents being requested thank you so independence a submitter submit Palomino okay Thank You director awareness here presented opinions recognized Thank You chair [Music] yes I stated I believe it was in the early part of 2010 2011 2012 young Sina sobbing 2014 AIP in dieta the corona ordenanza de una caja male Chunkin 2013 long talaga UPI me at young Cena's have been transferred from 2012 after 2011 a continuing appropriations una piña lee hwon at my commissioner ID token ena now unused unliquidated dire continuing appropriations for the following year in the year 2020 I mean 2014 if I may clarify how young annually investment program you may IP parang wish list tune in Dena to to Padilla heart means Anika carryovers our next year kappa guellen para governor nominee re madalasa a IP Naaman Sinha sulit Nam in last nine kena kailangan autonomy melanin project in terms of priority pero maraming in Dina - - pod young Issa don't young Sheena Sabina 2014 okay with respect to the appropriations of the excise tax funds essentially transferring them to the so in 2014 2014 so inappropriate the any funds are in accordance with the annual investment plan sample 300 I invest plans for from 2010 to 2016 for all those years casino you 2014 a with your permission because in 2012 a I pee pee I'm a poor and page 16 called 3000 escorted women million people on lump sum of 5 million pesos for 2012-2013 done on tempo and page 14 of the annual investment program Leeman million the important person 2014 AIP 300 million adele sallekhana inappropriate era in a lump sum / emporium 300 million so annual investment program vanilla okay well so similar bust moon 2013 you will be lucky [Music] may I just in 2014 regards to P I mean we did not appropriate anything for P I mean 2013 2012 2011 so Brannon it will balance as the gentleman from Ponca said you inappropriateness e is for 2011 P ima was sixty-two million and then in two thousand twelve two thousand penny with Bogota na kanuto 855 million at the poor Allen Bauer parent empowering dito approbation ordinance 0:08 thus 2010 September 13 2010 in approve mr. Sabourin Piniella Wiegand in approved governor on September 21 2010 now therefore the syllabi appropriated the amount of 321 million five hundred thirty-five thousand fifty eight passes of 40s and doubles from the province's share in tobacco excise taxes and there are a seven one seven one for the years 2002 to 2009 Oh a to palana apron so an apron to seven years to include the amount of 18 million nine hundred fourteen thousand five hundred twenty five pesos 420 path from the national government as the notice of payment schedule so in a for programming even economía a takuya I'm Ellen well upon P I'm in an island in the amount of 289 million five hundred thirty-five thousand fifty eight pesos and forty eight centavos so at appropriate avoiding Lampson not 289 million in 2010 which was approved by the governor this ordinance shall take effect immediately well Apple break down cones and a gamete in a gallon Pusa excise tax latter so three in 2010 328 million pesos and inappropriate near for I me and then in 2011 provincial appropriations ordinance 0 - 22 - 2011 passed and March 7 2011 approved by the governor and March 10 2011 governor on Plato's 57 million pesos 580,000 624 pesos there are to be set aside for the p IM nominate Orion program economic and Apollonia Indianapolis unto Him may I'm a VP ima P I'm a a profession or the despot assigned by Angelo Marcos barber this was in 2011 then sue natural boy 2012 you appropriated another two hundred thirty two million pesos two rounds of 233 million for the P I mean so I was cutting billion of item inappropriate you as lump sum for the PME out of tobacco punch mr. chair just to reconcile no because I'm comparing the appropriation ordinances with the report of madam Vicente de la Cruz if you will read the vice governor is making much of the fact that in 2014 you did not appropriate any amount for p.m. is the collector yes I know in the column observations or other remarks by madam Vicente de la Cruz for 2014 it says no share from our a7 171 tobacco excise tax was released to the province for this year so a la Poma little mass share so it was not out of a desire not to use seven one seven one for a different purpose but rather that none less released to you from the national government this is what I gather from here and from the 2010 Worcester I will check now there was quite a large received at 322 million so I will check now against the appropriation ordinances but in 2014 may I state again there was there was no appropriation for P I me because no she robbed seven ones have been one was released as stated in this document mr. chairman there were no no pardon 2015 provincial appropriations ordinance 34 - 2015 pass and April 13 2015 and approved by the governor on April 15 to ditional from the session approved a god-given talent Conti because no Alan and I MPI me but the title of the ordinance is this little an appropriation an ordinance appropriating the sum of two hundred twenty seven million three hundred eighty seven thousand two hundred eighty six measures from the province's share in the tobacco excise tax under are a seven one seven one for the year 2012 for various development undertakings projects and services so now therefore built or did the need to bring ordinance on you your honors some Campanella vegan the receiver appropriated the amount of 227 million three hundred eighty seven thousand eight hundred twenty six passers from the provinces here in the tobacco excise tax under are a seven one seven one for the year 2012 for various urgent development undertakings projects and services such as the following well Apple well upon amount sparrow in in a level have such as the poly means meaning balance ago Bernal Kamaka I know I'm charitable verbatim such as the following later a amortization a plant Bank of the benefits monetization of a seven one seven one precedes no amount letter B for case of too small payload herbs and tobacco's no amount C maintenance and repair of provincial equipment for the construction and rehabilitation of Fanta market roads no amount construction of plan to market roads no amount construction of farmers multiple birth centers FMC no amount letter of purchase of small farm implements and other assistance to farmers such as one purchase of water pumps and other farm equipment purchase of fertilizer insecticides and backpack sprayers for case of seeds seedlings of new variety rice and vegetable crops for tobacco farmer livelihood programs no amount lethargy capital financial and technical assistance to operatives and tobacco farmers well upon amount the indicated its livelihood an alternative farming assistance number one purchase of 40 d chicks ducks sheep goats and other livestock no amount purchase of assorted a new variety of vegetables I'll just make a general statement they it does there is no indication as to how much money is going to its item alternative processing packaging and marketing Egypt but net non Ganesha kornek production production support alternative livelihood programs for purposes spirit amounts indicate buyback and other marketing programs for political alternative crops to tobacco such a garlic shallots rice corn mango dragon fruit and bonsai etc establishment of pilot plants alternative farming technology and Agri tourism such as little farms biodiversity zones as facilities for alternate plan techniques inque development of agro tourism centres as alternative livelihood for tobacco growers section 2 the preparations made under this ordinance are in accordance with the implementing rules and regulations of our a seven one seven one section three this ordinance shall take effect immediately so gonna deport you appropriated 227 million unjust without any indication as to how it will be spent I mean how much for its projects see governor Dean Bo panic submit Neto you're requested to answer the question clinical chairman on Corbett an appropriate I think I proceed to lasso so this was requested by the governor meet was forwarded to be efficient and what I do is I refer to the Committee on Appropriations then they appropriated and approve it then it could be tackled down any questions from the may acknowledge the presence of senior deputy might not really been a chance' mr. chairman just a quick question to the governor he made mention earlier upon the questions a series of questions asked by majority leader for Enya's should mention that philosopy ugly funds are not solely from the farmers for the farmers memorandum circularity known as a seven one seven one it's a program LPI me understanding latina bonito a nice coupon a pala managing statement now and I will Hindi at otama in pakka because Co at Andina in finding on lucky put a mini big eyes among our tobacco farmers at yamaja Munna dad at familia nila yung Sonata become the king sectoral come Minchin maybe neba guys halimbawa acababa even catalyst Anunnaki not even a Naruto come in son maybe knee bigger policy bopping farm activities cattle at noon turismo at UN panga Alicia sat Abajo you know gleep at some us high-value crops Catalan and dragon fruit at manga nishang Tino tula young DNA on pero Kellan man hindi and lumi Lisa McKeon nang Waka's nah I be gay sir Maha Maha the problem with that piece of German the statement of the governor cannot be supported with the documents records again the bond o tamanho mcaren upon only now now you mala appropriations national province of Ilocos Norte immediately but then again a personal resolution and provincial board to justify the transfer and for the governor we provide that metal necessary funds to spend the money with its very irregular and highly irregular for appropriating funds without putting line item specific line items as to where to spend the specific amount as required by seven one seven one Apple bergamot psilocybin at with madam governor believe Begay nothing else a normal sense and we can debate all night long the Sabine didn't knock upon a time a second another the Maya in the Latin the peon at the same time there is a paper trail now the propriety napping Moberly can now love some people like a really listening provincial governor on a provincial board so official governor and the kenapa Hana Susilo zombie movie program and gusano property and then never of course in the succeeding proceedings mr. chairman naughty marketer McCallum and provincial board attend admitted at the oppositional governor as to where to spend the money I what I will tell my irregularities sermon yes if I may respond by me yes without being argumentative Johann Galle okay congressman casillo been busy tell em poker marito halimbawa pasa GUI information come in Somali Molly Lila siapa Regina Kaku young a beneficiary in an array seven-one-seven once in a bikini na na 0 young too long Subala dear Masha belong recipient of fertilizers amoeba nummy-nummy me guy maraming Tana gun on Danes a barangay gulp eggnog ah cemento hominin Calzada @c similan iranian colored animal ah PIPA to Musa bohemia' young Anakin a government scholar nagging ji p at space young summer program drink summer job at mayor tampa ha now 4920 seulji you pineal e cocina beanie appoggio canina now meirin sealing request up in Ely so in the interest of fairness and equity young the municipality of P neelima Alma dial not begin de mundo selasa group on I mean sue ballot young group on Amina a bag embargo Marceau ability or Choi Eatontown long Ito uncle Elena minion Tim puke man alone nishang dot e non grupo knee a polka Kooyong and regarding the lump sample humming thing in Hindi who lump sum to die limited number Tottenham ra7 one marijuana dough Noonan and John at Molly wanna Greenham process along AIP piccata Poznan Alicia stop iron lung machine seen on Bauer department head annual procurement program piccata Poznan requirement pasa cada project Hindle among young project plan diem project procurement management plan marina requirement bbm Adnan cava Samara me Pam proceso and Hindi and beanie big I belong discretionary ATM or an among non gubernatorial in addition or rather during the previous hearings we requested the locus not a provincial government for the submission of the annual investment program but so far what we requested from 2010 to 2016 however what has been submitted in our possession right now is only 2011 in 2012 so again the committee is directing the pga in to please submit the AAP for 2010 2013 2014 2015 in 2016 this already requested otherwise again we will issue a subpoena for this document it's not necessary mr. chairman to issue a subpoena we will comply and many on HR it to antiknock a long and long yu-mong irrelevant once a transaction pero Coombes 11:26 cannot rely on young Hong Kong a on a table a bollock pasta handgun 2010 he began ami yes because you should have between 2011-2012 that was in connection with the resolution number 82 now for resolution number 1 1 2 6 they are requesting for the 2010 2013-14 up to 16 any more questions mr. secretary torch answer I just would like to take advantage of the situation to inquire from sponsors of this resolution specially why and we just focusing on Ilocos Norte when the abuse and misuse of the tobacco access path can be traced many decades ago but a Peruvian economist on excise taxes Isabella Abra a maritime power Luna tangled there's excess to us Saku Saku peri and again saranya so maybe this is the best time to examine and look into the misuse and abuse of the excess touch in the whole region but it's meant to be benefiting the farmers Balan and Bob on quality not in tobacco oil a cooler let me die samoa cigar producing countries they'll envy Nogami to pass a new x-ray stars so I really would like to ask and I'd appreciate if congressman Casilla will clarify it with me why are we focusing only on one province if we want to investigate and help positively the farmers of the locust and the region that should be benefiting from the excise tax Heba megundal-sama not in lats Allah at MPC cannot in the hub indeed Muhammad and Tama sake say stuff congressman Casilla and the co-sponsors of the measure representative casillo Thank You mr. chairman such a good post article Evan Dunham deputy Minority Leader I mean resolution poquito I never battled Owens sulla at piggyback dialogue Oh naginata burrito sir Groupon I mean the concern of Abbas a say Novus Norte otaku I mean you wanna sue masala on the hill a minimum poison comprehension level organization Imam excessive as a tobacco I've not only Japan regional [Music] [Music] of the seven one seven one of all the tobacco producing provinces should benefit on all our effort is to start with a particular item and subject matter of the resolution which is in particular did not thank the gentleman join me if I filed a resolution calling for a an investigation of the abuse and misuse of the excise tax for the whole region you muhabba and block would they support such a measure of organizations because they are the ones will be providing us with data with that qualifying statement I am not sure whether they will join me or not but anyway I will file a resolution that will call for an investigation finally but whose access taxi the man appointed ministration tangle monopolies and police abuse area in the year 2000 the mobile team scanned along Saku Saku Parramatta and now is the time to investigate all of this now and and rehash and adjust below so that it may benefit directly the farmers and not to be misused by anyone anymore we reserve that right chairman and we will be very happy of the Maccabean block joins us otherwise we will do it alone absent a tarantula this committee will conduct an inquiry if there is a solution or a privileged speech that is being referred to us we'll take action on that as long as it will be referred to this committee representative or dato sir mr. chairman can I get the reaction of the [Music] [Music] [Music] yes you gave systems to the I mean paracord interment mr. Kikuyu unlucky baguette post a vanilla a young municipal and pinning Lee in a circle on Jung soo-jung message tag apini Lisa piccata and Alan Koh will animal coming not hang got no requests Milazzo I mean young that pina colada and I'm in a group or young group on Ellen teen pokeman alone at Bennigan's deal amongst young a bono or fertilizer kundi paren Calzada na neun farm to market road now papa Natasha barangay gulping Santa don't see who young parampara Nancy Mullin and Amanda Quezada galleys re7 171 hollows petunia directamente Shannon Baha'i top assume an opinion Nash young space or summer Employment Program you pour a gallon shall miss mom provincial dialer GIP at special and acne no Santa own cada summer at Michonne pepti Altima Marin passion hutong ethanol mangling mementos apini Lindemann galaxy' provincial mayor Tom Parata and a loans are up in Ely municipio so young sinners are people nacio young teen Otunga plaza nabina mr. Fujioka nina hindi naman saguru totally zero maybe Nagaina manyate in provincial - Oh at me Nibbana Montsegur him by an amp in elimination also provide that that Mister the dimension space is totally different appropriation or amount and services given as if you are saying to the beneficiary in a hotel Aubrey and I could burn Ohio and you are the province of not they that should and it's an unconditional it should be given a hobby for peace I was up in Depot you allotment non-pro business adipose you know your subject matter and again mr. chairman it seems that you are too young Vinney guy for a sim for for a single person beneficiary but you are invoking other appropriations not burn out of discipline one-seven-one leader was about to be my question the governor mentioned is best what is is possible spread Express then a bond get long space that young government scholar what is this platinum its employment you also fund up from seven one seven one no that's not derived from seven one that's correct but the other I've been a battle called on casino message so he nearly young mi young farm to market road delawanna young/nasa baron Jay Gould paying it Callaway Dunlop atopic NASA bhai nila yung Asylum garlic telega subpoena Lee Young a bono or fertilizer sample gallium superb incident provincia was a municipio I'm not certain better on Alam ko unusual young cemento galaxy' provincially owned our app or young sand and gravel usually comes from the locality I'm not certain in the case of P Neely and barangay bullpen petition Campanella vegan you are appealing to you because we knew appropriate funds this way a new ID reviewing authority of Imperial Sangguniang Seba any appropriation made by the Hungarian baiance or sangria and bundles of butter and lava Ranieri be open in your de puta vice governor yes your honor for in on provincial in moonship your llama shares in 212 million Dean William shear nila I couldn't pump in a pocket on you Basilica not Nuremberg appropriate Nepal am Sam Bell the day I employ conclusive provincial gonna go on your Bahamas Amana by-and-by on that they are enduring today appropriate dilemma I see Alibaba Yun pineal and Lavinia knee I'm sure Lampanelli Vanessa Bayer along bajalia beginning at Pattaya del champagne can you prove that anything as problem chang-geun Yin anymore any more questions because of there are none you know Mike this document sir I move request that the provincial appropriations number 0:08 best 2010 be marked as Iko Iko and that page 1 the Marcus echo echo 1 page 2 us echo echo 2 and there is a certification here he should be the provincial Finance Committee as echo echo does 3 signed by the balloon a truly Kalahari Bitola and all of them the recertification the amount for ordinance provincial appropriations ordinance number 0 thus 0:22 does 2011 it be marked as Foxtrot Foxtrot and the page 1 B Marcus Foxtrot Foxtrot 1 and page 2 as Foxtrot Foxtrot two provincial approbation ordinance number 0.5 - 2012 be Marcus golf ball and pitch 1 as golf golf - 1 and page 2 as golf ball thus - for provincial approbation ordinance number 16 thus 2012 the same be marked as double lapel hotel hotel and that page 1 be Marcus hotel Hotel - 1 and page 2 as hotel Hotel does - for provincial appropriations ordinance number 0 0 4 - 2013 the same be marked as double India or India India and that page 1 DeMarcus India India that's why and Paige to us India India - - and then last his provincial appropriations ordinance number zero does 34 - 2015 the same be marked as double Juliet or Juliet Juliet and paid - and B Marcus Juliet Juliet - one page to us Juliet Juliet bus - and the last bits as Juliet Juliet nurse Lee Thank You mr. chairman the presence of representative arnelle T are there any further questions if there are none I would like to announce all the resource persons you know - the members that the next hearing will be set on October 9th and for the next hearing I'd like to summarize the documents that are to be submitted by the different agencies for DBM the release ma'am director Rivera the detail the release of the funds from the excise tax for locos Norte yes commissioner ito as we have agreed you will submit the list of transactions together with the projects now Castleman Jalen's in you my own you amount in the new voucher what we need are what are the projects for that certain butcher tightening the standalone and for the local norte we need the submission of the AAP for 2010 13 14 15 and 16 and we also like to inform of course what we issued the motions that were approved in this committee a show cause order for mr. March 1 miss Irene Mendoza why they should not be cited for contempt for not appealing after appearing in spite of the fact that we already issued the subpoena and I believe that the Tony libido should be issued a subpoena also considering that he has not appealed we mr. Chairman I move that we already issue a subpoena for attorney in a bio any second an objection to bring none the motion is approved so I mean German during the last meeting we also requested the good governor and she said she'll give us a copy of the MOA with the depth and the resolution of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan for the paseo the power marina Poblana submit I brought it with me pod thank you thank you please show the page please get the copy of the document that is to be submitted the governor on me mr. chairman also the next meeting the presence of nte represent the next steering block a please be informed that about the ninth same time the venue will be announced later on October 9 at 9:30 October that will be the next steering if there are no more questions any motion to adjourn secure the Assessors present depend upon a adjourn yes mr. chairman also the can be invited the qvm are head the few quality management review heads advocacy well last year I saw a plastic not pal concept are there any question for the municipal Assessors Shamokin president in new municipal assess or can you and be palpable at image Palacios okay also let me be corrected we will not observe because we invited the members of the municipal as a source of Ilocos Norte during the last hearing I'd left orders to destroy the Sangguniang Panlalawigan I think representative Chris all ago requested for the withdrawal of the resolution are declaring representative arenas as persona non-grata was already it was it already withdrawn hi good afternoon yes last session on September 14 we passed three resolutions actually I was the presiding officer as a vice governor was absent the first of which was provincial resolution number 100 2017 a resolution to expunge from the records of the symphony panel Oregon draft resolution number 2017 - 0 7 - 0 8 8 entitled a resolution strongly denouncing the Proceedings of the House Committee on good government and more importantly to your question sir we also passed resolution number 1 0 1 - 2017 a resolution recalling provincial resolution number 0 8 6 - 2017 declaring congressman adult recife yes first district of the province of Ilocos Norte is persona non grata expressing apology for having passed the same and to expunge or strikeout the measure from the records of the cymbidium for Louie gun and lastly we also passed provincial resolution number 1 0 2 - 2017 a resolution expressing the sincerest apology over the synchrony and peluda gonna be lost Martha - the House Committee on good government and public accountability thank you we request the page to get the copy or for these three resolutions now to the president of the Palacios association the reason why you were invited to attend this hearing we have been possession of resolution number two zero 17.00 three and this resolution [Music] again is unanimously resolving to denounce the Proceedings of the hearing for a solution number two could you please please rise so that you could take your oath please raise your right hand do you swear to tell the truth the whole truth and nothing but the truth before this congressional inquiry shall be good thank you the Acting President of municipal Assessors League in resolution in your approval a big new impossible in it or that why are you denouncing the Proceedings of this house setting in yoruba in the tomato green iguana monopoly explain possa Committee Papa Norman without their own journals that was a whistle Mylene resolution actually this this resolution was made done July during our meeting this was brought about by the survival of us not the burden of eternal Abijah during the preview Ruben Salazar Stein your honors [Music] during the Prohibition SSO Stangl owners hidden from the the body about the template the template resolution floating around the province and he suggested to the Association that they can adapt same resolution well in somebody pond the members of the municipal Assessor speak of you know us not as the adoption at the same and then it was journalism unanimously metabolic coming information a you know key Nokia Lumia work forward to some resolution then the penis aanenson grupo so information polemic are things are many pinup in mandolin dopo it among municipal as a source that is why we really need a tour Neela bio because accordingly to Saturn Ella bio who prepared this resolution potato young Maya Pope in a permanent preparado neural she attended by the prominent will permit Oh actually the haven't seen the template or a bit Sabine it took up Joaquin no pill and now she's having resolution that perceptible a and a good number minimum is a policy associate Urmila biome just mentioned about the template during of meeting resolution a popular manga kayo in Armenia pouillon yes because you address this resolution to me to transmit a copy of this resolution to the Opera House Majority Leader Horace information guidance the Bossip abandoning semester did you know a presidency not be new d'etre you are you in effect lecturing the House of Representatives at opening lalamon now second whereas new however the power of legislative inquiry does not give Congress the power to deprive any citizen of the constitutionally vested rights such as the right to freedom of movement and to be presumed innocent until one is proven guilty where else the Arts Committee and good government and public accountability the house in conducting the Proceedings of this horrible governor mm across failed to observe the above-mentioned constitutional rights so DNA declare in Ebola in the nominee no observe that under tree whereas in fact Avenue the proceeding ceased to be one indeed of legislation as it had become in aid of one's political ambitions whereas malleable baka copia need a BA degree in the potato passenger to the carding and discontent of billing the unilaterally without consultation and valid justifications authorize the possible detention of the Honorable governor Alma Marcos denying in the process the chance of fair hearing whereas let me produce inhabited you are condemning the actions in order to serve as a wake-up call for the house to observe the rule of law whereas if the horrible government will be detained all members of the league will have a day and night vigil in front of Congress to demonstrate their support to her against this uncanny proceedings so you are interfering in our proceedings which is contemptuous for the committee can order your arrest for interfering in its proceedings in denominator or Madusa resolution at in Australia so mr. ababa we are here for you sir good afternoon your honors we are very sorry for you resolution opinion sir no nagging negative effect Oh actually in the food allergen I mean an alarm onion contain no resolution sir can you relate to us what happened by the pond EB sir sake David William Servat no means a bit a bit come maybe not spoken minato your honor no bug happened when i mean- in them in your honor [Music] so and inoculate you man I mean yes push your honor that content know that we are the incumbent punishable as a source of our respective municipalities here in indicated as far lost and eternal eternal and I mean and then number two the during our monthly regular meeting held on July 5 2017 at the office of the provincial assess all provincial capital privacy locus not that we were joined by attorney mes labaik who is the OIC provincial assessor and concurrently the provincial level of it sir also coming up esta be a local assessment operation of the provincial assessor's office and will further be Lorenzo jr. or IC head of the IT department of the provincial government of us Norte invited to report for particular topics in our prepared agenda number 3 pop that in the 17 during the provincial as a search time at or near mezcla by or inform us that he had the opportunity to attend meetings of the different leagues of Ilocos Norte wherein he had a solution of support in favor of the Honorable governor I am the our Marcos was invariably adopted for the dimension of the template resolution in his possession which the municipal Assessors League of Ilocos Norte can adapt so that our manifestation of support will be unified and consistent with the other leagues number 5 that without going over the contents of the aforementioned template resolution mr. robe Paul Biya Copan moonship Alice Adams move for its adoption in was unanimously seconded an approved that with the exception of the signatories of the resolution none of us had ever gone over the specific details and contents of the said resolution as adapted and transmitted to the Honorable House of Representatives saying then that we sincerely extend our deepest apologies to the Honorable House of Representatives particularly the honorable chairman Danny T mantle and all the members of the House Committee and the government and public accountability for whatever adverse effect a resolution may have cost eight that we did not have the slightest intention to cast disrespected honorable committee nor any of its members as our only motive was to manifest our support for an objective impartial and fair conduct of the proceedings being held at the House of Representatives in relation to the alleged misuse of our a seven one seven one funds nine that we are iterating our deepest apologies and prayers for forgiveness from the honorable members of the committee and government and public accountability into the whole institution in witnessing off we have hereunto set our hands and affix our signatures lists seven the day of August 2017 at the city of blah blah province of Balochistan signed by the way we have mr. Ventura with molasses or big test so mr. the passenger no meeting deep in Abbas a template hindi panicking about a number same template sir oh but can you say under banana region I'll get up there New Year honors the template was given to me by a tour de la balloon I just copied plainly in the copy that I have made to this honorable body your honor I just only attested to the correctness in a secretary whatever proceedings in the meeting I have recorded that's why you gave me the copy of the template I did in the minutes just after the meeting and you a fight yes your honor yes your honor so your certification will be already the qualification because you stated here I hereby certify to the correctness of the above resolution which is a true and exact accept from the minutes of meeting called for the purpose in the mnemonic a type animating path so how can it be part of your minutes in insert moon and I love supreme or after you join in Aomori home vinegar tablet para luma bass Paran canarian ago suppose appeal hearing it more multiplication putalik dawn because you are making it appear that such account or transaction happened when our Tony it did not happen you can invoke your right against self-incrimination tell pacification an abugida Whanui Illuminati array but Kapoor my admin and then be called in mr. Furtado in a test Mahna Mahna Mahna Mahna Indian abacus happens a meeting why did you attest to it pina petunia mo yirou certification near mr. Ventura in hindi mo Barbossa in abuddin grassman y para Davos a resolution convenient in demobilization and then you attest I know babies have been attested pin a petunia Mona Tama use of the be given name is Terra para la balle sorry pomade obsession runner that's why we ask for an apology as my Explorer remember Matthew manitoc submitted already resolution both resolution three resolutions one expressing apology the other one withdrawing the resolution declaring person a non grata and the other one apologizing for I love the resolution denouncing the proceedings so there are already three yes but I requested I want to question later on mr. Thurmond are word members it is possible the presiding officer dr. present mr. bill Hindu or bad or and the secretary mr. Antonio Ventura yeah as I said he says section 21 the people provides at the Senate or Bowser or any of its receptacle may conduct enquiries in a depleted station in the whole dance with it's duly published also pretend that the rights of person appearing in or affected shall be respected whereas however the power of legislative inquiry does not give Congress the power to deprive any citizenship of constitutionally vested rights such as the rights of freedom of movement and to be presumed innocent until one is proven guilty now that in our booth of eleven say that issue in tension deeper Sabino does not give the power to does not give Congress the power to deprive any citizen of constitutionally vested rights it with [Music] [Music] sorry sets committee and good government and the public accountability in conducting the presses against the Honorable they fail to observe the above-mentioned constitutional rights where did we mean you tell us monopolies netting economy yet in acronym noon to observe we be talking a Gallagher a Michigan or and the only reason why we code is to help NASA in and Mia Angelo Minami simply not by random anonymous is other no I mean we are not but now we are saying that we tell to observe the above-mentioned constitutional rights I know unified lamin to observe the constitutional rights of govern or I may be moral [Music] there are no rights that we that we hear let me fail the right now let me ask you again Apple did observe the right the position rights of God I need or not no we did that stated that no pain so which is near to store that we know that is a seven-letter stop or that began the more we service oriented [Music] [Music] [Music] which is which are we observing the rights of [Music] so you say that in fact the proceeding is to be won in a pledge nation become in aid once political ambition that proceeding it is in a place in this nation including in aid of one's political and be shown that's indeed a maybe too good victim identity Angela Pina in I'm in the Manila processor [Music] it was him he he goes around announcing this is not a pepper I hope you know why mr. chairman if that is so in order also for this members of this committee your so as president you can pass your resolution saying one in tsunami no my own logo I don't think we have a copy but they have already passed resolution number 2 0 1 7 - 0 0 5 a resolution with drawing the solution number two zero seven seven zero suitry in swim children expressing profound apologies those committing good government and public accountability on to the house of options yes but they did not say that is on why they are withdrawing IP she say that they were forced they were just they signed without seeing their signature number 500 adamant pushing and pushing and Papa had delegated it or Nutella gondola pony opponent in a bio template the apostle number three the apostle number five novella gay without going over the contents of the opponent mentioned template resolution mr. a coupon move for its adoption was unanimously seconded and a proper analogy melon ornament from Assessor Puna teen is a being Ivana majority leader big tumor in Poland an area ring I own at 92 Latin original and Daniela repo dito Obama assess or not and Alice Cassini dad Co sub history toponymy say to the man coming of birth pollutant Ron UMP suppose but not inside specials the did human piece on a GE rock on the poor young man i'm apolog analytic your peace upon analogous a boy a girl vo La La Push I meant by lights around Bali NASA Abajo but has no shop and Pune tin Depot 1.5 billion pesos stolen petition you remember Manhattan molasses or Sakuma Gulen I mean my enemies in smelling Leto to see my poem to mimic a family casino I made my booting hollering popping propecia IntelliJ alkenyl again Athena Peggy Molina shot in a Latin molasses or bullet number on the boy mr. lonegan victim identity tenure committee Nami and Ito dynamically Punahou slacker Napoleon Vista Ghana PDP no solution may you know I'm part Pina say kaletnik an unfamiliar Olympian Hashanah and to Mendel ared to polyamine a cricketer mr. chairman since they've already given the resolutions of withdrawing their previous resolution may explain now get a tomorrow bye-bye and detour together over started ah we are here no we are here investigating as a congressman boondock said huh nobody gotten me KitKat I'm lying to the Luna mini up why me no that's the way I understood it as a member of disco [Music] no no no the demo hit create a detailed record so we are here not to harass anybody no but we are just here to put what is right and writes meaner and writes a column in sha no but we are just talking to the transactions which she that the ban on the miss the ministry Danny Apple govern adora so they D lying thank you very much mr. chairman considering that I am the representative of half of this Assessors more than half the 12 of them come from my district the other from the other pages we give them the same kindness we showed to disagree and Piniella Wiegand the prep pressured in Scylla in fact they already stated very clearly he'll begin a well-orchestrated mosquito sabaha basses dito very my sticker Varinius Bert Doogan and congresso fishbowl boop boop doop Eliyahu D total when important panini by instead nests of good in prison issue panini rapper Yung did not go and ela I plead to my colleagues but I've been said that alibi but I think he has been promoted again as did back German madam governor sheila bio terminus lunches opt-in perk of our rules it should really be someone who's a permanent employee but for lack of qualified employees Nahanni Papo Papo committee what is the nature of the employment opportunity barrier 1/4 - paseo that's what I understand from checking with our HR that's what man what is his position is also the Assessor now how can I be the provincial Assessor poor he's merely the OIC assessor and Coulomb who commit a legacy foul assistant provincial treasurer a provincial assessor and under the Local Government Code provision you assist the provincial assessor Prada patent but this labaik now is oh I see of the provincial Assessors offices oh I see up the back aluminium in a grid type array ho-young provincial assess or assistant provincial assess or while adding assistant so channel on our NOC bolt-in belong oh I see Assessor in the meantime the Gahanna puka me hon Ghanaian telecom problema and human resource Ilocos alumni Minneola hot nanny who sign at mama great I checked mom doing lots of provincial accounting office where it then but a lion has been the OIC for the longest time since 2009 CPA diversity who are qualified to be the provincial accountant per Indian ampicillin appropriate a so wrong that papillae po natin you Melinda qualified and then we again employed designated a set up the buckets because since the provincial attorney who advises you then he heads the back then he also heads the provincial assessment office made you poor incongruous propositions are made then he goes around the province rallying people to issue resolutions against the House of Representatives so sir mr. Chairman I move that we issue a show cause order to turn alibi out why he should not be cited in contempt for making the passing a template as alleged here in the affidavit of the all the Assessors of the province of Louis knowledge states that in the submitting during the provincial sales time attorney mas la bio informed us that he had the to attend meetings of the different leagues of Ilocos Norte we're in a resolution of support in favor of durable governor Marcos was invariably adapted and that he mentioned of a template resolution he is the provincial authority of the governor is the legal of you so he might be the author of all of this and is going all over the province denouncing the House of Representatives while he entered his appearance as frontal barely condemned to promote that he show cause order be issued him but he will personally submit to the committee any objection may I have some clarifications Danny no attorney does not appear in the resolution which was passed but it was torn illa by oku yes that's why I would try to I would like to put it on record now in paragraph four of their joint of a they say that without going over the contents of the aforementioned template and this is proven that the Sangguniang Panlalawigan resolution which has been withdrawn has exactly the same contents yes I stand corrected Jeremy thank you very much okay there's a pending motion an objection and I bring on the motion to support any further questions I think we also had subpoenaed issued to other members now we already issued a subpoena earlier we passed a motion issuing to issue a subpoena to eternal about you members of the sample division I think they were issued subpoenas to in bright ear and yes yes and I'm honestly surprised governor thank you for finally showing up may I take this equation no your honor please mr. chairman you have the floor yes as the presiding officer of the central Impala we can a pillock was not your honors with regards to the two resolutions that were passed denouncing and declaring swords and so as presiding officer mr. Chairman I would like to extend my sincerest apologies especially to the majority of Florida congressman Rodolfo Hospital Varinius to this office by the end to the house of present representatives I should have been circumspect and puddin when I presided during the passage of those resolutions please accept my sincerest apologies I am really really sorry I know how these things go thank you thank you thank you and I was saying mr. chairman subpoenas were issued to minato device governor and they're here already also anyway we have had your colleagues before they have withdrawn it see where organ under him but I'll not a problem and Poe so we moved that the subpoena be recalled already supported appearance here chairman inquire if mr. Gilbert sorry bust the vice president for operations this year he has submitted a that with the medical certificate Marisa medical certificate only we should the subpoena to him to appear for him today Marin letter shillitoe please I already booked a flight for Manila through Cebu Pacific plate number and Lesser departing Cebu this morning however I support abdominal pains apparently due to my gallbladder issue I went to I went to see my doctor advised me to rest for t25 listen be under observation for possible surgery is there a medical certificate yes he has a medical certificate signed by in area D Tyrone oil what geologists analogous because I think mr. chairman that the testimony mr. cerebus will be very very vital it was according to one of the employees of the provincial treasurer miss miss tubulin is it Apollo who said that she handed the money it miss miss gennadiy number oh and the money no but according to mr. Goh sin it was certain - ah who gave the money the payment to him in check so I think that is very vital so I hope we can get him so what is the pleasure of well we show again a subpoena would be to show cause order be issued to mr. Suri bus a new second second I second it mr. chairman only because he indeed gave a medical certificate but he did not make any commitment that he will make himself available for future meetings of this body so I second the motion for the humans operation any objection they bring on the motion scary any further questions but the his explanation should be submitted by him personally since it's under subpoena in the next hearing on October 9 mr. chairman is mr. Coleman transaction Naboo marina quarantine multi-table Halligan eighteen point six million of 460,000 and provincial government of Ilocos Norte non-major nagging masala Motel transaction lien dial nikita po natin around the building department the transaction pinyin you know construction eighteen point six million halal records feel judged not in Tulsa bidding pero I'll check I'm checkup or conducting your December 1 2011 18 point six million pesos cash cash in the papa yes your honor December 1 onion naman K dr. Fabian grow and president in a grand star Nana supply phenomena Sasaki on moved assemble to 2011 shall I be Miranda mr. March or not five million four hundred thousand persons exhibition PO and supplier Narang Sasaki on now Casa I see mr. Markkula submersible Pune the mayor and she and mr. Chua is an arrow pocket oppose Napolitan gap and cash advance an eighteen million six hundred thousand in unison abhi maja - the eighteen point six million a cinema nursery Sun lugar consignments of all at no dinner deliver aunty aunty my grand star analysis akheon VAR a new point tool at nelson opinion yes your honor okay in the gun Sheila DeVito when we December 2 2011 can happen order an acquaintance a second I've been a yahren named mr. mark Chua at Merrill bank to the auto check deposit slip shall vinegar now Mercado alpha-alpha Tom Abba mr. go yes your honor that video Jupiter branch action item and got mr. go I will not be guided in Lund check there you wanna check a pulse on a sub Rico 5,400,000 B layer and dissemble to arrow pocket a Pushmo penal double cash advance account number zero zero six nine four eight zero zero one zero eight one account owned by mr. mark chua linh I'll tell happy human biood mr. go I will Pinacate amount check deposit slip young al-mulk not in i'ma check Z and marking nothing sir I think a bit Asia Susan Otten among kebab I add a video check deposit slip 5,400,000 in table of grandstand motors and Industrial Corporation humor Al Capone and mr. Fabian go no buy ads forty units also assembled to knowledge may proceed dated December - yes your December 2 2011 Oh may I say Oh mr. Okubo unknown on transaction I don't record your own or how it was speed this is the missing record that I have a la la macchina I mean the transaction york sharpen of lane it was only is Miss Irene windows you know representing sushi I remember sir at you mr. mark Chua al-kahf Nino you down payment the 5,400,000 balaiah charity on so I'll pull payment [Music] yes your honor [Music] [Music] [Music] that's correct your honor I said then 1 7 1 billion subpoena supply 10 800 AD Nyonya in advance women 600,000 so satin mr. chair Thank You c'n green tea may acknowledge the presence of Representative nearby on the 3rd deputy speakers Sharon green representative Arnold teal and just us the mom is it true that attorney is also the chairman of the query Council he was assigned as provincial quarry as well that's Dominion hahaha provincial Assessor provincial quarry Ranieri organize who nah man nah appeal eatin cayelin Malakand melaka in talega on now ooh boss belly can be read so many like Iassogna began in yokomen on counting picasso anna-marie organised lahardee on I'm just meeting them on poet in a 27 day 25 days ago thank you are there any further questions from the members of the committee and the members without sufficient appeal devera yes mr. chair just say query with regards to a Tony Michelle L Galan is she present your honor because he is the owner and chief operating officer of the house of pre-cast's incorporated attended this meeting we have also invited [Music] we have invited miss mr. Salvador Alan died of art in formal mr. Erik saludo proprietor integrated conservation unlimited a Tony Mitchell Galan owner and chief operating officer the house of precast incorporated but there are people here who have been repeatedly invited and I'm not cheering up to may be right for the issuance of subpoena because they're not voluntarily assisting the committee same mother the robust our body to you well this elevation impetus a Miss well this you miss punk techno dimension a mind on it on Ted valgus what is the position now miss Valdes miss Josie thanking your honors his no miss grace baldesarra yes your honor Supply Officer their names were mentioned in previous testimony C as recipients of cos advances she panted administrative officer Tricia supply be sure to under the GI soldier yes sir have you submitted to us inventory of your vehicles mr. Castro owned by the province of lotion are they not yet your honor only da re can you give us an inventory especially the transactions that we are looking at for 2010 to 2011 before the 40 before the 70 there are documents here that have been marked as exhibits which tend to show that mr. go and mr. Chia also transactions were about twenty multi cups can you submit inventory of properties of the province Motor Vehicles yes your honor with the permission of the provincial government may be the inventory of vehicles were that were acquired in 2010 and 2011 other than the 40 and the 70 because we can I will issue a subpoena duces tecum boom in the economy tomato potato Parramatta we would want to finish our resolution already by the next hearing in October 9 at Makaha October 13 otherwise this will drag again until November so we are appealing to you never submit assignment document say and as far as these eight 8/2 numbered resolution is concerned mara Bannerman upon opinion of this hearing but this is the first time for that earlier transactions were alluded to and documents required a subpoena duces tecum is not necessary that in pune mean an among the record Numair on [Music] [Music] [Music] good afternoon mr. chair I am Roxana castro of the legal office of the pci and your honor miss grace I asked me to have this honorable committee to receive her letter because she's on her eighth month of pregnancy and upset shaken she is not fit to travel and his advice to have a complete bed rest for one week so she was not able to attend today's this is to respectfully inform the Nobel Committee that I will not be able to attend deliberation scheduled on September 25 for the reason that I am currently hospital due to my sensitive and delicate pregnancy or gel copy of my medical certificate and my obstetrical Cassandra port assured to attach show that I am presently unfit to travel on advice of a complete bed rest bed bed rest for one week attached she read is a medical certificate in Shambala possibilities eight months you know that is that would be very hard for her to travel so you up at Milan because I think there it is very delicate non-indictment pregnancy it is very hard for a for a female to travel log eight month pregnancy water bottle where are we - is she still connected with Cora rampages nominally bitter heavy rain this one is you put our if that is right Paula Galen for self and improve its visible over Thursday yes miss him - upper part of the provincial government below snorty as a consultant I know Mon know we all know mr. Bravo mr. Franco submitted a letter informing us focused 29 didn't develop any motion yes mr. Chairman I move that those aforementioned personalities we should subpoena the next scheduled committee meeting your honor please I request the committee secretary to mr. [Music] Salvatore Holland I'm sorry erik sorbo atonia Michelle Phelan any seconded the motion and the objection to being on the motions carried any part there were questions there being none any motion to adjourn before we adjourn again may remind everyone that the next hearing on the two resolutions regarding this matter will be in October 9 9:30 a.m. any motion in a second the hearing is now adjourned thank you to everyone you you
