I couldn't help but wonder... is SATC season 3 dated, or it only gets better with each rewatch?

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments
Captions
So, I rewatched Sex and the City season 3 and I  really didn't have to do it because this is my   favorite SATC season, I've seen it million times  and at this point, I know it by heart. At last,   we finally get Anthony, Aidan, Trey,  and the best side character ever,   Bunny McDougall. This is the season where  Carrie basically sabotages her own happiness,   Charlotte realizes that life isn't a fairytale,  Miranda tries to become more vulnerable but fails,   and Samantha is the most non-judgmental  friend one could ever have. As always,   I'm not analyzing this season episode by episode  but rather by breaking down the main characters,   their arcs, their fashion, etc., which  means there will be spoilers. Also,   get ready for unhinged fashion TED Talks as  season 3 serves some of the most iconic Sex and   the City looks like the Dior newspaper print  dress, and the Prada lipstick skirt, as well   as the abundance of flower brooches, and mostly  authentic Fendi baguettes. So let's get into it. I know I usually start with Carrie but you  know what? Charlotte was given nothing but   breadcrumbs of storylines in the past two seasons  and now it is finally her time to shine. So let   her have her moment. Her character's arc starts  already in the first episode. She's not wasting   any time. The whole Staten Island episode is  heavily fairytale-themed with Carrie having her   Cinderella moment, the White Knight rescue fantasy  discussion, and Charlotte making a wish. But you   know what I say, be careful what you wish for. -  I'm getting married this year! From that moment   onwards Charlotte really becomes committed  to finding her future husband and getting   married. After a couple of bad dates with the  guy with anger management issues, The bad kisser,   The guy who insults women in order to achieve  satisfaction, Charlotte finally meets her future   husband Trey while being dressed in the iconic  Prada skirt. Now then, two things. Number one.   Listen I know, trust me, I know that Trey is dull  af, and he has the worst sense of humor ever, but   he is played by the one and only Kyle MacLachlan,  and we stand Kyle MacLachlan in this household.   Do you guys remember this meme from a couple of  years ago about Disney princesses being a reason   for our unrealistic hair expectations? Well,  Kyle MacLachlan, or should I say Special Agent   Dale Cooper, because that's who he is to me, gave  me unrealistic hair expectations when it comes to   straight white men over 30. You'll understand  when you're older. And the thing number two:   the Prada skirt. If you've been following the  media surrounding fashion on Sex and the City   I'm sure that you've noticed that Charlotte's  lipstick print skirt is usually considered one   of the most memorable pieces of clothing from  the entire show. But what those fashion writers   fail to explain is precisely why this Prada  spring 2000 skirt is so amazing. After all,   the length is pretty conservative, and the print  itself is quite peculiar. Now, I don't want to   flex on you (I mean maybe a little I do) but I do  own an entire look from the same Prada collection,   and I would call myself a vintage Prada enthusiast  so.... welcome to my fashion Ted Talk. Miuccia   Prada's spring 2000 collection paid homage to  Yves Saint Laurent, hence the prints of lips,   hearts, and lipsticks but it was also referencing  the depiction of upper classes in films of Luis   Buñuel and Michelangelo Antonioni. Both directors  usually placed their films in higher societies,   aiming to expose the facade of the bourgeoisie,  that below the glamorous surface lurks corruption,   loneliness, and superficial relationships without  real emotional intimacy between romantic partners.   Do you see where I'm going with this? Muccia Prada  also said that behind her spring 2000 collection   stood the idea of "a lady who's not a lady, a  lady who pretends to be proper". And we all know   that Charlotte isn't such a goody-goody after  all. - Yes. That's right, aha, don't stop. Just   like that. So having Charlotte wear the lipstick  skirt in the scene when she meets Trey pretty much   serves as a sad foreshadowing of their marriage.  Exactly like the heroines of Buñuel and Antonioni,   Charlotte leads a seemingly picture-perfect life.  On the surface level, she has everything she ever   dreamed about: a handsome husband, who is a heart  surgeon. A heart surgeon you guys, who can mend   her broken heart! Oh, so perfect. She lives in  this gorgeous apartment filled with lavish china   sets, dust-ruffle-less beds, and whatnot. But deep  inside she becomes incredibly lonely, she's stuck   in a marriage with a guy who can't express his  emotions and refuses to address his problems,   which only leads Charlotte to become more and more  sexually frustrated. Pretty much like Catherine   Deneuve’s Severine in Luis Bunuel’s 1967 film  called Belle de Jour. - Damn it! I just really   want to be f. In Patricia Field we trust. We  might not always agree with her styling choices,   especially in her latest work, but you can tell  me that this level of film and fashion knowledge   isn't something worth admiring. - My marriage is a  fake Fendi. And that's pretty much what happens to   Charlotte in season three. She goes from being  single to married for three months to finally   separated in the last episode. - Charlotte kissing  the gardener. - Charlotte you're a McDougall now. oh my God, Bunny is this what you call Tradition?  Now, I know that it is tempting to mock Charlotte   for her willingness to get married for the sake of  being married, especially now that cohabitation,   and staying single forever is socially  acceptable. But I can guarantee you that   there are still many communities that value  more traditional family structures, and until   this day many women experience immense pressure  to get married. And even in the SATC universe,   we had characters like Lexi Featherston, who  was supposed to serve as a cautionary tale to   all the party girls out there. You can be single  and fabulous exclamation mark, but only until   a certain age. Past that all that is left for  you is to settle down, and if you don't *sigh* I wouldn't necessarily call myself a certified  Charlotte apologist, but I like that she   learns from her mistakes which allows her to  grow as a person. And even in this season,   there were a couple of moments when she  was letting go of this rigid idea of the   person that she was supposed to be. The most  noticeable one was when Charlotte and Trey   sat on the floor in Charlotte's apartment after  they separated, and they had what it felt to be,   their first honest conversation ever. It  literally took them an entire season to   finally openly talk about their emotions. And  I really liked that at this moment Charlotte   didn't care if her hair is messy, or what  will her neighbors think about it. You know,   stupid things Charlotte cares about. Also,  Charlotte dressed as a drag king. 10 out of 10. Okay, so here's a thing. 20 years ago being  a Carrie was aspirational, right? Celebrities   wanted to be her, designers were dying to dress  her, but now, I'm assuming as a form of rejection   of this worldwide obsession with her character  people became overly judgmental of her actions and   personality. And listen, I don't say she doesn't  deserve any criticism but aren't we a little too   harsh? where is the middle ground? Because she  is the way she is by the design. Sometimes she's   relatable, other times she's a mess, or annoying  and that's what makes her character feel like a   human because humans are complex. Let me use  an example. At the beginning of season three,   Carrie finds out about Big and Natasha's  wedding. This leads to her pondering about women,   who simply exist to make us feel bad about  ourselves, which in Carrie's case this woman   of course is Natasha. But the thing is that  Natasha was nothing but kind and sweet to   Carrie. She never said anything mean to her,  she never gave her a side-eye or did anything   to indicate that she secretly disliked her.  If anything I would assume that Natasha was   the one to be petrified of the celebrity  columnist her husband dated. But of course,   we never see Natasha's perspective in all  of this. - She's shiny hair, style section   Vera Wang and I'm the sex column they  run next to ads for penile implants.   It is very tempting and easy to call out  Carrie for acting really immature here,   being deeply insecure, and projecting her  own insecurities on Natasha. Which, yes,   she does. But at the same time, don't you  just want to hug her? And tell her: Bestie,   start practicing self-love, go with Charlotte  to those affirmation classes or something, and   don't let your own insecurities ruin your life.  Really this scene is so painful. Carrie basically   realizes that Big wasn't, I don't know, forced  into this marriage, right? He chose Natasha.   They have their own song. OMG, this scene is so  profoundly sad. Don't you want to just tear up?   Just a little bit? And that's what I mean when  I say Carrie is a complex character. She can be   insufferable and relatable at the same time!  Luckily, to Carrie's rescue appears Aidan,   the perfect boyfriend archetype who hates  smoking. And okay. After some ups and downs,   Carrie finally quit smoking for him but imagine  how bad must have her apartment still smell. Like,   cigarette smell lingers in houses for years and  years after quitting. And if I were such a smoke   hater I don't think I would want to hang out  at Carrie's apartment as much as Aidan does.   Anyway, Aidan is sweet, lovable, he's a handyman  who can repair a sink if it's broken. That's a   huge asset if you ask me. He's tall, loves dogs,  and introduces Carrie to his parents, unlike Mr.   Big in season one. - You make me really happy.  Aidan really feels like a great guy. He's just   not a guy for someone like Carrie, who thrives on  drama. Ultimately, this is why Carrie was so drawn   to Mr. Big because he just fed her with endless  supplies of drama. Like, that must be it! Because   if you think about it, he is so not interesting as  a character. All we know about him, at this point,   is that he is this Big Fish in New York, goes  to church with his mother, his ex-wife is a book   editor, and he listens to old music. Also, his  name is John. Ok, technically we don't know this   yet but come on he's such not a John. He's not  a romantic type, nor particularly generous. He   doesn't have a great sense of humor except for  those rare scenes, it's usually one scene per   season, when he's hilariously funny. This season  is the drunk Big at the furniture fair. There's   something about him saying "beige, beige  everything in my house is beige" that is   really funny for me. To which Carrie famously  responds: - I thought you wanted beige, meaning   Natasha is the beige vanilla simple girl from The  Way We Were. After meeting Aidan, and realizing   that Carrie has moved on, Big starts to leave her  voicemails, he randomly shows up at her apartment.   Until Carrie decides to sabotage her own life by  starting an affair with him. I'm not gonna lie to   you I find this elevator scene very disturbing  and the whole affair to be pretty raw. Because   it's not like Carrie and Big go on romantic  trips to Paris or something, you know, like   they do in the movies. No, they just meet in those  progressively cheaper hotels and they are kind of   mean to each other. It almost feels like  a form of addiction. It was fun at first,   but it's not anymore, and they just don't know  how to stop. Which I assume is a continuation of   season 2 idea that Carrie is addicted to toxic  relationships and she's a masochist for being   with Mr Big. And we all know what happens next.  Natasha catches Carrie in her own apartment,   falls from the stairs while chasing her, breaks  her tooth, and finally decides to divorce Big.   After a couple of weeks, Carrie is still driven by  guilty conscience and stalks Natasha to her lunch.   There is surprisingly a lot of stocking in this  season, I noticed. But yeah, this is Carrie at her   lowest. There is no excuses to her actions. Not  only she ruined Natasha's marriage but she also   ruined her lunch and had the audacity to drink  Natasha's water. That's a no for me. But hey,   at least she was dressed in the one and only Dior  newspaper print dress. And you know what it means?   The fashion Ted Talk number two. The whole season  3 of Sex and the City is basically an ad for John   Galliano-era Dior. No judgment here, just pure  facts. Carrie happens to own the Dior Saddle bag   in pretty much every finish this bag was produced  at the time. Personally, I never got the appeal   of the Dior Saddle bag, mostly because I would  call myself a Dior malice girly, which is another   Galliano designed bag for Dior. - My Christian  Dior purse. - I'll get it! I always imagine that   if Carrie ever met real-life John Galliano, their  conversation would be similar to the one she had   with Carrie Fisher. - I'm Carrie, you're Carrie.  I write, you write. Carrie would be like: you   love fashion, I love fashion. You're problematic,  I'm problematic. Let me wear your designs because   we're a match made in heaven. Because so it  happens that John Galliano came up with this   print idea after noticing unhoused Parisians using  newspapers to protect themselves from freezing...   But wait! There is more! Galliano was also  inspired by the 1920s and 30s Trump balls   where wealthy Parisians dressed up as peasants  um basically for fun. If I were him, I would   just say I'm referencing Elsa Schiaparelli,  or this 1866 screen-printed ball gown. But   ok. Sarah Jessica Parker looks incredible and this  dress. The whole collection was really successful,   and until this day it is one of the most known  Dior collections ever. But back to this scene.   After endless internet searches I still can't  find who designed Natasha's pink dress. It   actually looks so different from anything she  wore on the show. Not just because of the color,   but the fabric, and the overall retro feel.  And then it caught me thinking. What if she's   wearing a Dior dress too... but it's vintage  Dior? Huh? After all, Carrie and Natasha are   each other opposites yet they fell from the same  guy. Similarly, Christian Dior and John Galliano   had totally different styles, dressed totally  different women yet they both created under the   same label. Is this an over interpretation? Yes,  yes, it is. But I'm gonna run with it regardless. In season 3 Samantha is a National Treasure  and should be protected at all costs. She's   our trisexual queen - I'm a trisexual. I'll  try anything once. A proud bisexual ally. She   has that brilliant HIV test scene, and she's  a non-judgmental and supportive friend. What   an icon. - Don't you want to judge me? Just  a little bit? - Not my style. Since Samantha   wasn't giving a love interest, and in season four  she literally gets two, I've been thinking about   her relationship with Charlotte. Shoutout to you  bestie for suggesting this topic. And honestly,   after watching this season I started to understand  those wild conspiracy theories about Miranda   Samantha and Charlotte being just different parts  of Carrie's psychic, or that Carrie as a writer   invented them for the sake of her column. Look,  I understand that Samantha and Charlotte don't   really have that much in common, or at least until  now in the show they don't, and that's why they   rarely hang out together. It's usually Carrie who  unites the group. That's fine. Plus Sex and The   City often pits the characters against each other.  Like in season four it's Charlotte and Miranda:   Charlotte has a baby fever, but she's infertile.  Miranda on the other hand, accidentally gets   pregnant and considers terminating her pregnancy.  Likewise in season three, we get the conflict   between Samantha and Charlotte and there are  different views on sex. And it does sound like   a good idea, and in some scenes it works. This was  a very cute moment. But for me the psychology just   isn't there. What’s in this friendship for  Samantha? Why she puts up with Charlotte's   continuous sl*t-shaming, dramatically leaving  their branches, and basically her pure disgust   of Samantha's lifestyle. And I don't understand  why Samantha forgives her so quickly. They had   this massive fight before Charlotte's wedding in  this bridal salon. Charlotte said some awful awful   things. She once again sl*t-shamed Samantha, and  revealed that she only invited Samantha to her   wedding so that she didn't feel left out. And the  next scene is Charlotte's wedding and they are all   good. Like what!? I know that one does not Watch  Sex and the City for realism but this fight scene   could be the least realistic thing in the entire  show. Not Carrie's excessive shoe collection,   nor her apartment, but the fact that  this fight didn't end their friend group. As much as I love Miranda and Steve, their  chemistry and relationship, this season I   felt like we've seen enough of Steve. In  season two he was so charming and lovable   but in season three he was giving me some serious  Nate from The Devil Wears Prada vibes. You know,   like a whiny boyfriend, who acts all childish  and vilifies his girlfriend for thriving in   her career. Miranda was working so hard to get  a promotion at her work and he was like "ooooh   let's get a puppy, let's have a baby, watch me  play basketball". Steve, GROWN UP! Especially   since Miranda really tried to open up and be  more vulnerable with him. I really loved their   fight scene at the beginning of season when Steve  wanted to move in with Miranda ,which of course   absolutely terrified her. Whenever I think about  Miranda the word control comes to mind. You know,   she's a corporate lawyer, her life is all  about facts and figures, she's pragmatic,   direct and very analytical. So the idea  of showing someone that sometimes she   can't control everything, that her life  gets messy too so basically revealing   her true self to somebody sounds like a  really tough thing for her to do. - Steve I really tried. Single Miranda honestly  deserves her own show. Her struggles were   so real. As someone who has always been the  cute one, not the sexy one, I found myself   relating to her her inner goddess workouts,  or pretending to be a stewardess for a day,   and the overall quest of becoming a sexy Miranda.  She was just so relatable this season. - I'm on   valium. Everything's okay. No matter if she had a  hangover straight for my horror movie, or when she   felt invisible to potential mates, I don't think  I speak only for myself when I say: been there,   done that. - So uh what's like to kiss somebody  with those things? Even Miranda with braces felt   real and weirdly triggering too, because that was  a question I heard a lot as a teenager with braces   back in 2006. Ew. - You have a back pillow?  - Yeah and I'm getting old.com. On the whole,   season three is one of the strongest Sex in the  City seasons. It has so many memorable lines,   scenes, and fashion moments. But it's also a very  paradoxical season: it is dated yet it will never   get old and it only gets better with each rewatch.  In my opinion, it is extremely important to call   out SATC for its problematic storylines but we  shouldn't simultaneously lose the early 2000s   perspective. It might not feel that long ago, but  watching Carrie freely smoke indoors, and learn   about the so-called Brazilian wax feels... like a  completely different world. Back then story lines   like Miranda getting an STD or Samantha taking  an HIV test were shocking. Stuff like this was   rarely if ever shown on TV. And it wasn't just  for giggles like Charlotte getting Crabs in season   two. No, those were emotional and gripping arcs.  Samantha literally passed out because of anxiety   surrounding the test, and Miranda needed to  contact all her past sexual partners as well   as have a sincere conversation with Steve. That  sounds like hell! I also read somewhere that in   the early 2000s Sex and The City was one of few TV  shows to use certain vulgar words. Which only goes   to show how prudish television was at a time. And  SATC continues to shock even today. Just a little   bit differently. In 2023 watching Carrie being  absolutely grossed out and repulsed by the idea of   dating a bisexual guy is shocking. Same with the  episode where Samantha dated a black guy in the   show's foray into racial commentary. Aged. Like.  Milk. Yet in season 3 there are many universal   storylines like love, affair, and friendship that  will always stay relevant. I really liked how the   season further explored Carrie's friendship with  each of the girls. Charlotte was so sweet to stay   with Carrie and read together that wedding article  because she knew how emotionally difficult this   will be. Samantha was nothing but supportive of  Carrie this entire season and Miranda... Well,   I don't know if we should all be Miranda's  but we definitely should have a Miranda in   our lives. But most importantly, this season is my  warm blanket, it never fails to make me laugh. I   absolutely lose it when Miranda pretends to be a  flight attendant, or Samantha's funky spunk guy. Gets me every time. Thank you guys so so much for  watching. I'll see you in the next video. Bye!
Info
Channel: Kasia Sopniewska
Views: 90,903
Rating: undefined out of 5
Keywords: sex and the city rewatch, sex and the city review, sex and the city season 3, sex and the city newspaper dress, satc carrie, satc carrie and aiden, satc carrie and big, sex and the city lipstick, sex and the city charlotte and trey, sex and the city miranda and steve, carrie and big affair, carrie and big affair episode, carrie aidan meet, dior newspaper dress, john galliano, john galliano dior, prada lipstick, sex and the city fashion, and just like that, satc review
Id: XAxZKtTaMR0
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 24min 17sec (1457 seconds)
Published: Tue Feb 21 2023
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.