How Famous Landmarks Could Have Looked

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments
Captions
(gentle music) - [Narrator] For as long as societies have existed, humans have been building incredible monuments and landmarks dedicated to, well, humans. Some of these landmarks have been around for so long we take them for granted. But not every monument was destined to look the way it does today. Alternative designs have been pitched for almost every structure you know of. From a goth version of the Taj Mahal to a Mount Rushmore with a woman's face on it. And even weirdly wacky White House designs. Don't believe me? Well, get ready to feast your eyes on some of the boldest, coolest and craziest ways famous landmarks around the world could have turned out. (upbeat music) An edgy design. The world's fair is an important part of architectural history. When cities host the event they tend to commission impressive and amazing structures that redefine their skylines. The world's fair is responsible for landmarks like the Seattle Space Needle, Brussels Atomium and Paris' enormous guillotine. Oh wait, sorry, I meant the Eiffel Tower. Though it very nearly was a giant version of that massive head removing apparatus. When Paris landed the host position at the world's fair in 1889, the French wanted to commemorate the occasion with a new landmark. Before Gustav Eiffel's tower design was chosen, however, 700 other designs were submitted for consideration. One was a giant lighthouse nearly 1000 feet tall made of solid granite. Its designer claimed it would also feature lights so bright nearly everyone in Paris would be able to read a newspaper at night. Imagine living next to that, trying to get some sleep. The real piece de resistance though, was this pitch for an enormous guillotine right in the center of Paris. The guillotine would commemorate the French Revolution, where the French used one of these deadly devices to dispose of the Royal family and many members of the ruling class. Though it was never revealed exactly how tall this guillotine was supposed to be, it would've been big enough to make the Statue of Liberty sweat, if she ever got on the wrong side of the French people. A Capitol chicken. In many ways, the Capitol Building is at the heart of American democracy. It's housed Congress for over 120 years. It's where presidents are sworn in and where the laws of the nation are written. But for all that, it almost ended up looking like a fried chicken, fast food restaurant. In 1792, Thomas Jefferson proposed an architectural competition be held to decide on the design for the, then unbuilt, Capitol Building. Jefferson was an architect himself so he figured he could pick a design that would please his buddy, the very first President of the United States, George Washington. But there was an entry that certainly didn't impress him. This one, from amateur architect James Diamond. While the building itself isn't too bad, it featured an unfortunate irregularity at the top. This sketch is meant to represent a weather vane. And no it isn't shaped like a chicken, it's meant to be a bald eagle. The giant derpy-looking bird didn't impress Washington and in 1793, they went with William Thornton's design, which they thought expressed grandeur and beauty. Here's a fun fact for you, when they were deciding what America's national bird would be, Benjamin Franklin championed the mighty Turkey. So, as silly as Diamond's design looks, it could have been even worse. L'elephant de Triomphe. Let's move back to sophisticated Paris. And no, don't worry, they weren't proposing anything crazy like building a giant electric chair in place of the Louvre. Now, the Arc de Triomphe was commissioned by Napoleon in 1806 to commemorate and celebrate France's many military victories. Well, technically, Napoleon's many military victories. It was finished in 1836 and now stands as a testament to the enduring spirit of the French people, along with Napoleon's ego. 45 years earlier, however, a much stranger design was pitched in its place, L'Elephant Triomphal. This absolutely insane elephant monument would've featured a spiral staircase leading into the animal's belly, along with a complex drainage system so that water would be constantly spewing from its trunk. While the elephant would've only stood 33 feet tall, 130 feet smaller than the arch, it would've featured some extravagant interior decor and even a garden. Sadly, the design was rejected by the French government. However, Napoleon may have been inspired by the unused design when he commissioned the L'Elephant de Bastille monument, which was sadly never finished. This would've been only 15 minutes away from Moulin Rouge park, which also used to feature a giant elephant statue. "Why was Paris so obsessed with elephants?" I hear you ask. Well, they were just a late Renaissance fixation for the French, being perceived as noble and strong. That said, it's pretty amazing to think that Paris's skyline could have looked completely different to what it is today. Giant elephants, massive guillotines, that sounds more like some sort of fever dream than a skyline. The Full Rushmore. Mount Rushmore is dedicated to some of America's most important presidents. The monument took 14 grueling years to finish, with each face being carved out of the mountain by hand and measuring in at a staggering 60 feet. But technically it's only half finished. The project began in 1927, under the supervision of a man named Gutzon Borglum. Borglum was obsessed with the idea of a monument to the great men of American history and originally had wanted to include the bodies of the presidents in the rock face as well, just in case anyone thought they might be inappropriately shirtless below the neck. Borglum also planned to include the entire history of America but Congress eventually scaled back the project, recognizing Borglum was going overboard. However, after construction began, it was pitched that Susan B. Anthony, an important abolitionist and women's rights advocate be added to the monument. This idea was so popular that a congressional bill was written to include Susan and First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt even wrote to Borglum herself, praising the idea. So why isn't Susan on the mountain today? Well, Borglum was a massive bigot and fought tooth and nail against the idea of any women being featured on his very manly mountain. But that wasn't the only reason. The monument had already taken 14 years to carve out and adding Susan would've extended construction time to 17.5 years. Including all the bodies may have doubled that. If they wanted to include the entire history of America, well, heck they might still have been working on it today. What do you think, should old Susan have been engraved on that mountain? And if you could pick anyone else to be immortalized on Mountain Rushmore, who would it be? Elvis Presley? Michael Jordan? Hulk Hogan? Let me know down in the comments below and be sure to subscribe for more amazing content. Now, what have we got next? Enigma of the Black Taj. India's Taj Mahal is one of the most recognizable and beloved buildings in the world. But it's pristine marble hides a dark secret, literally. Shah Jahan, the once Mughal emperor of India was a great lover of grand architecture and is responsible for some amazing structures, such as the Wazir Khan and, likely, "Aladdin" inspiring Jama Masjid. When his beloved wife Mumtaz Mahal died in 1631, Jahan was so heartbroke he commissioned his greatest project yet, her mausoleum. Built over 22 years, the Taj Mahal is a marvel of engineering and was constructed to be completely symmetrical, down to the tiniest detail. It's so symmetrical, in fact, that many historians believe the Taj Mahal is incomplete. Why? Well, because there's only one. Somewhere between 1640 and 1655, Jahan actually began construction of a second Taj Mahal across the river from the first. This Mahal would've been identical to the first in every way except for one, instead of white marble, it would've been made from pitch black stone. This would further the beautiful symmetry begun in the original and Jahan plans to be buried in the dark Taj across from his wife. Unfortunately, after his passing, Jahan's children were so preoccupied fighting each other over the emperor's inheritance that the project was all but forgotten. Talk about having a dark past. #quadrupletowers. September 11th, 2001 was a dark day for New York City. An attack on the World Trade Center devastated both the near 1800 feet Twin Towers and left a huge mark in American history. It was eventually decided that a new World Trade Center would be constructed not far from the original site. While SOMs One World Trade Center design won the honor of being built, the competition was heated and several alternative designs were proposed. Foster + Partners, for example, put forward this towering horrifying sun blotting design that has more angles than a geometry class. Shigeru Ban pitched this design, which either looks like an untextured building from a video game or like Spider-Man has just done a couple laps around it. The proposal that takes the cake, however, has to be the Richard Meier and Partners design. The RMP Design would've featured not one, not two but five towers. Each over 1000 feet tall. What's more, each tower would be connected to the next through a series of skyscraper bridges, making them resemble a series of enormous hashtags. Even they admitted this themselves but argued the sign promotes harmony, stability and dignity. You can really tell they wrote that before Twitter existed. Zany Ziggurats. When you picture the Lincoln Memorial, what descriptors come to mind? Probably words like stoic, proud and dignified, right? You don't think horrifying, imposing or a cult. Well that's because they didn't go for one of the rejected designs, which are all pretty crazy. One featured a giant ancient Egyptian looking pyramid. While another was an ancient Greek Parthenon-style building. Real lack of originality on display here guys. The best and scariest ripoff, however, must be this, the Lincoln Ziggurat. Ziggurats are tiered pyramids made from large steps and trace their origins to ancient Mesopotamia. They also look a little too threatening for a memorial if you ask me. I mean, imagine the giant Lincoln statue perched on top of this staring down at you. Not quite as inspiring as it is terrifying. The ziggurat appears to be about 100 feet tall, so about the height of a nine story building, and would've featured an entrance at the base. What would've been inside was never depicted, presumably a sacrificial chamber where you would offer your firstborn to High Lord Lincoln. In the end, they went with the much less ostentatious Lincoln Memorial we all know today. It was unveiled on May 30th, 1922 and dedicated by former president William Taft. I'm sure he was wondering when his giant memorial was going to be built the whole time. Sorry Taft, not yet. Mario Kart Bridge. London Bridge is a beautiful and iconic piece of architecture. For over a century, it's been one of London's most enduring and defining landmarks. Except this isn't London Bridge, it's Tower bridge. This miserable, boring slab of concrete is London Bridge. Don't feel bad though, mixing these two up must be one of the most common labeling mistakes in the world. It probably wouldn't happen as much, however, if Tower Bridge had gone with another proposed design. This incredibly unique bridge, proposed by FJ Palmer back in the 19th century, resembles a fancy figure eight but it kind of looks like it's been plucked straight off a Mario Kart track. So, assuming you don't have any red shells to contend with while you're crossing this thing, how would it work? Well, each loop of the bridge features two retractable sections at either side. This meant that, if a ship needed to pass, one section could be retracted and the ship could enter the center of the loop. And then, once the first section was replaced, the other end could be retracted. This would mean a ship could pass through the bridge without foot traffic ever stopping. While that may seem like a lot of hassle, it's far more considerate to road users than the current bridge, which grinds traffic to a halt whenever a ship passes by. So why was this design rejected? Well, it's possible it was just too complex. The Tower Bridge we know today took eight years, and 70,000 tons of concrete, 10,000 tons of steel and 432 workers across five different companies to build. But it's possible that creating four experimental sliding bridges would've taken even more than that. Although that's just a theory. Why do you think this design never materialized? Let me know down in the comments. The Knock-off of Liberty. The Statue of Liberty is one of the most iconic American symbols there is. But what if I told you that this 150 foot tall lady wasn't meant to embody America at all? She was actually meant to represent Egypt. When egomaniac Auguste Bartholdi visited Egypt in 1855, he didn't feel awe at the country's wonders, he felt jealous. He took one look at the carvings of Abu Simbel and thought it was only fair he have a giant statue in the country too. Think I'm being harsh? He once said, "The Americans believe liberty illuminates the world, in reality, it's my genius." Geez, I'm amazed he wasn't confused for one of those giant carvings, seeing how big his head was. So Auguste got to work. Eventually designing this statue, called Egypt Carrying the Light to Asia. It was an 86 foot tall statue of an Egyptian farmer on a 48 foot tall pedestal. It was meant to represent the industrialization of Egypt and is much humbler looking than the Statue of Liberty. It would have had a glowing niqab though. It was meant to stand at the Suez Canal, which Egypt had recently finished. The canal is of huge importance to Egypt, even today thousands of ships pass through it every year, earning the country billions of dollars. So why isn't this lady of light there to welcome them? Probably because the country had to take out a high interest loan of over 1 billion Egyptian pounds to finish the project and didn't wanna cough up for a new statue as well. And, after all, they've already got hundreds. Annoyed, Bartholdi quickly, and lazily, repurposed the design. France commissioned it for the equivalent of $6.7 million before gifting it to America, making the Statue of Liberty a knockoff re-gift of a monument. Oof, that's got me right in the patriotism. White House Washout. The White House is one of the most well known and important buildings in America and has been the home of 46 presidents and more than twice as many presidential dogs. Being the seat of power for one of the most powerful nations in modern history, it makes sense that there was some deliberation over the design for the White House. A competition held and judged by George Washington, that previously mentioned first ever president, eventually landed on Irish architect James Hoban's design. Don't tell Washington but Hoban actually modeled the entire design on Leinster House in Dublin, his hometown. There were several competing designs that nearly made it through though. This boxy design was submitted by Phillip Hart but wasn't considered sophisticated or elegant enough for Washington. Here's a pitch from James Diamond, who you'll remember from his rejected Capitol design. It's distinctive but the staircases are positioned awkwardly far from the building's entrance. Wait, hang on, go back a picture. Seriously, James, let the chicken go. Founding Father and future president Thomas Jefferson also happened to be an architect and submitted this design influenced by classical European architecture. While Jefferson had no hard feelings about losing the competition, he also couldn't resist making a few upgrades to the White House while he was president. Like building a wine cellar and installing two water closets upstairs. I guess he really did win in the end. Burgeoning Khalifa. The Burj Khalifa currently stands as the world's tallest skyscraper, coming in at a staggering 2,716 feet and 140 floors. And hey, if that isn't magnificent enough for you, it almost had a cape. In 2014, designers OP-EN pitched what would've been the largest art installation in the world. Their idea was to wrap the Burj Khalifa, which again, I must stress, is the biggest building in the world, in a super lightweight fabric. The installation was to be called Exo-Burj, with the fabric imitating the Burj Khalifa's own reflective facade. From a distance, the Khalifa would've theoretically reflected the urban landscape of Dubai. Whereas, up close, it would've reflected the viewer. Fan shaped support structures would've cascaded down, keeping the material in place. This would've turned the Burj Khalifa into the world's tallest mirror, which I'm sure all the local birds would've appreciated. If the Burj Khalifa is 2,716 feet tall and has a width of about 557 feet, this would mean that the veil would be equal to 243,668 square feet of material. Mm that's bigger than two entire Manhattan city blocks. So why didn't the Burj become a giant reflective tube? Well, it may have been pitched at a bad time. In 2014, the Burj Khalifa's management announced they couldn't even afford to keep air conditioning and elevators running. So giving the building the world's biggest bridal veil probably wasn't at the top of their priority list. The Washington Shrine. The Washington Monument stands today as one of America's most enduring, elegant and uncomplicated landmarks. Nothing wrong with being simple but it wasn't always destined to be so understated. After architect Robert Mills won a competition to design a monument commemorating America's founding father, George Washington, he went nuts. His initial 1836 proposal was this enormous, almost religious-looking, structure. At the base was a large classical style temple 250 feet in diameter and 100 feet high. From the center, a huge 500 foot column would emerge, with a statue of Washington riding a horse drawn carriage resting over the main entrance. So what happened? Well, the National Washington Monument Society, who ran the competition, relied on public funds. As it turns out ambitious, unique and grand projects estimated to cost more than $1 million, roughly $30 million today, don't mix super well with public funding. Construction didn't even begin until 1848, 12 years after Mills submitted his entry. And in 1856, the money and enthusiasm for the project completely dried up. The monument sat unfinished for decade after decade before Congress had to step in in 1876, 40 years after the competition began. By this point, Mills was long dead. And maybe that's for the best. When Congress took over the project, they stripped Mills' design down to the cheapest thing they could call a finished job. While it stands now at an impressive 555 feet, that's still 45 feet short of what Mills envisioned. Well, compared to what it could have been, the Washington Monument today looks more like a Washington toothpick. Sydney Danger House. The Sydney Opera House is one of the world's most recognizable buildings. Love it or hate it, there's no denying that its design is distinct, memorable and totally one of a kind. That's why it's so bizarre to learn that, not only could it have looked different, but it was nearly the total opposite of the building we know today. In 1956, the international competition to design the national opera house was opened and eventually won by Danish architect Jorn Utzon. But an American architect named Joseph Marzella came in close second place with this blueprint. Its brutalist design features sharp angles and invokes a much more powerful and intimidating feel. You know, exactly what you want for the opera. In all seriousness though, it's pretty interesting they went with the design they did. Utzon's entry into the competition was just as bold as Marzella's, but felt lighter, freer and more playful. Looking at the two designs side by side though, I don't know if the current design could look much lighter or fluffier, unless of course it was made out of pastry. I bet the acoustics in there would be terrible though. Life Under Glass. The sixties were a time of great change in America. Music was becoming more experimental, youths were converting to hippyism and mad super villains were trying to encase cities in giant snow globes. No I'm not joking. Meet eccentric architect R Buckminster Fuller who, in 1960, came up with the crazy idea to build a giant glass dome over Manhattan. This dome would've been made from wire reinforced shatterproof glass. At its full height, Fuller's dome would've reached a whole mile into the air and stretched from 62nd street all the way to 22nd street, making it 1.8 miles in diameter. In Fuller's vision, the dome would resemble a glistening hemisphere of mirror from the outside. Sounds like more of a road hazard to me. So what would the benefits be of life under the dome? According to Fuller, it would keep cities comfortable regulated temperature all year round, saving individuals up to 80% on heating. The city would also not have to pay for snow removal, which Fuller claims would've paid for the dome within 10 years. While his exact math on this costing is unknown, today New York City pays 1.8 million per inch of snowfall it removes. Now, to be fair, old Bucky, he wasn't totally nuts. In his proposal, he acknowledged the project likely wouldn't get funding but that it would be an excellent way to design cities in the future. What do you think, would you mind living in a giant fishbowl? Let me know down in the comments. Christ the Transporter. Since it was finished in 1931, Christ the Redeemer, or Cristo Redentor, has arguably become Brazil's most well known landmark. The nearly 100 foot tall statue is known for its warm, open arms, which themselves span 90 feet. That's almost as long as three school buses. Because of the statue's positioning, it looks like Christ is opening his arms wide, ready to embrace the city of Rio de Janeiro below. Surely this is a commentary on Christ's warm, loving, and forgiving nature. Nope. Originally Christ was just meant to be carrying a bunch of stuff. The statue was commissioned by a group of Brazilians who feared, after World War I, that Brazil was at risk of becoming a less God-fearing nation. They viewed the statue as a way to reclaim Rio on behalf of Christianity. The original design by Heitor da Silva Costa had Jesus carrying an enormous cross in one hand and a globe in the other. While this was probably symbolic of, I don't know, Christ's morning forearm routine, you've gotta admit it looks a lot busier than the final design. Even people at the time mocked the mock up, dubbing it the less rousing Christ With A Ball monument. Da Silva Costa eventually teamed up with a man named Carlos Oswald and together they decided that Christ himself should be the cross. Inspired thinking there. Although I like to think he's just lining up for the most catastrophic crowd surf in history. (upbeat music) And there you have it, a little sneak peek into an alternate world where Manhattan's under a dome, there's a chicken on the White House and Mount Rushmore still isn't finished. Which was your favorite design? Are there any you wish had been built instead of what we ended up getting? Let me know down in the comments and thanks for watching.
Info
Channel: BE AMAZED
Views: 3,300,682
Rating: undefined out of 5
Keywords: beamazed, be amazed, top 10, whitehouse alternative designs, eiffel tower alternative designs, alternative designs nyc, alternative designs capitol building, alternative designs statue of liberty, alternative designs arc de triomphe elephant, alternative designs mount rushmore, how mount rushmore could've looked, the black taj mahal, alternative designs how the world trade centre could've looked, sydney opera house croissant, manhattan glass dome, nyc glass dome design
Id: fDCGtlzAYvc
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 27min 20sec (1640 seconds)
Published: Wed Mar 23 2022
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.