Finding Arthur's Old House In Red Dead Redemption 2 & Who REALLY Murdered His Wife And Son! (RDR2)

hey how's it going guy who's mr. boss for the win here and in today's Red Dead Redemption 2 video we're gonna be trying to find Arthur's old house where it actually might be located and who really killed his son Isaac and the mother of his son Eliza we're gonna be discussing all of that in this video today so before we can begin I'm sure there's some you guys that don't know that Arthur had a son and I don't know if this individual was his wife temporarily or just the mother of his son but we actually hear about this information in a optional mission that occurs in chapter 6 Arthur and reigns fall are riding on horseback through the grizzly mountains and Arthur starts to talk about his son and Eliza take a listen to this [Music] don't talk about it much what was his name Isaac his mother the last waitress I met but she got pregnant she knew who I was what my life was I didn't want to promise nothing I couldn't keep but I said I'd do right by them every few months I'd stop by there for a few days he was such a good kid she was too I guess just a kid 19 what happened one day saw two crosses outside I knew right away turned out some bastards had come through robbed shot him dead now for $10 pardon me meaning that kind of pain wait where are you going but I know now that you don't get to live a bad life and have good things happen to you I think you're being hard on yourself maybe all I can do now is try and make some things right okay so that background right there was important because we understand that Eliza and Isaac are not alive and that Arthur returned to their home one day and there were two crosses buried out front and he knew right away that they had been murdered so now that you know that the next thing we need to do is take a look at a scene from the official trailer for Red Dead Redemption - this is the third trailer this short scene right here has Arthur walking away from a small house and you can see there are two graves and I think that these are the graves of Isaac and Eliza now the reason I was inspired to dive into this mystery is because one of the top posts on the Red Dead mystery subreddit it's like the second one of all time the second highest there is called this is Arthur's old home and it points to a location in game that looks to fit the description of Arthur's home so I was very interested in this and I wanted to check it out to see if this made sense as indeed being Arthur's old home so it's actually located in Lemoine basically what you want to do is find the oh in bayou and this small homestead will be located right there now the first thing that could indicate why this is Arthur's old home or the home of Eliza and Isaac is because of those two graves that are located out front and this small homestead has those exact two graves one of the crosses is in perfect condition and one of the crosses seems to be sort of worn down and broken over so these could be the graves of Isaac and Eliza and if we actually go inside of the house we can gather some more information as well that might indicate that this is Arthur's old house the reason for that is on the mantel of the fireplace there's a statue of a deer or a stag which of course we know is Arthur's spirit animal if he chooses to have good honor so those are all the things that make sense that point to the fact that yes this could be Arthur's old home now let's talk about the things that don't make sense the first is that this is located in Lemoine and Lemoine is based off of real-life Louisiana like super deep in the south Arthur has stated on many occasions that he has never been this far south and that Isaac and Eliza he actually met them in the Northeast I would have to speculate somewhere like Ohio or something like that it definitely wasn't anywhere that we experienced in game because in Chapter four when the gang officially moves to San Denis or at least really close to it Arthur says many times that not only does he not like this area at all he can't stand it but this is his first time seeing a big city like San Denis and that wouldn't make sense if his old home was just a couple of feet away from that big city so those are all things that don't make sense the graves are I think a coincidence and I think that the dear statue is a coincidence as well it's quite a convenient one but I think the location we saw in that third trailer is not in the game like maybe Rockstar cut that content from the actual game and they just used it for the trailer that's kind of what I'm thinking now the next thing I want to dive into is who murdered Eliza and Isaac because that's what Arthur said happened to them they were murdered all for ten dollars and it got me thinking who would be capable of doing something like this well the serial killer of course now in case you guys have no idea who the serial killer is the serial killer Edmund Lowry jr. actually has three clues that you need to find scattered throughout the world one of them is in West Elizabeth one of them is in New Hanover and one of them is in Lemoine essentially what you need to find is three hanging torsos or bodies and there's going to be three pieces of a map that you ultimately need to put together and once you've collected all three of these pieces it will lead you to an area called Lucky's cabin which is just on the outskirts of Valentine this is where the serial killers lair I guess you could say is and one of the things that's interesting on the inside is he has a lot of like newspaper clippings of his crimes like all the murders that he's committed and a lot of them extend further out than we've seen like in territories and places that aren't even mentioned in game like they bring up Ohio in California and New York so it seems as if the serial killer has been around and has done more than just murder people in the five states that we see in game okay so how does this relate to Eliza well if we actually go on the other side of I guess his little bunker you can see a very interesting poster and that poster is actually for a girl that he is I guess going after or a missing girl called Eliza bloom now it is kind of hard to read the wanted poster but you guys can see there that it's reward for the information on a missing girl Eliza bloom she was last seen near Valentine in the Dakota River now we don't know what Eliza's last name is but it could have possibly been bloom and I don't know if that fits the description of Arthur's lover or at least the mother of her son but it is interesting I don't know any other Eliza's in game and Rockstar goes like out of their way to put this in the middle of our view here which again kind of interesting stuff now as you guys know if you try and complete this serial killer mystery you actually go into the final room of his little bunker and if you inspect the knife on the floor you'll actually get knocked out by the serial killer and long story short you wake up and he talks to you for a little bit and then you have the option to throw like a severed head at him however I wanted to see if we would get more lines of dialogue from him maybe he would bring up Eliza and Isaac if we did nothing so that's what I wanted to find out and this is what happened do you like Payne is it your friend it's about to become your very close friend very close but when it's over great liao there's no point fighting you might as well try and relax a little bit [Music] [Laughter] okay so even though that was incredibly creepy and we end up getting killed by the serial killer he didn't give us any further lines of dialogues or any more details regarding Isaac and Eliza so a little disappointing as far as that goes and we don't get any further clues from the serial killer when we actually get caught up by him or when we turn him in whether he did anything to Arthur or his family Eliza or Isaac in fact he doesn't even seem to know who Arthur is but then again he might not have because remember Arthur got there after the murders had been committed now the only reason why I would suspect that this is not the same Eliza is I think the serial killer murders four different intentions it seems as if Eliza and Isaac were murdered because they were getting robbed Arthur if you remember says it was all for ten dollars so I don't know if Edmund Lowry jr. would kill someone for ten dollars I think he does it for the sport of it and not so the money overall these are two interesting theories I don't know if they have enough legs to stand up on their own I think there's a lot of things that debunk Arthur's old house I legitimately think Rockstar cut that from the game altogether and I think that the serial killer even though he has murdered a ton of people it doesn't fit the description of the type of you know murder in person that he would go after in order for to commit like one of his crazy crimes but then again I could be wrong as always I'd love to hear from you guys in the comments down below please let me know what you think about both of these mysteries that we covered today do you ever think we will get to see Arthur's old house in the game will we get more back story on Eliza and Isaac let me know your thoughts opinions and more in the comments down below I'd love to hear from you guys down there if you did go and enjoy this video though a like rating would of course be awesome and subscribe to my youtube channel if you are new you like daily Red Dead Redemption to videos like this with all the way guys like I said thanks so much for watching take care and I'll see you guys in the next video

Channel: MrBossFTW

Views: 1,336,908

Keywords: rdr2, red dead redemption 2, rdr2 arthur wife, rdr2 arthur wife and son, rdr2 arthur morgan wife, rdr2 eliza, rdr2 eliza bloom, rdr2 eliza and isaac, rdr2 arthur isaac, rdr2 arthur eliza, rdr2 arthur's home, rdr2 arthur's house, rdr2 serial killer, rdr2 edmund lowry jr, red dead redemption 2 arthur wife, red dead redemption 2 arthur wife and son, red dead redemption 2 arthur morgan wife, red dead redemption 2 eliza, red dead redemption 2 eliza grave, mrbossftw, rockstar games

Id: mC88ukJ3NpM

Length: 11min 33sec (693 seconds)

Published: Sat Mar 02 2019