China's growing influence in Europe - Serbia and the New Silk Road | DW Documentary

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments
Captions
Sometimes Goran can’t believe his eyes. I can’t believe they’ve ruined so much so quickly. They’ve done all this in less than a year. Eastern Serbia has large gold and copper deposits. Mines are springing up at lightning speed. The builders are Chinese firms and they have brought their labor forces with them. Serbia is the Balkan state closest to China, and China has big plans for it. Bor is Europe’s biggest copper mine, 250 kilometers southeast of Belgrade. China acquired it in 2018. Goran Jakovlevic lives here... in one of the most polluted places in all of Serbia. For years he has watched his home town be sold off. He complains that the Serbian state has imposed no regulations on the new owners. And there is far too little information. We’ve just rolled over and left everything to them. It’s like eastern Serbia has somehow been sacrificed. I don't know if it’s because of Chinese influence in international organizations or because they give us cheap loans for new highways. Driving around the mine, the scale on which China is building here becomes clear. The gold and copper are to be extracted as quickly as possible. Gigantic new sites are being developed and access roads built, all with imported labor. After their shift, the workers return to their lodgings. The mood seems good. No one speaks English. The locals watch the expansion with suspicion, expecting worse to come. At first, they’re only mining the surface layer. Underneath, deeper in the ground, there is a gigantic area, five to six kilometers across, that stretches all the way to Bor. When they finish mining the surface in about ten years, they will continue deeper underground and reach the town. Then Bor and its people will have nothing left. Goran is in contact with the residents around the mine. They are all in danger. Southeast Europe has welcomed Chinese investment. Serbia is a literal gold mine for major new infrastructure projects. The country is feverishly expanding its rail and road networks. Half of all projects have gone to China. In return, China will get the long-awaited connection to Western Europe from the Greek port of Piraeus. Serbia has become China’s bridge to Europe, symbolized by the Pupin Bridge. At 15 hundred meters long, and one of the most important Danube crossings in Belgrade, it was the first Chinese project here built by Chinese firms with Chinese funds. China's Serbian policy is built on the principle of modern infrastructure. Investments and loans worth billions in exchange for influence and access to Europe. Another prestige project is the high-speed rail line between Budapest and Belgrade, a joint venture by Serbia, China and Russia. A Chinese bank is financing the lion’s share of the more than two billion euro project. China has a strong interest in an effective Balkan rail network. The capital Belgrade is the investment hot spot. Construction will soon begin on a subway system, financed and built by China. Chinese companies will also build a new sewage treatment plant for the Serbian capital, an estimated investment of almost 10 billion euros. China is active in commercial enterprise. A recent Chinese investment is an automotive factory in northern Serbia, which will also produce parts for German companies. Its launch in the spring of 2023 was virtually a state ceremony. President Aleksandar Vucic sees Chinese involvement in his country as a great opportunity. It’s a good partner of Serbia. We have had, so far, a very regular relationship and they have been investing hugely into our steel mill and our copper mine. And it was an open, transparent tender procedure for that copper mine. Another few companies had applied for that and it was pretty much the same case with the steel mill and they saved more than 5000 people’s jobs in a very important city. Of course they work together with us on many important infrastructure projects, but still by far the biggest investor in Serbia is Germany. The new Chinese cultural center in Belgrade symbolizes Serb-Chinese relations. The Chinese embassy once stood here, but it was destroyed by NATO bombs during the Kosovo War. The new modern building is a testament to the bonds between the two countries. Liu Yu works for the Chinese state railway corporation in Belgrade, which supports these good relations. He makes good money as a department head. Liu is on his way to an appointment with a Serbian business partner. A lot of money is at stake. Liu believes China's presence here makes Serbians wealthy. Chinese investment has made it easier for Serbians to find work and earn more. So I think it’s a win-win situation for everyone involved. Liu has an unusual hobby, establishing contact between Serbian and Chinese firms. So far it is voluntary, in his spare time but one day he hopes to earn from it. Liu is a kind of private lobbyist for China. He arrives at Belt, a Serbian company outside Belgrade. Liu wants to persuade the owner to make new deals with his Chinese clients. Hello, how are you? Hi, fine thanks. Come in. Liu wants to ensure that ordered shipments will arrive on time. Look, I promised you there would be no supply bottlenecks, and we're still well on track, all on schedule. We should finish as quickly as possible so there aren’t any work stoppages. I'm also here to ask about the prices, because there have been some wild fluctuations. The partners would like more certainty about this. The war in Ukraine has stressed the economic situation. Liu is trying to talk the Serbian businessman down. Only then will the Chinese agree. Their price expectations are still far apart. The first Chinese who immigrated permanently to Serbia in the late 1990s started doing business here, in Block 70, the market. It is a maze of more than 300 stores and stalls. In the middle of the market, Kit and his Serbian partner Jovana run a small art school for Chinese children. What about this part here? I want to finish painting the tree first. Kit is a child of immigrants. His parents came to Serbia for economic reasons. When we first came here, everyone assumed that if you were Chinese you sold fast-food or socks. Now the Chinese here live relatively well. Not all, but if they started early and have been in business for some time, they’re doing very well. You can tell by their cars and houses, and the private schools their children attend, which can cost 20,000 dollars or euros per year. Kit, too, wants to earn a good living. He has several jobs and often works well into the night. The little art school is a side job. A large part of his income comes from marketing for Chinese firms and restaurants. The Chinese trust more in other Chinese and prefer to work with them whenever they can. Not only in social media marketing, but generally. They would rather bring someone over from China, for example as a cook, and pay twice what they would for a local cook who is just as good. I guess it's part of the Chinese mentality we trust ourselves the most. He says he often works until three in the morning, which his parents found reassuring. But now he wants to change, to become part of Serbian society a dream which could come true within the next few days. A few meters away. Weiya Chen is off today. The Chinese 25-year-old is showing her Serbian friend Sanya around the market. Everything is new and exotic to Sanya. Weiya knows almost every shop in Block 70. She wants to show Sanya where she spent her childhood. To do so, they have to enter a cordoned-off section of the market that was the scene of a fire a few years ago. Entry is forbidden, but the area is not secured. Weiya hasn’t been there in years. So this was my parents’ shop, 140. Weiya’s parents had a shoe store here. It’s really heartbreaking. It feels like all my memories have burned with the shop, with everything. My uncle’s shop was over there, upstairs. We were also neighbors. It’s all burned. Weiya’s father died and her mother has moved back to China. Weiya has decided to stay and is now on her own. The country is in a gold-rush fever. Building is happening everywhere, and many of the large construction sites are in Chinese hands. Serbia is part of the New Silk Road, one of the world’s largest infrastructure projects. It will link the Chinese and European markets. These workers are building 40 kilometers of a new highway section. They are more talkative: How many days working? Three years. Three years in Serbia. Hard work or good work? I love Serbia, it’s good work. Here is work, and where do you live? Over there. Here, too, the Chinese corporate policy is clearly evident: They bring their own workers, who earn 1200 euros per month, significantly higher than the Serbian average. They are paid to be reliable and fast. Most of the Chinese workforce lives in shared barracks, which we are not allowed to film. Permanent immigrants live in the apartment blocks around the market. The Chinese have always found Serbia attractive, not least because of their shared communist past. And the community is growing. Weiya lives here too, with her cat. Her name is Pidjo, that literally means beer. Because I love drinking beer, that’s why her name is beer. As an office worker and translator for a Chinese firm, she earns enough to afford a middle-class lifestyle, a pet and a BMW. The only thing she sometimes misses is her mother. Why aren’t you working today? Because it’s the weekend, Mum. Oh, I completely forgot. Hi Pidjo, it’s me, your grandma. Why are you ignoring me? Weiya contacts her family using Chinese software. We don’t use Google, we don’t use Facebook or Instagram, these applications, but we do have our own applications. And if you want to contact with your foreign friends, it’s just impossible that you can do it. Maybe only through e-mails. But can you understand why it’s not allowed? Not really, because no one explained that to us. It’s just forbidden. But she never felt restricted in China. You basically do everything in China. Probably it’s not really free to talk too much about politics in China, but the thing is, we don’t really talk about politics. Because we trust our government and we just don’t talk about it. So it’s not like it’s forbidden and we really want to talk about it. It’s something that we never talk about. Weiya claims, for example, not to know about the war in Ukraine. Perhaps her non-political stance explains why she seems to have no problem with surveillance. I felt safer in China, because we have cameras everywhere. We don’t have homeless people, we don’t have a lot of crime, so it’s really, really safe to go out in China at any time. Even if we didn’t have these cameras, everybody is watching us, because we have our cell phones, we have our computers, they can look through our personal data very easily. So I think the cameras they put on the roads are protecting us. In the last few years, more cameras have been showing up in Belgrade, too. 8000 are planned to be installed. Danilo Krivokapic chairs an NGO for data protection. He is raising awareness about the cameras. It says, ‘Don’t record my face with this camera.’ The cameras are produced by the Chinese firm Huawei. Danilo’s problem is that they can be upgraded with software also Chinese - with facial recognition. This is the place where people gather, this is where people meet, try to go out in the city, but it’s also where people protest. And here we can see four out of 18 cameras that are placed around the square. This means that the whole square is completely covered with this type of camera. During a protest, authorities can learn who is critical of the government. Belgrade is the first European city where "smart" cameras are widespread. Danilo’s organization has started a campaign to pressure the Serbian government to ban the use of this technology. People just need to feel that somebody is watching them. This is the only thing that is important. And when they feel that somebody will know what they’re doing, with whom they are meeting, if they’re going to protest, they’re going to change their behavior. I believe this is very dangerous for a democratic society. Chinese companies are already at the forefront in Serbia when it comes to digital infrastructure, such as the 5G network. Is Serbia a testing ground for Chinese surveillance technology? Critics warn of excessive influence. But no one in business seems worried. The orientation toward China is strategic. So are the close ties with Russia, also a Slavic country. But Serbia also sees itself as committed to the European Union. What looks from outside like a see-saw policy is, from a Serbian viewpoint, just politics. The nearly seven-million-strong country in the middle of the Balkan peninsula sees itself as non-aligned, independent and free in its foreign policy and choice of business partners. A path successfully trodden by the communist former Yugoslavia. The former Serbian and Yugoslavian royal residence in the center of Belgrade symbolizes this continuity. It is now the official residence of the President of the Republic, an office held since 2017 by Aleksandar Vucic. The former minister of information under Slobodan Miloševic, and later Prime Minister, governs the country unchallenged. At the start of the Covid pandemic, he showed he’s got options. Chinese-flagged planes landed at Belgrade airport, embarrassing the EU. China was the first to deliver masks and vaccines. Serbian-Chinese vaccine diplomacy. In military terms, too, Serbia sees no need to commit. The government bought an air defense system from China as a signal to the West. Its position on the Russian war in Ukraine is also non-committal. While Serbia condemns Russia at the UN, Aleksandar Vucic does not sign off on sanctions. The head of state heeds no criticism for taking this path. Speaking about Russia, it was not me that was going to Moscow. It was many EU leaders that went to Moscow, since the war started. But I didn’t say anything to anyone. Why do you believe that some EU leaders have the right to do whatever they want and that we should not act as an independent state? The West is watching Serbia's back-and-forth policy with increasing concern. The European Parliament is alarmed that China is exploiting Serbia's ailing infrastructure and offering modernization and generous loans. The fear in Strasbourg is that Serbia is helping China to buy into and establish itself in Europe on a large scale. Serbia has been an official candidate for EU membership for years, so its actions are seen as particularly problematic. The Ukraine war is not just a local event between two countries, but is likely to pose the fundamental question: Are you on the side of democracy or of autocracies and dictatorships. Russia is clearly identifiable as a dictatorship, and China is going in this direction with President Xi’s third term. And so, for Serbia, the fundamental question arises: on which side do we stand? Do we want to go into the future with Russia or China. Do we expect more there? Or do we want to go toward Europe, that is, toward the free world and democracy. No one can take this decision away from the Serbs. They have to make it themselves, but it cannot be postponed much longer. Back to the Serbian company in Belgrade. Liu Yu is mainly interested in developing his business. How has it gone for him? Has he been able to convince the Serbian businessman to expand his business with the Chinese? I think this is only the beginning of our cooperation, when we try to make good on all of our promises, and we did. So we hope to increase the percentages in the following months and years. They seem to have made a deal. Liu has launched seven such partnerships so far. He needs 20 before he can start charging for his services and earn from them. On the way back, Liu begins to relax. Liu lives with his Chinese wife in a two-bedroom apartment. She is shy and doesn’t want to be filmed. He shows us his wedding photos. They have both gone through hard times. After spending the pandemic apart him in Serbia and her in China they finally celebrated their wedding. This is traditionally Chinese. But that wasn’t enough for his wife. So the couple was baptized Orthodox. Liu is pragmatic. But his sympathies are with his homeland. The big topic on Chinese television tonight is the China - Taiwan conflict and the planned visit by a US democrat. The problem arises when a third party interferes, in this case the U.S., which pursues its own interests and sets the brothers against each other, even selling weapons to the younger brother and making money from this dispute. Liu is convinced there will be no escalation or war. But on the news we see warships, aircraft carriers, fighter planes taking off, all for show? China just wants to show that we are strong enough and can hold our own in a war. We’re showing our muscles, showing that we’re strong, that's all. Liu feels happy in Serbia and wants to stay. He is driven to keep business running and it does. China is now at the top of its economic game, he says with pride. But the boom China is bringing to Serbia comes at a price. The Balkan nation owes China some 8 billion euros, about a quarter of the country’s total debt. China is poised to become the largest foreign creditor in the entire Western Balkans. This is especially true for Serbia. No one knows what will happen if Serbia can no longer service its debts. Could China use this scenario to demand long-term access to Serbian territory? European parliamentarians have long been warning about growing Chinese influence, and about potential environmental damage by Chinese-run industrial companies. Serbia is often suspected of having low environmental standards, lax controls and a lack of transparency. Many EU Parliamentarians are not convinced that Serbia is clearly committed to Europe. The country has been a membership candidate since 2012. The concern is that if Serbia becomes an EU member state, China could influence European policy through the back door. One demand is that, if Serbia really wants to join the EU, it must become less dependent on China. We cannot postpone for much longer the fundamental question of who is on the side of democracy and the rule of law. We must decide within months, or a few years at most. And Serbia also has to make its decision. If we are serious about the prospect of enlargement, then Europe must also be able to reform. China is buying into Serbia with the view of it becoming a member of the EU, and thus being in the position to block European foreign policy toward China. That must not happen. Our foreign policy must move away from one country being able to stop and block the entire European Union. If we can do that, then enlargement steps like Serbia will also become easier for us Europeans. Belgrade feels it is being treated unfairly and recalls the German Chancellor’s journey to China with a trade delegation. Why should Germany have the right to do business with China, but not Serbia? The question of where they stand seems to have been decided. The majority of Serbs want to join the EU. The president knows that, too. But he does not understand European concerns about becoming too financially dependent on Chinese debt. Tell me, what’s the difference between owing money to Germans and owing money to Chinese or to Americans. Money’s money. It’s not marked. There are irresponsible governments that always ask for some money, to get it from somewhere, and then they say ‘Well, that’s because we owe to Chinese.’ No, you have to handle how to tackle your public finances in a proper way. Then you have no problems. We have no problems with public debt. Public debt to GDP ratio is the best and the lowest in the region. We have no problems with public debt at all, because we take care of our public finances. Everything is under control. We are the very best place for investment. That’s why German investors are coming in huge numbers to our country. The Chinese community in Serbia, including Weiya, has little interest in these issues. In a bold decision, Weiya has left her job with the Chinese entrepreneur on short notice. How do you feel after both of you quit your jobs? We feel wonderful! I’ve been planning to open up my own café or dessert shop for a really long time, for almost two years. Because of Covid, I couldn’t start it very early, so that’s why I decided to quit from this job. I’ve finally found my partner here, and so I’m really excited about this. They have an appointment today with a roastery to have their own coffee creation blended. You’re such a perfectionist! Weiya is a businesswoman. In her new café, she wants to sell a roast that includes Chinese coffee beans. They anxiously await the result. It has a very sour taste. At the beginning, it’s a bit sour, but at the end it’s very bitter. And you can feel it on your tongue that it’s very bitter. They decide on the blend with Chinese notes. Now that they have the coffee, all they need is a space. An agent meeting downtown. Plans for the café are becoming more concrete every day. Basically we want to open up a kitchen, a cake shop. What do you think? Is this place able to become a kitchen for desserts? The property is a bit quirky, but they both seem to like it. Rent is 500 euros per month. What do you think of the price? I think it’s quite OK. Yeah, it’s OK for the space. Weiya documents everything for her mother, who will give her the money for the café: her wedding dowry, which Weiya prefers to invest in her passion project. I think I’m most likely going to take this place. I’ve been looking at so many places and this is the best one that I can find. I need to have a kitchen in my store, so it has to be separate. So that I can make sure that my cake is made in a safe place and it’s all clean. And this is just the perfect place for us. She is not afraid of the business risk. Everyone knows each other, all the Chinese people in Serbia. So once they know I have a shop here, they will all come and visit. The lease will be signed in a few days. Since 2010, China has drastically increased its investments in Serbia. Chinese corporations have built bridges, highways, and train lines. Sewage plants and the Belgrade subway are next on the agenda. And while political relations between the two countries are strengthening ... so are personal relationships. A wedding is taking place tonight in an exclusive restaurant outside Belgrade. Weiya is among the guests. Kit, the art teacher from Block 70, is marrying his Serbian fiancée Jovana. He has arrived. Today he is joining the Serbian community. Weiya has realized a dream with her own café in Serbia. Marriage is a distant prospect for her. But when she does think about getting married, she doesn't want to do it in China. I think it’s going to happen here, because I’m planning to stay in Serbia for a really long time. 250 kilometers southeast of Belgrade, Bor, the town with Europe’s largest copper mine, is coming to life. The cityscape is now distinctly Chinese. Goran Jakovlevic sees how his home town has changed. He regularly visits the people who live beside the mine, at the edge of the pit. They all fear what’s coming. How is life here? How? Terrible. What about the dust? Dust, commotion, terrible. When will they resettle you? No idea. Lots of talk and nothing happens. Are the authorities looking after you? They do nothing and say nothing. You’re left to fend for yourselves. The excavation destabilizes the ground. Cracks are already showing in many houses. At some point, it could all collapse. These are the losers in the China-Serbia economic arrangement. The family has been waiting for months to be resettled. Soon, they will have to say goodbye to their home.
Info
Channel: DW Documentary
Views: 368,031
Rating: undefined out of 5
Keywords: Documentary, DW documentary, full documentary, DW, documentary 2023, dw documentary, documentaries, Documentaries, documentary, China, Serbia, Belgrade, New Silk Road, surveillance, facial recognition software, raw materials
Id: -uGpOkn4nL4
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 42min 26sec (2546 seconds)
Published: Sun Jan 14 2024
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.