Beat the Icon: Morakniv vs Alternatives

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments
Captions
Whether you call it a Mora, a Mora Knife or my best attempt at the phonetically more correct Morakniv, a Mora is an absolutely iconic budget knife. We like to say that Mora stands for Mora Over Really Anything because they're so good and so inexpensive that it's often hard to justify recommending anything else. But can this icon be beat? Hey everyone, David C. Andersen here coming at you from the KnifeCenter and welcome to this episode of beat the icon where we take a look at the Morakniv. Now, knives are being made in the Mora region of Sweden, which is where these get their name from for over 400 years. But the seeds for the modern company started in 1891. And there's been various knife making companies in the more region over the years but the last two big holdouts finished consolidating only fairly recently, fully consolidated in about 2016 to form the Morakniv company. This is the classic number two kind of the classic old school style of a more a knife. And the things that are great about this one low price even though these aren't the lowest price versions anymore. Bush crafters love the scandi grind on this knife, you can kind of think of it as like a double plain chisel. It's great for carving wood, especially some of the softer European wood spirit wood species out there. It just works fantastically. But it's also just the general purpose grind that Scandinavian knives would come with in order to do everything. And for that reason, even today, they're great for just about anything. Some of them are priced low enough. They make great beater knives that don't feel like cheap knives, even though they are inexpensive, and he can do just about anything, you can put them about just about anywhere. And you can use them for just about anything. Now the question comes now, for doing this beat the icon series. How do we come up with some representative models? Because we're not talking about just one model? In this video, we're talking about, you know, the more as a brand. So what are the representative models here? What about the Garberg? Some of you may already be saying, well, the Garber is undoubtedly a very durable, very high performing knife and it's something that more enthusiast have been clamoring over for years. You've got a full length Tang, you've got great blade shape, great ergonomics. But the reason moras are iconic, in my mind is not because of what the Garber is, you know, the more is iconic, because they make knives that are so inexpensive, that don't feel cheap, that they outperform their price range, far beyond what you would expect. And the garbage doesn't quite do that. So great knife. Not we're what we're going to talk about. We do have to talk about the classic style of the number two right here. These come in right now these days about $36. So not the cheapest more is out there. The classic wood handles here take a little bit more time a little bit more cost, but they feel great. They work in a ton of different grips. They come with a carbon steel blade, some old versions were even triple laminated. I don't think you can get stainless on any of these versions currently. But the carbon steel is roughly equivalent to 1095 if they're still using the same stuff I'm familiar with sheath is simple and lightweight and compact injection molded with a leather flap here on the back for your belt loop. We also have to take a look at the companion which in my mind is kind of the quintessential modern Mora injection molded handle partial Tang but a pretty robust Tang going on there and the start at about 16 or $17 depending on which version you get. You can get a version with Sandvik 12 C 27 stainless steel or their C 100 carbon steel which is roughly 1095 equivalent as mentioned, you can get thicker versions heavy duty versions as well to add a few dollars. But these things feel great. You've got a just over four inch blade. In fact on both of these knives, you're dealing with about a four inch blade just over four inches on the number two actually. Great ergos great in a lot of different grips feel way more premium than $17 that this particular orange accented version goes for and they come with a very hearty injection molded sheath again compact lightweight, comes with a clip here on the back that with a J hook on the bottom that'll help secure it to your belt and you can use hanging off of some of the other accessories as well. Fantastic value knife. And this right here is why more over really anything is a thing because it's so nice and so inexpensive. One more we're going to look at as we look at the competition, the bushcraft black before the Garberg came out this was the go to for folks who wanted a more a knife that was affordable and was built incredible leat robustly it is not a full tank here, but you do have a pretty robust pretty long tank underneath the injection molded handles, the blade is a little bit thicker 3.2 millimeters. It comes with the bush crafters favorite feature the crisp spine, so you can scrape with it, you can strike a fire steel, and it just feels very good as well sheath on this one. There are a few different sheath options available. This one has injection molding, and you can either throw a clip or a belt loop on the back here, both are included in the package of this one, and the start about 46 bucks right now, all three of these knives make great options. They do things a little bit differently. But what else is out there, what can hold a candle to these if anything I'm going to show you and you're going to let me know, let's start with some of the something that might compare favorably to the classic style more. There's actually not a lot out there in this price range. And price range is important when we're talking about this that bushcraft black, there's like 46 bucks. So anything on this table, nothing's gonna be over $50 Today in the 2024 pricing scheme anyway, classic more is about 36 books, we can check out a Finnish brand Marttiini, this is the Lynx 131, four and a quarter inch blade $45. So not quite $10 more than the number two, but you can definitely see a lot of the same nice things going on. We've got a stainless steel blade here with a more aggressive clip point. I'm not actually sure the exact makeup of the steel, but they are pretty well respected. The handles definitely feel a little bit nicer. You've got curly birch, a little bit of a flair on the end, definitely a bit more of that finished puukko style of influence feels great, too. So the question of this versus the number two is, does it feel $9 more premium than that you do get at say a more premium sheath stitched leather all around instead of the injection molding. bit more of a even more of a classic feel, I should say. The only other thing that we carry that I felt really could compete in terms of kind of classic vintage feel, is this next knife it has been definitely more of an American style flavor than a Scandinavian style flavor. And that would be the old hickory fish and small game Kephart style knife 26 bucks and some change. You've got a four inch blade of carbon steel 1075, I believe, and hardwood handles full tang in this case. So maybe a little bit more robust. Still feels quite good even though it is a bit of a blockier handle. Here it is compared to the number two right there. What do you folks think the sheath on this is also a little bit nicer, you've got leather all around simple belt loop on the back, nothing complex. It's still quite nice. Alright, let's move on now to some potential competitors to the companion and in my opinion, this is a real hard knife to beat. There's a few few options here for you to take a look at though. The first is cheaper, actually, it's about $1 less expensive. From Marttiini again, this is the Condor timberjack starting at about $16.03 and three quarter inch carbon steel blade more rustic vibes as opposed to the the more speaking span style look of the Mora but overall length is about the same so you get more handle. Although it doesn't feel like more handle, they kind of feel about the same, slightly less blade. Still nice and sharp. And I should say that's actually a huge more benefit factory edges on them are absolutely phenomenal. You've got more of a finger guard on this knife, but it does kind of constrict my grip just a little bit. It's going to depend on your finger size, how that's going to feel and the sheath injection molded, not quite as nice. The plastic flap here on the back is definitely not as sturdy feeling as the clip on the Mora but it offers a different style with a similar price and performance on this should also be quite excellent. Beyond that cold steel actually makes a few options that make I think compelling companion alternatives. The first one is the Finn Hawk right here. You can see it's definitely got similar info influences as the more and you know, fin in the name, it leans into the puukko aspects a little bit more of the kind of Finnish heritage it is a little bit more expensive than your companions. This is about $23 So value for dollar is not quite as good and maybe feels just a tiny bit nicer fit and finish wise. There's less of the factory grind left on the Scandi portion of the Finn Hawk but it's a minor difference quite honestly. feels quite comfortable. You've got 4116 stainless steel, a German composition, four inch blade nice and sharp, nice and comfy feels straightening out reverse grip too, and she is very, very more inspired. injection molded with the same style of clip and hanger on the back feels really good and if the ergonomics of this feel like it might be a little better for you, it's hard to tell without holding it in hand quite honestly but very good knife, but as I said more expensive. So let's bring the price down a couple bucks, the Finn Bear $21 Same kind of steel here that 4116 Very similar sheath as you can see right there and very puukko inspired again, not a Scandi ground blade on this. As you can see you actually have a secondary bevel so if the Scandi is what matters to you, this isn't going to deliver if not another sturdy, everyday knife. Even more than either of those two knives though I think there's one knife and cold Steel's lineup that if you don't care about the Scandi ground aspect, or maybe you do and you don't want the scandi grind aspect. This knife is priced right in line with the companions and feels very solid as well. And that is the Pendleton light Hunter $18. So a buck or two more than a companion you get that German made steel. You get that nice finishing on here. The horizontal grain going on makes it feel a little more premium. nice comfy handle works in a lot of different styles of grips. Obviously hunting is in the name but this is just a great general purpose fixed blade for any kind of outdoor uses. And it comes with a very more s sheath. Again, check that out. What do y'all think? Next up, we're going to look at some competition to the bushcraft black and here's where things get a little interesting because the bushcraft black, in my mind has always kind of had a little bit of a split personality. Bushcraft is in the name yes, it does Bush crafty stuff quite well. But the handle and the shape and everything does more like it definitely feels like it is a compelling tactical option. If you want an affordable knife that is sturdy and can serve tactical rolls, this doesn't feel out of place. They're due to the finger guard and the shape of the tip. It's got enough belly to do hunting style tasks, or just again, just any kind of outdoor uses. So what we're going to do with the bushcraft black competition is actually split off those different portions of the identity and look at the competition. We'll start with bushcraft since it's in the name. First up, the pterosaur from Condor Joe flowers designed full length Tang on this, which some will say is superior and 47 bucks and some change are just under $48 For this, so a couple of bucks more than a bushcraft black, but in some ways it actually competes more favorably with the much more expensive Gerberg in some ways anyway. But what do you got, you got just over four inch blade here at 1095 carbon steel. So for the carbon steel variants of that bushcraft black, you're dealing with essentially the same material right there. You've got the crisp spine, as mentioned, you've got a more neutral handle and his slimmer handles a little more compact might fit some hand sizes and hand shapes a little bit better. And then you've got the protruding Tang at the back that you can use for scraping as well as hammering on things but you're not going to get that out of the the more as in this particular price range. sheaf is also very favorably compared to the more it's actually ambidextrous. So left or right it'll go in no problem which is an advantage over the Mora sheets those are set up for right hand use pretty much exclusively and you've got a leather belt loop here attached to the slider which can be removed if you want to just slip it into a pack without it. Next up another Bushcrafter the United cutlery bushcraft Explorer, we got to talk about this it's about $40 So undercuts the the bushcraft black just a little bit, 1095 high carbon steel. So same type of material, four and a quarter inch blade and hardwood handles here just scream bushcraft This is a classic bushcraft-y shape at this point, feels very comfortable. You've got that full tang for rigidity. You've got a really compelling sheath option right here. You can carry it either horizontally or vertically on your belt. We've got retention straps, Velcro on these. You've got a standard belt loop there. Lots of knife for your money quite honestly, the reason I think this is maybe not as popular as it could be everything about this knife screams bushcraft, but it's missing one key feature that most Bushcraft knives specifically want to have and that's the scandi grind it may look like it but you've actually got a hollow grind here with a secondary bevel. Still an excellent feeling knife it's still going to perform but it's not going to do necessarily that bushcraft thing quite as well as a you know a Scandi grounded knife might Your mileage may vary your use cases may vary. So this is definitely an option worth taking a look at. All right, next up What about some knives that can kind of, you know, go after the hunting side of something like the bushcraft black? Well, we've got a I've got a few here that are kind of in between price wise between the companion and the bushcraft black some might say they might compare more favorably to something like the Kansbol and the Mora lineup. But I don't have that on the table today. So we're gonna talk about some hunters now the book light max to large hunter from a buck knives so $32 us made knife and held up against the bushcraft black you can see here, let me do this a different way you can kind of see some fun similarities going on right here. blade steel you're dealing with 420HC, Buck gets a lot of performance out of that steel. The handle feels very locked in works excellent in a pinch grip, especially thanks to the bevels right there. And obviously this is made as a hunting knife so it's makes sense that the grips would work well for those bushcrafting grips. If you're doing like some of the carving stuff, you know the aggressive finger groove here at front you've got a peek right behind it gets in the way a little bit of some of those grips, not so much that you can't use it but it is something to keep in mind. Now the tang on this knife is full length it doesn't protrude out the back but it does come all the way back to just wear that rubber overmold the edge so that's a nice feature. sheath on this knife is simple nylon with a retention strap and a belt loop. Classic affordable gets the job done without being too fancy. You've got a hollow grind on that knife which is very, very hunting in its its nature especially on this knife. Gerber makes a few knives that could have made the table but I went with the spine because it felt the most more alike in its presentation. 35 bucks for this one 3.7 inch blade drop point with a full flat grind, great hunting profile, great slicing profile, the handle drops and it kind of reinforces the presentation of the belly of this knife which is going to help in those hunting tasks. You get grip from the rubber but you do have a full tang here. Now the steel here, seven car series stainless the more options are going to be seen as a little more desirable, a little more premium seven car not going to hold an edge. for that long. It is a fairly tough steel hover so this should be able to take some abuse especially when you combine it with that full tank there. One cool little feature about the handle just as an aside it's got a bit of a pattern to it. That kind of reminds me of some of the old like Scandinavian sweater designs so that's kind of I don't know if that was intentional or not but hey, it's their sheath on this is really a bit more of a mask almost just kind of clips in to this injection molded piece you got this long clip here on the side. Throw that on a belt or in a pocket could work is a little bit springy though. So keep that in mind if you like the looks of this feels pretty good though. And the price about 35 bucks. does it compare to a more you got to tell me All right, next up a couple more hunting spy inspired things. We've got another martini and the reason I say this feels more hunting as opposed to more bushcraft is that hollow grind on this one as well. 48 bucks for this you got to forage 420 series stainless with a full tank and G 10 handles so it feels a bit more elevated. Perhaps then your bushcraft black when you're dealing with that injection molded handle. Take your pick whatever you like, handle feels filling and yet neutral at the same time. It's quite nice. It's going to work in those bushcraft D grips even though I'm saying this is more of a hunting, hunting survival type of knife. In some ways this kind of fits some of those crossover rules similar to the bushcraft black I would say sheath is quote unquote nicer you've got leather going on right here with a kind of traditional style belt hanger right here as opposed to a stitched loop on the back. Definitely keeps that finish flavor to going on. feel super solid for the money I gotta say. At this next knife one more hunting inspired competitor feels least more like of the things that are on the table. But due to its price and due to what you could do with it. I think it deserves mentioned and that is the Schrade 169 old timer heritage fixed blade. Most Expensive knife on the table today 49.95 five inch D2 steel blade not going to be as tough as the 1095 equivalent on the bushcraft black, but it should hold an edge longer. So what do you want in your outdoor fixed blade? You've got an option either way. So like is it feels the least more like definitely feels fancier, more premium style presentation that a more but you can see why that I kind of say this has some some bushcraft black competition DNA built into it they're the handles are laminated wood. So you've got the look of wood dyed wood in this case, but more stability it's not going to swell like a wood handle can on some of these classic knives we've looked at. You've got the integrated bolster and guard just feels super premium almost a polished blade going on to very very nice sheath. Sorry I haven't unpacked it but it's leather with a retention strap. This feels on the table today probably the most knife for the money. Is it a bushcraft black competitor is it a more a competitor? Again, you gotta tell me down in the comments let me know. Alright, last but not least, what about some competitors to like the tactical side of the bushcraft black the first knife here I think does a good job of splitting personalities like the bushcraft Black does but it mostly feels like it firstly I should say feels like a tactical knife. That's the cold steel SRK compact This is a $33 knife so undercuts the bushcraft black here the two are next to each other. You got a five inch SK5 carbon steel blade should be a tiny bit tougher than the C 100. The bushcraft black maybe won't hold an edge quite as long however, five inches straight clip point flat grind on this knife just a very versatile shape overall injection molded handle here full length Tang on it feels really nice thickness compared to the bushcraft black it's a Scotia thicker. That might be the the blade coating in this case, however, doesn't feel quite as nice as the bushcraft black, but it feels just as capable to my mind. The sheath is maybe a little bit nicer. No Maybe about it. The sheath is a little more versatile. Certainly secure-ex, it clicks in quite nicely. You've got a lea- er, a nylon drop loop here on the back with some attachment options and versatility in the sheet that you can rig up all kinds of aftermarket solutions as well without having to get a new sheet. 33 bucks, what do you think? Two more the Schrade SCHF 31 drop point fixed blade definitely feels tactical. First and foremost is the $29 knife. However, you've got 8CR Series stainless steel with a four and a half inch blade and a hollow grind. You've got rubbery handles, very aggressive texturing on it to keep it in your grip. Here it is next to that bushcraft black, you can see the why I make the comparison between these two, you could definitely press it into other roles as well. Like the book we looked at earlier, however, the aggressive peek here behind the index finger area is going to impede certain grips. If you do any of that chest lever stuff where you're twisting the knife in your hand to get the angle you want. Those are going to be affected if not has a lot going for it for sure. Like the cold steel, we've got a pretty versatile sheath going on. It is a single piece loop here on the back. So if you wanted to do some aftermarket stuff on here, you would have to kind of cut that off, but it is an option if you want to 8CR steel, again, not seen as as desirable as the Steel's you're going to find in the Mora range. fairly tough, fairly okay on this edge retention again for a $30 knife, but does it beat the icon? That's the question. And last but not least, I actually wanted to talk about the Ontario SP five. We didn't have one on our shelf when we wanted to film so I have the SP one here which is basically just a longer version the SP two is a five and a half inch blade compared to the seven inch blade on this one. And it also has a Sawback but this has you know the tactical side of things definitely nailed down in terms of your your bushcraft black alternative, but in my mind this also is kind of always had that you know, use it for anything, vibe to it. Great beater knife, carbon steel blade, but like I said five and a half inches about $45 for it full length Tang. The sheath on these is nylon, they're ambidextrous, this retention strap can go either side. So that is a nice option with the sheep sheath. You've got Molle compatibility as well. Is this to tactical to be like a Mora competitor? If you're thinking of a more as just a straight up bushcraft knife, I would definitely agree with you. But in terms of a knife that's just you can use it indiscriminately starts to make a little more sense. But anyway, as I said at the beginning, I'm going to show you the competition you have to tell me in the comments. What of these if anything, beats the icon, what can take the fight to the Mora and when is it any of these knives? Do you know anything else that might qualify for that? If so, drop those in the comments as well. And last but not least, to get your hands on any of these things you see in front of me right now. Click the links in the description that will take you to KnifeCenter.com. While you're there, don't forget about our long running knife rewards program because the least thing we can do when you buy one of our knives today is give you some free money to spend on your next one. I'm David C. Andersen from the KnifeCenter signing off. See you next time.
Info
Channel: KnifeCenter
Views: 151,756
Rating: undefined out of 5
Keywords: KnifeCenter, Knife Center, Knifecenter.com, beat the icon, morakniv, mora knife, bushcraft knives, survival knife, fixed blade under $50, mora garberg, bora classic, mora companion, mora bushcraft, marttiini lynx, old hickory kephart, marttiini condor timberjack, cold steel finn hawk, cold steel finn bear, cold steel pendleton lite, condor terrasaur, united cutlery explorer, bucklite max 2, gerber spine, marttiini mft, schrade old timer, cold steel srk, schrade schf31
Id: tpIKXYwt6UA
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 25min 50sec (1550 seconds)
Published: Tue Mar 26 2024
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.