2k vs 12k: Can you see? Elegoo Saturn 3 resolution tests

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments
Captions
I printed this miniature 2 years ago, on a 2K Printer, in resin. And this one I just printed  now, on a brand new 12k printer: the Saturn 3 from Elegoo. And here is a match to help us. You look at both models on a  microscope and the difference is NUTs! The pixels here are quite big: 50 microns even so, you need 20 of them to make 1 millimeter. And here, the pixels are way smaller: 20 microns… Pixels are still visible, but  barely, they kind of fuse together! I was so impressed, I had dinner with a friend and I put both pieces in front of him: “Man, check the sharpness of this piece!” He looked closely at both and said: “You mean this one, right? I see more details!” “Right here: look at the  texture! That one is flat!” That’s fascinating, because in the original model,  this area is indeed “flat”. But the “Minecraft” effect of a lower resolution made this look “more detailed” and “textured” on places where the model is actually plain. That’s why I don’t like to compare Resin printers using RPG characters or Dragons because the more crusted, rusted, twisted, clothy, leathered, wrinkled, aged the model is, the more expectacular they look on any resolution… So, I want to understand exactly what changes when we move away from 2k, 4k or even 8k and start printing on a 12k resin printer. By the way, big thanks to Elegoo for sending the Saturn 3 for me to review The differences between the  Saturn 2 and the Saturn 3 are not just the resolution, I’ll talk about them later in this video. If I put these 3 rooks together in front of you and ask you to compare the text here at the top you wouldn’t need a microscope and everybody would say the same thing: this is good, this is better and this is even better, because we are all trained  to look for the same patterns when it comes to letters. We are not distracted by light or textures, it is just the shape. So, for text, more resolution always looks better. The improvement can be clearly seen even from the Saturn 2 to the Saturn 3 and if you anti-alias, text gets so perfect! But the biggest difference can be seen easily, at naked eye, in all models specially where there are no details at all: as I said, pixels are so tiny here that the transition from one voxel  to the next one is shaved out, and it finally looks pretty  much like injection moulded, so smooth - in the best way, not blurred! The result is that the surface  stop looking frosted or matte and it now looks shiny, almost polished. This is very good news for people  that paint their miniatures and even better for people that use  castable resins to make jewellery. If you don’t paint your prints, this “shiny/polished” surface is quite different than what people are used about resin… My wife tells me that this looks like a stone, and this looks very much like plastic. To me, this more “reflective” surface makes the actual details pop-out, I love it. She doesn’t. So, to me, resolution is a no-brainer: the higher the resolution, the better, unless you make a mistake... This Deer is the test model  that came with the Proxima 2K, printed at 50 microns. On the Saturn 3 the pixels are so  small… it doesn’t even look 3D Printed. But I made a mistake: I over-exposed a little bit and this fine mesh got a bit thicker so when you see both, side by side, at naked eye, the mesh that looks thinner, seems more delicate, and anyone would say: oh this piece has more “details”. So you really need to test  every resin on a new printer, because a “thicker” print  looks bloated and less sharp. So, it is inevitable: you will always print a bunch  of exposure tests like this… …or this… …and the Cones of Calibration are telling me that I still need to reduce my exposure time which nice because you will  be printing faster too. I also printed this famous bust modelled by David Eastman, but very tiny, at 15%… It is sooo tiny, and yet, so perfect! I took this super-macro photo, and, if you zoom in A LOT, you can see the layer lines Magnified like this, it  almost looks like FDM printed, if you had a 20 microns nozzle. I printed it again with 0.02 layer height: and on the microscope it looks even better! But our eyes are very silly, because, the black piece  looks far crisper and sharper than the grey one. So I took the grey one and spray painted black… Oh no! It was an opaque  paint, it looks velvet now, and on the microscope it is bizarre! At 30%, this looks like an amazing chess piece. So, when some people say that any pixel size that is smaller than 30 microns you don't actually see it with your eyes anymore it's kind of true! But it doesn't mean that you  cannot notice the effects So, surfaces get different and anti-aliasing get's way more effective on such small voxel size. And I will make a bet here: If we ever manage to have 10 microns or less, the surface of the resin prints  will go pretty much glossy and that will be amazing for  painting and amazing for jewelry. So, I want more! The righer the resolution, the better! I guess I will saparate the comparison between the Saturn 2 and Saturn 3 on a separate video that I will put here in just a few days, So, Subscribe! And thank you so much for watching.
Info
Channel: Geek Detour
Views: 719,576
Rating: undefined out of 5
Keywords: 3D Printed, 3D Printing, 3D Resin Printing, Elegoo, Saturn 3, Saturn 2 vs Saturn 3, 12k Resin Printer, 50 microns, 35 microns, 20 microns, Microns, 3D Resin Printed, Elegoo Saturn 3, Ultra, Voxel size, Anti-aliasing, Anti-alias, Antialias, Sharpness, Everson Siqueira, Geek Detour, Resin Casting, Jewelry Casting, UV Resin, yt:cc=on
Id: WGRoTCiIlts
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 6min 15sec (375 seconds)
Published: Sun Jul 16 2023
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.