Can a $2 knockoff high-flow nozzle from Aliexpress
beat the 10 times more expensive genuine Bondtech CHT? I declared Bondtechs 3D printer nozzle
with Core Heating Technology to one of the big innovations from last year and it didn’t
take too long until the knock-offs and copycats flooded Aliexpress. But are they any good?
Let’s find out more! Guten Tag everybody, I’m Stefan and welcome to CNC Kitchen! This video is sponsored by NordVPN. Take control
of your internet experience today and get huge discounts on NordVPNs 2-year plan with
four free additional months if you go to nordvpn.com/CNCKitchen or use the link in the description. 3D printers have been becoming really fast
recently, yet there is still one big physical challenge that holds them back and this is
how fast you can get the material in the nozzle to melt. The thermal conductivity of plastics
is almost by two orders of magnitude lower than the one in brass for example. This means
that even though the 3D printer nozzle can be super hot, it takes a bit of time until
the heat traveled into the filament to melt it. This means that at high speeds, when the
filament is quickly pushed through the hotend, the core can still be solid, while the outside
is already molten. Core Heating Technology tackled that by splitting up the filament
into three individual strands that are then thinner and therefore melt faster, making
it possible to basically double the maximum extrusion rate. Even though this technology
is patented by 3DSolex where Carl uses it for awesome Ultimaker high-flow printcores,
it, of course, didn’t take long until we saw knockoffs on the market, and even some
printer manufacturers snuck special nozzles for higher flow capability into their machines.
I would have even expected to see something like this on Bambulabs machines, but my cold
pulls looked very clean and I think they were very cautious not to run into legal problems
right at their launch. Talking about the patent, I think that 3DSolex and Bondtech deserve
a ton of credit for their work but there are currently some interesting things happening
around the patent, which I’ll discuss later. Anyways, a viewer send me one of them that
he purchased from Aliexpress where they are selling for only 2 to $5 instead of the still
reasonably priced $20 CHT from Bondtech. I deliberately didn’t put any links to the
knockoffs in the description because they might infringe on the patent, and I want to
stay out of legal trouble. I rather want to fund this objective investigation with your
views, so consider feeding the YouTube algorithm by leaving a like, sharing it and leaving
a comment below! So let’s take the Aliexpress CHT and put
it through its paces! Let’s first do an extrusion test, or as some like to call it,
a poop test. Here I extrude beans of filament at increasing speeds and by measuring their
weight, I can easily tell if we are under-extruding or not and compare the results of the Aliexpress
nozzle, to a genuine Bondtech CHT and an E3D V6. All nozzles have the same 0.4 mm orifice
size and I used the same hotend and extruder and an extrusion temperature of 215 °C with
some very standard PLA. Because I was curious, I started with the
Aliexpress CHT and oh boy, was I impressed by the results. I started at 5 mm³/s and
went all the way to 38 mm³/s. Usually, the last blobs are way smaller than in the beginning,
because, at these high speeds the extruder is not able anymore to push hard enough and
starts stripping and skipping. With the Aliexpress nozzle, even the last ones were hard to distinguish
by size. I weighed them one after another and put the values into a chart, which shows
that the extrusion amount slowly starts dropping until it completely drops down at around 30
mm³/s. I repeated the same procedure for a regular
E3D V6 nozzle and Bondtechs CHT. A regular nozzle was way behind, topping off at only
16 mm³/s. Don’t get me wrong, for most printing on standard machines, this is totally
sufficient and regular slicing profiles usually top out at 10 mm³/s or even less, yet if
you want to print fast or use bigger layers a regular nozzle can be the limiting part.
This is where the CHT comes in, where we have seen a doubling in performance in the past
by only changing the nozzle itself. Paaause! Quick ad break right here, because
I can’t feed my daughter with free printers and filament, and trust me, I tried. If you
check out the great offers that sponsors like NordVPN provide, they will continue helping
me create content like this. NordVPN doesn’t only offer a huge discount on their 2-year
plan right now and an amazing four months for free if you sign up under nordvpn.com/cnckitchen
or by using the link in the description, they are also running a Cybersecurity Awareness
Campaign, so that you know of potential online threats before it’s too late. Here’s one
lesson called “Man in the middle”. Since we can finally go outside and travel again
we’ll be connecting to a ton of free Wi-Fis in cafes or at airports. You might have seen
this yourself when you find several free networks and can’t be sure which is the official
one. If you connect to a random hotspot, this “man in the middle” might actually sniff
into your sent and received data and get a hold of passwords and credit card information.
NordVPNs Cybersecurity lesson here is that in cases like this, you need to make sure
that you see HTTPS in the address bar, which is also often indicated by the lock icon.
This won’t make sure that the WiFi is safe but it will make sure that you’re at least
using a safe browser-to-server connection. If you want to be even more secure, use a
VPN like NordVPN that encrypts all of your data before it leaves your device, so no one
can listen to it, regardless of a dodgy Wi-Fi or an insecure connection. When I’m on the
road, I personally use NordVPN exactly for this purpose because this is a way I can be
sure my data and my accounts are safe! NordVPN has over 5000 servers in 59 countries all
over the world to which you can connect and enjoy a free and unrestricted internet without
censorship or also to simply watch your favorite Netflix shows over the Christmas break that
are not available in your country, because NordVPN works on you PC, Mac, Smartphone,
tablet and even you Smart TV. Don’t believe me? Try it out risk-free with a 30-day money-back
guarantee and four months for free if you go to nordVPN.com/CNCKitchen or by using the
link in the description! Thanks to NordVPN for supporting my channel, and thank you for
trying out their great deal using the link in the description! The flow test with the official genuine CHT
was very similar to the one from Aliexpress. It actually even dropped off a little earlier
and was only able to melt 27 mm³/s. Before we investigate, if this also translates into
real printing performance, let’s take a closer look at the Aliexpress CHT and how
its design differs from Bondtechs high flow nozzle. From my previous investigation, I
know that the Bondtech design is made from one piece of metal into which they drill at
an angle to form the three channels and create the sharp blade that slices through the filament.
The nozzle from Aliexpress uses a way simpler approach because they use a regular nozzle
with an increased internal diameter and simply add a small piece of copper that has three
off-center bores which are chamfered on one side. If my Aliexpress CHT wasn’t assembled
in my bag to circumvent the patent or simply because it fell apart during shipping is something
I don’t know, but what we have clearly seen from the test is that this loose fit works,
even though there is no tight connection between the brass nozzle and the copper insert. When
we take a closer look at the two designs we can also see that the Aliexpress CHT has way
more material to transfer heat into the inside of the filament, compared to Bondtechs CHT,
which might be the reason it works so well. Interestingly enough, Bondtech uses a very
similar insert approach for their new Volcano high flow nozzle and the abrasion-resistant
CHT that will be available in January. If you, by the way, don’t want to miss the
review of them, make sure to be subscribed! I suspect Bondtechs reason for using an insert
is not to increase the size of the inner part but, in the case of the Volcano CHT, it’s
a way to even manufacture it in the first place and on the abrasion-resistant CHT, they
do this to have a hardened steel core and a very heat conductive sleeve for maximum
performance! Before we talk about the downsides of this
insert design, let’s see how the extrusion performance translates to real printing, where
internal stresses in the molten material will be more important, and also the cooling fan
will be turned on. I did three different tests. First, a simple meandering part that I print
in vase mode and increase the print speed every two mm. If you, by the way, want to
try this yourself, I uploaded it together with a small manual on printables. In my tests,
I started at 6 mm³/s and increased the extrusion speed every step by 2 mm³/s. The part printed
with the standard V6 nozzle failed quite early due to skipping of the filament and didn’t
get over 14 mm³/s. The Bondtech CHT print was significantly better and finished the
whole part up to 30 mm³/s, yet I was able to spot very strange blob artifacts starting
at 22 mm³/s. The print with the Aliexpress nozzle was quite similar and showed some minor
layer inconsistencies from 24 mm³/s upwards. The interesting test, though, will be the
print of a regular part with a ton of retracts where I wasn’t sure how the very uneven
internal shape of the Aliexpress nozzle would perform. I first started with retraction towers. I
had basically no more stringing at all after only setting the retraction to 0.4 mm. The
Aliexpress high-flow nozzle behaved differently from everything else I’ve seen in the past.
It also didn’t show any stringing at 0.4 mm but when the value increased, the hairs
came back again. This also was very clearly visible in my first test print, where I had
a ton of stringing at 1 mm retraction but only very little when I decreased it to 0.4
mm. In terms of printing quality, I could hardly see a difference between the contestants,
and all were able to produce nice surfaces and overhangs. I had similar results on the 3D Benchies,
which looked very nice if we disregard the ringing from the printer itself. The first
set was printed at medium speeds with a maximum flow rate close to 10 mm³/s, whereas on the
second batch, I increased the speed to 200%. Both of the Benchys printed with the high-flow
nozzle looked fine, yet the one printed with the Bondtech CHT had a significantly more
matte surface compared to the Aliexpress CHT, which is also a sign the knockoff melts the
material more efficiently. So, all in all, I’m honestly very positively
surprised about the cheap knockoff CHT. At least on my unit, the performance was on par
with Bondtechs nozzle, maybe even a little better, and even regular prints didn’t look
worse. The copper insert seems to do quite a good job splitting up the filament and heating
and melting it efficiently. Yet it also comes with some downsides. At least mine wasn’t
super nicely machined and I’m not sure if this small leftover chip would have blocked
the orifice if it at some point broke off. I am a huge fan of cold-pulling my nozzles
to remove residues, and with standard nozzles and even the CHT, this isn’t a problem,
but the big slug and the step on the knockoff make this basically impossible. I had to assemble mine myself and if you don’t
have good eyes there is a 50% chance that the copper insert is installed the wrong way
with the chamfers pointing to the wrong side, which then blocks more of the filament path
than it helps. And this is something I also heard from other sides during my research.
For some, the nozzle seems to work well, others had big problems using it and this might just
be due to inconsistent machining quality, which isn’t something I can say of the original
Bondtech nozzle. And then there is also the problem with the
patent. I’m not a lawyer and I don’t even want to get involved in these discussions
but there is a significant chance that the Aliexpress CHT infringes the 3DSolex patent.
The main patent claim is that a heat-conductive material, here our copper insert, is attached
to the inside of the nozzle. Is a loosely inserted copper slug really attached to the
wall only because there is heat transfer? Would that also mean that my butt is attached
to my radiator, simply because I sit on it, and it warms me? I think you understand what
I mean - patent language is hard and how you interpret these claims is something that layers
need to do, but there are currently a lot of things happening because E3D opposes the
patent in the EU and the US patent office rejected the patent in its current form. This
doesn’t mean that 3DSolex won’t get the patent in the US, but they have to pour more
money into it. We’ll see what the future holds. 3DSolex definitely deserves a ton of
credit for coming up with the core heating technology for 3D printers and Bondtech deserves
credit for its genius implementation and making it mainstream, yet we can also see, that patents
inspire others and motivate them to design around these innovations, potentially coming
up with even better solutions where we can all benefit from. If the Aliexpress CHT looks
as it does because it’s easier to manufacture or because they wanted to avoid patent infringement
is something I don’t know but the solution seems to work better than I expected, and
just looking at the current design, there is still a ton of potential to improve it
even more. And maybe in the end, calling it a knockoff wasn’t the right word, because
this design even improves on some things! But what are your thoughts on these cheap
Aliexpress CHT nozzles? Are they any good, or would you rather stick to the Bondtech
CHT, because it works and it supports their innovation? Thanks for watching, everyone! I hope you
found this video interesting! If you want to support my work, consider becoming a Patron
or YouTube member. Also check out the other videos in my library! I hope to see you in
the next one! Auf wiedersehen and goodbye!
