DAVID. GOOD EVENING, MARIA. THIS WITNESS IS ONE OF THOSE FRIENDS WHO HAD GONE TO THAT HOUSE IN JANUARY OF 2022 FOR A BIRTHDAY PARTY. SHE WAS ONE OF THE LAST PEOPLE TO LEAVE THE PARTY, AND SAYS SHE SAW SOMETHING AS SHE WAS PULLING AWAY. JULIANA NAGLE WAS IN THE BACK SEAT OF AN SUV, PULLING AWAY FROM 34 FAIRVIEW ROAD IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT, WHEN SHE SAYS SHE GLIMPSED SOMETHING THROUGH THE WINDOW, SOMETHING OUT OF THE ORDINARY, LIKE A BLACK BLOB. UM, IN THE GROUND BY THE FLAGPOLE. NICOLE SAID. THE OBJECT WAS ABOUT 5 TO 6FT IN SIZE. NEAGLE'S FRIEND, SARAH LEVINSON, WAS ALSO IN THE CAR AND, SAYS NAGLE AT THE TIME DID MENTION SEEING SOMETHING BUT DIDN'T SAY WHAT I ASKED FOR CLARIFICATION DID YOU RECEIVE ANY FURTHER CLARIFICATION? NO. UNDER CROSS-EXAMINATION, NAGLE ADMITTED SHE WAS DRUNK THAT NIGHT AND DIDN'T RECOGNIZE THE OBJECT. THEY PASSED AS A BODY DID NOT TELL MATTHEW MCCABE. HEY, STOP THE CAR. CORRECT. I DID NOT KNOW. THE NEXT MORNING, JOHN O'KEEFE'S BODY WAS FOUND AT THAT SAME SPOT. PROSECUTORS SAY KAREN REID BACKED INTO HIM WITH HER SUV. NAGLE ALSO REMEMBERED SEEING AN SUV SIMILAR TO REID'S PULL UP AT THAT SAME LOCATION. I SAW IT PULL UP, STOPPED, PULLED UP AGAIN, STOPPED, PULLED UP AGAIN BY THE FLAGPOLE, STOPPED. THAT'S ALL I SAW. THE DEFENSE HAS SAID O'KEEFE WAS KILLED INSIDE THE HOUSE DURING A FIGHT AND DOG ATTACK. BUT SO FAR, SIX WITNESSES WHO WERE THERE THAT NIGHT HAVE ALL TESTIFIED THEY NEVER SAW O'KEEFE OR REID COME INSIDE. ARE ALL OF THESE PEOPLE LYING? WHO ARE YOU TALKING ABOUT? SARAH LYING. MORE SPECIFIC. SARAH LYING. IS SARAH LYING THERE ARE PARTS OF HER TESTIMONY THAT ARE NOT CREDIBLE. IT'S NOT A MATTER OF ALL PEOPLE DOING ANYTHING. IT'S A MATTER OF WHETHER OR NOT THE EVIDENCE ON ITS OWN CAN STAND THE TEST OF SCRUTINY. NOW, WE'VE YET TO HEAR FROM TWO PEOPLE WHO WERE ALSO INSIDE THE HOUSE THAT NIGHT. AND THESE ARE TWO PEOPLE THAT THE DEFENSE HAS TRIED TO IMPLICATE IN JOHN O'KEEFE'S DEATH. EVEN THOUGH NO ONE OTHER THAN KAREN REID HAS EVER BEEN
