Why Indonesia Football's Success ROBS Asian football #indonesia #robbery #vietnam

a double win on Vietnam a qualification to round of 16 in Asian cup a first place finish in e23 Asian cup while Indonesia's victory in a Asian tournaments are respectable they are at the cost of destroying Indonesia and the entire football industry in Asia as a whole to start off a very important fact we need to acknowledge is that Indonesia's big football victory has nothing to do with its development of skills of current or wither players all the Improvement of their domestic league and this is the biggest difference compared to their neighbors tand and Vietnam the performance of Tor clubs in AFC champions league is already better than Australia and Vietnam has many private football academics fing the football players Indonesia Football League or Liga one at this point is still UND eveloped just like amateur League match fixing and Corruption is everywhere the top teams in Liga one cannot even reach The Knockout stage of the AFC cup people are having absolute no interest in the league even the first place team has cases where there are only 200 fans in their home stadium the current top scorer in the league David the Silva His Highest transfer market value is even was than chat's highest transfer market value in India sorry but not to be like not to mean to be dis disrespectable to chetry they're ranked 26 in the AFC league R rankings and and in the AFC cup their performance was terrible I just mentioned that before and lastly not to say that they have once have two leagues like where they start at the say they function at the same time in terms of their y performance they did qualify they did not qualify a single U23 tournament until this year and before they started the naturalizing players to play in u20 and U u8 and u20 tournament which this action is literally Shameless their performance is terrible their coach desp despite being a respectable coach from South Korea is inor compared to top Asian and European coach I actually feel quite sympathetic to South Koreans they have to suffer from the Netherlands U23 disguised as Indonesia U23 and they still almost made it until the panalty shoot out which is not easy for them the primary reason for Indonesia football to succeed is because of their naturalized players playing in the Europe naturalized players with Indonesia Destin or sometimes just simply without Destin at all are recruited in the Asian cup or even the Y competition for example J no IES he's born in Netherlands grew up in Netherland training camp and played in Italy Ser B his Growing Experience has no connection with Indonesia at all but he could still play for Indonesia just because his grandfather is born in Indonesia actually it should be maternal grandfather a few other examples are e backt a player who is currently playing Australian League League who also represented in the Indonesia Asian Cup squad so in short Indonesia players succeed because they buy get players from foreign countries instead of their domestic players in fact if you look at look at the two games against Vietnam national football team in the World Cup qualifier you can clearly see that half of their goals is scored by naturalized players and let's not count about the assists or opportunities created by the in the u22 Asian C Indonesia used naturalized players and to the semi-finals by defeating South Korea which is literally just Shameless and I will explain it more later if you are watching here you may feel strange about why I'm being so over sensitive on this topic like players that like players with grandfather born in Indonesia have their right to represent their own team so what's the problem with that yes it's right from Indonesia's perspective but not good at all from the Asian football's perspective think about the following you have two options first you spend millions of dollar and countless years develop their league making a league competitive trying to cultivate their own players by developing many football schools playing AFC cup all Champions League to get higher rating such as more players for such as it could increase the attractiveness of the league so that more Europeans would come and hire foreign coach and advisor to keep a strategic plans to football all of those take years to complete and it is not guaranteed that once you take five or 10 yes it will succeed second we just simply ask agents to go to Top Tire Top Tire football leagues England Germany Spain France Portugal Netherland to find players with distance from Indonesia and give them excessive salary that is literally even more than what they can earn in their life just like for example you give me like 10 million and ask me to go to a like a Timo State University and spend my entire life there like in this case I will definitely also be willing to do that because like I can't I'm definitely sure I can make like 10 10 million throughout my entire life that's the same logic here let's say you are the head of the Football Association what would you choose it's definitely a second one it's more convenient at much more easier and it has a higher chance to succeed than the first one in fact the first pass is what Vietnam and tand is is exactly doing in the past 10 years and what the second p is what Indonesia is doing and we all see the outcome Indonesia got defeat defeated by Vietnam got defeated by Indonesia in asan cup in World Cup qualifier that makes Vietnam look like a joke so as a result Asian teams and Football Association would seek more on desperately finding naturalized players to fill their squad in order to improve their performance in international competition and that was caus the following first the domestic players in Asia have less opportunities to represent their Nations because most of the POS positions are occupied by naturalized players second the increase of in the cost of finding uh naturalized players will inevitably decrease the cause of spending un cultivating domestic players subsequently leading to the Asian population not interested in the football anymore because the leag because the like the domestic players is is getting weaker and start the leag becoming less competitive another Viewpoint I would like to spe specifically mention here is the wide implementation of of naturalization policy in Asia may lead to unhealthy price competition and Monopoly because based on the current FIFA rule there are actually two ways to be naturalized first the players naturalize based on their Destin which is the one that I just talked about before the second is that the players do not have a des for their national team and if the player has not represented any FIFA me represented any FIFA members in an international a-level match and must IDE and resides in the country they represents for a minimum of five years consecutively then he can be naturalized some example of two that I can think about is like various natural players in ch China PR like they have Brazilians who is absolutely have no ancestry connection like ancestry connection like of being a Chinese but like he can still place in uh he can still represent the China PR just because he lived like in China for five after five for five years so like another example that I can think about is CH D he's originally a Chinese but due to that he's unable to gain opportunities to play in China P national team he ended up becoming a Singaporean and like represents the Singapore national team in like International competitions the two does not limit the ancestry of the player which means that there will be a huge number of candidates for the Football Association to choose for aan team given that the career future they have is inferior compared to the like the current the career future they can provide to the European player is inferior compared to them staying in a European or South American team the only way they persuade players to play for their national team is by giving them like significant amount of money and resources exceeding what they predict they can earn their football career this means that for rich countries like China P Qatar Saudi Arabia United Arab Emirates those countries could give a much higher price than other countries in this case those nations would monopolize the resource of naturalized players who is willing to come to Asia because they can give like much more money than the Southeastern countries and this would exacerbate the opportunities for country whose football is weaker such as Indonesia and Malaysia to catch up just a quick note I'm like if but well I'm talking about this topic I'm definitely going to mention like Saudi football league for a sec because Saudi this is what exactly Saudi football league is doing like they are giving players the prices that they will never be able to gain in EUR playing in a European league for example like Saudi give Cristiano like 200 million European dollars and this is some money that he will never able to get every like or every single European players get can get within a year so in this case like Saudi like top place will then go to Saudi and the United Arab Emirates and like some other golf countries instead of like going to East Asian countries so that's the same logic that's the same logic and lastly I have to read this again that Indonesia's use of naturalized player in your tournament such as U23 and U7 is literally just [ __ ] Shameless one important fact about y's competition like U7 and u20 is that many top players who succeed in their later football careers are actually not chosen into the squad for your competition when they are young for example Nani and sabroso in Portugal have like have never played in Portugal U7 team this is actually a bit different than senior teams because it is highly unlikely for top players to not be recruited by their national uh Team during their career so as teams are actually very difficult to naturalize the top players in another country but for U7 and U23 tournaments they can for Australian tand Vietnam they spend years trying to develop a U23 Squad that is competitive voter competition and for indon all they need is just buy players and succeed like this would make most Asian team look like a clone you know and if this policy did not get reversed I assume in five years we all see all participants are European despite the competition is called U7 Asian cup and lastly one last thing that I would like to mention is that the Naturalization policy in Asia is a like in football is actually much better because if you look like the ice hockey team you guys see that the United Arab Emirates hockey team literally have Russians in it this is just I'm not going to comment on that so overall Indonesia's Victory through naturalized players uh while it should be celebrated and respected would inevit inevitably destroy the football industry in Asia in the long row and this marks the end of the video and if you like this video please like And subscribe the K Channel formerly the North American Mass contest go go go thank you for your time and have a nice day

Channel: Kazusa's Castle

Views: 828

Keywords:

Id: PoNfrCaEgr0

Length: 11min 48sec (708 seconds)

Published: Mon May 20 2024