Thanks to Curiosity Stream for supporting
PBS Digital Studios. 120 million years ago, southern Australia
sat within the Antarctic circle. And for about half the year, the skies were
dark, and the land was intolerably cold. But it was here, near the bottom of the world,
that the last member of a great dynasty made its final stand. Koolasuchus was a huge, stream-dwelling carnivore
that could grow to almost five meters long and looked sort of like a giant salamander. As far as paleontologists know, this was the
last temnospondyl ever to grace the earth. Temnospondyls were a huge group of amphibians
that existed for 210 million years. And calling them ‘diverse’ would be putting
it mildly. Their ranks included armor-plated killers,
thin-snouted fishers, and a cute little oddball with a sail on its back. Creatures like these were among the most successful
early tetrapodomorphs, the group that includes all four-limbed vertebrates and their relatives. At a time when any animals with legs and backbones
were still pretty new, temnospondyls did incredibly well for themselves. For hundreds of millions of years, these pioneers
thrived and diversified on dry land, in bodies of freshwater, and even in the oceans. And the largest of them may have been the
biggest amphibians that ever lived. Yet in the end, two major threats would push
the temnospondyls—including the resilient Koolasuchus—to extinction. One was the world’s always-changing climate. The other was a development that altered the
course of life’s history on planet earth: The amniote egg. The reign of these amphibians began in what’s
now Scotland, around 330 million years ago, when a new kind of tetrapodomorph arrived
on the scene. That’s where the little, twenty-centimeter
Balanerpeton became the first known temnospondyl to appear in the fossil record. Another was Dendrerpeton, whose name means
“tree creeper”—because its remains are often found inside the fossils of hollowed-out
tree trunks. Both animals had hard, sturdy limb and ankle
bones, indicating that they mainly lived on dry land, like modern red-backed salamanders
do. So, we don’t know what the common ancestor
of all temnospondyls was, but based on the anatomy of these two early species, scientists
think it was probably terrestrial. With their stronger limbs, early temnospondyls
were better-equipped for walking on land and wading through shallow water than some of
the more fish-like tetrapods— like Acanthostega —that had come before them. But temnospondyls didn’t live on land all
of the time. They’re considered amphibians, and amphibians
are reproductively tied to the water. They tend to go through an aquatic stage when
they’re larvae, and a terrestrial or semi-aquatic stage when they’re adults. And like fish, amphibians lay eggs that don’t
have protective shells. The outermost layer of fish and amphibian
eggs is a thin membrane that doesn’t retain water very well. So if the eggs don’t stay wet, they dry
out -- which is one reason most living amphibians lay their eggs in water. And back in the early Carboniferous Period,
earth was an amphibian’s paradise. It was warm and lush, teeming with swamplands. And it was in this environment where temnospondyls
truly thrived. By the end of the Carboniferous, they had
become the single most diverse group of tetrapodomorphs on earth. But a lot of them looked very different from
amphibians we know. For one thing, some of them had claws--a trait
that modern amphibians usually lack. But more importantly, living frogs, toads,
and salamanders generally have skin that’s thin and moist, with no scales. Through this permeable layer, they absorb
water and oxygen. But many temnospondyl species were covered
in scales. And some had large, plate-like coverings on
their backs or their bellies. So, paleontologists are still figuring out
whether these creatures breathed through their skin like modern amphibians do, even with
those scales and plates. Now, despite all these variations among species,
temnospondyls did share a few key traits. For example, they all had a set of large openings
on their palates. Most of them had broad, flat skulls. And many had big tusks protruding from their
lower jaws. In fact, in some species, like Africa’s
Nigerpeton, the tusks actually poked through openings in the top of the skull! Now, as the Carboniferous Period gave way
to the Permian, the climate became more volatile, and glacial activity increased at the poles. But things stayed warm and wet year-round
near the equator, so temnospondyls still did OK. And although the first temnospondyls lived
on dry land as adults, it’s in the late Carboniferous and early Permian when we see
forms that were even better adapted to life in the water. Take Trimerorhachis, which looked like an
overgrown axolotl. It had a huge head but very short limbs, and
scientists have found that many of its bones weren’t fully ossified. That means its bones didn’t completely harden
as they developed from cartilage. And this is a sign that Trimerorhachis was
largely aquatic. Because you don’t need a fully ossified
skeleton if you spend most of your time in the water. It’s only essential if you’re big and
terrestrial. Another major player in Permian waters was
Prionosuchus, a genus from Brazil. It probably used its long, narrow snout to
catch fish in freshwater, like the gharial does today. It’s only known from incomplete material,
but some scientists think Prionosuchus was about five meters long, and others think it
could’ve been almost twice that length -- making it larger than any crocodile alive today. And aquatic temnospondyls weren’t limited
to freshwater. Ocean-dwelling amphibians don’t exist today,
but fossils of temnospondyls have been found in marine deposits. Iberospondylus, for example, was a Carboniferous
genus that thrived in coastal environments in what’s now Spain. And it, along with other aquatic amphibians,
was equipped with an an amazing apparatus that tells us that it lived in the water:
a lateral line system. Sharks and some other fish today have networks
of sensory organs that detect underwater vibrations, movement, and pressure changes. And these structures leave distinct grooves
and pits in the skull, which are also found in some temnospondyls. But others bear no trace of this system, indicating
that, as adults, those animals lived on land. This includes what’s probably the Permian’s
most famous amphibian: Eryops, found in Texas and the southwestern United States. With big legs and strong, well-ossified bones,
it spent at least some of its adult life on land, where it hunted with curved, bladed
teeth. The biggest species of Eryops was more than
two meters long, but some terrestrial temnospondyls were much smaller. Platyhystrix lived in the same time and place
as Eryops, but it was only 60-centimeters long and was quite different in a lot of other
ways, too. It belonged to a subgroup of smaller temnospondyls
called the dissorophoids, and it had short, stubby legs and … a sail on its back. Actually, Platyhystrix looked like
a miniature version of another creature that shared its habitat: the stem-mammal known
as Dimetrodon. And Dimetrodon was among a group of ascendant
animals that would turn out to have a distinct advantage over the temnospondyls, as the climate
began to change. Toward the end of the Permian, the planet
became increasingly dry. Irregular rainfall led to a decline in swamplands
in many corners of the world. And this was bad news for the temnos, because,
again, their mode of reproduction bound them to the water. Even terrestrial species like Eryops had to
lay their eggs in bodies of water, which were now growing more scarce. But Dimetrodon didn’t have this problem. In all probability, it reproduced by laying
amniotic eggs. And these things were an evolutionary game-changer. Now, there are different types of amniotic
eggs. Some are soft and leathery, and others have
a mineralized shell that’s usually made of calcium. Either way, this outer layer helps protect
the embryo from damage. But more importantly, the shell also prevents
the embryo from drying out. And it acts as a semi-permeable barrier, letting
oxygen in and carbon dioxide out. Now, reptiles are amniotes, and so are mammals. But at some point, mammals, as well as some
reptiles, took this a step further with the ability to give live birth. And honestly, I could do a whole episode just
about that transition. That's actually a really good idea, hold on. Remind me to do an episode about placentas Ok I'll remind you OK, now let’s get back to Dimetrodon. Unlike the temnospondyls, these early amniotes
were free to reproduce far from the water, by laying eggs with protective shells, which
were probably more leathery than mineralized. But on an increasingly dry planet, that gave
amniotes a critical advantage. And although the first amniotes evolved in
the Carboniferous, it was during the Permian that they started taking over the world’s
land environments. As the Permian progressed, amniote predators
like Dimetrodon, Ophiacodon, and eventually saber-toothed gorgonopsians became widespread. Unable to compete with these amniotes, and
facing a harsh new climate, terrestrial temnospondyls either vanished outright or returned to the
water. Now, fans of this channel will know that the
Permian ended 252 million years ago with the biggest mass extinction of all time, the so-called
“great dying,” which wiped out 96 percent of marine life and 70 percent of land-based
organisms. By the time this catastrophe occurred, most
lineages of temnospondyls had already gone extinct, under pressure from the amniotes. But afterward, in the Triassic, some amphibians
still held on. One lineage of aquatic temnospondyls proliferated
in the early Triassic: the Stereospondyls. They took over niches that had been left vacant
by the Great Dying, and radiated across Pangea, onto every modern continent, into a host of
subgroups. These gave rise to the marine trematosauroids,
which likely fished in coastal waters, and the freshwater metoposaurs. And their appearance in the fossil record
corresponds with the Carnian pluvial episode, that period of intense seasonal rainfall that
went on for two million years. This phenomenon gave metoposaurs plenty of
lush, watery habitats, in what had been a drying world. As a result, some species became almost staggeringly
common: Mass bonebeds containing hundreds of metoposaurs have turned up in Africa, Europe
and North America. But you know by now that all success is fleeting. Aquatic temnospondyls managed to hang on for
tens of millions of years by sticking to watery habitats and avoiding the amniotes on land. But all that changed after aquatic amniotes
started to spread. In the mid-Triassic, around the world, aquatic
ecosystems began to be overrun with swimming reptiles -- from phytosaurs to the first turtles. Gradually, the remaining freshwater and marine
temnospondyls found themselves displaced. The fossil record shows a global decline of
these once-successful amphibians and the rise of ecologically similar, croc-like reptiles
during the Triassic and Jurassic. By the early Cretaceous, the temnospondyls
had vanished from every continent. Every continent, that is, except for Australia,
whose southern wilds were still home to the tenacious Koolasuchus. For a time, the waters here were too cold
for crocodylians. But eventually, the climate warmed, and by
about 113 million years ago, crocodylians had arrived with it. The last known Koolasuchus appears in the
fossil record shortly after that, 110 million years ago. But, did the legacy of the temnospondyls die
with it? Maybe not. There may have been an epilogue. All modern amphibians—frogs, toads, salamanders,
and the legless caecilians—belong to the same subclass of animals known as the Lissamphibia. And some paleontologists think that some or
all of the lissamphibians are descended from the dissorophoids, that group of smaller temnospondyls. Dissorophoids tended to have wide heads, and
the cavities in their skulls indicate that they, like frogs, had large eardrums. And some of them, like cute little Gerobactrachus
had frog-like teeth as well. But in natural history, things are seldom
clear-cut. One popular hypothesis holds that, while frogs
and salamanders evolved from dissorophoids, caecilians descended from a different group
of amphibians. Right now, there’s no real consensus about
where modern amphibians came from. Maybe the temnospondyls gave rise to them,
and maybe they didn’t. Still, it’s fascinating to wonder about
the legacy of these, the amphibians that once reigned over the ancient world. On a warm evening, when you hear frogs croaking
and chirping, you just might be listening to the living successors of Koolasuchus and
the other temnospondyls joining their voices in chorus. Thanks for joining me today. And BIG thanks to CuriosityStream for supporting
PBS Digital Studios. With CuriosityStream you can stream documentary
films, and programs about science, nature, and history, including CuriosityStream originals! For example, there’s Ancient Earth 1 & 2,
six episodes about life in deep time, from the age of giant insects to the rise of the
mammals! CuriosityStream offers unlimited streaming,
and for you Eons viewers, you can check it out at curiositystream.com/eons and use the
promo code EONS. And now a special thanks to our four eontologists, David Reed Rasmussen, Jon Ivy, Eric Lawrence, and Steve. Thank you so much for your support! If you’d like to join them, head over to patreon.com/eons and pledge for some neat n nerdy rewards. Now, what do you want to know about the story of life on Earth? Let us know in the comments. And don’t forget to go to youtube.com/eons and subscribe!
Wow. I can’t imagine the larger amphibians of our past living on our planet today. But even so... clone them! (If possible)
The koolasuchus episode of Walking With Dinosaurs messed me up as a kid. Worse than Jaws. It’s extremely interesting, though. Such a unique niche biome with no modern equivalent.
https://youtu.be/XMROB0mUB2E
I seriously have doubts about temnospondyls being outcompeted, because every time we argue that “x group of animals was superior and outcompeted y group”, we always seem to find contradicting evidence that show they actually died off for entirely different reasons (examples include birds vs pterosaurs, carnivoran mammals vs. South American predators, tyrannosaurs vs. Other predatory theropods)
Amniotes do have an advantage in that they can breed out of water, but since temnospondyls never actually lived in places where they couldn’t get access to water, there were no temnospondyls to outcompete in those areas. You can’t outcompete something that’s not present there to start with.
The areas temnospondyls lived in were areas where they could afford to breed in water anyways, meaning that the amniotes’ advantage becomes pointless.
The drier climate is probably what did them in.
Fascinating! Thank you for sharing.
So....do frogs and salamanders belong in r/natureismetal ?