Was Pope John Paul I Murdered by Poisoning? (Dr Taylor Marshall #202)

was John Paul the first not John Paul - but John Paul the first was he murdered by Vatican officials he was the September Pope of 1978 he ruled for only 33 days and there are a number of conspiracies surrounding the final days of his life especially as a regards to vatican bank and some people also think that he is the Bishop of white that was prophesied in the Third Secret of fátima that's not something that I hold or Tim holds but we're here today to talk about John Paul the first and this conspiracy surrounding whether he was murdered or whether he died of natural causes so first off Tim is this a conspiracy theory is it a conspiracy what are we talking about I think most people heard of this but let's situate it for him yeah that's a good question I mean conceptually there's an important distinction to be drawn between I think a legitimate conspiracy that that that has enough evidence to go into popular record and public record as something that's just happened like Brutus and Cassius you know with whis ease or something like that and a conspiracy theory we were talking to I think Pat coffin about the difference a little bit the other day and it's an important thing a conspiracy theory I think it's a CIA generated term and it has built into it in incredulity subjectively an incredible 'ti there objectively so yeah this definitely as you and I were just saying before we roll here it's definitely much much closer to a conspiracy theory it's along with anything from you know a kooky theory like Elvis is still alive and you know was probed by aliens or whatever - - the more plausible conspiracy theory accounts my general distinction is on a preponderance of the evidence test meaning 51 percent or more is preponderance of the evidence I call it a conspiracy theory if it's anywhere under 51 percent right so this is there are elements of this I think we'll get into right away that are compelling right there there are elements of this that can't just be flat denied there are other elements of it which are somewhat ridiculous like the notion that that jp1 was some sort of roundabout super ultra conservative hero in the first place that's that's never true I've never found that to be the case but um so I put it I put it somewhere in the order of it yeah I don't believe even it's not at the preponderance of the evidence meaning an impractical judgement Aristotle says prudence is basically made on a preponderance of the evidence basis so going forward I don't walk around talking when I first hear jp1 as if this is all absolutely real I just say there's an interesting set of facts surrounding his death and the days preceding his death which is to say his short papacy also 33 days is from the Gospels an interesting concept but not a number what do you what how would you characterize this isn't one we've talked about a ton privately so what about it I I would give it a 50/50 I wouldn't go to 51 I'm open to this being a murder there's two hypotheses on this one is John Paul one was this arch-conservative and he was gonna bring back the Latin Mass and he was gonna reform the church and kick out the Freemasons and he had this big agenda for reform after the horrors of the late-1960s right yeah and I I'm gonna go through some facts that show that if that's probably not the case he doesn't seem to be an arch-conservative he took the name John Paul which is an innovation two names to show tribute to John the 23rd and Paul is sick so he's definitely in line with the reforms of John the 23rd and politics the other hypothesis is that the Vatican Bank had been so corrupted and had been under minded to the tune of a quarter of a billion dollars of lost assets that he was going to clean up the Vatican Bank now this is people know this story not because of reading church history they know from Godfather three Godfather three has Michael Corleone II basically trying to present himself as a as a noble moral Catholic in his later days and he comes to the rescue of the Vatican Bank towards the end of Paul two sixes reign and offers to bail them out in exchange for some not so legit stuff from the Holy See and in that film John Paul the first is poisoned and dies and it relates the immobile re deal that Michael Corleone's putting together if you want to learn more I guess watch Godfather three I don't think it's accurate or anything it's drama it's Hollywood there's some sketchy stuff in that film so I don't know but that's where people I think generally are aware of the John Paul one Contras people said what do you think about cough are the three that really happened so when they're saying that they're talking about was John Paul the first murder was he poisoned in his bedroom based on the Vatican Bank ad deal that was going down in 1978 77 into 1978 so people who assert that John Paul the first was murdered and I again I think it's kind of a 50-50 toss-up they're coming from those two I guess those are the motives either he was a arch-conservative fixing everything back to how it was or Vatican Bank or both I guess right and they're they're they're interesting surrounding facts like the Vatican Vatican City as a as a polity had had they within a week or something changed the rules on papal op Topsy's is always one of these first things these people throw at you right I've I've heard it was debunked but then I heard that it was not you know you'll hear it's debunked and it wasn't debunked I've looked into it the sketchy part about a lot of these jp1 conspiracy theory issues and items is they're very hard to verify one way or the other so what well we'll be doing is sighting from a couple of the author that have written and it's kind of like look it's your barbecue you know you know i i'm just gonna cite i'm gonna cite to you a lot today that one that i think that's a key that's a key fact that's you know is is very hard to verify and if true it looks kind of fishy it's it's circumstantial which isn't always bad but yeah there are some more substantial facts i guess we can get our teeth around once yeah particularly with the bank so i'm gonna go through the life of Albina Luciani that's john paul one and basically i just want to introduce everybody who was john paul one i mean this guy was po for 33 days we basically most catholic out there no zero about him other than he proceeded john paul ii and i think in as we go through this you know bio bullet point of john paul one i'll be no luciani you'll see that he's he's definitely in the spirit of John the 23rd and Paul the six and I think as we move through this it's gonna debunk the idea you know that he was gonna take Archbishop Lefebvre and wave his Crozier and bring everything back to 1955 and make him CES right yeah that's not Albie no Luciani though early luciani well i just go into the the bios oh he was pope for 33 days i mentioned that he was born in 1912 in for no d canal first pope born in the 20th century I don't know where he came by that good oh yeah yeah yeah so this is in northern Italy like Venice area he was the son of Jeannie Giovanni Luciani and his mother was bortolotti Ong I don't know if I'm saying that right he was baptized the day he was born the Midwife brought him to baptize them it sounds like because he might have been in danger of death he's the oldest of four children at the age of 10 so this is 1922 during Lent he hears the sermons of a visiting Capuchin friar and he's inspired to become a priest he told his dad I want to become a priest so that's the origin of his vocation of the priesthood he tried to join the Jesuits but he was denied thanks be to God that's like it yeah and he was ordained in 1935 at the age of 23 so pretty young priest he wrote a doctoral thesis on the origin of the human soul according to Antonio Rose Meany now Rose meanies kind of a proto modernist see if his books were placed on the index um he had some sketchy things pope leo xiii rose media by the ways in the 1800's late and Publio the 13th big hero of mine big hero of Tim's we've talked a lot about the greatness of Pope Leo the 13th and by the way why isn't he canonized doesn't make any sense in 1887 leo xiii condemned 40 propositions by Rose Meany so he's a proto modernist leo xiii didn't like him glue chiotti writes a doctoral thesis against Rose Meany so here earlier in Luciano's jump all one's life he is in line with the anti modernist movement I think it's an important point to make I'm just curious dr. L dissertation at Bologna was it it was the center room no I believe it's in Rome Oh was it I didn't write it down with school okay me neither I I was just there mine yeah 1958 he's appointed Bishop of vittorio veneto by john xxiii now this is kind of interesting in 67 and 69 he's involved in this ism it's and it involves the Eastern Orthodox Church it's called the sysm of Montaner I don't know if I'm saying it right the sysm of Monte air so in this small town I think it's less than 3000 people the pastor died in so luciani John Paul 1 before he spoke he appointed a new pastor the people there rejected the pastor and they said we want our Vicar the assistant priest to be the pastor and our bishop luciani said no way I'm the bishop I get to a point who's gonna be your pastor and so the people locked up that priest in the Attic I think of the rectory he basically would it let him become their pastor and I said no we want our old assistant pastor to be the pastor and he said no way so Luciani comes to town with the police and removes the Blessed Sacrament from the church shuts it down the people respond by starting a new church in town in line with the Eastern Orthodox Church and they start celebrating the Liturgy of st. John Chrysostom in the town and it exists while to this day that Orthodox Church Wow so Luciani was not gonna back down and give him the pastor they wanted in fact I think he gave him three pastors in a row and they all got rejected until they became Eastern Orthodox like guys what's your long-term plan like you're gonna kill this pastor like you're gonna have to feed him up in the Attic exactly have to give him a therm break so I know you didn't think this through yeah I know it's kind of interesting then it kind of shows that Luciani like heat good Chianti he had some comedies you know these ladies yeah yeah he's like I'm the bishop on him give you your pastor so yeah you know interesting now in light a plant yeah in 1968 when he's bishop he submits a report to his predecessor as the patriarch of venice giovanni Gurbani and argued that the contraceptive pill should be allowed to Catholics right so everybody listen up luciani who became John Paul 1 presented a report asking for Catholics to use the birth control pill which is a new invention they didn't know much about it but he says hey I think this is in line with Catholic teaching moral teaching as long as people aren't using I think the argument was condoms but they're using this pill it's okay this report was was brought together and submitted to Paul the six all the six responds that year with a statement which is called Humanae Vitae so this puts John Paul 1 in context with Paul 2 6 regarding birth control and Humanae Vitae was really a response to this report that has its origin with luciani 1968 which which he I I knew I found this in past research he had a pretty thorough going Li anti-church position on artificial contraception like it was maybe at the time Gianni Luciana yeah Luciani proto proto jp1 yeah so he later in his life he kind of refused to acknowledge Humana vitae refused to talk on it so he is not people have to understand again those of us you know traditionalists and traditionalist sympathizers in the church who want a spiritual father so desperately like orphans orphans that we are yes we want a spiritual father so desperately so uh like an orphan ring up to some man on the street are you my daddy are you my daddy yeah and then the next man passes in a dress coat that looks halfway presentable are you my daddy argument this is us this is us this is what we were talking about this woodcarving the other day like but you know Benedict said it's the age of absconding fathers and he's absolutely right so we're trying to make this guy this guy kind of fits in the bill right he got killed and he got killed under some I mean he died under some suspicious circumstances let's let's craft the the Nair you know the facts around the narrative instead of the other way around but I think that's kind of what's happened with him because he he was not this hyper conservative I mean cuz it's just picture this like Jay Paul the sixth who's not a conservative never taken to be conservative had the good sense to have Cardinal OD toe mystic Dominican Cardinal OD right part two of Humana vitae right and and that's why it's so solid is because OD OD who's also a sort of fátima conspiracy guy that did I like and trust very much partly first theology he had the good sense to do that and that's Paul the sixth who's you know out here in in left field meanwhile people are saying jp1 he's some hyper you know conservative guy and he's he's opposing all the six is doing there never accepts it so they you got to put these I know it's complex you got to put these colors facts in to proper constellation it's staggering how few Pope's get everything or nearly everything right you know this is why we love Leo the 13th he's one of the few there's just everything he writes on he hits out of the part yeah JP one is not one of those guys yeah I mean I've heard it said people with conviction o John Paul Owen he was gonna bring back the Latin Mass and enroll back vatican ii no he wasn't his name is John Paul which is in honor of John the 23rd Paul 6th he's totally in line with them so they respond that he said these are the - one of them made him a bishop and one made him an arch Bishop right I think that's why he says out there my spiritual fathers John the 23rd maybe a bishop Paul the six made me an archbishop or a cardinal I forget so that that's what they respond but but no he is more in line with their program you're saying yeah right yeah that's it's kind of obvious you know now it's true when you want to beat a came out luciani recognized it but for the rest of his as far as I could tell for the rest of his episcopate up until Pope he was radio silent on it in fact he was asked to come and give a ten year anniversary keynote on it and he didn't didn't do it he didn't even show up for it so right it seems that he was you know it's kind of like I guess Jerome on on the deuterocanonical books he's not a big fan of him but the Pope said these are N and so he's like they're in their translated they're there right yeah broad sense love to bring that up but psych aid to Rome to churchmen he put him in so I think it's kind of you know luciani is deferring and saying wow it's in a papal document but he's not enthusiastic about promoting human ivj it seems right right so in 1969 he becomes the patriarch archbishop of venice by paul the six and he's named Cardinal in 1973 and he did clash with priests who's supported the liberalisation of divorce in Italy so there's your loss coming through about making divorce more lacks he did suspend those priests so that's that's good and then he is elected Pope in 1978 he's called the September Pope 33 days and we do know as you mentioned before Tim that the Vatican Bank is rocked at this time yeah what it was a quarter of a billion is that right that's a she quarter of a billion somehow the claim was over three billion dollars but but the Vatican Bank ended up losing a quarter of a billion dollars so yeah work that out and then when we get when we get into this this is quarter of a billion in nineteen seventy seven dollars right right I'd even done the math what that is in two thousand eighteen dollars yeah pre stagflation inflation whatever it is like that that's that's a that's a pretty penny even then most of this information on the bank comes from David gallops in 1984 book in God's name he again the interesting thing well to me the most interesting facet of his claims and there there are several interesting ones is the role played by the P to Carbonari Lodge of the illegal its how illegalized Italian high-ranking masons who were the same house or a same same publishing font of the Alta bandida which we've talked about before which video we talking I'll tow Bendita in first fátima one not not Fatima secret one secret to her secret three but the very first battle what we did yeah if y'all want to watch that one on Alta Bendita that Tim did it's it's called Third Secret of fátima and the smoke of Satan that's right that's right yeah but it's not it's not Fatima Secret three when we did the sequence it was the first one we did right yeah so that that's that's grabby that that the two guys that were actually according to y'all up and III think I think this is relatively unlike many of the other facts it's easy to corroborate the other facts in y'all ups book they were actually being uh they went to trial for this and ended up dying mafioso like deaths these two operators in the case I guess Godfather three picks up on it some but you know so the Pope had been in potential danger because of the corruption in the Vatican Bank is is the basic liner note it's the Banco Ambrosiano say same one we've talked about before you you did a video that was like half almost half a million views or something at this point on on why did Benedict resign it's it's that Bank yeah I'll put that in the right corner this is why did pope benedict xvi resign as relates to the Vatican Bank and Archbishop viga knows all over that story you're not just in the McCarrick story archbishop being to the Ground Zero in the resignation of Pope in the 16th and the Vatican Bank scandal in the 2010 11 12 13 scandal there's actually two major scandals there's the late 70s Vatican Bank scandal which we're talking about today John Paul one well we have a sketchy death and then there is the Vatican Bank scandal of 2010 11 12 where we have a sketchy papal resignation both of them Vatican Bank front center and I did I do believe a hundred percent in both of those events and their relationship to the subsequent church history as we're living it right now well here's why because when it's a sovereign state the Vatican City and they don't have the same I don't want to say regulatory structures in place sound like FDR for heaven's sakes that heaven forfend but I mean when there aren't the same there's not the same transparency in Vatican City and there I guess equivalents quasi equivalent of like the Federal Reserve Bank Banco Ambrosiano that were used to the were accustomed to transparency or something like it at least translucency there's nothing like it there so they never straightened this out from the 60s 70s right I mean this is the stuff of the the less wacky part of the conspiracy theory is like hey they kind of there's this ostensibly thing that that's happening in the late 70s and it's coming out in 1982 right the corruption was real even mainstream sources verify this much and it never got straightened out in the 80s 90s early 2000 so yeah it's the same same source of trouble the bank's head was Bishop Paul Marcinkus he worked with a secular man named Roberto Calvi of Banco Abruzzo know he was another high-ranking p2 officer alte vendido lodged freemason freemason Marcinkus at the time was head of the Vatican Bank was indicted in 82 as an accessory in the 3.5 billion collapse of Banco Ambrosiano the bank itself lost only a quarter a billion dollars only right right so kalbi the mafioso operator inside inside man was the member of p2 and was later found dead in London in 1982 after disappearing just before right like the week before the corruption became public so this seems to be real stuff yeah people are dying in relation to this scandal which is a lot of money what your subject isn't much much money so this is not wacky stuff David y'all up when he published this book in 1984 he he had his claims had the ring of truth he's saying look I'll put all donate every penny I make to a charity of the Vatican's choice if you agreed to investigate this claim not always that always if you mean such such a deal then that that lends you a bit of credibility he his central thesis is this that when the body of JP 1 was found and there is some controversy over in what condition his body was found in regard to this Banco Ambrosiano scandal they say initially his contorted hand gripped a piece of paper that was later destroyed because it named high-ranking members of the Curia who were freemasons and had money laundering and other numerous scandal rolls probably with members of the p2 Carbonari the hi-hi-hi italian freemasons so yeah and Marcinkus is is central to the facts the constellation of facts and a couple other bishops and then they're like these three operators inside the p2 that were like mafia types do with that what it's it's a messy constellation effects but it's interesting and there seems to be something there yeah what do you think well and it's interesting it's interesting that Godfather three not that I'm signing in his history please please don't do read me that way but you know you mentioned the mafioso types who are working with these Cardinals trying to bail out cover up this this loss of money and by the way we're not saying that oh I just while you're talking Tim I put it into a Inflation Calculator so to 250 million in 1977 is almost 1.1 billion today's dollars so we're talking a lot of billion bucks yeah and by the way this isn't the money was lost like oh we invested in some penny stocks and it's gone this means the money was stolen people right when mafias the types are in there these are getting funneled through accounting a accounts money laundering etc somebody stole a billion dollars right transferred it out of the Vatican Bank it's gone did I say trillion I made a billion billion yeah okay a billion in today's dollars two and fifty million back then hey that means the church had that much money in the books just interesting and it went somewhere and people are dying for it and in The Godfather 3 they make Michael Corleone II you know Michael Corleone er from Godfather one with the busted up face you know yeah he is one of the Mafia's the types involved in it trying to bail him out and help him but of course he's wants to get his his mafia deal out of it right and another interesting element here I don't I think you mentioned the name but yeah I'm gone into it is John Murray Volo John Murray villo is a name he got a no he was the Cardinal Secretary of Vatican City yeah under Paul the sixth and it's alleged by many including Malachy Martin that it was Jean Marie below who was working with these other Cardinals and the Mafia who had him murdered John Paul one murdered there are lots of testimonies that John Murray Volo who was a French Cardinal Secretary of State that he was a freemason from Fran a riot and I tend to believe that I've seen a lot of evidence on that again you can't be sure because hey you can't trust the Freemasons if they say so-and-so was a freemason and B if you are Freemason to secret society they're not gonna tell you anyway personally they're not gonna announce it and C and C sorry to jump in he'll go because the sites that claim more certainty than then reasoned reasonable speculation which is what we're doing or overstep their boundaries because of a and B it's true everyone out there understand some of these issues you just can't walk between the raindrops and get more than a kind of reasons speculative 'ti or whatever you know I mean you you can't go further than we're going because the only sites that are like oh yeah but you know Novus Ordo watch or whatever they're like no this is certain how you don't you don't know you're not a member of the p2 obviously yeah and you're not you don't have you know you're not one of five or ten privileged Vatican operators that actually probably are alive that know what actually happens so how do you get further than we're getting anyway yeah yeah all you can do is collect a constellation of facts and see if it tips you over 51% and I think both of us neither of us are willing to do that incidentally jean-marie valo if for all of our Malachy Martin readers out there windswept house great novel in that book there's a character named carnal jean-claude a Vince Ennis they got hopefully I'm saying that right Malky Martin that's his presentation of John Murray Volo so when and by the way that you can go to a website online and put in windswept house who the characters represent yeah and there's a there's a log and it tells you everybody in windswept house who they are in history because it's Malachy Martin called it faction it's facts with fiction we might that might be contested we understand we don't I don't think Tim and I trust everything Malachy Martin says but for those of you that would read windswept house and you want to make that connection John Murray below is jean-claude de vincennes is he's a cardinal corrupt guy and we wasn't Malachy Martin dr. Marshall wasn't he one of the popularizers of the idea that that JP one was killed because he was a conservative like so I thought he's one of the main I've listened to I think two interviews with Malachy Martin where he asserts unequivocally that John Paul one was poisoned al ki Martin when he talks about it he repeats it over and over as a one hundred percent certainty to art Bell those I think it's the art of interviews that John Paul the first was poisoned he was murdered I don't recall Malachy Martin saying it was because John Paul one was an arch-conservative okay yeah maybe maybe I'm not sure the Malachy Martin follows that train of thought that John Paul one was gonna be the super reformer post Vatican two maybe I'm wrong maybe I'm wrong go listen to the the art bell 1984 Malachy Martin interviews there it's good stuff whether it's faction or what you don't i was thinking to him i was wondering if we took some of the juicy parts from the Arbel interview and we did like we ran him on our show and we did a commentary on it I'd be pretty dead I think it'd be cool in the comments y'all want to see that let us know so that's you know Jean Ravello theory theory really it's that he it was his hand that actually poisoned the cup that's the that's the theory I've always heard that's what everyone goes with I didn't know that he might have been you know sort of depicted fictionally in in Godfather 3 this is all new to me I'd always heard stop it Godfather to so but below is according to Malachy Martin and others and all these theories he's the one that actually had that closest to access because of his station to jp1 and he's the one that actually poisoned the cup yeah right well there's another theory that came out last year which doesn't have John Murray Volo poisoning the cup this is in the 2017 book the godmother not to be confused with Godfather 3 right yeah the book is called the godmother moderate confused with with cardinal any of the Cardinals that were implicated in the respirate ok uncle well know what I'm about to say relates to uncle Ted McCarrick check this out alright check this out so 2017 godmother Madre Pass Kalina she says or in that book it says father Charles Moreau notes the coincidence that John Paul one had attempted to discipline Cardinal Sebastian Obagi oh alright I think we mention this before we started rolling today yeah Cardinal Biagio was a super liberal modernist Bishop and was involved in getting Theodore McCarrick ordained a bishop in 1977 may remember this folks in May of 1977 mckarrick was created a bishop and he already had a reputation remember the allegation of a sexual abuse in New York City goes back to is it 70 or 71 one of those yeah early he was young yeah so he's already to send a child molester and by the way this all happens under Cardinal Spellman of New York Cardinal Spellman is a notorious homosexual wicked dude a liberal guess who his nemesis was Carl I think we should do a video on this to Tim who's Carlos Bellman's nemesis a guy named Moulton Sheen yes yeah Fulton sheen and Cardinal Spellman who was a notorious homosexual and a liberal were opposed and locked horns often and by the way many this is not spoken about widely but I think there's something to it one of the reasons why cardinal Dolan has Fulton Sheen's body locked down in New York City yes absolutely I think the the spellman proto J's of New York City all those Monsignors and priests they don't want Fulton sheen canonized he's the you think he's a nemesis of their boy Cardinal Spellman and as long as Fulton Sheen's bodies locked in the basement of st. Patrick's Cathedral New York City full machine isn't get it gonna get canonized what's interesting yeah yeah everybody's yeah why would a cardinal Dolan just release the body of Fulton sheen doesn't make any sense just just release it so you'd be canonized what's it matter this is why it matters because wait a minute and also remember remember Bella Dodd in Fulton sheen and she said how many Cardinals did she have four four Cardinals you can do the math of who was Cardinals I was at that time and figure out who those were and I'm pretty sure Spellman was one of them based on his theology based on his economics based on his sexual behavior the American arrogance yeah the American government has records of Spelman bringing homosexual actors from Broadway to the rectory of Cardinal Spellman really you know the government our government made it up or it happened and I don't always trust our government but Spellman is a bad dude I want to go back to something really really basic just for 20 seconds I think a lot of people out there scratch their heads when they hear about these rivalries inter inter Cardinal it or inter Episcopal intra Episcopal or intra Cardinal it rival against bishops that kind of stuff bishops against Bishop or even Fulton sheen but he's so good he's almost the same yeah what do you mean he hasn't good guys have enemies be my I think that in the in the you know sort of neutered Church of nice people get used to being told that that you don't have enemy Jesus talked about enemies all the time so obvious enemies presumes you have enemies love your enemies presumed you have them but if you stand for something we're gonna have enemies the the kind of [ __ ] run females running around their main goal in life ostensibly as far as I can tell is to never get any enemies so you don't take any stands but yes Cardinal who are we just talking almond Spellman terminal Spellman and and Archbishop Fulton sheen or were mortal mortal rivals and this is mortal combat sense yeah yeah fatality hopefully hopefully not we're wearing we're in the realm of jp1 so maybe that's a fatality to scorpion yeah but anyway so yeah it's an important thing to point out the people you know just as we go along there are these rivalries it's what you want to see the good guys have well I don't like when I look at the US Senate and I see that they're going to lunch with each other you know a conservative in a in a arch liberal it's like you guys are both system is designed based on you representing your ideology that's healthy that's good I don't want you guys all buddies I don't like when I turn on the OKC Thunder and I see them slapping high-fives with the other teams right the good guys and the bad guys are supposed to oppose each other that's the way the whole thing set up so yeah so the bitter rivals and you know well done by Archbishop Fulton sheen for opposing the agenda with every breath of a wicked wicked prelate like Cardinal Spellman and it shows some restraint on the part of archbishop full machine because Bella Dodd knew who all these corrupt priests bishops and Cardinals were but it was Fulton sheen who as her director told her do not reveal the names so full machine could have easily destroyed Spellman if Spellman was on the list and I think he was by saying yeah Bella Dodd go on go on CBS and read the names because then there'd be egg all over the Asaph of Spelman and others but I I don't get why not I I I'm gonna go full-bore but yeah he was a restrained guy he's known for his restraint right and it wasn't from a compromising sort of character it was true you know the virtue of being you know restrained but I kind of wish he wasn't yes operated well either way yeah if we go back to this book so the godmother right Madre Pass Galena so she says that it was Biagio who was the last human person to have seen Paul John Paul the first alive and so this suggests that it was Biagio Cardinal Biagio who poisoned the cup the tea its allegedly it's tea right yeah so that poison was added to the tea of John Paul the first before bedtime and that it was Biagio who poisoned the cup but the really interesting part about this as well we will take home as Biagio and is related to the spellman mckarrick situation yes that's not really so can't overlook it yeah and it's also it's interesting that McCarrick is also related to financial problems as we're seeing with the papal Foundation millions of dollars as well he was the founder of the papal foundation X Cardinal Theodore McCarrick so we have Mr a sexual immorality and we have sketchiness with funds bank accounts right now there are there are multiple accounts of the actual minutes and and let's say our of JP ones death is everyone out there might imagine we know that he was reportedly reading Thomas campus's imitation of Christ he was he was in the middle of that book he took it to bed it was there about 10:00 p.m. that the Pope had he was about to retire to bed allegedly he had learned that some neo-fascists had fired upon bunch of Communists in the streets outside of one of the party's offices in Rome that one was killed in the Pope lamented to John Magee who is according to other stories John Magee is I think a biographer he's the last person to have have talked to him alive so you have lots of contradiction here which is natural but he said even the young are killing each other these days or something like that so and he was upset by this or whatever then retired to his room to read more thomas campus imitation of christ and whatever happens then happened so there are lots of different accounts and all of these people seem somewhat credible yeah many of them seem you know somewhat credible and in other ways less credible that's on it what do you make what do you do with right what do you do with that much contradiction yeah that's where I get that's where I spin my wheels the other the other things that we presented with Fatima or Akita or they it's like there's there's a coherent story there's a coherent narrative even if some people try to malign us is Fatima soar whatever no there's there's a real story that emerges here with something like this is why you just can't get there I can't get there because there's so much contradiction and I think that's her point for this show is that really I'm setting out to do this show because I want to debunk and refute the often repeated hypothesis that John Paul the one the first was the supposed great reformer yes gonna who's gonna go on hard to get with humanity vitae it seems like he wasn't gonna do that he's gonna come up rollback Vatika - no he wasn't gonna do that he's gonna bring back the Latin Mass no he wasn't gonna do that I mean he's the first pope ever who was inaugurated and not crowned I guess you could go back to the patristic era but you know he did not put on the papal tiara he took two names so he was definitely on the the opening up of the church and a modernizing of the church so some people said well he's the bishop and white who was killed because if he will it may not be bullets and arrows like we see in Fatima 3a it was just a cup of tea well yeah I don't think so so I think what we've done is we've debunked that it's like this this really weird trad theory that jp1 was our daddy and he was gonna come back he's gonna fix everything I don't think so and many of those as we were talking about many of those theories were on board for I mean we're pretty much you know with you just you have to be you know what you called the trad theory it's like yeah I mean a lot of those are and I shouldn't call it I shouldn't call the triad theory I should call it a conspiracy there yeah which we don't agree okay yeah all right it's super sticky people that's what people have to understand you can't just be one of these goons out there say oh the Fatima there's nothing to that the third secrets fully revealed it's not it's demonstrably not even by the the things I go back to is Sochi on that we feel confident yeah I'm 100% basically based on the the Vatican contradicted itself on that in in major fundamental way we talked about that yeah see our favorite part series on that right so you can't just be all one way or all the other but then what you you were accidentally oops I shouldn't call it a trad theory it's a conspiracy theory that probably doesn't rise to the level of credibility or whatever that many traditionalists follow it's like yeah this is interesting but I don't it's not at the same level of establishment if I fact and that's ultimately people where our loyalties have to lie remember like Aristotle talking about at the beginning of the ethics he's like I have loyalty to my friend the author of the forms he's talking about old Plato but and I love play and I love my friend but I love the truth more it must be counted dearer to me right that's that's all we I would be kind of neat in a way it would be tidy in a sense if JP one was this arch-conservative he demonstrably was going to bring back all you know undo all of the reforms made semi recently for him you know with her within a decade in half and that would be kind of dope I mean it would be cool like I can get there but you have to let the facts shape the narrative you can't let the narrative shape the facts yes right which is what some people start accusing us to doing with fat well it's like no you have to distinguish distinguish distinguish and then when you're sick of distinguishing distinguish some more right and that's that's what we're really doing now one quick thing I know I know what your response will be to this and I'm it'll be appropriate but dr. Marshall but it is interesting that Cardinal tar Ciccio personae who is played this I think nefarious role in in Fatima central centrally nefarious role in Fatima and the 2000 revelation of secret 3a he reports in writing that there was this meeting between sister Lucy in 77 in 1977 and Alby no progeny JP - yeah luciani and that she he emerged from his meeting with sister Lucy - I guess some sort of foyer where Cardinal Bertone II was waiting and he looked white he looked action-y he looked upset and that he reported that she'd told him he would be Pope at the next Conclave in like a year and it would be a very short papacy meaning you're gonna die yeah boy so that's Bertoni who yeah I don't believe in when it comes to Fatima but as the sort of opponent of the reform of the reform this would be something more like an admission by a party opponent which would seem to be more if jp1 had been a conservative this would make it more believable that it came out of one of the sort of opponents of the Conservatives mouse-like Bertoni so there's a response to this I forget what what is it it's you know I I had read and I don't know it's been a while but allegedly sister Lucia was asked about this did you prophesy that John Paul one would be calm Pope and she says I'm not something like this I'm paraphrasing something like I'm not sure I think I told the sisters in the convent he will one day make a great Pope or he would be a good Pope so she's from what I read and I don't know what the source is is she sort of distance herself either she's doing a humility I just want to say yeah I prophesied the Pope got it you know nailed it yeah nailed it or or she just she was saying maybe I was misunderstood you know like she said you'll be a you'd be a great Pope that doesn't necessarily mean you will be so anyway I just again I don't trust Bertoni carnal Bertoni either anything he says I'm like not so sure about that I don't know if there's any other source besides Cardinal Bertone II on that I just think that that Lucy herself downplayed it but two things to two responses to the response like replies to the objection use the domestic language odd one yeah so that that's not really a contradiction by sister Lucy she's just like yeah yeah I remember that meeting with him I said that his shoes were awesome it's like okay that doesn't that's not a contradiction yeah remembers having said something about JP and while something-something papal about Luciani so that is nope noteworthy and that is prescient I mean that that that involves her capacity for the app apparitional prescience right she's making a prediction in 1977 about the Conclave in 1978 so that's almost closer to an affirmation than a contradiction that's just that's all I'd point out and to now this one's really near and dear to me cuz you said I don't trust anything Bertoni said well me neither I don't trust the guy for them that can throw him but remember this this legal standard I was adverting to a lot in the Fatima videos because the legal standards are really helpful um it's a it's an admission by a party opponent sure Bertoni is basically an opponent of I think I think the veritable message of Fatima which is the veritable message of the church if I've understood all these things correctly and you have as well I think repentance you know maybe corruption in the church maybe other things we won't go there but except apostasy in the church we need to as the lady call them to order in the straighten things out Bertoni is an opponent of all that but if anything the fact that he admitted that this meeting took place or he's the the scribe as per this account between albini and how is it Alby know Albini Luciana I'll be non I'll be no Gianni is that you see like all white with pink eyes he'll find his name in the kidnapping in English we would say albino but yeah in Italy okay you know OB no no well so he's the scribe of this meeting and if anything it sort of cuts against I mean it adds fuel to the fire that's all I'm saying of the whole Fatima late 7d you know late yeah 60s late 70s thing well yeah because now we have perhaps the prophesy of John Paul one becoming Pope wrapped into sister Lucia and the Fatima thing and the white though yeah the bishop and white like maybe this is this can't be a bishop of white Tim there's no way well I'm not saying I think it is I'm just saying this is why I'm pushing back a little bit because I don't think you can see how people looking at his best yeah they're like oh we could connect that we connect that yeah okay so John Paul once bishop and why he got killed in three a the Pope got killed and just trying to make sense of it I mean Brody saying that John Paul to getting shot in st. Peter's Square has some sort of fulfillment of 3/8 of a Pope being shot and killed but he didn't die we've we've gone through all that in previous video right so I think we won't bore people if you want to learn more about that go to the older Fatima videos we did what was it a month ago yeah so I think we can take home from all of this that again I say it's a 50/50 that jp1 was murdered the motive was not anything having to do with vatican ii or doctrine if it happened it was vatican bank scandal that's it yeah that's my elevator pitch I know is if someone grabs me with a cup of coffee after mass one day and asked me about it that's what I would say i I mean I I'm I'm pretty close to you on this but I mean I think I'm a little less than 50/50 on it no no in which the direction in which direction in toward toward maybe not you know maybe thirty seventy that he was killed so thirty that he was killed seventy he wasn't killed that's your tonight okay 30 maybe thirty to thirty five sixty five which we had a cool graphics that were like on the screen showing our I know but we're like it wouldn't even be worth the top of the graph because I'm like changing like maybe forty mile times moving yeah yeah the pie chart is growing and shrinking but but I see I'm more inclined to toward what what physicists called it a grand unifying theorem that if he I'm more inclined than you are toward a grand unifying theorem if he actually was killed like you said in your half a million viewed Benedict why did he retire video if there was some Banco ambrosia no thing that did involve the P to the Freemasons then all of a sudden I think that wraps with it more of the the traditionalist claims about maybe you really did have this letter that that this 1984 book swears he did in his hand that was a bunch of Freemasons once you get the Freemasons in there it was a list of Freemasons and it was what 110 Freemasons we didn't talk about this maybe we should talk about it at the end the speculation talk about a now huh from various sources is that it was a list of like 110 or 120 Freemasons probably all P to Carbonari Lodge highest Lodge in Italy that had infiltrated the Vatican and that he was going to out so this does bring it more toward this brings more of the the facts from the wayward constellation toward a center I'm more inclined to believe if was killed it prob the banco brought you don't know stuff probably okay why do you need a billion dollars how many male hookers does this by you know how I mean I I think the financial corruption particularly when it's P to the Freemasons that have their hand in it probably point to all the other stuff so I'm less than 50/50 but the list is interesting and supposedly below was at the top of that list exactly and he was Secretary of State which is huge right yeah it's he's the most powerful Cardinal on earth I know what's interesting about this whole thing as we see we have a parallel structure that's emerged both with benedict xvi and john paul 1 maybe we can just close with this to get people thinking let's get the gears moving so with Ben at the 16th and I would encourage everybody to go see my video why did pope benedict xvi resign the vatican bank its goodwin bend at the 16th there's a vatican bank scandal he brings in this unknown guy archbishop vegan o to go in within a year vegan o finds all this hidden money and exposes it all the cardinals hate vegan oh been at the 16th takes vegan Oh puts him in america as the new CEO and says hey go check out things over in DC or he busts basically mckarrick right meanwhile bennett xvi receives a binder with a red binder full of names of corrupt priests both in financial and in sexual immorality then xvi receives this red binder he decides to resign a few months later he's resigned there's also the shutting down the ATM machines at vatican city just go see that whole video let's now look at john paul 1 right we have a list it's not a red binder we have a list of Vatican officials who are associated with the Freemasons we have a Vatican Bank scandal of 250 million dollars in nineteen seventy seven dollars a billion in today's money right but we don't have a papal resignation we have a papal death I just saying this of a sketchy man you immorality you get lists of clergy you get vatican bank scandals and we have one pope dead another pope resigned a little cynical i don't think it's just it's not just doctrine it's not just dogma I guess I'm too much of a cynic or I say follow the money don't follow the doctrine it's too muddy if you want to know what's really going on in Vatican City and the corruption follow the money and you'll find out what's up yeah there's also the the uncontroverted fact of this this operator p2 operator Calvi who is unequivocally p2 he was found to be p2 in 1982 when this was coming out he was like the day or two days before it all broke he was found murdered right and and and later we found out that he was a freemason who found out that he was basically running things with the bank he was he had this well-established relationship with Bishop Marcinkus who was that the Vatican insider with regard to Banco Ambrosiano that's not like wacky tinfoil hat stuff that's all on the public record just like the Vatican Bank stuff would be on the public record with with Benedict right it's the nice thing about fiscal trails financial money paths is that they lead the hardest evidence right they leave a paper trail yeah and therefore they're not juicy in the same sense that we don't know what what all that stolen free Masonic money or collusion Ettore collusive money was ultimately whether it ended up chasing in terms of which purchased which objects that it purchase and buy but um we do know that there's this amount missing it was this villain and the villains in both cases the the 1982 case and the 20 whatever was 2012 case was p2 freemason involved that's and it's a large chunk of money heads will roll like you kept saying in your video on the other thing so that you know and I think the rest of the the conspiracy if you know you plug in a couple gaps and I'm still only thirty thirty five percent on this but I think the rest of it it's in you eighths itself yeah because you know just steal money and then go you know give it to a bunch of orphans or whatnot you steal money and you go do bad things yep it's a tricky one they didn't Ricky what it is so um there's a lot there but I think the conclusion is pretty clear I hope people agree with us if you don't agree with us leave us comment will engage you there and talk about it there's something we missed let us know about it we can always revisit it if you like these videos please hit the like button that tells YouTube that this is a cool video and they'll show it to other people and please subscribe to the channel and hit the little bell button and you'll be notified every time there's a new video out anything else you want to add Tim no I'm sorry yeah be holy be be a well educated as well educated as you can on these things and don't claim to be better educated because you can't get that's right that's the certain point there are limits there's absolute limits yes pray the rosary every day live the message of Fatima read the Bible every day read scripture get close to our Lord never lose hope stay in the Catholic Church stay in the boat and yeah on the screen you'll see more videos we've done click on one of those click on all the playlists enjoy god bless everyone Oh

Channel: Dr Taylor Marshall

Views: 90,485

Rating: 4.8925705 out of 5

Keywords: Dr Taylor Marshall, Pope John Paul I, Pope John Paul II, Pope Paul VI

Id: eJFR0EyiKHw

Length: 59min 29sec (3569 seconds)

Published: Wed Jan 16 2019