This video was brought to you by us: Slidebean. Make beautiful slide presentations in no time. Get one free month by signing up at slidebean.com/youtube. This episode starts with a basic problem:
people love going to the cinema but it’s very expensive. And, in order to solve this, one company wanted
to disrupt an entire market. MoviePass tried to change the moviegoing experience
altogether, with a simple idea. For a monthly fee, subscribers could go to
the cinema once a day, every day. Cheap movies every day of the month? Sounds great. But, ironically, too many subscribers would
eventually be a bad thing. MoviePass went from being a hit to entirely
collapsing, in just THREE DAYS. This is Startup Forensics, MoviePass. Today, we’ll see: the origins of MoviePass The first tumbles MoviePass vs AMC Friends and foes Internal chaos The fall Our protagonist is Stacy Spikes, a tech and
film entrepreneur from California, who was convinced that a subscription moviegoing service
could work. For a flat fee, viewers could go to the movies
as many times as they wanted. In theory, at least. And he had this idea way back in 2005. He just couldn’t get ANYONE to buy into
it. Big cinema companies like AMC, Regal, and
Cinemark were focused on IMAX and 3D and not on subscriptions. So, for six years, he unsuccessfully tried
to sell MoviePass until, in 2011, he met Hamet Watt, who helped raise $1 million dollars
to start. This money came from two investors, True Ventures
and… AOL <AOL? You can wonder if it was a sign of things to come Anyways. Initially, MoviePass was $50 a month for a
movie each day. So, if you went to the movies once every week,
each movie cost $12.5. Twice would be just $6. Pretty good, actually. The online system allowed users to pick a
movie and seat, then print a voucher to claim the tickets at the counter. And it was only available in 21 theaters in
San Francisco. But people loved it. The day it was launched,19 000 tried to subscribe,
and the server crashed. That looks like the first part of a very successful story. But you’ve seen this show before. From the start, things went wrong. First, NO ONE in MoviePass told those 21 cinemas
about the test, so the tickets were blocked. Also, there was a conflict of interest. MoviePss used a database from the website
MovieTickets.com, BUT AMC, one of the biggest cinema chains in the US, owned part of Movetickets
and they weren’t happy. In fact, they threatened to shut down MoviePass. They now had to rethink everything, but other
tests weren’t working, mainly because they were cumbersome and required printing. And printers are evil beings. Who owns a printer anymore? Now, let’s be clear, MoviePass was a GOOD
idea. They had mapped out all the movie theaters
in the US so they could pinpoint any theater they wanted and had taken into consideration
population and income to create regional plans. All this with a team of FIVE people. It just lacked one detail. Spikes and Watt wanted real-time, digital
transactions and the only way to do this was with a card. So, they first joined forces with Discover
Card. It worked well enough to gain more attention. So much so, that eventually Mastercard itself
got into the action. Now, they hit it big. The MoviePass card was accepted everywhere
Mastercard was. Also, they included different plans, from
$19,99 to $50, and even had regional fees, so, it catered to more users. All you had to do was sign up, pay and your
MoviePass would show up in the mailbox. Subscriptions grew and Spikes was very confident. Yeah, about that. Theaters CAN stop you. And, they did. But, before that happened, things went well
for MoviePass. Companies like Lambert Media and Moxie Pictures
invested millions and in October 2017, its stock was valued at $39. Remember this. But there was still one big hurdle: AMC. And not only AMC but the movie theater industry. From the start, the relationship wasn’t
easy. AMC constantly fought against MoviePass, even
releasing statements that clarified they had no association with it. Why? Well, there are two sides to the story. AMC and other theater chains claimed MoviePass
wasn’t sustainable, and that it affected them directly. Let’s see why: MoviePass used something
called breakage. Businesses like gyms use breakage all the
time: they benefit from people who sign up and rarely use; those makeup for users who
go to the gym every day. But people hate gyms. And LOVE movies. If they find a cheaper way to go to the cinema,
they’ll use it. And MoviePass was very, VERY cheap. The lowest fee at the time was $14.95 per
month, the cost of just ONE regular ticket. So, besides AMC’s argument, perhaps there
was something else. After all, MoviePass wanted to be disruptive What if, in the future, MoviePass could become
so big that they would DICTATE ticket prices? This idea scared cinemas. Companies like AMC weren’t against subscriptions,
they were against MoviePass. So, why the hell did the two join forces? Well, the numbers were too enticing. MoviePass boasted having 30 000 subscribers
and a 100% lift per user, per month. And that wasn’t the best part. They had an ace up their sleeve: DATA. Through their system, MoviePass had direct
access to consumers’ tendencies and tastes, a key element in boosting sales and theaters
wanted this. So, the trade seemed simple: cinemas paid
MoviePass for data and, in turn, MoviePass paid full fare for the tickets, which they
sold at a discount to massive amounts of subscribers. And so, a one-year pilot program began in
2014. But at the end of this pilot, something WEIRD
happened. An independent report showed things weren’t
that promising. Before MoviePass, the average use was 1.5
times per month and after MoviePass, it increased to just 3 times per month, initially. The report stated: Besides, MoviePass data seemed off, inaccurate
and poorly analyzed. In fact, some of the data in the program was
missing. Let’s add Spikes defense here: he said his
data was exactly what he promised and that there was still interest from AMC, until there
was some personnel change inside. Whatever happened, AMC didn’t like it and,
in 2016, pulled out of the deal. This was a big hit for a company that was
already struggling internally. With AMC out of the race, the other big companies,
Cinemark and Regal didn’t want to join and Moviepass was left on its own. They hired Mitch Lowe, a former Netflix executive,
to rake in any money he could find, but the outlook was bleak. We were going out of business, said Lowe. The company that once tried to shake the world
was on life-support. But they were still attractive because of
one thing: DATA. And this was enough to motivate one investor. In 2017, Helios and Matheson Analytics (HMNY)
offered $25 million for 51% of the company, with a catch. HMNY wanted to expand aggressively. They drove the price down to just $10 so that
they could reach 100 000 subscribers and then go public. $10 per month! For unlimited movies! Clearly, some key people inside MoviePass
disagreed. Stacy Spikes himself believed that such a
low price would only work as a promotion and that it should’ve ended quicker than it
did. But the idea was working TOO well. In three days, the company had 150 000 new
subscribers, and, by December 2017, they had one million and rising. To celebrate, Mitch Lowe and HMNY’s CEO,
Ted Farnsworth posed in front of an AMC cinema, each holding a MoviePass and a big, HUGE,
smile on their faces. At the time, it seemed right to celebrate. Now, not so much. Here’s what Lowe said about that picture. Because things took a turn for the worse. Fast. Many, MANY, things went wrong for Moviepass. They grew fast but couldn’t fulfill the
demand. Sure, they had hundreds of thousands of new
users every month, but Mastercard could only ship 35 000 to 50 000 cards a week. This meant some users, even if they paid,
didn’t get their MoviePass until months later. Then, the system constantly collapsed: some
screenings just disappeared from the app and others were blocked or there seemed to be
no seats available, when in fact, the theater was empty. Even Spikes, the co-founder, wasn’t safe. He was fired in January 2018. Through an email that read: your services
will no longer be needed. BTW, he now rents an office at WeWork. But it doesn’t stop there for MoviePass. Users realized they could trick the system. Family members shared cards and reward points
to get free screenings. Yet Lowe insisted only 12% to 20% of the users
committed fraud. Yeah, there were 3 million users so that’s
600 000 users committing fraud! I’d worry. And investors and partners like Mastercard
DID worry. It was evident that things were bad and the
company took actions that seemed just wrong. For example, they changed from a movie a day
to just four per month. They also limited big premiers so that they
wouldn’t lose a lot of money. But users didn’t know this until they tried
to buy tickets and realized the movie was blocked. Whcih was, of course, not cool. Blockbusters like Avengers couldn’t be watched
more than once. And there was no IMAX or 3D available. Also, they implemented dynamic fares for some
movies, like Uber. But subscriptions were still $10. They lost $104 MILLION in just three months. Forget breakage, MoviePass was dying. Then came THE WEEKEND. Not that guy. On July 27th, 2018, with the premiere of Mission
Impossible: Fallout, MoviePass urged users to “experience #Missionimpossible”. But, MoviePass didn’t inform anybody that
Mission Impossible was blocked. No one could see it. No one. So, right there and then, MasterCard pulled
the plug and BLOCKED all the MoviePass cards. Life support was gone. Coincidentally, word got out that HMNY borrowed
$5 million to “make certain required payments”. Subscribers wanted out but they couldn’t
even unsubscribe. Everything crashed. So, they took to twitter. Just look for #moviepassfail. In a matter of hours, HMNY’s stock fell
to 0. Nothing. Then it was kicked out of NASDAQ. Even the New York Attorney General got in
on it as MoviePass was under investigation for misleading investors. And by Monday, MoviePass disappeared. The website only had a statement saying goodbye
or something. But its demise left us one big lesson. Sure, MoviePass wanted to disrupt moviegoing,
and a subscription service isn’t farfetched. In fact, AMC launched its own version to relative
stability. But greed blinded MoviePass. They didn’t see that they had disrupted
a very small ecosystem, in which all the actors need to in sync. And, until that changes, outsiders need to
be on good terms. MoviePass wasn’t in good terms from the get-go. And, after all, MoviePass needed them more
than they needed MoviePass. Don't forget to hit that subscribe button. We have new videos coming up every week. See you next week.
There are so many errors in this
K