Beaming internet from the middle of the
woods using an extra-large pizza-sized satellite dish placed on top of your house up
to a satellite orbiting 550 kilometers outside Earth’s atmosphere, well let’s be honest, is
technologically mind-blowing. What’s even crazier is that the Starlink satellites move incredibly
fast, around 27,000 kilometers per hour, and data is being sent back and forth between them
at hundreds of megabits per second, all while the dish and satellite are continuously angling
or steering the beam of data pointed directly between them. On top of that, the dish switches
between different satellites every 4 or so minutes because they move out of the dishes’ field of
view rather quickly. If you have no clue as to how this is possible, stick around because we’re
going to dive into the multiple key technologies which enable satellite internet to magically work.
First, we’ll explore inside the satellite dish and see how it generates a beam of data that is able
to reach space. Second, we’ll see how this dish continuously steers the beam so that it points
directly at a satellite moving across the sky. And third, we’ll dive into what exactly the dish and
satellite are sending inside the beam that results in your ability to stream five HD movies or shows
simultaneously. This video is quite long as it’s full of in-depth details. We recommend watching
it first at one point two five times speed, and then a second time at one and a half speed
to understand it as a complete technology. So, stick around, and let’s jump right in.
First, let’s start by clarifying the difference between a television satellite dish
such as this one, and the Starlink ground dish, which Elon Musk dubbed Dishy McFlatface or Dishy
for short. TV dishes use a parabolic reflector to focus the electromagnetic waves which are
the TV signals sent from broadcast satellites orbiting the Earth at an altitude of 35 thousand
kilometers. TV satellite dishes only receive TV signals from space, they can’t send data.
Dishy, however, both sends and receives internet data from a Starlink satellite orbiting 550
kilometers away. While the Starlink satellite is 60 times closer than TV satellites, it’s still an
incredible distance to wirelessly send a signal, and thus the beams between Dishy and the Starlink
satellite need to be focused into tight powerful beams that are continuously angled or steered to
point at one another. Compare this to TV broadcast signals which come from a satellite the size of
a van, and whose signals propagate in a wide fan that covers land masses larger than North
America. Table size Starlink satellites, however, need to be in a low earth orbit
to provide for 20-millisecond latencies, which is critical for smoothly playing internet
games or surfing the web, and as a result, their coverage is much smaller. Thus 10,000 or more
Starlink satellites, all orbiting at incredibly fast speeds in a low earth orbit, are required to
provide satellite internet to the entire earth. Let’s now open up Dishy McFlatface. At the back,
we have a pair of motors and an ethernet cable that connects to the router. Note that these
motors don’t continuously move Dishy to point directly at the Starlink satellite; they’re used
only for initial setup to get the dish pointed in the proper general direction. Opening up Dishy,
we find an aluminum structural back-plate and on the other side, we find a massive printed circuit
board or PCB. One side has 640 small microchips and 20 larger microchips organized in
a pattern with very intricate traces fanning out from the larger to smaller microchips,
along with additional chips including the main CPU and GPS module on the edge of the PCB. On the
other side are 1,400ish copper circles with a grid of squares between the circles. On the next layer,
there’s a rubber honeycomb pattern with small, notched cop-per circles, and behind that, we find
another honeycomb pattern and then the front side of Dishy. So, what are we looking at? Well, in
essence, we have 1280 antennas arranged in a hexagonal honeycomb pattern, with each stack of
copper circles being a single antenna controlled by the microchips on the PCB. This massive array
works together in what’s called a phased array in order to send and receive electromagnetic
waves that are angled to and from a Starlink satellite orbiting 550 kilometers above. Let’s
zoom in and see how a single antenna operates. Here we have an aperture coupled patch antenna
composed of 6 layers, most of which are inside the PCB. It looks very different from the
antenna of an old-school radio, and is honestly, incredibly complicated, so let’s simplify
it. We’ll remove a few of the layers for now, and step through the basic principles of
how we generate an electromagnetic wave that propagates out from this antenna.
To start, at the bottom we have a microstrip transmission line feed coming from one of the
small microchips. This transmission line feed is just a copper PCB trace or wire that abruptly ends
under the antenna stack. We send a 12 Gigahertz high-frequency voltage or signal to the feed
wire which is a voltage that goes up and down in a sinusoidal fashion, going from positive
to negative and back to positive once every 83 pico-seconds, 12 billion times a second, or 12
Gigahertz. Note that high-frequency electricity works differently from direct current or low
frequency 50 or 60-hertz household electricity. For example, above the copper feed wire, we
have a copper circle with notches cut into it called an antenna patch. With DC or
low-frequency alternating current, there wouldn’t be much happening because the patch
is isolated, but with a high-frequency signal, the power sent to the feed wire is coupled or sent
to the patch. How exactly does this happen? Well, as mentioned earlier, a 12 Gigahertz signal is
applied to the copper feed wire. When the voltage is at the bottom of its sinusoidal, or trough,
we have a concentration of electrons pushed to the end of the feed wire thus creating a zone of
negative charge which corresponds to the maximum negative voltage. This concentration of electrons
on the tip of the wire repels all electrons away, including the electrons on the top of the patch,
and as a result, these electrons are pushed to the other side of the circular patch. Thus, one
side of the patch becomes positively charged, while the other becomes negatively
charged, thereby creating electric fields between the patch and feed wire like so.
However, when we reverse the voltage to the copper feed wire 42 picoseconds later, we have a
concentration of positive charges, or a lack of electrons at the end of the wire, and thus the
electrons in the patch flow to the other side, the voltage in the patch is flipped, and the
direction of the electric fields are also flipped. Because the feed wire voltage oscillates back and
forth, 42 picoseconds between one peak and trough, the electric fields in the patch will also
oscillate as the electrons, or current, flows back and forth.
If we pause the oscillation we can see some of these electric field vectors,
or arrows, from the patch, are vertical, and because they are equal and opposite, they cancel
out. However, other electric fields are horizontal in the same plane of the patch and are called
fringing fields. These fringing fields are in the same direction and thus they add to each other,
resulting in a combined electric field pointing in this direction. At the same time, electrons
flowing from one side of the disk to the other, which is an electric current, generate a
magnetic field with a strength and direction, or vector, perpendicular to the fringing
electric field vector. As a result, we have an electric field pointing one way, and
a magnetic field pointing perpendicular to that. Let’s move forward in time to where the
voltage on the feedline becomes positive, and now, we’re at the peak of the sinusoid, 42
picoseconds later. The charge concentrations, or voltage, as well as the current, is all
flipped, and thus the electric and magnetic fields point in the opposite directions. Electric
and magnetic fields propagate in all directions, and by creating these oscillating fields,
we’ve generated an electromagnetic wave which travels in the direction perpendicular to
both the electric and magnetic field vectors. Because the two sets of field vectors are not
all in the same plane, but rather are curved, the propagating electromagnetic wave travels outwards
in an expanding shell or balloon-like fashion, kind of like a light bulb on the ceiling. Let’s
simplify the visual so we only see the peak and trough or top and bottom of each wave and note
that the trough is just a vector pointed in the opposite direction. Additionally, the strengths
of these field vectors directly relate back to the voltage and signal that we originally sent
to the copper microstrip feed wire at the bottom of the stack. Which means, if we want to make
these electric and magnetic fields stronger, we just have to increase the voltage sent to the
feedline. It’s like a dimmer on a light switch: more power equals a brighter light.
Thus far we’ve been talking about this aperture-coupled patch-antenna as transmitting;
however, it can also be used for receiving a signal. In this microchip, called a front-end
module, we switch the antenna from transmit to receive and turn off the 12 Gigahertz signal.
When an electromagnetic wave from the satellite is directed towards Dishy, the electric fields
from this incoming signal will influence the electrons in the copper patch, thus generating
an oscillating flow of electrons. This received high-frequency signal is then coupled to the
feedline where it’s sent to the front-end module chip which amplifies the signal. Thus, these
antennas can be used to both transmit and receive electromagnetic waves, but, not at the same time.
Two quick things to note. First, as seen earlier, this antenna has many more layers and is more
complicated than we’ve discussed. For example, here are two circular patches. The bottom is
used to transmit at 13 Gigahertz while the top to receive at 11.7 Gigahertz. Additionally,
there are two H slots and two feed wires to support circular polarization, a reflective plane
in the back, and also, there are multiple features for isolating the operation of one antenna from
the adjacent antennas. We’ve included these and many more details in the creator’s comments which
you can find in the English Canadian subtitles. The second note is that there are electromagnetic
waves of all different frequencies from thousands of different sources passing through
every point on Earth, whether it be visible light from the sun, radio waves from radio or
cell towers, or TV signals from satellites or towers. Therefore in order to block out all
other frequencies of electromagnetic waves, these antenna patches are designed with
very exact dimensions so that they receive and transmit only a very narrow range of
frequencies, and all the other frequencies outside this range are essentially ignored
by the antenna. Let’s move on and see how a single antenna can be combined with others in
order to amplify the beam to reach outer space. This single antenna is only a centimeter or
so in diameter and using only it would be like turning on and off one light bulb and trying
to see it from the international space station. What we need is a way to make the light a few
thousand times brighter, and then focus all the electromagnetic waves into a single powerful
beam. Enter the massive Mr. McFlatface PCB, 55 centimeters wide with a total of 1280
identical antennas in a hexagonal array. The technique of combining all the antennas’
power together is called beamforming. So how does it work? Well, let’s first see what
happens when we have two simplified antennas spaced a short distance away. As mentioned before,
one antenna generates an electromagnetic wave that propagates outwards in a balloon shape. At every
single point in space, there’s only one electric field vector with a strength and direction and
thus the two antennas’ oscillating electric field vectors combine together at all points in
space. In some areas, the electric fields from the antennas are pointing in the same direction
with overlapping peaks, and thus add together via constructive interference, and in other locations,
they’re oppo-site with one peak and one trough, and thus they cancel each other via destructive
interference. We can now see that the zone where they add together constructively is far tighter,
or more focused, than a single antenna alone. When we add even more antennas, the zone of
constructive interference becomes even more focused in what is called a beam front.
Thus, by adding 1280 antennas together we can form a beam with so much intensity and
directionality that it can reach outer space. Now you might be thinking that the strength of 1
antenna duplicated 1280 times over would result in a combined power of, well, 1280 times a single
antenna, but you’d be mistaken. The effective power and range of the main beam from all these
antennas combined is actually closer to 3500 times that of a single antenna. The quick explanation
is that by having these patterns of constructive and destructive interference, it’s as if we
took a single antenna, multiplied it by 1280, and then placed a whole bunch of mirrors around
it and left only a single hole for the main beam to exit through. The long explanation requires
a ton of math and physics, so let’s move on. Dishy McFlatface and the Starlink Satellites
undoubtedly have some rather complicated science and engineering inside and to fully comprehend it
all you have to be a multidisciplinary student. To help you do that, check out Brilliant, which
is sponsoring this video. Brilliant is an amazing tool for learning. They teach a wide range
of STEM topics in hands-on, interactive ways, many of which directly relate to Starlink
and other cutting-edge technologies such as electric cars, quantum computers,
rocketry, or neural networks. For example, they have an entire course dedicated
to Waves and Light, and another one on gravitational physics which will greatly help
in understanding Starlink and SpaceX rockets. Brilliant is nothing like a boring textbook,
but rather all the courses use interactive modules to make the lessons entertaining
and to help the concepts stick in your head. To really understand today’s frontier technologies
and to help you become a revolutionary engineer and entrepreneur like Elon Musk, you have
to be versed in a wide range of fields in science and engineering. We recommend you sign
up, try out some of the lessons for free and, if you like them, which we’re sure you will, sign
up for an annual subscription. To the viewers of this channel, Brilliant is offering 20% off an
annual subscription to the first 200 people who sign up. Just go to brilliant.org/brancheducation.
You can find that link in the description below. Now let’s continue exploring how a powerful
beam can be continuously swept across the sky, and then how we fill it with hundreds
of megabits of data every second. As a quick refresher from before, here’s
an array of 1280 antennas and we fed them all with the same 12 Gigahertz signal in order to
create a laser-like beam propagating perpendicular to Dishy. However, as mentioned earlier, we need
to be able to angle this beam so that it points directly at the Starlink satellite zooming
across the sky at 27,000 kilometers per hour. Using the motors isn’t feasible because they would
break within a month and aren’t accurate enough. So, the solution is to use what’s
called phased array beam steering. Let’s go back to our two-antenna
example. Before we were feeding the same signal to the two antennas, and thus
the antennas were in phase with one another. Understanding phase is critical, so quickly:
changing the height or amplitude of the signal is done by changing the power sent to the
antenna, thus making the signal stronger or weaker. The frequency is how many peaks and
troughs, or wavelengths there are in one second, and changing the phase is shifting the signal left
or right. Phase shifting is measured in degrees between 0 and 359, because, if we shift the signal
360 degrees, or one full wavelength, then we’re back at the beginning, exactly as if we were to
loop around a circle. For example, here’s a signal with a 45-degree phase shift, here’s another
with a 180-degree shift, and then another with a 315-degree shift. Your eyes can’t see differences
in phase shifted visible light, however, high-tech circuitry such as what’s inside Dishy is really
good at detecting and working with phase shifts. So then, how do we use phase shifting to angle the
beam and have it point directly at the satellite? The solution is to phase shift the signal sent to
one antenna with respect to the other antenna and, as a result, the timing of the peaks and troughs
emitted from one antenna is different from the other. These peaks and troughs propagate
outwards, and the location of the constructive interference is now angled to the left with
destructive interference everywhere else. If we change the phase of the antennas again, the
zone of constructive interference is angled to the right. Therefore, by continuously changing
the phase of the signals sent to the antennas, we can create a sweeping zone of
the constructive interference. Let's bring in six more antennas and simplify
the visual so that we only see a section of the peaks from each wave. Far away from the
antennas, the waves join to form a wave front that is a planar wave. Kind of like ocean
waves crashing on a shoreline. Just as before, by continuously changing the timing of when
each wave peak is emitted by each antenna, we can change the angle at which the wave front
is formed, essentially steering the beam in one direction or another. And, if we bring in
more antennas in a two-dimensional array, we can now steer the beam in any direction
within a one-hundred-degree field of view. Let’s move back to view all 1280 antennas in
Dishy. In order to know the exact angle the beam needs to be pointed or steered, we use the GPS
coordinates of Dishy from this chip over here, along with the orbital position of the Starlink
satellite which is known in Dishy’s software. The software computes the exact set of 3D angles and
the required phase shift for each of the antennas. These phase shift results are then sent
to the 20 larger chips called beamformers, and each beamformer coordinates between 32 smaller
chips called front end modules, each of which controls 2 antennas. Every few microseconds, these
computations are recalculated and disseminated to all the microchips in order to perfectly aim the
beam at the satellite. As a result, the beam can be steered anywhere in a 100-degree field of view.
There are a few quick notes. First, the main beam, also called the main lobe looks like this.
However, constructive and destructive interference isn’t perfect, and as a result
there are additional side lobes of lesser power. Third, Mr. McFlatface holds is a single phased
array, however, on the Starlink satellite, there are in fact 4 phased array antennas. Two
are used to communicate with multiple Dishys, and 2 are used to communicate with the ground
stations to relay the internet traffic. And fourth, phased arrays are used in many
applications, and interestingly they’re used on commercial airlines to allow for mid-flight
internet. So this video also tangentially explains how mid-flight internet works.
Before we explore how actual data is sent, we want to mention that this video took a month
to research, two dozen script revisions, and two months to model and animate. If your mind is blown
by the complexity of this technology and the depth of this video click the subscribe button, like
this video, write a comment below, and we’ll be sure to create more videos like this one.
The third topic we’re going to dive into is how information gets sent between Dishy and
the Starlink satellite. For example, we’ve talked about high-frequency
sinusoid-shaped electromagnetic waves, but that doesn’t look anything like binary
and even less like your favorite TV show. So, what’s happening? Well, Dishy and the
satellite indeed send a signal that looks like this; however, they vary the amplitude and the
phase of the transmitted signal and then assign or encode 6-bit binary values to each different
combination or permutation of amplitude and phase. With 6 bits, there are 64 different
values, and thus we need 64 different permutations of amplitude and phase. However,
instead of listing all the permutations, it’s more easily visualized by arranging the 64
different values in a graph called a constellation diagram as shown. Let’s look at the point 011 101
and draw a line from the origin to this point. The distance from the origin is the amplitude
of the signal, and the angle from the positive-X axis is the phase. It’s a bit like using polar
coordinates. Thus, for Dishy to send these 6-bits, it transmits a signal with an amplitude
of 59% and a phase shift of 121 degrees. Then, if the next value being sent is 101 000, the
signal switches to an 87% amplitude or brightness, and a 305-degree phase shift. After that it sends
the next value with a different amplitude and phase shift. Each of these 6-bit groupings are
called symbols and they last for only 10 or so nanoseconds before the next symbol is sent.
Lots of times you see the signal scrunched up like this however, because the frequency of
the signal is just once every 83 picoseconds, or 12 Gigahertz, and since a symbol lasts 10
nanoseconds, it’s more accurate to have around 120 wavelengths per symbol before the next symbol
is sent. Because we’re dealing on the order of pico and nanoseconds, that means that we
can fit 90 million 6-bit groups or symbols, resulting in 540 million bits per second. However,
note that this data transfer is shared between download and upload. Since this particular antenna
can’t transmit and receive data at the same time, about 74 milliseconds of every second is
used to send data from Dishy to the Starlink satellite and 926 milliseconds is used to send
data from the satellite down to Dishy. And, for the sake of reducing latency, these time
slots get distributed throughout a single second instead of grouping them all together.
This technique of sending 6-bit values using different variations of amplitude and
phase is called 64QAM or Quadrature Amplitude Modulation and is more complicated than we
discussed but let’s not get sidetracked. Now that we have a stream of millions of 6-bit
symbols yielding hundreds of megabits of data per second, in order to turn it into your favorite
TV show we use the advanced video codec, or h.264 format. You can learn more about that in our
video that explores image compression shown here. I’m sure you have many questions, and by
all means put them in the comments below, but before we finish let’s clarify two things.
First, the scale of practically everything in this video is off. Here’s the correct scale of Dishy
and the Starlink Satellite, however Dishy is 550 kilometers away which we can’t correctly show. In
stark contrast, the emitted electromagnetic waves are only around 2.5 centimeters apart, and thus
between Dishy and the satellite there are around 22 million wavelengths which is many more than the
few waves that you see here. Additionally, in this animation we’re showing the wavelengths slowly
making their way up and down, when in reality it only takes around 2 milliseconds for an
electromagnetic wave emitted from Dishy or the Starlink satellite to reach the other.
The second clarification is that we disproportionately show Dishy emitting
electromagnetic waves and sending them to the satellite. In reality the satellite dish
is more frequently in receive mode and the steps and physics of receiving an electromagnetic wave
are similar to emitting one, just in reverse. That’s pretty much it for how Starlink and Dishy
send data to each other. The original script for this video was over 45 minutes long, so all the
details that were cut got thrown in the creator’s comments found in the English Canada subtitles.
Thank you to all of our Patreon and YouTube Membership Sponsors for helping to make
this video. Also, thank you to Colin O’Flynn at NewAE Technology for lending us a
Starlink Dishy PCB for imaging and research. This is Branch Education, and we
create 3D animations that dive deep into the technology that drives our
modern world. Watch another Branch video by clicking one of these cards or click here
to subscribe. Thanks for watching to the end!
