CJI got Angry-"Don't shout at me, you are in the Court!", on Electoral Bond, Supreme Court of India

but we have find applications today morning the application is not numbered it is not registered you'll follow what source for the go Mr sorry no oral mentioning in my quot I'm I'm not I'm in the in the matter I'm saying I am saying No Such application on board Let It Be circulated we'll deal with it in the normal cause but I respectfully submitting C we will not tolerate this you have to follow the rules in my court if make an order today my application will be infructuous I am saying kindly defer the issue of Grant of alpha aware proceedings were going on you could have interv at that stage what is this after the judgment is passed you want to intervene now the order is of 15th March ask you are aware about the proceedings pending before the not anywhere people were not parties at any time everybody the whole world knew that this matter was being heard back one second Mr you come here after the judgment is delivered you now you you file an application that's not I have come only in regard March kindly appreciate I have no problem in Declaration of the list of donors or the list of recipients will not hear you right now we have a specific application board you asked your Advocate on record to follow the procedure file an email it will be dealt with the register listing we'll take a I am saying kindly if I do it for Mr rohi senior C then Mr RI you look at me as chief justice I have no Fai to tell all the other Juniors to whom I decline list mentioning in the morning what SCE for the go is SCE for the not mentioning I'm not appearing in the matter and speaking a submission we have no such application on board before us I have got it with made my second wait one time sorry Mr yes my submission is en G has beened behind the back of the public this second yes one second this please listen to me one second I have a citizen of this country one second yes don't shout at me no no I very soft please listen to me yes this is not a high corner meeting okay you are in the court yes you want to move an application file an application what I told Mr RI applies to you the question is no question my friend has come Mr Nar one second yes you've got my decision as chief justice we not hearing you if you want to file an application file an application move it on the email that's the rule in this court no we go by what want another I said what I wanted to say that this judment is Rend behind the back of the people of this country it doesn't B us it doesn't cons not please once we have said no please move the your says do not do not continue and persist yes I only say it was on represent Pro theer obing in the administration of justice you are obing in the process of AD jce the en judment is against behind the back of these people Parliament has been that's all that's all we heard please that's all we will not hear you till you move follow the procedure prescribed we are filing it please do we fing it please do we'll consider it 10:00 my friend came from Canada take took a 1:00 flight kind to us may I mention my Lord my petition for so that is pending whatever Lord want to do that do only I Will Not Disturb Lord Mr apart from being a senior Council you're the president of the SCBA yeah you should know the procedure you have written a letter to me asking me to invoke my S Moto jurisdiction yes yes my Lord to mention so that I should not dist Lord we should not waste it honorable time Court's time that's why are Allied will not whatever feel better Mr agala please keep it that keep it at that I may have to say something more which will be perhaps abolutely dist begging with your we have been telling you that you are interfering you're obing us don't stop when we are not heard and we are we feel threatened yes now uh we should notice on the last occasion to State Bank of India uh Kap you appearing you're for the State Bank that's right yes I for the State Bank yes uh Mr s in our order which we in the in the Judgment which we delivered we had expressly asked State Bank of India to disclose all details the language of the Judgment was all details have to be disclosed uh therefore that includes the bond numbers as well so let SBI not be selective in the disclosure of details we intend to clarify that it shall disclose all details including the bond numbers and every part of the information which is in its possession and custody don't wait for an order of the Court we banked on the fact that the State Bank of India would be candid and fair to the court well I just whatever your say if your say Bond numbers we can disclose the bond number there's no problem scre them why has the uh why has the SBI not disclosed I wanted to tell how we understood your judgment give me five minutes only to explain our conduct we of course if say give anything more everything will be given there's no question FBI's attitude appears to be you tell us to disclose a particular detail and we'll disclose it that's not the that's not fair process this is the Judgment of the Supreme Court as chairman of the State Bank of India I'm Duty bound to comply with the Judgment I will disclose every part of the information which is in my custody as directed by the Supreme Court because when we said all details of the purchases that means every conceivable detail which is available with State Bank of India and we clarified by saying including uh that should be I mean State Bank of India has the best legal advice open to it yeah I will not take a lot to the three orders to how we understood them all your first your lordship's first order was 12th April 2019 and we have for convenience or we have put the three orders together for just see that we'll give everything there's no question just to explain that it's not that the impression which is being created is that State Bank of India has been playing ducks and DRS of the court I just wanted to clear that up if your lordship sees the 12th April 2019 order in paragraph 16 I asked my friend to make a little compilation of the orders so we could your yes par 17 right par 16 you got this yes this is the inter mod my lords had been pleased to make after noting all the changes the court would have to ensure that any interim Arrangement that may be made would not take the balance in favor of either of the parties but the same ensures adequate safeguards against the competing claims of the parties which are yet to be adjudicated in the above perspective according to us the just and proper interim direction would be to require can we just see par 15 again one yes the court therefore has to ensure that any interim Arrangement that may be made would not tilt the balance in favor of either of the parties but the same would ensure adequate safeguards against the competing claims of the parties which are yet to be adjudicated in the perspective according to us the just and proper interim direction would be to require all political parties who have received donation through the Electoral bonds to submit to the election commission of India and seal cover detailed particulars of the donors against Each Bond the amount of each such Bond and the full particulars of the credit received against each such Bond namely the particular of the bank account to which the amount had been credited and the date of each such credit so your lord felt this would what would ensure transparency that you give all this but you keep it in a SE cover so a political party doesn't need Bond number if a political party comes and say I received so much from so and so that giv take it you're not arguing a case for a political party right no no no no on the contrary for I'm saying the reverse I'm so sorry I'm saying the reverse 16 Mr Salway was relating to the political parties who had to submit the data to the correct to the election commission correct and they have and this has no that's a that's a separate issue they whatever they have declared or not declared that's a separate issue but as far as the Judgment of this court is concerned because you supposed to I'm coming in a minute will just give me one minute how we understood it par 16 with as my Lord is therefore noticed only required the political parties to give all these details and these details have been given or not if they have not been given that's between the ECI and the political parties we have I have no I'm as not the Chief Justice said I'm not preparing for a political party then par 17 was the mechanism your said detail will be furnished in respect of electoral bonds the detail of such bonds that may be received by a political party up to a date for issuing such bonds as with the ministry that is February 19 will be submitted on before 3rd of May 19 the seal covers will remain in the custody of the ECS we had no role to play yours had put this mechanism in in place in your lordship's judgment your Lordships dealt with the diverse aspects including the need to preserve some degree of anonymity and you will not Mark that in par 125 where your Lordships discuss the Electoral trust as a alternative to this system and in the conclusions which par 218 I if if you not the compilation be PDF page 76 yeah your say we direct the disclosure of information on contribution received by political parties under the Electoral bond schem to give logical and complete effect to the ruling on 12th April the court issued an interim Direction ordering order directing that the information of donation received from donation will be received must be submitted by political parties the coure directed political parties to submit detailed particulars of dollar against Each Bond the amount of each Bond and the full particulars of the credit received against Each Bond namely the particulars of the bank account to which the amount has been credited and and the date on which such credit has been made I'm only not saying this to explain how we understood the order so this correlation between which political parties receive money from whom comes in here because the political party says I have received so much money from so and so

Channel: Court Live

Views: 13,183

Keywords: #law, #judge, #courtlive, #advocate, #SupremeCourt, #Mussorrie, #lawyer, #legal, #livehighcourt, #indianlaw, #live, #court, #argument, live stream, power of judge, ias, ips, police, judiciary, learn law, supreme court of india, young lawyers, high court, patna high court, bihar, bihar news, court proceedings, ipc, crpc, cpc, evidence, clat, law entrance, bihar judiciary, bihar judicial, exams, bpsc, patna police, bihar police, constitution, news, politics, political news, bjp, aap, congress

Id: xvopmwle3SA

Length: 12min 13sec (733 seconds)

Published: Sat Apr 06 2024