Best Tumbler? Stanley vs Yeti? Let’s Find Out!

some drinks taste best when they're cold and others taste best when they're hot so the question is which Tumblr does the best job at keeping that beverage at the right temperature we'll see which tumblers do the best job at keeping drinks hot and cold we'll also see which ones prevent splashes and Spills when they tip over finally we'll see which Tumblers or dishwashers safe at a price of $8 the least expensive Tumblr we'll be testing is made by hassle Outfitters all the Tumblers will be testing are 20 o it's made of stainless steel and it's vacuum insulated they claim this tumbler is sweatproof and non-slippery they also claim that it keeps hot water for 3 hours in cold ice for 9 hours it's BPA free and it's made of food grade materials the hassle Outfitters is made in China and the hassle weighs 35.5 G many of the Tumblers claim to be spill Splash or leak proof so let's add a few ounces of water to each tumbler and see how they perform unfortunately the house will made quite a mess at a price of $9 is this Juro brand it's a double wall vacuum insulated Tumblr with lid and straw the manufacturer claims that any hot drink will stay hot for up to 6 hours cooler drinks will stay cool for up to 20 24 hours made with 100% stainless steel and the lid is BPA free for only $9 it also comes with two different types of lid a new slide lid as well as a flip lid the Juro is made in China and the Juro is pretty light at 277.49 and straw it's made with food grade stainless steel they claim it'll keep your drinks hot for 3 hours and cold for 9 the splash proof lid snugly grips each tumbler they also claim anti-perspiration no condensation and easy to clean the meron is made in China and it's brand keeps liquids warm for 6 hours and cold for 24 they claim their coating is four times more durable chip and scratch resistant large 3-in opening fits ice and is easy to fill and pour the interior is Electro polished to prevent retaining flavors the clean canteen is made in China the clean canteen weighs 3177 G and the clean canteen made an even bigger mess than the hassle definitely not the Tumblr of choice when wearing your Sunday Best at a price of $19 is this Artic brand it's a double wall vacuum insulated travel mug with airtight seal they it's overbuilt and not overpriced a flip top screw on close your lid to prevent unwanted spills keeps eyes for 24 hours and hot for six it's designed by Arctic outdoors in Katy Texas in made in China and it's 36.2 G for the Arctic and the arctic's Press on lid is closed and on nice and tight and the Arctic did a great job of voting spills and splashes it also proved to be leak proof when gently placed upside down at a price of $20 is this turis diamond plate brand copper lined 188 stainless steel construction is durable and material won't retain taste or odors keeps your drink hot for 8 hours and cold for 24 designed in Venice Florida and made in China and the diamond plate weighs 338.15 hours the Coleman Tumblr is made in China and the Coleman is lighter than average at 299.8 G and the Coleman's lid is on nice and tight and properly closed and the colan perform better than the hassle and clean canteen but not nearly as well as some of the other brands at a price of $22 is this Arctic tumblr's brand case beverage is cold for 16 hours and hot for up to 8 hours they claim that the lid on the Tumblr is Spill and splash proof 100% BPA free and sweat free the lid is designed to be used with or without a straw the Arctic tumblers is made in China and it's 35.6 G for the Arctic and the Arctic Tumblr is ready to Tumble and the Arctic Tumblr kept everything inside the tumbler after tip over and when placed upside down at a price of $23 is this iron flask brand they claim it keeps beverages hot for 5 hours and cold for 20 it's constructed of 188 premium stainless steel 100% BPA free and non-toxic it comes with two leak proof Lids it even includes an extra straw the iron flask is made in China and the iron flask weighs also seems to have a very well-designed lid for avoiding spills and leaks and iron flask performed very well and held everything inside the tumbler also at a price of $23 is this mirror brand made of 188 stainless steel features a thermo 3D double wall vacuum insulation the mirror is made in China and it's 324.50 G for the mirror and the mirror claims that it doesn't leak or spill but unfortunately it does spill when tipped over it also leaks pretty bad when facing upside down at a price of $25 is this camack brand it has an 188 stainless steel full powder coat finish drink clean with BPA BPS and BPF free it's even dishwasher safe spill resistant and triy mode lid for flow control the camo back is made in China and a camo back weighs 318.15 G in a fully closed position the Camel Back has a vent hole that prevents a complete seal and the Camel Back spilled some water when tipped over and when facing downward at a price of $28 is this Hydro Flask brand it has a temp Shield double wall vacuum insulation the powder coat is supposed to be durable and free the closable press in lid is supposed to stop splashes and trap temperature made with 188 prograde stainless steel it's supposed to be dishwasher safe the hydr flask is made in China and hydr flask is pretty light at only 29293 G and the Hydro Flask does claim to stop splashes but it does not claim to stop leaks and hydr flas performed as advertised with a small amount of water escaping during tip over and when facing downward at a price of $30 is this Stanley quencher H20 this is a very popular Tumblr with tens of thousands of reviews use it claims to have an advanced lid construction the straw opening is designed to resist splashes with the seal that holds a reusable straw the Stanley is made in China and it's 315.3 G for the Stanley three positions include closed an opening for sipping and an opening for a straw and a Stanley lid is in the fully closed position and the Stanley did a great job with tip over and it did not leak in the upside down position the Stanley did leak a very small amount of water and the most expensive tumber we'll be testing is made by Yeti and cost $35 this is an extremely popular tumber with about 140,000 reviews tens of thousands of these tumblers are sold every month stainless steel vacuum insulated Tumblr with mag slider lid the magslider lid uses magnets to keep your favorite beverage from spilling the lid is not leak proof and it will not prevent spills however it is BPA free and dishwasher safe the yeti is made in China and the yeti is by far the heaviest yet at 382.48 brand is very forthcoming about their tumbler not being leak or spillproof however it still performed fairly well with just a small amount of water escaping during the test in the next test let's fill all the Tumblers with ice cold water and we'll measure the temperature of the water after just 5 hours the water is very close to 33° F and the shop temperature is right at 77.2 De F and it's been right at 5 hours and the house will perform well at 41.3 de F and the jural lid does a better job of sealing and it's about a half a degree warmer than the hassle at 41.8 and the meran has a narrow and Tall design and the Maran moves into the lead at 39.5 de and the clean canteen lid does not create a airtight seal and it moves into fourth place behind the hassle at 42° and the Artic lid offers a great seal but it's not quite as thermally efficient as some of the other brands at 42.5 and the turis Tumblr performed very well at 40.6 De to move into second place and the Coleman is about 4° warmer than the leader the meran at 43.4 De and the Arctic tumblers performed about the same as the Coleman at 43.5 De the iron flask lid offers a pretty good seal and the water temperature is at 42.6 and the mirror performed better than average at 41.8 De and the Camelback offers a very thermally efficient tumbler at 39.1 de to move into the lead and the lid on the Hydro Flask offers a decent seal but the Tumblr isn't quite as efficient as some of the other brands at 43.5 and the Stanley is a very popular tumbler and it seems to make sense as a Stanley just moved into the lead at 38.9 De very impressive and the yeti is also very popular and it too performed very well at 41.9 De so the Stanley came out on top at 38.9 De ever the Camelback performed almost as well at 39.1 meran also performed very well at 39.5 de since the Tumblers are completely full let's measure the Tipping Point for each tumbler the stakes are pretty high if the hassle tips over since it splashes and leaks badly and the hassle perform well at 20.9 De if the jural is in use the opening is going to be open and it tips over at 20.6 De which is almost as good as the hassle and am meron's tall and narrow profile makes it a lot more prone to tip over and am Aman laid down at 16.6 6° of tilt and the clean canteen isn't nearly as tall and narrow as the meran and that really helps 19.1 de and the Artic is tapered quite a bit at the bottom of the tumbler and it toppled over at 17.8 de and the turis has a profile that favors staying upright and is 20° for the turis and the colan looks deceptively welld designed for this test but the bottom of the Tumblr is rounded which really hurts and 16.1 de is the worst yet and the Arctic tumblers also appears to have a pretty good profile for this test but the bottom of the Tumblr is a little more rounded than some of the other tumblers with a very similar profile and it's over at 18.8 De and the iron flask is built like a 1980s bodybuilder and all of that upper body weight on top of those skinny legs really hurts at only 16.4 de and the mirror mirror is not on a wall but it did take a fall at 17.7 De okay just trying to have some fun with this and the Camel Back has a lot of taper on the bottom and it also has a nonslip silicone base if it gets bumped the camel back probably will not slide but it will lay over at 12.6 deg of tilt and the Hydro Flask has a pretty good profile for this test for the most part however the very bottom of the tumbler is rounded and the Hydro Flask took a fall at 19.2 de and the Stanley is pretty topheavy but the bottom of the Tumblr is pretty squared off and the Stanley fell over at around 19.4 de and the most popular Tumblr on the market has a very small taper towards the very bottom of the Tumblr but the bottom of the Tumblr is very welld designed to keep this Tumblr upright and 21.1 de is the best yet so the yeti came out on top at 21.1 De however the Hassel Juro and turis tumblers also perform very well at around 20° or better if you're like me that Tumblr comes in really handy for keeping coffee nice and warm so let's heat up some water and then we'll place it inside of a freezer that's set to -40° C which also works out to be - 40° F and the water is just over 180° which is more than hot enough for this next test there's already a small amount of water inside the cooler which will help cool this water down just a little I'll give the cooler several minutes for the internal temperature to stabilize throughout I'll quickly fill up all the Tumblers and then we'll begin the three-hour test and the water temperature is starting out at 156.25 1° inside the hassle and the Juro does have a sealed lid and that helped quite a bit and it's 99.8 de for the Juro and the narrowmouth on auran reduces the opportunity for heat loss and Aman moves into the lead at 9.8 de and a clean canteen also has an unsealed lid just like the hassle and that really hurt the performance of the tumbler at 94° and the Arctic has a sealed lid just like the Juro and the Arctic performed about the same as the Juro at 98.3 de and the turis diamond plate also has a sealed lid and moves into second place behind the Merin at right at 100° unfortunately the Coleman really struggled in this test at 87.7 de or about 22° cooler than the meran and the Arctic tumblers has a lid that offers a really good SE seal and it's 96° for the Arctic tumblers and the iron flask has a plastic lid that not only seals but also overlaps with the rim of the tumbler and that's a very good design and the iron flash just secured an ironclad lead at 11 15.8 de very impressive and the mirror also performed a lot better than average at 102.8 De and the cam back performed very well at keeping water cold and it also performed very well at holding heat at 106.2 De and the rim on the Hydro Flask isn't as well protected from cold temperatures as a camel back and that really hurt his per performance at 94.7 de and there are several reasons why the Stanley is an incredibly popular tumbler and one of the reasons is that the Stanley does a terrific job at keeping liquids warm at 106.7 de and a Yeti also is an extremely popular Tumblr but it doesn't hold heat quite as well as a Stanley at 98.8 De so the iron flask came out on top at 11 15.8 de Aman finished in second at 10.8 Stanley in the camel back also performed very well at just over 106° a tip over is one thing but let's see what happens when these completely full tumblers tumble off the table at a distance of almost 30 in onto a concrete floor if the hassle Falls onto a hard floor from 30 in is probably going to be a hassle to clean up unfortunately the lid broke from the impact and the juro's lid stayed on the tumbler but the jural lid did break the tumbler also leaked some water onto the floor and am mica's lid did a decent job at containing the water in the previous tip over test however the amica's lid did come off the tumbler and the lid did experience quite a bit of damage from the impact and a clean canteen also lost his top from impacting the floor no damage to the lid and the arctic's lid just about held everything in but the lid did experience a pretty bad crack from the impact and the turis survived the head-on collision with the floor without losing its top only a very small amount of water escaped and the lid survived without any damage and the Coleman's lid stayed on the tumbler but it did move out of the fully seated position and leaked out several ounces of water no visible damage to the lid and the flip top totally flipped out on the Arctic tumblers from the impact it did contain most of the water and the lid survived without any damage and the iron flask has a screw on lid that's designed to take a licking and keep on ticking it looks like a small amount of water might have escaped but the lid is still as good as new and the mirror lost some water on the previous tip over test and it spilled pretty much everything out after hitting the floor the lid survived without any damage and the camel back's tapered bottom makes it pretty prone to tipping over unfortunately the camel back's lid was not able to stay attached to the tumbler however the lid did survive without any damage and the Hydro Flask held on to its top after impact but it did leak a little bit more water than iron flask no damage to the lid and the Stanley also has a screw on top and the lid stayed attached to the Stanley but the lid moved to the open position and leaked a little water just like most of the other brands the yeti has a press on lid unfortunately the lid popped off after impact but the lid held up just fine most of the Tumblers received the best possible rating of one for durability however four of the brands experienced a lot of damage to their Lids from the impact if you're looking for a tumbler that can handle a pretty hard impact while also containing its content the turis and the iron flask perform the best with the best possible rating a one all of these tumblers claim to hold 20 oz but can they actually hold 20 oz I've got very close to 20 oz inside of this measuring cup and the hassle will hold 20 oz but you'll have to sip some of the contents before installing the lid and the jural came very close to 20 oz but came up just a little short and the meran has plenty of space for 20 oz and I was able to install the lid without creating a spill and a clean canteen holds 20 oz but there's not enough space to install the lid and the artick has a little more capacity than the clean canteen but there's not enough to install the lid with 20 oz and the Jervis diamond plate came up about a/2 ooun short just like the Jervis the Coleman also came up just a little bit short and the Arctic tumblers also came up about a/ ooun short on space and the iron flask will hold about 20 oz without the lid but that's about it and the mirror is pretty much maxed out but a couple of sips in the lid should fit camels are known for their desire for water and this Camel Back easily held 20 o with plenty of room to spare for the lid and the Hydro Flask is out of space a little early at around 19 1/2 o and the Stanley not only does a great job of keeping beverages cold it also holds 20 o as advertised with the lid and the yeti also does a great job of keeping drinks cold but it came up about a half ounce short if you like to drink your Morning Joe on the go you'll probably want to keep one hand on the wheel while opening and closing the tumbler so let's see which tumblers are for the easiest access Lids let's skip the hassle since it can't be closed and the jural lid pops off before the flip lid opens so you'll probably need to use both hands to open the Juro and it takes quite a bit of force to open the lid at 4.78 lb even though the am is narrow and easy to grip with just one hand the slider is difficult to work with and the amkin slider just doesn't like to slide at 2.7 lbs of force skipping the clean canteen since the lid remains open and the flip lid cover on the Arctic seems pretty easy to work with and the flip top is unlocked at 3/4 of a pound the best yet and the turis diamond plate not only does a pretty good job of preventing big messes if it falls over it also is pretty easy to open about a half a pound of force and the Coleman takes a little bit more effort to open than the turis and it takes about a pound of force to slide to slider on the Coleman opening the flip top on the Arctic tumblers is pretty easy and it's 1.22 lb of force according to the scale and the name iron flas seems to fit as the flip top is as solid as iron and pretty hard to open with just one hand and it takes 3.72 lbs to flip the flip top to the open position if the mirror topples over it's probably going to spill however the slider is very easy to open and only a quar pound of force and the Camel Back can be opened with just one hand but it definitely takes quite a bit of effort and 3.87 pounds is quite a bit of force for a sliding lid cover and the hydro flash slides freely once it gets moving but it takes 3.25 lbs of force to get the slider to begin sliding unless you have a bionic can with 10 fingers you're going to need two hands to open the Stanley once the Stanley lid is unlocked it takes 2.24 lbs to move and one of the reasons the yeti is by far the bestselling Tumblr in the world is because of its very Innovative and userfriendly sliding lid cover and it takes less than a pound of force to slide the slider on the yeti in the final test let's spray the Tumblers with a mix of hydrogen peroxide vinegar and salt to see if these tumblers are resistant to corrosion and it's only been a couple of hours so let's take a closer look at each brand and the hassle is supposed to be hand washed and it's definitely not very corrosion resistant unfortunately quite a bit of rust has already formed just like the hassle the jural also experienced quite a bit of oxidation definitely not dishwasher safe and ameran performed very well on the croan resistant test no visible rust on the inside or outside of the tumbler and the clean canteen also performed very well with just a couple of spots where rust is just beginning to form and the Arctic did perform better than the hassle and the Juro but not quite as well as the Merkin or the clean canteen and the turis performed about the same as the Arctic with just a few areas of rust beginning to form unfortunately the Coleman experienced quite a bit of oxidation compared to most of the other brands and the Arctic also experienced quite a bit of corrosion but not quite as bad as the hassle or the Juro and the iron flask performed very well with just one little spot of rust and the mirror also performed extremely well without any visible rust just a few spots of rust have formed on the cam back definitely better than average and the Hydro Flask experienced quite a bit of rust on the inside and outside of the tumbler once again the Stanley is proving its worth without any visible rust on the inside or outside of the Tumblr and the yeti experienced some rusting on the outside of the Tumblr so which Tumblr is the best the Tumblers are organized from least expensive to most expensive I've converted the raw scores into an A through F grading scale to help make sense of the results for a price of around $20 I really like the turus diamond plate it performed very well at thermal efficiency earning A's in both hot and cold temperature performance it's also welld designed to avoid tipping over if it does tip over or even falls off the table it's probably not going to make a huge mess regarding ergonomics the lid on the turis is very easy to open the biggest downside to the turis is that it is a little more susceptible to corrosion compared to some of the other brands for only around $3 more I really like the iron flask it performed very well in just about every category the biggest downside is it does tip over pretty easily in my opinion the best all-around Tumblr in the lineup is indeed the Stanley it earned a for holding heat in cold tip over spill Splash resistance lid durability impacting the floor from 30 in and corrosion resistance the biggest downside is that it does take a couple of hands to open the lid now I know why my coffee's been getting cold I've been using the wrong tumbler all the videos in this channel including this one are viewers suggested so if you have a video idea I hope you'll take time to leave a comment thanks so much for watching please take care and I look forward to next time

Channel: Project Farm

Views: 1,314,653

Keywords: Tumbler review, best tumbler, stanley tumbler review, yeti tumbler review, hydro flask tumbler review, camelbak tumbler review, MiiR Tumbler review, Iron Flask Tumbler review, Arctic Tumblers review, coleman tumbler review, tervis diamond plate tumbler review, RTIC tumbler review, Klean Kanteen tumbler review, murricon tumbler review, Juro tumbler review, hasle outfitters tumbler review

Id: 3S51X9h6K6g

Length: 20min 22sec (1222 seconds)

Published: Sun Jan 14 2024