Baseball Has An Angel Hernandez Problem

Angel Hernandez has been an MLB umpire for 31 years yet despite with all this experience he is the worst umpire in MLB history Angel has blown several calls is overly confrontational and even tried suing MLB for discrimination in a 2018 players poll conducted by ESPN he was voted as the worst umpire in the league with 22% of players identifying him in 2023 Angel finished the regular season as the lowest rated umpire with 161 won bad calls in just 10 games including the lowest rated game last night he set a new record with the largest Miss on a strikeout with a strikeout pitch that missed outside by 6.7 in his controversial calls and poor performance have plagued MLB for years leaving fans players and managers frustrated and questioning the Integrity of the game while also making him one of the most disliked figures in baseball and for good reason because over here he miss calls on this side he missed up high he missed for both godamn sides and I'm sure if Angel could see this video he'd be very upset or even Sumi for discrimination but the result is clear MLB has an Angel Hernandez problem now can one man's judgment calls really make or break America's favorite pastime for years Angel Hernandez has been at the center of controversy in MLB as an Umpire Hernandez has the power to influence the outcome of games with his decisions behind the plate and on the field however his track record is tarnished by inconsistency questionable calls and a perceived lack of accountability in a sport where every pitch and every play matters the impact of an umpire's decision cannot be overstated enough as frustration grows many are left wondering how one can continue to umire despite all these issues the Angel Hernandez problem has exposed deeper issues within MLB's umpire system highlighting the need for increased accountability and a closer examination of the human element in officiating born in Havana Cuba Angel's journey to becoming a major league baseball empire began right after high school he cut his teeth in the minor leagues before finally making it up to the majors full-time as a National League umpire in 1993 in the year since Hernandez has found himself at the center of numerous high-profile incidents that have called his judgment and confidence into question one of the most notorious incidents involving Hernandez occurred on May 8th 2013 during a game between the Cleveland Indians and Oakland Athletics most of the time bad calls are limited to plays when the ball stays in the park but even Hernandez was able to find away on this one Hernandez ruled what was appeared to be a clear home run as a double a decision that ultimately contributed to Oakland's loss even after MLB aded the call was incorrect the original ruling stood to this day Hernandez has refused to admit that this call was incorrect and has even attempted to blame the quality of the replay equipment Hernandez's issues extend beyond on isolated incidents in 2017 he filed a racial discrimination lawsuit against MLB alleging that he had been passed over for crew chief positions and high-profile assignments due to his Latino Heritage luckily for us MLB was able to win this lawsuit and even got an open look to see that emilyb thinks he's terrible too one of the many things EML noted was not confident in Hernandez's ability to perform effectively on an even more intense stage and for this reason did not select him for the World Series That season now after losing this case you would think that you would try and improve to climb up the ladder but still Hernandez remains a lightninging rod for criticism and controversy from players like Ian Kinsler proclaiming that Hernandez needs to find another job to MLB's own defense in the lawsuit painting him as an Empire who inflames onfield tension it's clear that angel Hernandez's presence on the diamond is a problem that extends far beyond the occasional blown call but how deep does the impact of Angel Hernandez's officiating go a closer look reveals the troubling pattern of game-changing decisions that have left players managers and fans alike questioning the very Integrity of the sport in 1998 the Mets faithful will recall an unfortunate moment where Hernandez essentially stole a game from them with a shocking and I mean shocking call when Atlanta's Michael Tucker sped around third base in the bottom of the 11th inning Mets left fielder threw a dart home for the Mets catcher who was able to tag Tucker's foot before he touched home of course Hernandez thought otherwise handing the Braves a 3-2 Victory and a sweep over the Mets in 2013 Hernandez proved that he could make an impact all the way across the field by blowing a call at first base during a 33 game in the 10th inning between the white socks and the Marlins Angel ruled that the Marlins had completed a double play against Chicago even though Alex Rios had clearly beaten out the throw now in 2018 Angel was on his way to umpire in the 2018 World Series before getting overturned three times at first base on video reviews during game three of that Year's ALDS between the Yankees and the Red Sox and it turns out Hernandez's Antics no no borders this man is international in a 2023 game between nikaragua and Venezuela Angel shocked even the most hardened of Baseball fans with his calls these incidents and countless others like them have led many to question the overall fairness and integrity of the sport when Hernandez is involved how can players and teams be expected to compete on a Level Playing Field when the strike zone seems to shift with each game how can managers effectively strategize when they can't even trust the consistency of the calls being made the Angel Hernandez problem has exposed a deeper issue within baseball's umpiring system the lack of accountability for those who consistently underperform despite his track record of controversial calls and the vocal criticism from players and managers Hernandez remains a fixture in Major League Baseball with seemingly no consequences for his actions this raises a critical question why is it so difficult to remove problematic umpires like Angel Hernandez from the sport the answer lies in a complex web of structural and organizational challenges that have long shielded umpires from the kind of accountability that players and managers face on a daily basis unlike players and managers who face constant scrutiny and the everpresent threat of being benched traded or fired for poor performance umpires like Hernandez seem to operate in a protective bubble shielded from the consequences of their actions at the heart of this issue lies the powerful umpires Union the Major League Baseball umpires Association the mlbua has long fought for the rights and job security of its members negotiating strong collective bargaining agreements that make it nearly impossible to fire an Umpire for performance related issues in fact the last time an MLB Empire was terminated for performance reasons was back in 1999 when the league dismissed 22 Empires during a failed Mass resignation attempt this Ironclad job security has created a culture of complacency among some Empires who know that their positions are essentially guaranteed regardless of how many calls they blow or how much criticism they face for someone like Angel Hernandez this Union's protection acts as a safety net allowing him to continue officiating high-profile games despite his track record of inconsistency and error but the union is just one piece of the puzzle MLB itself has been hesitant to take a hard stance against problematic umpires often opting for behind the-scenes reassignments or quiet demotions rather than public disciplinary action this reluctancy to confront the issue headon has only extended the problem as players managers and fans grow increasingly frustrated with the lack of accountability for umpires who consistently underperform the per ition that umpires are Untouchable has reduced trust in the system adding to the complexity of the situation are legal hurdles involved in any attempt to remove an Umpire from their position Hernandez's racial discrimination lawsuit against MLB while ultimately unsuccessful highlighted the potential for legal action should the league attempt to terminate any umpire's employment even if MLB had legitimate performance related reasons for firing an Umpire the threat of a lengthy and expensive legal battle could demotivate them from taking AC action but as the calls for change grow louder and the impact of controversial calls becomes increasingly apparent the question remains how long can this broken system sustain itself before something gives with the very Integrity of the sport at stake it's becoming clear that something must be done to address the Angel Hernandez problem and ensure fair and consistent officiating experience for players and fans alike and that brings us to the elephant in the room the growing push for automated umpiring in baseball as the debate over Angel Hernandez and his fellow umpire rages on many are beginning to wonder if the solution lies not in human accountability but in the cold unbiased Precision of Technology the debate over replacing human umpires with technology has been simmering for years but the high-profile missteps of officials like Hernandez has brought this issue to a boiling point supporters of automation argue that it would eliminate the inconsistency and bias that have plagued the sport for decades with the machine calling balls and Strikes every pitch would be judged by the same objective standard regardless on who's on the mound or at the plate no longer would players or managers have to worry about an umpire's personal Vendetta or a particularly generous Strike Zone altering the course of the game the technology for automated umpiring already exists and has been successfully tested in the minor leagues the automated ball Strike Zone uses high-speed cameras to track the trajectory of each pitch instantly determin whether it passed through the strike zone in Trials the system has proven to be highly accurate with a margin of error far smaller than that of even the best human umpires now while many are advocating for automated systems some argue that removing the human element from umpiring would fundamentally change the nature of the game the art of pitch framing for example where catchers subtly move their gloves to influence an umpire's call would become obsolete the Lively arguments between manag and umpires a beloved part of baseball's theatrical tradition would be reduced to cold clinical challenges but there's also the question of how automated umpiring would handle the nuances and judgment calls that are an integral part of the sport would it be able to make split-second decisions on Che swings or adjust for The Unique dimensions of each ballpark these are valid concerns but they pale in comparison to the damage being done by the current system when an Umpire like Angel Hernandez can consistently make game-changing mistakes without consequence it ruins the very Integrity of the sport it's no longer about the skill of the players or the strategy of the managers but the actions of an unaccountable official automated umpiring for all its potential drawbacks offers a path forward it's a chance to level the plane field to ensure that every team has a fair shot at Victory based on their performance not the unpredictability of human error and while it may take some getting used to the benefits of a more consistent accurate and transparent officiating system would be felt across the board of course the transition to automated umpiring wouldn't happen overnight it would likely be a gradual process with the technology being phased in overtime and human umpire still playing a role in certain aspects of the game as we move forward towards the future of automated umpiring MLB the question stands how has MLB handled the Angel Hernandez problem so far while MLB has been aggressive in its legal defense it has taken a more measured approach in addressing the broader concerns about umpiring quality and accountability the league has ackn knowledge the need for improvement implementing incremental changes like the expansion of instant replay and the use of technology to evaluate umpire performance however these efforts have been met with resistance from the umpire's union which has fought to protect the autonomy and the job security of its members behind the scenes MLB has reportedly taken steps to address the Angel Hernandez situation more directly in 2019 the Lee quietly removed Hernandez from a crew chief position after he was caught in an ESPN EAS dropping incident and while Hernandez has continued to work in high-profile games there have been Whispers that MLB is increasingly hesitant to assign them to crucial postseason matchups or more prominent regular season broadcasts looking ahead EML finds itself at a Crossroads when it comes to the future of umpiring the successful testing of the automated ball strike system in the minor leagues has put the prospect of robot umps firmly on the table offering a solution to the inconsistency and controversy that has plagued the human element but the league has also recognized the challenges and potential unintended consequences of such a large shift from the logistical hurdles of implementation to the resistance from traditionalists who view umpiring as an integral part of the game with every blown call and every viral clip of Hernandez's latest misstep the pressure mounts for the league to take decisive action whether that means a more aggressive approach to performance-based discipline a faster track towards automation or fundamental rethinking of of the Umpire roles in the game remains to be seen the road ahead is uncertain but one thing is clear the status quo cannot hold forever sooner or later something will have to give do you know what else is a large issue in MLB pitching be sure to click this video right here to learn more about the epidemic taking over baseball

Channel: Bottom Of The Inning

Views: 320,148

Keywords: MLB, Baseball, Worldseries, sport, baseballlife, shoheiohtani, Yankees, RedSox, Mets, Fastball, curveball, Miketrout, Dodgers, baseballseason

Id: NV9pxvAGG3s

Length: 13min 49sec (829 seconds)

Published: Thu Apr 25 2024