Antikythera Fragment #6 - Ancient Tool Technology - Making A Hand Powered Drill

Video Statistics and Information

Video
Captions Word Cloud
Reddit Comments

even Chris's casting molds are a work of art

👍︎︎ 16 👤︎︎ u/scrochum 📅︎︎ Feb 27 2018 🗫︎ replies

Clickspring is such a badass, I am an unapologetic fanboy.

👍︎︎ 9 👤︎︎ u/Roving_Rhythmatist 📅︎︎ Feb 27 2018 🗫︎ replies

Stupid question... Did he make a casting mold for the flywheel because there was no block of the metal he wanted to make it out of (bronze I think?) to make/put on the lathe?

👍︎︎ 6 👤︎︎ u/Wasilewski 📅︎︎ Feb 27 2018 🗫︎ replies

Mesmerizing

👍︎︎ 2 👤︎︎ u/Noble69 📅︎︎ Feb 27 2018 🗫︎ replies

yay, i knew it had to come out one of these days. And two videos in one week no less

👍︎︎ 2 👤︎︎ u/CoSonfused 📅︎︎ Feb 27 2018 🗫︎ replies

I wish there was a way for a normal person to make a living doing this. All I want to do is make cool shit but the starting costs (equipment, space and materials) and education required are crazy. Oh well, I’ll be dreaming from my local maker space.

👍︎︎ 2 👤︎︎ u/Shaxinater 📅︎︎ Feb 27 2018 🗫︎ replies
Captions
G'day Chris here, and welcome back to Clickspring. Among the many engineering achievements demonstrated within the Antikythera mechanism, is one thats largely hidden from view. And that's the Ancient Greeks ability to create very precise, small holes. The device is full of them, and they're all critical in one way or another to its ability to function. To receive locating pins, to act as reliable bearings for the gearing assemblies, and to form the starting point of the many square openings found in the various parts. Now the ability to put a small, accurately sized hole exactly where it needs it to go, is no simple achievement even today. So its worthwhile investigating just how it could have been done in the Ancient World. The evidence suggests that the vast majority of the holes in the machine were drilled. And a likely candidate is one of the oldest drilling tools on record: The Pump Drill. I've designed this version to be a genuine working tool, with interchangeable drill bits. So it'll need to be durable and robust enough for daily use. But it will also need to be light and sensitive enough to cover the full range of holes found within the mechanism. Where practical, I'm using the raw materials known to be available in the period, like for example raw copper and tin to make bronze, and this local oak for the timber components. Where it gets a little difficult to source authentic materials, or if the material choice has no significant bearing on the outcome, I've used some modern substitutes. Like for example mild steel as a substitute for wrought iron, HDPE for the casting pattern, and heavy gauge fishing line in lieu of a gut based cable. And if you'd like to build one of these for yourself, the plans are available as a free download, so be sure to check the description box below for the link. OK, so first up is the flywheel, which I cast from bronze. Traditionally the pattern for something like this would be made from timber. But as you can see HDPE is a lot more fun to turn, and best of all there's no dust to cleanup afterwards. Now so far in the build I've been using a modern lathe for all of the turned parts, and of course it raises the question: What was the equivalent technology of the day? Well certainly there's enough evidence on the historical record to suggest the widespread existence of turning technology. In fact the Roman author and engineer Vitruvius, writing at around the time that the mechanism was lost. Mentions lathes in a completely offhand manner, expecting the reader to be thoroughly familiar with the idea. As if the technology was so commonplace, that it barely required explaining. As it happens, the Antikythera Mechanism may in fact be the very best evidence available to establish the full extent of that lathe technology, at least as it relates to smaller scale engineering. And its something that I'll be covering in detail in a later video. OK, so with the pattern complete, I rammed up a sand mould in preparation for the pour. So thats the mould ready to go, and the crucible is charged with weighed quantities of tin and copper to give an 85/10 bronze. The remaining 5 percent will be made up with lead and added once the melt is well established. The pouring basin and gating will be thrown back into the crucible for the next melt, but the feeder and riser will be used as a source of round stock for other parts, and you'll see them being used later in the video. Much like the small parts vise, I think the "as cast" surface makes a great contrast with the turned surfaces. And you can see that this bronze behaves very much like a free cutting brass, which makes it perfect for free hand turning. And that's the flywheel complete for the moment. Next up are what I'm calling the collets, The parts of the tool that'll hold the various drill bits. I cast some long round stock from the same bronze as the flywheel, and then turned it down to an appropriate starting diameter. I then formed the basic collet profile. Now the precedent of square drivers operating in square holes is well established within the mechanism, so I've used the same idea for this drill design. And whilst I've used the mill to remove the bulk of the waste stock for the driver squares, this step could easily have been done with a course file. Much like the process of opening up the internal square in the flywheel, it just would have required more time and physical effort. And speaking of which, that's next. Starting with the center hole position, I roughly marked out the square, and then set about opening it up. OK, so with the major bronze components on track, its time to have a look at the shaft and drive handle. The handle is a straightforward profile, and again whilst I've used a modern saw to save time, its easy to imagine this sort of shape being cut with a simpler tool. And the same applies to these holes. They're not difficult to form, nor do they need to be terribly precise. They could be made using the lathe tech of the day, or even by using much cruder methods like gouging and then filing. To complete the part, I gave it a light sand, followed by a linseed oil finish. A bushing will ensure a smooth vertical motion of the drive handle on the shaft, and it fits neatly inside the diameter of the feeder that was cut from the flywheel casting. The holes in the shaft were formed on the lathe. And I've made the shaft as long as possible, whilst still keeping the overall tool length practical. This'll help to minimise the effect of angular drift at the top of the tool when its being used. Now the shaft ends would be a weak point of the tool if not given a simple reinforcement. And that's the purpose of the short ferrules located at each end. I've formed the ferrules to be a tight fit over the ends of the shaft, so that although they're firm enough to sit tightly in place when the tool is in use, they can if required, still be slid off the end. The shanks of the collets have also been formed to be a snug fit inside the shaft. But they need to be a cross drilled, along with the receiving end of the shaft, to accept a retaining/drive pin. The drive pin as a sort of thumb pin, that can be easily inserted and removed by hand. The other end of the tool of course needs to be supported whilst in operation. So I've designed it to have a free rotating knob. Now you may have noticed that I've used a shop made drill bit for the last few drilling operations. This type of drill bit is incredibly effective at forming small precise holes. And was being used by clock makers for many hundreds of years prior to the invention of the modern twist drill. Its quite possible that its use extends all of the way back to antiquity, so its a reasonable candidate for the sort of drill bit used to construct the AM. I've created a separate video showing a process that could plausibly have been used to make this type of drill bit, so be sure to check out that video. In any event, once created, the drill bits themselves can then be used to drill out the collets. Each of the 3 test bits correspond to a critical feature found within the mechanism. One is for a standard bearing hole, one for a standard retaining pin, and the smallest, coming in at just 0.8 of a mm, corresponds with the holes used to locate the calendar ring. Now there is evidence of the use of soft solder within the mechanism wreckage, and certainly soft solder would be suitable to hold the bits in their collets. But equally plausible, and I think a little more convenient, is resin. I'm using shellac, but any hard resin available at the time would have worked well. The bit is solidly held, yet a gentle heat can be used to soften the bond. And permit the bit to be replaced, or extended for sharpening as it wears out. The driving line needs to be securely fastened. And since this part of the tool is under considerable strain, I've turned up a couple of tie off rings to ensure both a good solid hold on the cable, and a modest distribution of the load around the hole. And with that, the tool is complete, so lets give it a test. Its interesting to see that the same practices that apply to modern drilling, also apply to this tool. A center punch mark is essential to ensure that the hole ends up where it should be. A few light turns with the drill, are enough to gently open up a good starting point. And of course the entire drill pivots on that drill tip. So it has a strong tendency to follow the marked position. The driving action is quite straightforward. It doesn't take a lot of effort, just a consistent force to keep the flywheel moving. Although it does take a bit of concentration to keep the tool upright. Its easy to let the angle drift a little, and so risk wallowing the hole. The concept of using a pilot hole also transfers. The larger bit will cut through on its own, but its much easier to pilot the hole first with a smaller bit, and then follow with the larger bit. Now one thing the tool needs, is the ability to be able to vary its inertia and downforce, as the circumstances change. So I made some extra flywheels of different sizes to give it that flexibility. The larger flywheel, helps overcome the cutting forces experienced by the larger bits. And the smaller flywheel gives the tool more sensitivity for the smaller holes. And its certainly a very practical tool to use. The changeout of drill bits and flywheels is fast and easy, and the drilling time is comparable to a modern drill. Now as to whether or not this type of tool was used to build the mechanism, well who knows. But I do think its fair to say that its a contender. These test pieces compare well with the holes found throughout the wreckage of the mechanism. And certainly there's no doubt that the tool is capable of making holes to at least that standard. I'll continue to experiment with it, and we'll see how it performs throughout the rest of the project. Thanks for watching, I'll see you later. Now if you enjoyed this video, and you'd like to help me make more, then consider becoming a Clickspring Patron. As a patron of the Channel, you get immediate access to the Patron Series of videos. This includes the 5 videos of the Wedge Style hand Vise Project, and at present the first 7 videos of the Byzantine Sundial Calendar Build. There's also the first 4 episodes of the new Tools Glorious Tools series, with more to come as that series progresses. In the most recent episode, I go through the things to consider when setting up your own home shop. And don't forget that as a patron you also get free access to the plans for the Patron Series projects. So you can follow along, and build them yourself if you wish. Visit Patreon.com/clickspring to find out more. Thanks again for watching, I'll catch you on the next video.
Info
Channel: Clickspring
Views: 1,737,675
Rating: 4.9174719 out of 5
Keywords: pump drill, Antikythera, pump drillbit, drillbit, drill bit, Antikythera mechanism, case hardening, ancient drill bit, case hardened, carbon steel, ancient greece, hellenistic, greek, drill, ancient tools, antikythera, clickspring, the antikythera mechanism, martensite, austenite, pack carburizing, carburizing, metallurgy
Id: OtWVA7_9Rik
Channel Id: undefined
Length: 22min 40sec (1360 seconds)
Published: Mon Feb 26 2018
Related Videos
Note
Please note that this website is currently a work in progress! Lots of interesting data and statistics to come.