3 Creepy Real Trick-or-Treating Horror Stories - Part 2

four years ago I took my youngest sister and her two friends trick-or-treating I'm 18 now I was obviously 14 during the time of this story my youngest sister was only seven at the time along with her two friends who of the two I'll only name one marry for privacy reasons I didn't have plans anyway so I guess I was actually a bit happy that my parents made me walk with them plus I Loki told my sister to fill an extra bag for me at each house by now we were more than a mile away from my house the girls bags were all pretty full now and I was ordering them to start making their loop back in the direction of our house the girls were approaching the front door of a corner house across the street from an old closed-off community park the house already stood out from the rest on the block and that there was a 3-foot wooden fence surrounding the perimeter except for the walkway and driveway and a bunch of overgrown trees and bushes on the front lawn almost completely blocking the actual house from view they tried looking for the doorbell but then called that to me that there wasn't one I answered back telling them to just knock on the door my sister counted on the door in three different intervals then I called for them to skip this house as the three girls were walking down the stoop the front door to the house creaked open and somebody could just barely be seen poking their head out from behind the door which was open just a crack the girls walked back up the stoop and simultaneously yelled trick-or-treat from the sidewalk all I could see was an arm reach out from around the door and then the person's pointer finger lifting up as if to say one second the arm kind of creepley pulled back into the house my view of it not seeing a body made the situation really eerie the door closed and for what felt like 20 seconds they just stood there on the stoop I was about to ask them what was going on but once again the front door to the house cracked open once again just an arm came into view for me this time I could see him waving the girls to come into the house with his hand my sister and her two friends were actually making their way into the house before even looking back at me for approval at this point the feeling in my stomach told me something wasn't right here and I yelled to the girls to come back the really disturbing part was as soon as I yelled this the person shut the front door almost slamming it in their faces the three girls came back over to me I told them that was enough trick-or-treating for the night i nurtured them to continue walking forward keeping my eyes on the house barely through the overgrown bushes in front of the house I saw the blinds to one of the front windows wrestling around and in older men sitting by the window we continued walking home now the girls told me the men initially said one second while I go get the candy and then shut the door when he came back out he whispered to come inside to get the candy I was considering calling the cops and reporting this guy but I wanted to get home and see what my parents had to say first we were probably halfway down the block when I turned around and saw a person standing by the corner of the block right where the house was we made it back to our house where I told my parents they called my sister's friend's parents and when they got there we all had a long conversation about it we then all drove over to the house and separate cars with my mom talking with a 911 the car when we got to the house we learned before the cops even arrived by a neighbor that the house had been vacant for months Mary's dad was the quickest one to realize what was actually going on here a sexual predator or maybe even worse was hiding in the house for Halloween waiting to lure unsuspecting kids into the house to snatch them and what scares me the most to this day was that my sister and her friends were about to enter that house before I told them not to Halloween can be a very dangerous holiday two years ago I was home on Halloween and for the most part it was a pretty normal day since Halloween was on a Friday all my friends were out partying however I was doing homework not one of my most exciting nights but I didn't mind too much I really had to get this homework done anyway my mom and dad were handing out candy to the trick-or-treaters as they usually do my house doesn't usually get many because we're pretty much the only house on the block that hands out so it's often ignored because it's not worth their time tonight was no exception later that night my mom calls me down and tells me to watch the door for trick-or-treaters because my neighbors had come over asking for help with their costumes for a party so my neighbors and my parents both went upstairs to work on the costumes leaving me alone downstairs it didn't bother me because I had finished my homework and I could just play my ps4 while listening for knocks on the front door which was close by only a couple more trick-or-treaters came in about an hour pretty typical for this area however around 11:00 p.m. I heard a knock at the door I thought it was pretty weird since it had almost been an hour since the last knock and it was pretty late for trick-or-treaters to still be out regardless I grabbed the candy and went to answer the door it's important to note that there's a small room in between the front door and the living room when we answer the front door we make sure to lock the door behind us leading to the living room so our dogs don't run up and start barking and whatnot I did the same thing here when I answered the door there was a surprisingly large man at least 6 foot 3 inches tall with a somewhat muscular physique standing in front of me wearing a Michael Myers costume not a cheap one either it looked pretty expensive for a costume he stood in front of me but didn't say a single word I thought it was pretty unusual because it's kind of customary to say trick-or-treat but nope he didn't do a thing but stare at me it was almost like he was a statue I thought he was really trying to sell the character and creeped me out and it was working I was feeling a little intimidated because I'm pretty small for a guy only about 5 feet 10 inches tall I decided to break the awkward silence and say trick or treat for him while handing him some candy I couldn't believe what he did next in response to me handing him candy he took a few steps into my house this was when I started getting really uncomfortable you're supposed to take the candy say thank you and go it's like an unspoken rule that you don't walk into people's houses without permission it was at this moment that I also noticed that he didn't have any type of bag for candy this was a huge red flag because I realized then that he was not there to trick-or-treat before I could respond the man reached into his pocket and pulled something out I didn't want to look at it but I was assuming it was a weapon and I had no idea what to do I'd locked myself into a small room with a psychopath much larger than me holding a weapon blocking the only exits we all like to pretend and make up scenarios in our heads where we have to be the hero and save the day but here I was stuck in a real-life situation completely unable to move not able to save myself I was frozen in fear it was such a weird feeling almost like I was dreaming the entire thing I had no control over my body now what a cliche way of dying I thought it would be getting stabbed to death by someone dressed up as Michael Myers on Halloween thankfully it didn't go like that because without warning the guy takes off his mask and jokingly says I'm just messing with you bro I'm still frozen in shock and can't respond in any way he then says I scared you though right completely confused and still afraid I managed to respond with yeah you got me he put the knife back in his pocket which gave me a huge sign of relief and said I didn't really come here to trick-or-treat but what can I have that candy anyway I'm really hungry I didn't hesitate to give him the candy because he creeped me out and he still did have a knife he then goes on to mention how he just left his friend's Halloween party and he saw my lights on and decided to prank me it was obvious that he was drunk and high and thought knocking on someone's house pretending to be Michael Myers qualifies as a good prank he mentions how he owns a tattoo place about an hour away from here and even says that I'm pretty chill and that we should hang out sometime he tells me to put his name and number in my phone so we can chill soon I make sure to take his name and number down after all the last thing I wanted to do was upset this weird guy's still blocking my only exit with a knife I basically agreed to everything he said because I was still terrified and just wanted the conversation to end as soon as possible but this conversation seemed to go on for hours despite this I still didn't feel comfortable or safe I had to find a way to get this guy out of my house there was something way off about him and I got vibes that he was a dangerous person so I decided to make up a lie and say that I had something cooking in the oven that I needed to check on and then I text him later and it worked he said ok and turned around to leave my house I could not close and lock the door quick enough when he left my heart was still beating so fast that I thought it was going to burst for my chest that was easily the most terrifying and weirdest experience of my life I decided to not contact the police though since the guy didn't have any malicious intent I guess he was just completely out of it and just a overall really creepy person I still have his number to this day but we've never texted or called each other just the way I like it as terrifying as that situation was I can laugh at it now and use it as an interesting story to share with my friends so I guess one good thing did come from it just be careful who you open your door for on Halloween there's some very weird and messed up people out there I got lucky this guy wasn't a complete psychopath because nothing was stopping him from stabbing me [Music] Halloween used to be my favorite holiday but ever since one not so sweet round of trick-or-treating I've kind of switched over to liking Christmas the most 2006 I was fourteen years old me and Johnny my best friend at the time we're going trick-or-treating together I remember it was a Tuesday night so everyone had school the next day that meant the craziness with the teenagers going around with TP and shaving cream wasn't as extreme nor was anything really my parents want to be back by 11 o'clock the latest same with Johnny it was around 8:30 I would constantly check my wristwatch we were down a bunch of blocks close to the woods and the highway by the east end of town this would likely be our last year of trick-or-treating so we were trying to get as much candy as possible we rang doorbell after doorbell as the night wore on and the amount of kids outside lessons the number of people answering their doors also decreased then it started to drizzle and that's when it really became a ghost town outside but that didn't stop us we were now three houses down from the house that was commonly known around there as hell house it was nicknamed this because of the alleged murder that happened inside decades ago plus the fact that the house looks like it was built over a hundred years ago and stuck out from the other houses two miles away there was even a whole webpage dedicated to the house with a little lore behind it I don't really remember the full details anymore the website is down now but at the time nobody seemed to know if anybody lived there or not at the time I was sure the neighbors knew but we didn't live very close to the house long story short me and Johnny were feeling brave and cocky so we hopped the creepy fence surrounding the seemingly abandoned property and walked up to the stoop which was made out of ancient and worn-out looking red bricks we knocked on the door a few times since there was no doorbell the drizzle turned to rain and we suddenly didn't want to move out from under the front warning Johnny jokingly knocked on the door again but my focus was shifted to walking home in this rain suddenly a loud thud made us both jump Johnny said it sounded like it came from a window upstairs to which I replied let's leave we walked quickly back down the red brick pathway hopped over the front black graveyard like gate and stopped to look back at the house on this dark rainy Halloween night Johnny bumped me on the shoulder and pointed to the upper middle window of the house and I felt like my heart dropped from my chest when I saw somebody clear as day staring down at us only there was something so disturbing about this person's face I couldn't tell what it was through the rain and foggy window but I swear that face and just this whole scene seemed like something you would see in a horror movie we both jumped once again when the person at the window quickly and aggressively turned and seemingly ran away from the window all we could assume was that they were coming outside after us we quickly went to hide by the neighbor's fence which was facing the back yard of the house the sound of the rain thankfully masked the sound of our breathing and whispering this neighboring fence was made of wood and had a bunch of holes allowing us to peek through to the lawn next door suddenly the entire fence started to shake a little yet we couldn't see anyone on the other side we were certain it wasn't us who had done it Johnny and I agreed it was time to make a run for it back to my house we both stood up and when we turned to run I saw something at the edge of the fence at first I was confused as to what it was due to the darkness but it soon hit me that this was a person leaning over to this side of the fence exposing their body down to their waistline with one arm reaching around the fence the way this person was positioned and staring at us made for a horrifying scene and memory we dropped our candy bags and ran for it after running five blocks am I getting a few cuts and bruises from tripping twice in the rain we got back to my house we agreed not to say a word given that what we did could probably get us in trouble the really scary part is the next day after school we went to go ask some of the neighbors over there if they knew who lived there and they all gave the same response they had no idea if anybody lived there or not they never saw a car in the driveway or anybody outside one of the neighbors even pointed out that the house had a for sale sign very briefly a few months prior but disappeared within a few days we told all the neighbors our story and they were all very disturbed by the news I moved out of that neighborhood in 2007 the next year and I've never had to worry about the story behind that house or who was living there since all I know is something strange was going on inside of that house and I kind of wish I found out what [Music]

Channel: Mr. Nightmare

Views: 2,919,033

Rating: 4.9326239 out of 5

Keywords: halloween stories, scary trick or treat, trick or treat stories, trick or treat, scary stories, scary halloween stories, mr. nightmare, halloween, true scary stories, true stories

Id: vi3JbupJ9r8

Length: 15min 8sec (908 seconds)

Published: Fri Oct 28 2016